9 Terrible 2015 Oscar Nominations - Corrected

The nine ill-advised 2015 nominees and the suggestions for their replacements.

Tom Hardy Locke The Oscars has always proven contentious. If Crash isn€™t beating Brokeback Mountain to Best Picture, then Renee Zellweger is taking home an award for Cold Mountain when really it should have been anyone in the room but her. Sometimes what happens at the Oscars is, as in life, simply not fair at all. Still, it's difficult to remember the last time the Academy got it so wrong at just the nominations stage. With such a great set of 2014 contenders to choose from, it€™s hard to believe that the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences (AMPAS) managed to get it so wrong in so many categories for 2015. Where prestige pics like The Theory of Everything and American Sniper rule, other acclaimed dramas are inexplicably largely ignored (Gone Girl) or shut out altogether (A Most Violent Year). This article won't touch the arena of Best Picture for this list, because there are simply too many great movies from 2014 that could be in there that aren€™t (no Foxcatcher, Gone Girl, Nightcrawler, Under the Skin, Blue Ruin, Fury, A Most Wanted Man...). Instead, it'll look to the remaining categories. More specifically, the nine ill-advised 2015 nominees and the suggestions for their replacements.

9. Jake Gyllenhaal (Nightcrawler) Instead Of Bradley Cooper (American Sniper) - Best Actor

There's nothing wrong with Bradley Cooper in American Sniper. In fact, as Chris Kyle, the real life sniper dubbed the "most lethal in US history", Cooper puts in one of his finest performances to date. But in another tough year for male leads vying for Academy recognition, Cooper simply wasn't one of the strongest five contenders. Early buzz and awards noms aplenty for Oscar Isaac (A Most Violent Year) and David Oyelowo (Selma) came to nothing when the Best Actor picks for Oscar 2015 were announced, and it seems a tad unreasonable that the pair - both of them exceptional performers doing their career-best work right now - still have zero Oscar noms to their name, while Cooper has now been nominated three years in a row. Whereas Cooper is solid in Sniper, Gyllenhaal undergoes one of the greatest, most memorable star transformations of recent times for Dan Gilroy's media satire Nightcrawler. Gyllenhaal is iconic and uncannily compelling in the film, so it's remarkable that the Academy was able to ignore him.

8. David Fincher (Gone Girl) Instead Of Morten Tyldum (The Imitation Game) - Best Director

David Fincher has never won an Oscar. The Imitation Game director Morten Tyldum, however, could by all means win one this year; Fincher, meanwhile, doesn't have that chance because he isn't even in the running. Let's put things into perspective: David Fincher is practically his own brand, a filmmaker known for an intense, moody, blackly comic style and a Kubrickian attention to detail, famed for such modern classics as Seven, Zodiac, The Social Network and now 2014 smash hit Gone Girl. Morten Tyldum is the director you'd never heard of until he got nominated for showing up to direct The Imitation Game. That would be because Tyldum is a journeyman helmer with a generic, personality-free technique. The Imitation Game is a big player at the 2015 Oscars (it has eight nominations in total), and you can guarantee it's because Oscar-gobblers the Weinsteins have yet again done a stand-up job of campaigning their film so hard they edged out the competition. Tyldum's nod appears more like evidence of how effective an expensive barrage of Oscar campaigning can be, and at this point, Fincher seems at risk of joining Hitchcock and Kubrick in the 'Greatest Filmmakers Never to Win a Directing Oscar' club.

7. Robert Elswit (Nightcrawler) Instead Of Roger Deakins (Unbroken) - Best Cinematography

This is getting beyond a joke now. Roger Deakins, longtime collaborator of the Coen brothers and Sam Mendes, has been nominated 12 times for the Best Cinematography Oscar without so much as being allowed to borrow the thing for an hour. That's not for lack of trying, with Deakins's past achievements including having Skyfall, The Assassination of Jesse James and O Brother, Where Art Thou? make your eyes pop right out of your head with their sheer beauty. With that in mind, it kind of makes sense that AMPAS would nominate Deakins again this year, in the vague hope that, if he keeps showing up, eventually he'll get given an Oscar for SOMETHING. Still, it's no secret that Deakins's lensing on Angelina Jolie's WWII biopic Unbroken is weaker than his usual stuff. In contrast, regular Paul Thomas Anderson DoP Robert Elswit produced arguably his best ever imagery for Nightcrawler, which is saying something considering he's been responsible for some damn handsome films. Elswit has already won an Oscar for his elegant framing (for There Will Be Blood), but the nocturnal neon desert that LA became in his hands for Nightcrawler should have earned him another nom.

