9 Violent Mainstream Movie Scenes That Went Too Far

So... much... bloodshed.

Jessica Alba Killer Inside Me
IFC Films

We, as a mainstream moviegoing audience, like to believe there's a tacit agreement between us and the directors of the films we pay to enjoy. When we plop down in front of the screen for those couple of hours, we want to feel something - whether that be a tickled funny bone, a jolted heart, or a croak in our throat - but we don't want to feel too much.

Specifically, we don't want a heavy queasiness in our stomachs that lasts long after we've walked out of the theatre. You know, the kind that comes from witnessing something so vile and disgusting that our brains fight to exorcise the image immediately. Some filmmakers, it turns out, have not received that memo. Or they used it to give someone a paper cut on their eyeball before crumpling it up and eating it. Violence can be a nimble tool in crafting a story, but it can also be a gimmicky trick to fall back on, using it to induce a cheap, visceral reaction from an audience.

The key is deciding what level of brutality is needed to drive the point home, and when it crosses the threshold into excessive and exploitative. All of the scenes on this list are intense. But some of them only tiptoe past the boundary of good taste, while others relish in leapfrogging it by a mile.


9. The Diner Scene Just Can't Help Itself - A History Of Violence

There are moments of ultra-violence in David Cronenberg's film that are both justified and so, so satisfying to the audience's lizard brain. There are others that dwell on the violence seemingly for no other reason than "It's right there in the title, folks." Some scenes just flat out love how disturbing they are.

Take, for instance, the diner scene where we first learn that Viggo Mortensen is a Jason Bourne-esque badass despite his soft-spoken demeanor and Dorothy Hamill hairstyle. Two dipsh*ts try to rob his business, and when he complies, they randomly decide not to just take the money he's already offered them. Instead, they decide they're going to rape one of the waitresses. Why? 'Cause...violence, you guys!

This pushes Viggo into superhero mode, dispatching one bad guy with a coffee pot, and shooting the other several times until he crashes through a glass door. The first bad guy, not quite dead, stabs Viggo in the foot and he retaliates by shooting him in the face. All of which is awesome. But then, for no reason other than "Hey, what if we showed the guy's jaw-less face gurgling to death on his own blood?" they show the guy's jaw-less face gurgling to death on his own blood. One huge step too far, Cronenberg.


8. Alex Murphy Is Relentlessly Shot To A Pulp - RoboCop

RoboCop 1987 Alex Murphy Hand Shot Off
Columbia Pictures

Watching it now, the original Robocop plays as a strange breed of ultra-violent satire and cheesy, pulp fiction. For every scene of unnecessarily graphic dismemberment, there's a scene at Omnicorp that relies entirely on 80s catchphrases that absolutely do not stand the test of time. But the moment that instigates Alex Murphy's transformation into RoboCop still manages a level of revoltion that even the goriest of modern horror movies typically fail to achieve.

It's not the amount of blood, either. When the dad from That 70's Show first blows off Murphy's hand with a shotgun, it's not the sound or the blood splatter or even the casual laughter from the group that makes it stick. It's the look on Murphy's face. It's pure shock. It's fear and bewilderment and dread all rolled into one. It's some of the best acting in the film. But then it goes downhill. Fast.

The rest of the crew dismantles him piece by piece, first shooting off his arm, then putting a constant stream of shotgun shells through his traumatized body while he screams in agony, somehow staying on his feet to collect more and more bullets with his flesh. The barrage lasts for a painful 15 seconds.


7. A Man Gets His Faced Smashed With A Bottle Out Of Nowhere - Pan's Labyrinth

Pan's Labyrinth
Warner Bros. Pictures

Here's a lesson for aspiring filmmakers: When your movie, ostensibly a fairy tale, appears to be for all ages, either refrain from inserting a gratuitous face-stabbing into the middle of it, or advertise the hell out of its adult content. Guillermo del Toro chose something in between, and it was a risky decision that paid off... for the most part.

Throughout Pan's Labyrinth, the director tests just how grim he could make this fantasy, incorporating just as many moments of bone-chilling, violent realism as he does whimsical elements. So it's always hard to tell what the vibe of any given scene is going to be. And so we find the film's most nightmarish monster to be Captain Vidal, a man who hunts down anti-fascist rebels.

One such dissident makes the mistake of being in the wrong place at the wrong time, and is repeatedly smashed in the face with a glass bottle (with disturbingly mechanized strikes) until he dies, while his helpless father watches on. This first act of violence is the most violent and thus, the most efficiently traumatising for any children who happened to follow along with the mostly fantastical plot up until that point.


6. Bunny Bludgeons A Prisoner To Death - Platoon

Platoon Bunny
Universal

When talking about war movies that went overboard with the violence, the first example to come up is always Saving Private Ryan. The opening scenes at Omaha Beach are top-to-bottom carnage, with limbs flying off and thousands of bodies getting shredded by bullets. And yet, somehow, those scenes don't seem as infuriatingly excessive as this one from Platoon.

And it's because Saving Private Ryan had a clear intent with its violence (it's f*cking war), whereas Platoon just wanted the audience to hate one character as much as possible. So the mission is much less noble (and much less subtle). After finding a couple of Vietnamese villagers in hiding, Charlie Sheen's character goes off on them. He shoots at the feet of a physically (and seemingly mentally) disabled man, commanding the one-legged villager to "dance, motherf*cker!"

He then breaks down into hysterics, because his very humanity has just been shaken. It was an oddly beautiful moment of recognition from the character. The scene should have ended there. Unfortunately, the postscript to that moment is much, much worse. Sheen's comrade Bunny, a sadistic meathead played to the hilt by Kevin Dillon, proceeds to beat the villager to death with the butt of his rifle.

