9 Worst Billion Dollar Movies

Which members of the billion-dollar club deserve to be excluded the most?

Jurassic World Fallen Kingdom T Rex
Universal

At the start of this century, only one film - Titanic - had grossed over a billion dollars. Now? 36 films have crossed a billion worldwide and this tally is only looking set to increase.

As Incredibles 2 joins the billion-dollar ranks as member number 36, it's a good time to look back on all these ridiculously successful movies. The billion dollar club is definitely film's most exclusive club, but are the films in it deserving of their high grosses? For the most part, yes, but there are some glaring exceptions. There are a bunch of them which prove that high box office revenue doesn't mean high quality.

Such movies definitely did not deserve to have made so much money, but then again, a film's box office gross is very, very rarely dictated by its quality. Given how disappointing these films are and how expensive going to the cinema is, it's mysterious that so many people actually went and wasted their money on such undeserving movies.

These 9 movies are the billion dollar club's worst members to date and despite them being so successful, they certainly aren't too well-liked by many of the people that paid to view them.

9. Avengers: Age Of Ultron

Avengers Age Of Ultron Hulkbuster Hulk
Marvel Studios

Ranking: #8

Worldwide Earnings: $1,405,403,694

First things first: Avengers Age of Ultron isn't a terrible movie but given the generally high standards of the billion-dollar club, it's certainly one of the club's worst members.

Age of Ultron is an insultingly safe, wildly over-stuffed and generally personality-free blockbuster that does little more than serve up one overdone set piece after another without giving its characters meaningful things to do or raising any stakes in the narrative. Worst of all, it's an entirely inconsequential movie that added nothing to the ongoing narrative of the MCU. Out of the franchise ranking, it's the 4th worst; only Thor, Iron Man 2 and Thor: The Dark World are below it.

This was a 2015 movie, a year which added five billion dollar movies (this, The Force Awakens, Jurassic World, Furious 7 and Minions) to the club, which is more than any other year.

Age of Ultron summarizes 2015 well; it was the year of over-hyped blockbusters that largely disappointed, with this, Spectre and Jurassic World embarrassingly being out-done by Furious 7 and Mission Impossible 5. Even in a year full of let-downs, Age of Ultron was arguably the most disappointing film of that year.


8. Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom

Jurassic World Fallen Kingdom Jeff Goldblum
Universal

Ranking: #15

Worldwide Earnings: $1,235,455,500

We were all crossing our fingers but we all knew that, with a tragic inevitability, Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom would cross the billion-dollar mark. Indeed, it has and it was the 35th member of the club. Is it a worthy one? No.

It may have offered some good spectacle here and there, featured two good villains and turned Bryce Dallas Howard's Claire Dearing, previously one of the worst film characters of the decade, into a solid character, but other than that this is a laughably stupid and generally rote film which lacks the spirit and adventurous charm of the original; instead it feels like a generic science-fiction Hollywood product that happens to feature dinosaurs.

Any movie that brings in the ridiculously lovable Jeff Goldblum, reprising one of his best parts no less, for a meaningless two-minute cameo definitely deserves to end up on this kind of list.

After Jurassic World 3, the franchise needs to be put to rest. After four under-done sequels which failed to learn anything from each other's mistakes, we've had enough. Universal: we gave you four chances and you blew it. We'd much rather just re-watch the original on repeat.


7. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey

THE HOBBIT  AN UNEXPECTED JOURNEY Bilbo
New Line Cinema

Ranking: #34

Worldwide Earnings: $1,021,103,568

After The Return of the King became the second ever billion-dollar movie nearly a decade earlier, The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey reached similar heights at the box office, which just shows that high revenue doesn't indicate quality. After all, the worst Middle Earth film by some distance is the second highest-grossing of the lot.

Lacking the genuine perfection of the Lord of the Rings trilogy, which is still arguably the best Hollywood franchise of All Time or the exhilarating spectacle of both of its follow-ups (which were improvements), this one is a major chore to sit through. It's less an epic adventure, more a seemingly endless trudge through some forests.

Like Age of Ultron and Fallen Kingdom, it's not a terrible film since the final act is pretty epic and the performances are largely superb, but it's fatally undone by its indifferent script and terrible pacing. Rather than being thrilling, it's often numbingly boring.

This was such a disappointment that neither of the subsequent two grossed as much, which is hardly surprising. To make a trilogy of three-hour movies out of a 300 page book has to be one of the worst Hollywood decisions in recent memory.


6. Alice In Wonderland

Alice In Wonderland
Disney

Ranking: #32

Worldwide Gross: $1,025,467,110

Why is this a billion dollar movie? Does anyone even know?

It may have been based on a beloved children's book and had Johnny Depp and Tim Burton (back when both were still well-liked) on-board, but even so, there's no real explanation to why this ended up being the 5th highest grossing movie ever at one point.

Essentially, this was a random movie that somehow destroyed the box office without anyone really liking it very much. It isn't quite as terrible as some say it is and it also has one of Johnny Depp's better recent performances, but that's far from a recommendation.

Both hyper-active and portentous, this is an explosion of admittedly great style that lacks enough substance to anchor it in a tolerable manner, resulting in a complete mess that's not an awful lot better than an already forgettable Disney animated movie.

It's sequel, released six years later, was a major box-office bomb, hinting that no-one really cared for the original. The mystery of why this was such a huge hit is a difficult one to decipher.


5. Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace

Star Wars Episode I The Phantom Menace
Lucasfilm

Ranking: #31

Worldwide Earnings: $1,027,044,677

This was more or less the most anticipated movie in the history of cinema. It was a staggering success and was the second highest-grossing film ever for a little while (after Titanic). A 3D re-release in 2012 brought the worldwide gross over a billion.

The Phantom Menace did leave many viewers heart-broken and disappointed and it's still regarded as the poster-child for disappointing movies. Now that it's nearly 20 years old, we can look upon it fairly and... yes, it's still underwhelming.

It is not without its moments, but even if it's not as bad as Star Wars: The Clone Wars or Solo: A Star Wars Story, it's still the worst of the main series. The dialogue is atrocious, emotional drama or humor is non-existent, it's full of irritating characters, it's positively drowning in dated CGI and worst of all it's just a dull story about trade routes which, aside from Anakin Skywalker being found, barely affects the saga at all.

It remains a major disappointment and this misjudged, often wooden and occasionally racist prequel is full of awful moments; the first half prior to the pod-race is often unwatchable.


4. Avatar

Avatar Sam Worthington
20th Century Fox

Ranking: #1

Worldwide Earnings: $2,787,965,087

The highest grossing film ever with a $600-million lead over second place movie Titanic, Avatar drew us all in since it promised - and delivered - a cinematic spectacle unlike anything else ever filmed. After conquering the world, everyone turned on it, just like with Titanic 12 years earlier, but this time the backlash is entirely justified.

Avatar doesn't really work as a movie. It's a huge shame since the special effects are amazing and there are some interesting themes lurking in there, so this movie did have plenty of potential, but it is unfortunately a failure. It's a noble failure, but it's still a failure.

Boasting a bland plot, a clunky script and a terrible lead performance from Sam Worthington, not to mention a ridiculously bloated length, Avatar simply doesn't hold up on a smaller screen at all. It is almost impossible to find anyone who actually likes this movie nowadays and that's hardly surprising. To be honest, when James Cameron does finally release those Avatar sequels he's currently wasting a decade of his life on (just think what other projects he could've been doing instead), it's quite likely they'll under-perform at the box office.


3. Transformers: Dark Of The Moon

Transformers Dark Of The Moon Bumblebee
Paramount Pictures

Ranking: #19

Worldwide Earnings: $1,123,794,079

This third installment is still the most successful of the endlessly-maligned Transformers series and, with hindsight, it is surprising that this turned out to be a billion dollar movie. After all, it was following Revenge of the Fallen, which is arguably one of the worst films ever made, but for some reason audiences still went back for more.

Dark of the Moon is far better than Revenge of the Fallen, but then again most films are. It is lifted up considerably by the amazing Battle of Chicago finale, which is definitely some of the best directing Michael Bay has ever done and lasts for a full half-hour, but the rest of the film lacks a lot.

Before the great finale, you've got two hours of immature humor, terrible plotting, appalling acting, offensive material and surprisingly few memorable action scenes, so it's much better just to watch the final battle and skip the rest of the movie.

At one point in time this was the 4th highest-grossing movie ever, which is a rather distressing statistic.


2. Pirates Of The Caribbean: On Stranger Tides

Pirates Of The Caribbean Jack Sparrow On Stranger Tides
Disney

Ranking: #27

Worldwide Earnings: $1,045,713,802

It's safe to say very few people will disagree with this one.

A movie hated by nearly everyone, On Stranger Tides is the fourth Pirates of the Caribbean film. Dead Man's Chest and At World's End have been trashed far too much over the years and are actually alright, but this one fully earned the backlash.

On Stranger Tides' main issue is that it's just too bland. There's hardly any good action and humor or pathos are non-existent, making this one of the most indifferent viewing experiences imaginable. Even the crazy psycho killer-mermaids are complete bores.

As for Johnny Depp's Captain Jack Sparrow, even he isn't fun to watch anymore in this movie and given that he was being paid an obscene $55 million for the movie, he could've at least put some effort in. Meanwhile, Penelope Cruz is wasted in a dull love interest role and, similarly, in one of his rare film outings TV veteran Ian McShane is stuck playing a very uninspiring Blackbeard.

Speaking of money, this is the most expensive film ever made and cost around $400 million to make. What a terrible waste.


1. Transformers: Age Of Extinction

Transformers Age Of Extinction Optimus And Grimlock 1700x956
Paramount Pictures

Ranking: #22

Worldwide Earnings: $1,104,054,072

Many are likely to agree that Age of Extinction is the worst billion-dollar movie. Why wouldn't they?

It might have some decent scenes and solid performances here and there, but this is pretty much everything we've come to expect from the Transformers films - excessive action, bad writing, mechanical storytelling, offensive humor and general overkill on every level - but this time with different actors and stretched out to 165 minutes.

It's truly inexplicable that this ended up being a billion dollar movie, since the Transformers films are widely hated and there surely aren't enough fans of such weak material to make it so ridiculously successful. The fact that this was the highest grossing film of 2014, beating out an actually great box office top ten, is extremely upsetting.

This movie is just nearly three hours of empty spectacle that's more draining and depressing than fun and aside from the hilariously obvious product placement, there's no joy to be had from watching this.

Age of Extinction is, without a shadow of a doubt, the worst billion-dollar movie. Hopefully nothing this underwhelming will ever join the billion-dollar club again, but only time will tell.


Contributor

Film Studies graduate, aspiring screenwriter and all-around nerd who, despite being a pretentious cinephile who loves art-house movies, also loves modern blockbusters and would rather watch superhero movies than classic Hollywood films. Once met Tommy Wiseau.