9 Movie Performances So Perfect They Survived Reboots

"Everything sucks, burn it all... except that one guy!"

Deadpool Wade Wilson
Fox

You'd normally expect a reboot to mean that a studio or film-maker wants nothing more to do with the thing they're trying to replace. It's effectively the equivalent of replanting seeds in a scorched field - a symbolic gesture that lets the audience know that this new thing is exactly that - new and different and not in any way weighed down by the issues of its predecessor.

In strange, rare cases, though, there's one element in the scrapped former generation that is just too perfect for the film-makers to move on from. Sometimes that manifests as ideas or occasionally plot threads that make the jump over the reset, but in the rarest of cases, it's decided that an actor has played the character so perfectly that recasting would be a disservice.

In those cases, you end up watching a wholly new film in a new universe or timeline that has a recognisable character wandering around as if that's just totally fine...

WARNING: This article contains spoilers for Spider-Man: Far From Home. SPOILERS are on the final page.

9. Deadpool - Ryan Reynolds

wolverine origins deadpool
Marvel

Movies: X-Men Origins: Wolverine & Deadpool

You really have to hand it to Ryan Reynolds, he's pretty much the best evidence of the old adage that "if at first you don't succeed, try again." For a while, it looked like he was box office poison for comic book movies (what with Blade Trinity, RIPD, X-Men Origins AND Green Lantern to his name), but then it all came up roses with Deadpool.

And to think, his awful, character-betraying role in X-Men Origins: Wolverine would normally have been the end of his attachment to the character. Instead, Reynolds retained the enthusiasm for Deadpool that had driven him to accept the role in the first place (despite the script) and helped get his own project greenlit to restore Deadpool's good name.

And thank God they let him.


8. Ghost Rider - Nic Cage

Ghost Rider Nic Cage
Columbia pictures

Movies: Ghost Rider & Ghost Rider: Spirit Of Vengeance

The story of Ghost Rider: Spirit Of Vengeance is a strange one, because it looks, for all intents and purposes, like a normal sequel. You'd be forgiven for thinking as much too, especially since Nic Cage returned to set his skull on fire for a second time.

But in reality, Cage actually survived the franchise being rebooted quietly as revealed by co-director Brian Taylor who sought to make the follow-up "100% different" to the original with collaborator Mark Neveldine:

"We basically said, we want to do it, [would] absolutely love to do it, but it's gotta be 100% different from the first movie, everything, except for Nic. We want the character to look different, feel different, sound different. The backstory of the character's different, the origin of the story is expanded upon in ways that the first movie didn't hint at, at all."It's pretty much a reboot, only with the same actor, which makes it: a requel. Or a seboot, I can't decide which one I like better... The first attraction was Nic and the second was the character and just how cool it could be. [I wanted to] kinda make the Ghost Rider movie that I wished I had seen before."

Unfortunately for everyone involved, the rebootquel ended up being a disaster too.


7. M - Judi Dench

Skyfall M Judi Dench
MGM

Movies: Goldeneye to Skyfall

Obviously, the James Bond continuity is a different kettle of spies to pretty much every other cinematic franchise out there, because it periodically recasts the lead and continues in largely the same timeline (with some retconning and forgetting thrown in every now and then). But Casino Royale was different.

That movie was consciously developed as a reboot, with Eon hoping to introduce a less experienced and more vulnerable Bond and bringing in Daniel Craig for the lead role. There was also a new Q and a new Felix Leiter and pretty much everything was all shiny and new. Well, almost everything.

When you've got someone as wonderful as Judy Dench playing M, you don't mess with the formula, so she was the only element of Die Another Day that survived the reboot. And rightly so.


6. Spock - Leonard Nimoy

Old Spock Star Trek
Paramount Pictures

Appearances: Star Trek: The Original Series to Star Trek: Into Darkness

The Star Trek Kelvin Timeline is a bit of a strange one, since it remakes the original series TV show but also simultaneously acts as a new prequel to the Next Generation movies, but that's not unprecedented since it's exactly what the X-Men movie franchise has done.

What's slightly more confusing about it is the fact that despite the movie being a reboot and introducing a new cast who look nothing like the ones from the TV show, one of the originals is ported in in the shape of Leonard Nimoy's Spock Prime. It's almost like his character managed to not only exist outside of the timeline within the film's time travel plot, but also jumped through the reboot portal at the same time.

Given the majesty of Nimoy's performance, there was no problem accepting it.