Though we only see the weapon strike the man's head once, the ensuing shots of Bunny relishing the beating are even more difficult to take. The fact that no one else steps in to stop it is even more sickening.


5. The Elevator Scene (Obviously) - Drive

2011's Drive is an excellent piece of pop art, with it's hyper-realism and stark color palette creating some very striking, beautifully crafted scenes. This is not quite one of those. While in an elevator with his newfound love interest, Ryan Gosling's character silently expresses his intent to her by embracing her in a deep, warm, Notebook-style kiss.

But there's someone else in the elevator with them. And that man must die. And Driver knows this even before he plants one on his lady. And so the tone switches in a heartbeat to that of intense ultra-violence, Driver bashing this man (whose motivations are intentionally vague) into the wall headfirst, then tossing him to the ground and stomping the ever-loving hell out of his brain bucket. In a matter of seconds, his head is just a pile of skull fragments and torn skin chunks.

Why does he continue his assault after the guy is obviously dead? Is the ability to liquifying someone's face an inherent skill, or was he trained to do this? We don't get those answers. Instead, we just accept someone being stomped on until their heart stops beating and/or their head gets mashed into a chunky pudding because it "looks cool." (Which, to be fair, it totally does.)


4. Relentless Machine Gun Carnage - Rambo

Rambo Machine Gun
Warner Bros

This entire article could be about how off-base the fourth installment in the Rambo series turned out to be. 2008's Rambo was war porn cranked up to the highest decibel level. Whereas the original First Blood painted a picture of war-induced psychological trauma by using violence as a canvas, Rambo says "f*ck all that" and pulls the brain right out of its skull, chucking it through the air like a grenade.

There's no doubt that every Rambo movie needs violence. It is, after all, built into the very DNA of our titular anti-hero. But does any movie need this much violence? It wouldn't be such a problem if the frequent orgies of bloodshed didn't feel like obvious attempts to pad out the runtime to make it a feature-length film, instead of the half hour of overwrought, mumbled dialogue it would have been otherwise.

Gore enthusiasts will find the extended sequence of Rambo mowing down his adversaries with a truck-mounted machine gun a scene worthy to be looped, but everyone else will either be covering their eyes or checking their watches. The fight in the middle of all this that has a pacifist bash an enemy's brains in to save his friends life takes all of 20 seconds, and is a much more effective use of violence.


3. Tony Scott Drags Out Patricia Arquette's Tortorous Fight Scene - True Romance

James Gandolfini and Patricia Arquette put on one of the most grotesque displays of mixed-gender, up-close fighting you're likely to see (if you're lucky, nothing else will even come close to this.) True Romance was written by Quentin Tarantino, though the directing duties fell to Tony Scott, who doesn't have nearly as much staging creativity or restraint as Tarantino when it comes to filming violence.

The Reservoir Dogs' torture scene is a stiff, Victorian-era period piece compared to the hyper-violent lunacy of this fight. At almost every point in this scene, most of the audience is just waiting for this to be over so we can cheer when Arquette walks away. And we know that's going to happen, yet Tony Scott refuses to let her (or us) off that easy.

He literally throws everything he's got at her, making what would be an uncomfortable fight scene between two guys even more cold-blooded by brutalizing a woman. It shouldn't matter what genders are involved, obviously, except that Scott is constantly taunting us with it, having Gandolfini call her "baby" in between choking her and smashing her head into a wall, all while focusing on Arquette's cleavage in many of these shots.


2. Nicky Watches His Brother Beaten To A Pulp - Casino

Mob movies are typically forgiven for containing what might otherwise be considered a gratuitous amount of bloodshed, because the film simply wouldn't be a realistic portrayal of that world without it. All the classics feature a heavy dose of extreme violence: Goodfellas, The Godfather II, Scarface, even The Departed.

But none can hold a candle to the stomach-turning displays of sadism inflicted on the characters of Martin Scorsese's Casino. Although the scene of Joe Pesci's character interrogating a guy by squeezing his head in a vice is pretty gruesome, there's an underlying element of dark humor to it that makes the whole thing a little more palatable. Not so for the scene in which Pesci and his onscreen brother are relentlessly bludgeoned to within an inch of their lives with aluminum baseball bats.

Pesci's brother is the first to get worked over, and the sound of metal striking bone reverberates with a sickening thud. It's made so much worse by the fact that Pesci is made to watch the whole thing. He's completely helpless, and that translates over to the audience, as well. By the time they start pounding away on Pesci, even Scorsese has enough sense to know that we've seen enough, and mercifully cuts away after a few swings.


1. Casey Affleck Beats Jessica Alba For Two Minutes - The Killer Inside Me

We'd already witnessed Jessica Alba's character get whipped by a belt way too hard for way too long, but that was okay because she turned out to be into the whole bondage thing. It was a pleasurable kind of pain.

That rationale doesn't fly in this scene, which might be the most nauseating beating ever inserted into a motion picture. I'd provide the context of the scene, but it doesn't even matter. Casey Affleck beats Jessica Alba within an inch of her life for an unflinching two minutes. Every punch is shown in precise, graphic detail. It's truly hard to even describe the scene, because the images of it will forever send my stomach into backflips. He beats her so hard that he is physically drained after it's over.

That's really all you need to know about it. That, and Jessica Alba's face is a bloody, disfigured mess of crooked bones and swollen skin. Warning: Because I value the readers of WhatCulture and prefer not to inflict emotional scarring on anyone, I have to seriously recommend that only those of you with the strongest of stomachs watch the following clip. It makes the rest of the article look like child's play.

What other times did mainstream movies overstep the limits of violence? If your stomach can take it, head down to the comments and join the discussion.


Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.