9 Most Undeserved Movie Plot Twists
Films that didn't earn their big reveal.
A big twist is often the difference between a good film and a classic one, but if most M. Night Shyamalan movies have taught us one thing, it's that they don't always work. Not all filmmakers seem to realise it, but twists have to be earned.
If the big reveal doesn't make sense within the context of the story or opens up a massive plothole, the audience simply won't buy it, and why should they? Without the necessary groundwork, a twist is no more than a cheap trick.
The element of surprise only works when it's offset against subtle foreshadowing and makes sense within the context of the narrative. For instance, Fight Club's revelation that Tyler Durden was a figment of the unnamed protagonist's imagination hit home because the movie fed the audience nuanced clues throughout. By the time the credits rolled, you wondered why you didn't pick up on it earlier.
When an unforeseen stinger arrives straight out of left field, though, the audience comes away feeling cheated, aggrieved that they weren't given a fair chance to figure things out for themselves, and in these instances, the filmmaker doesn't have the right to claim they hit the viewer with a 'twist'.
9. A Perfect Getaway: The Two Leads Are The Killers
Adventure-thriller A Perfect Getaway cast Steve Zahn and Milla Jovovich as a pair of newlyweds who take a romantic hiking trip to Hawaii, encountering several fellow travellers along the way. Despite its title, nothing about the movie is perfect. Not the couple's Honeymoon, and certainly not the twist it serves up in the final act.
When people start turning up dead, the film becomes a murder-mystery, but writer-director David Twohy wasn't playing fair when he put the story together.
The first third of the film encourages the audience to empathise with the leads, only to out them as the killers later on. Most viewers would have been shocked to learn they had been duped into rooting for two monsters if it wasn't for one problematic scene.
There's a sequence where Zahn and Jovovich's characters discuss how they believe one of the other couples could be responsible for the murders. Why would they think that when they know full well they did the killings? Nobody else hears the conversation; it's dialogue designed solely to cheat the audience.
This sequence would only have worked if the protagonists' insanity prevented them from even realising they were committing the atrocities, but since that's never established, Twohy sits on a throne of lies.
8. Perfect Stranger: A Flashback Out Of Nowhere
Halle Berry-fronted thriller Perfect Stranger breaks every rule in the book on movie twists. Any filmmaker worth their salt knows they should be foreshadowed with subtle clues for eagle-eyed viewers to spot, but this one comes out of nowhere.
Berry plays a plucky reporter who's hellbent on proving a rich advertising executive played by Bruce Willis murdered her best friend. It's a vanilla thriller throughout, until the final act when an outrageous twist changes everything.
A third-act flashback turns the movie on its head right at the end, revealing that Berry's character was the murderer the whole time, driven to commit this terrible act by a traumatic childhood in which her abusive father was killed by her mother.
Curveballs like this are fine, as long as they make sense in the context of the story, but in Perfect Stranger there are zero clues that Berry might be the killer and no references to her troubled past. It simply doesn't work.
7. Saw: Jigsaw Was In The Room The Whole Time
While the audience was still reeling after watching Cary Elwes commit self-harm, Saw recapped everything that had come before in a series of flashbacks and told them to forget everything they believed about Zep being the killer.
This would have been fine, except for the part where Jigsaw turns out to have been masquerading as that corpse in the middle of the room since the opening scene. How could he possibly have remained ramrod still for the duration?
His two captives may have lacked logic and problem-solving skills, but even they shouldn't have been able to tell the difference between a corpse and a man playing dead with prosthesis glued to his dead. One of them was a doctor, for Pete's sake.
Anyone would have struggled to lie dead still on the floor of that dingy bathroom without moving a fingernail for all those hours, let alone a terminally ill man. Outing Zep as just another pawn worked fine, but the Jigsaw reveal was a twist too far.
6. Signs: The Aliens' Water Allergy
M. Night Shyamalan doesn't make exclusively bad films - The Sixth Sense earned its ghostly reveal and Unbreakable is an original take on superheroism - but the director often throws in twists that come at the expense of his movies.
Anti-climactic alien invasion thriller Signs is a good example. After building up a sense of creeping horror as the extraterrestrials closed in on Graham (Mel Gibson), his brother Merrill (Joaquin Phoenix) and his children (Rory Culkin and Abigail Breslin), the movie dropped a clanger by revealing that water is like Kryptonite to the aliens.
This simply doesn't work as a twist because it means the invaders should have keeled over in agony the moment they set foot on our planet, given how much water vapour is in its atmosphere. Moreover, why would a race advanced enough to traverse the galaxy choose to land on a planet that's 70% covered in the one thing that kills them?
