9 Terrible 2015 Oscar Nominations - Corrected
The nine ill-advised 2015 nominees and the suggestions for their replacements.
The Oscars has always proven contentious. If Crash isnt beating Brokeback Mountain to Best Picture, then Renee Zellweger is taking home an award for Cold Mountain when really it should have been anyone in the room but her. Sometimes what happens at the Oscars is, as in life, simply not fair at all. Still, it's difficult to remember the last time the Academy got it so wrong at just the nominations stage. With such a great set of 2014 contenders to choose from, its hard to believe that the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences (AMPAS) managed to get it so wrong in so many categories for 2015. Where prestige pics like The Theory of Everything and American Sniper rule, other acclaimed dramas are inexplicably largely ignored (Gone Girl) or shut out altogether (A Most Violent Year). This article won't touch the arena of Best Picture for this list, because there are simply too many great movies from 2014 that could be in there that arent (no Foxcatcher, Gone Girl, Nightcrawler, Under the Skin, Blue Ruin, Fury, A Most Wanted Man...). Instead, it'll look to the remaining categories. More specifically, the nine ill-advised 2015 nominees and the suggestions for their replacements.
9. Jake Gyllenhaal (Nightcrawler) Instead Of Bradley Cooper (American Sniper) - Best Actor

8. David Fincher (Gone Girl) Instead Of Morten Tyldum (The Imitation Game) - Best Director

7. Robert Elswit (Nightcrawler) Instead Of Roger Deakins (Unbroken) - Best Cinematography

6. Tom Hardy (Locke/The Drop) Instead Of Benedict Cumberbatch (The Imitation Game) - For Best Actor

5. Mica Levi (Under The Skin) Instead Of Johann Johansson (The Theory Of Everything) - For Original Score

4. Ben Mendelsohn (Starred Up) Instead Of Robert Duvall (The Judge) - Best Supporting Actor
Truth be told, there were many, many great supporting male performances to be found in 2014, male side-characters generally continuing to be the most consistently interesting in English-language film. Some of the standouts from last year that would have made good Best Supporting Actor nominees this time around: Robert Pattinson in The Rover, Riz Ahmed in Nightcrawler, Tyler Perry in Gone Girl, Matthias Schoenaerts in The Drop, Toby Kebbell in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes and pretty much everyone running the tank in Fury (yes, including Shia LaBeouf). Rather than choose any of those more obviously Oscar-friendly choices, however, we're going for a leftfield pick that really should have been nominated by now anyway: Ben Mendelsohn. In Starred Up, Mendelsohn expertly plays a veteran prisoner as a conflicted, intimidating alpha, but the Aussie actor could've been nominated for any one of his excellent performances from the past five years, including for Animal Kingdom, Killing Them Softly or The Place Beyond the Pines. At the very least, Mendelsohn's overdue nomination in place of Duvall's 'he might not be around much longer so let's nominate him quick'-safety net vote would have stopped David Dobkin's widely-derided legal drama from getting to call itself "The Oscar-nominated The Judge".3. The Lego Movie Instead Of Literally Any Of The Competition - Best Animation

2. Gillian Flynn (Gone Girl) Instead Of Graham Moore (The Imitation Game) - Adapted Screenplay

1. Rene Russo (Nightcrawler) Instead Of Meryl Streep (Into The Woods) - Best Supporting Actress