6. Tom Hardy (Locke/The Drop) Instead Of Benedict Cumberbatch (The Imitation Game) - For Best Actor

Tom Hardy is often cited as 'the greatest actor of his generation'. His number of Oscar nominations so far? Zero. Perhaps Bronson, Inception, The Dark Knight Rises, Warrior and Lawless - in all of which Hardy gives blistering, wildly different performances - aren't the type of films to receive much Academy recognition, but Hardy got a little bit more Oscar-friendly this year via a quietly mesmerising turn in gangster flick The Drop and a huge one-man-theatre bit in domestic drama/M6 thriller Locke. Hardy has been getting notice from critics' circles, but for the 2015 Oscar Best Actor nom he's been beaten to the punch, unsurprisingly, by The Imitation Game's Benedict Cumberbatch. Which is, frankly, something of a joke. Not just because Cumberbatch is so uneven in the film (he switches from aloof and arrogant to pained and passionate from one scene to the next), but because his portrayal of Alan Turing isn't even accurate. Whereas Cumberbatch goes vaguely autistic as Turing, channelling Sherlock by way of Mr Spock, the man himself was nothing of the sort. If we're going for Brits to fill Cumberbatch's place, we don't even have to opt for Hardy's superior aforementioneds: Ralph Fiennes, Timothy Spall and Jack O'Connell also missed out to King of the Cumberbitches, despite a revelatory comedic turn in The Grand Budapest Hotel, a career-defining, Cannes-winning performance in Mr. Turner and a raw bit of Hollywood attention grabbing in Unbroken, respectively.

5. Mica Levi (Under The Skin) Instead Of Johann Johansson (The Theory Of Everything) - For Original Score

Every individual piece of Johann Johannsson's The Theory of Everything score sounds basically the same. Seriously, give it a listen, and afterwards try to pick out a single melody from that aural soup. Johannsson's effort is altogether a faintly pleasant plod, but a plod nonetheless, all faux-emotive with its repetitive piano and strings, and sounding a lot like someone was trying to get an Oscar nomination (or, at the very least, to imitate to the point of almost ripping off Dario Marianelli's Oscar-winning score for Atonement). End result: mission accomplished. And so, the genuinely radical scoring of Mica Levi, for Jonathan Glazer's sci-fi mind-blower Under the Skin, has gone unrewarded in the process. Glazer's film may not have been to everyone's taste, but there's no denying that Levi's soundtrack is outstanding: frightening, moving, eerie and thrilling, it's a fluctuating, pulsating score that enhances and perfectly matches Under the Skin's odd skewed-realist imagery. Whereas Levi's Under the Skin soundtrack is new movie scoring at its best, Johannsson's work on The Theory of Everything is scoring at its least imaginative, sounding like it was made by a machine invented solely to produce generic music for historical romances.

4. Ben Mendelsohn (Starred Up) Instead Of Robert Duvall (The Judge) - Best Supporting Actor

Truth be told, there were many, many great supporting male performances to be found in 2014, male side-characters generally continuing to be the most consistently interesting in English-language film. Some of the standouts from last year that would have made good Best Supporting Actor nominees this time around: Robert Pattinson in The Rover, Riz Ahmed in Nightcrawler, Tyler Perry in Gone Girl, Matthias Schoenaerts in The Drop, Toby Kebbell in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes and pretty much everyone running the tank in Fury (yes, including Shia LaBeouf). Rather than choose any of those more obviously Oscar-friendly choices, however, we're going for a leftfield pick that really should have been nominated by now anyway: Ben Mendelsohn. In Starred Up, Mendelsohn expertly plays a veteran prisoner as a conflicted, intimidating alpha, but the Aussie actor could've been nominated for any one of his excellent performances from the past five years, including for Animal Kingdom, Killing Them Softly or The Place Beyond the Pines. At the very least, Mendelsohn's overdue nomination in place of Duvall's 'he might not be around much longer so let's nominate him quick'-safety net vote would have stopped David Dobkin's widely-derided legal drama from getting to call itself "The Oscar-nominated The Judge".