5. Now You See Me: Dylan Was The Fifth Horseman
It makes sense for a magical heist film's grand finale to out everything as one big ruse, but Now You See Me deserves no prestige for the execution of its big twist.
Once viewers were given a peek behind the curtain, they realised that FBI agent Dylan Rhodes's (played by Mark Ruffalo) investigation was one big con to exact revenge on Morgan Freeman's character for the death of his magician father.
In one fell swoop, Now You See Me made a mockery of its only interesting character and descended far beyond the realms of implausibility. The idea of a reputed FBI agent pulling the wool over the collective eyes of his entire department and teaming up with a bunch of magician teenagers is just downright silly.
The only thing more less believable than Dylan turning out to be the fifth Horseman is the fact Now You See Me made more than enough money to push a sequel into development and kick franchise plans into motion. What sorcery is this?
4. Skyfall: Raoul's Plan To Get Captured
Alan Partridge is probably a big fan of Skyfall, because it absolutely doesn't get Bond wrong. It's up there with the best of 007's outings, but it's a well known fact that every time a villain does the whole 'everything that's happened was all part of my plan' thing, huge plotholes open up. This is certainly the case with Javier Bardem’s Raoul Silva.
The movie's big twist kicks it when it transpires that former MI6 agent Raoul's diabolical scheme was to be captured by Bond all along, so he could take revenge on Judy Dench's M while she testified at a public enquiry.
But here's the thing: to pull this plan off, you'd have to literally be god because it's dependent on factors beyond Raoul's control. He needed to account for Bond following him to that remote island and taking him alive, as well as the international travel and prisoner processing time to ensure his escape coincided with M's hearing.
Even Doctor Evil's plans were more plausible than this.
3. Planet Of The Apes: Thade Inherits The Earth
When Tim Burton forgettably rehashed the original Planet of the Apes in 2001, he decided not to rehash the classic 'it was Earth all along' ending and went in another direction. The movie closes with Mark Wahlberg's Leo Davidson returning to Earth via the same electrical storm that deposited him on the simian planet, only to find that the evil General Thade beat him to it and conquered the world many decades ago.
No matter how many ways you examine this twist, it simply doesn't make sense. There's no explanation for how Thade found his way to Earth, or the fact he appears to have invented time travel based on the fact the Lincoln Memorial has been rendered in his image.
This twist doesn't hold water because Burton prioritised visual impact over narrative cohesion. The final scene feels tacked on, as though it was brainstormed at the last minute but nobody sat down to figure out how to execute it in a plothole-free way.
Presumably the plans was to use this scenario as a launchpad for a sequel that never happened, but an entire cinematic universe's worth of inter-connected follow-ups couldn't have made sense of this mess.
2. The Life Of David Gale: The Protagonist Was Innocent
Kevin Spacey and Kate Winslet play death penalty opponents in The Life Of David Gale, the former is a Death Row inmate facing capital punishment, and the latter a journalist who takes a keen interest in the case.
Long story short and spoilery, Spacey's David Gale is innocent of the crime he stands accused of, having plotted with his terminally-ill lover to make her suicide look like murder, but is executed for it anyway in a misguided attempt to prove a point.
Gale and his accomplice go to great lengths fabricating evidence alluding to his 'guilt', all in the name of proving that innocent people can be convicted of crimes they didn't commit thanks to a flawed justice system, but this is a twist that doesn't ring true.
All Spacey's character succeeds in proving is that people are convicted of crimes when there's compelling that they did it. Gale went out of his way to present himself as the murderer, and ultimately committed a pointless act of martyrdom.
1. Seven Pounds: Ben's Organ Donation
Seven Pounds opens with Will Smith's Ben Thomas dialling 911 to report his own suicide before hitting the viewer with a series of flashbacks outlining the events preceding his death. It establishes how Ben wants to help seven people of his choosing, but the how and why of the situation is kept under wraps until the end.
One twist later and it turns out the protagonist was responsible for a car crash that caused the death of his wife along with six other innocent people, and to atone for that, he's made it his mission to find seven thoroughly decent people in need of transplants so he can off himself and ensure his organs go to them.
This is a plot point that doesn't hold up under scrutiny because a modicum of research into medical policies would have told the screenwriters that organ donation doesn't work that way. In most cases, the donor doesn't get to choose who inherits his organs after death, especially if it's seven people he's just met.
There is a strict waiting list system in place for a reason, and the contents of one man's will wouldn't have changed that.