5. Ash - Bruce Campbell

Ash The Evil Dead
New Line Cinema

Movies: The Evil Dead franchise

After years of fans balking at the idea, Sam Raimi worked with director Fede Alvarez on a reboot/remake of The Evil Dead that left fans scratching their heads a little thanks to an Easter Egg.

The question of whether it was actually a sequel was rather fitting, considering the fact that Evil Dead II's status as either a remake or a sequel has been under question since it came out too. As with that film, the answer to the 2013 conundrum is that it's a continuation of the first movie that is designed to mirror the events of that movie as a reflection of a cyclical curse. According to the director, anyway.

It's still at least a soft reboot though, even though the expected sequels haven't yet come, which makes the fact that Bruce Campbell's Ash turns up during the credits all the more wild.


4. Hanson & Penhall - Johnny Depp And Peter DeLuise

21 Jump St Johnny Death
MGM

Appearances: 21 Jump Street (twice)

Between 1987 and 1991, TV cop shows were redefined when a fresh-faced Johnny Depp went back to school as part of the 21 Jump Street crew, investigating crimes in schools using a group of young-looking, naive officers.

Ultimately, Depp got annoyed with his teen idol label off the back of the show and quit before the start of the fifth and final season, but the show picked up lots of fans and went on to have cult appeal. That made it the perfect nostalgic property to reboot and 25 years after the original, Channing Tatum and Jonah Hill took on the lead roles.

They join the revived 21 Jump Street programme, which should have been a hint of this being the same timeline, and even though it's a reboot of the show, original stars Johnny Depp and Peter DeLuise show up for a third act, brief cameo as their original characters that sees them killed off.


3. The Trickster - Mark Hamill

The Flash Trickster Barry Mar Hamill
The CW

Shows: The Flash (twice)

When you hire Mark Hamill to play or voice a character, he has the annoying habit of being so brilliant that everyone wants him to continue doing so forever. There was no way anyone else could have been Luke Skywalker, for instance, and his take on the Joker is easily the most enduring from animation history.

To slightly less fanfare, Hamill also appeared as The Trickster in the 1990s TV adaptation of The Flash that people seem to regularly forget existed. But The CW didn't forget, because they cast the star of that show - John Wesley Shipp - as Henry Allen (as well as Jay Garrick later) and retroactively seemed to include it as part of their CW DC multiverse by incorporating images from it.

They also ported some characters over, including Vito D'Ambrosio's Mayor Anthony Bellows who was a police officer in the original show, and Amanda Pays' Dr Tina McGee among other side figures. More notably, they also brought Hamill back to portray The Trickster for the second time, using images from his appearances in the 1990 series for his police reports.


2. Charlie - John Forsyth

Charlie's Angels Intercom
Columbia Pictures

Appearances: Charlie's Angels (twice)

Film-makers obviously really like the idea of Charlie's Angels, since they've now rebooted it for a second time (much to the delight of the bros who love a good movie gender swap). And there is absolutely something to be said for the magic of a mysterious benefactor who is never seen on-screen who sends his band of weaponised ladies out to fight injustice.

That unseen presence was originally played by the legendary John Forsythe whose rich voice seemed perfect for the millionaire backer of the team. It was so fitting, in fact, that when the time came to cast Charlie for the 2000 reboot of the franchise, McG turned back to Forsyth. Just as he always should have.

WARNING: The next page has SPOILERS FOR SPIDER-MAN: FAR FEOM HOME.


1. J Jonah Jameson - JK Simmons

J Jonah Jameson
Sony Pictures

Movies: Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy & Spider-Man: Far From Home

For all of the great things that happen in Spider-Man: Far From Home, there is one moment more than any that will endure in the minds of the audience. It's not Peter and MJ’s conclusion or the reveal of Nick Fury’s plan at the end or even the Mysterio twist - it's the stunning and secret return of JK Simmons as J Jonah Jameson.

Simmons was one of the best things about the Sam Raimi trilogy, fitting JJJ's brusque, aggressive character perfectly to the point that it was almost inconceivable that the Amazing Spider-Man reboot. So inconceivable that they simply didn’t do it.

In that respect it’s great to see him back for Far From Home. He’s playing a slightly different version of Jameson but it’s still him.

Which other reboot survivors should be added to this list? Share your picks below in the comments thread.


Watch Next


Spider-Man Movie Quiz: True Or False

Dr Connors
Sony Pictures

1. The Amazing Spider-Man (2012) Is The First Film To Introduce Dr Curt Connors?

In this post: 
Deadpool
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.