3. The Lego Movie Instead Of Literally Any Of The Competition - Best Animation

It's not that it's necessarily a bad year for Oscar's Animation category. In fact, the overall critical approval rating for the five nominated for Animated Feature Film - that would be Big Hero 6, The Boxtrolls, How to Train Your Dragon 2, Song of the Sea and The Tale of the Princess Kaguya - is high. But not included in that list is one of the very best films of the year, and the movie which, it was assumed, would be Oscar's animated winner in 2015: Phil Lord and Christopher Miller's The Lego Movie. This was a movie about toys working on so many levels that even the Guardian forgot it'd been cooked up to sell Scandinavian building blocks and subsequently included it in their top ten films of 2014 list. It has been suggested that the humour of The Lego Movie was too contemporary to make sense to the majority of Oscar voters, who overall have a median age of 62 (basically think Mickey Rourke trying to enjoy this film and you get the idea). And sure, it's difficult to imagine a bunch of rich, old men would go for the ironic comedy style or approve of the anti-capitalist sentiment of the whole thing, but the beauty of The Lego Movie's animation alone warranted that nomination.

2. Gillian Flynn (Gone Girl) Instead Of Graham Moore (The Imitation Game) - Adapted Screenplay

It would've been nice to have seen some diversity at this year's extremely white, extremely male Oscars (we're talking 129 white nominees to two black nominees, and 116 men to 26 women. Go equality!). But one of the categories in which it seemed likely that girls would actually be allowed, aside from the ones like Best Actress in which AMPAS is inevitably forced to take female humans into account, was Adapted Screenplay. Gillian Flynn seemed a shoo-in for adapting her own novel, Gone Girl, into a lean, intelligent, adult take on married life and the American media for David Fincher. For some reason, though, both screenplay categories this year were revealed to be comprised entirely of white men, meaning Flynn didn't have enough Y chromosome to take part. Few will argue that the scripts for Birdman and Foxcatcher don't deserve to be up for Best Adapted Screenplay, but somehow the bland biopic gruel that is Graham Moore's The Imitation Game screenplay got in over Flynn's stellar work on Gone Girl. That's despite Moore altering the facts, almost whitewashing out the really rather crucial homosexual element of the story and straight-up just making up a new personality for subject Alan Turing from scratch.

1. Rene Russo (Nightcrawler) Instead Of Meryl Streep (Into The Woods) - Best Supporting Actress

Yes, it's true that women over 40 have a hard time in Hollywood. Unless, that is, they're Meryl Streep, in which case they're guaranteed an Oscar nomination every single time they make a movie, regardless of the quality of the film (see: The Iron Lady) or even the quality of the performance (see: August, Osage County). And so, Meryl makes her annual appearance at the Oscars in 2015 for turning up in Disney's singalong-a-Sondheim trashfest Into the Woods, director Rob Marshall's latest attempt to make a relatively adequate film. After three wins and a record 19 Oscar nominations - that's more than any actor or actress in history - it seems fairer to just discount Meryl altogether and give anybody else who's up for it a chance from now on. Rene Russo, for example, would have made a good 'other than Streep' contender for Best Supporting Actress this year. Russo - who is superb as a ruthless yet brittle news station chief in Nightcrawler - has never been nominated for a single Oscar and, at 60-years-old, might never get another chance at a nomination, because any half-decent upcoming role that happens to be available for a woman her age will likely just go to Meryl Streep.

Contributor
Contributor

Lover of film, writer of words, pretentious beyond belief. Thinks Scorsese and Kubrick are the kings of cinema, but PT Anderson and David Fincher are the dashing young princes. Follow Brogan on twitter if you can take shameless self-promotion: @BroganMorris1