A Star Is Born Review: 7 Ups & 2 Downs

A major Oscar contender.

A Star Is Born Bradley Cooper Lady Gaga
Warner Bros.

Bradley Cooper's A Star is Born hits cinemas worldwide this week, and while it's easy to be sceptical about this being the third remake of the 1937 romantic drama, Cooper has categorically proven there's life left in the story yet.

Critics have been lavishing praise on the movie and with damn fine reason: it succeeds as both a powerful musical showcase and a heart-rending drama, and is sure to be a major player in the upcoming awards race.

While the movie would ultimately be a disappointingly safe pick for the Best Picture Oscar, it's clear the film is a front-runner in countless categories, and is likely to walk away with at least a few Academy Awards (and a truckload of nominations, no doubt).

Straddled expertly between crowd-pleasing musical drama and something a little darker and more artistic, A Star is Born is sure to please both mainstream audiences and those who like their movies a little more hard-edged.

If you were worried it'd end up as nothing more than cynical Oscar-bait, fear not: this is a legitimately great film in its own right, Oscars be-damned...


Downs...

2. Lady Gaga's Too Attractive To Be A "Plain Jane"

A Star Is Born Lady Gaga
Warner Bros.

A small but undeniable nitpick about the movie is the decision to make Lady Gaga's protagonist Ally a "plain" woman who has been rejected countless times by music executives for not being pretty enough.

While to a point this feels tied to the movie's commentary about the superficiality of the pop music industry, not to mention Ally's own low self-esteem, it's also clear Ally's supposed to be incredibly average-looking.

This is, of course, completely comical, and while it's thankfully not a point the movie labours too much, it's still a bit of a groaner that an obviously conventionally attractive woman is supposed to be "just OK" in the eyes of the viewer.


1. It Feels A Bit Rushed

Ally and Jackson A Star Is Born
Warner Bros.

A Star is Born is not a short movie by any stretch, clocking in at 135 minutes, but there are certainly moments that feel a little too rushed given their storytelling importance.

After a methodical and engrossing first act that brings shy singer Ally and alcoholic rock star Jackson Maine (Cooper) together, act two quickly rushes through Ally's rise to stardom, and it feels like some of the key beats were basically glossed over.

This was most likely an editorial decision to keep the movie from feeling too bloated, especially as we've all seen these rise-to-fame stories countless times before, but even so, it all just feels a little too easy, and the passage of time is too breathless for its own good.

So, some fairly minor quibbles in the grand scheme of things, then. On the other hand, here's everything the film gets right...


Ups...

7. Bradley Cooper & Lady Gaga's Oscar-Worthy Performances

A Star Is Born Bradley Cooper Lady Gaga
Warner Bros.

Early next year, Lady Gaga might well be an Oscar winner, and that's no joke. Her performance as Ally transcends her obvious label as a singer-turned-actress, giving an expectedly soulful, heartfelt series of musical renditions, but also delivering the dramatic goods just as passionately.

It's a crowd-pleasing performance that's likely to make her a Best Actress front-runner, and given her appeal worldwide, it wouldn't be remotely surprising if she won the award outright.

Though she's sure to win the lion's share of the critical praise, Bradley Cooper meanwhile delivers his best performance to date here, digging deep into a self-destructive artist while mostly skirting around typical substance abuse cliches. If his previous Oscar nominations felt a little soft, his inevitable nomination here feels incredibly well-earned.

Together, the pair's chemistry is the primary reason the movie works as well as it does despite the evident familiarity of the material.


6. The Spine-Tingling Music

Ally Piano A Star Is Born
Warner Bros.

You don't need to be a fan of Lady Gaga's music or pop music in general to appreciate the hair-raising appeal of the songs on offer here.

Some of the lesser songs do fall into the category of fairly disposable pop fare - though during Ally's ascent into over-produced, chart-topping success, that's clearly the point - but her early rendition of "Shallow" is chillingly beautiful and pretty much guaranteed to win the Best Original Song Oscar already.

That's to say nothing of the closing song, "I'll Never Love Again", an already soul-stirring tune which is lent even more emotional weight by Cooper's impeccable editing and direction.

Needless to say, the soundtrack for this movie is going to make some crazy bank.


5. It's A Stunning Directorial Debut For Bradley Cooper

A Star Is Born Bradley Cooper
Warner Bros.

A Star is Born is Bradley Cooper's directorial debut, but from the sheer artistry and confidence on display here, you'd never guess it. Clearly working with the likes of David O. Russell and Clint Eastwood over the years has rubbed off on Cooper, because this is one of the most persuasive and well-constructed major debuts in years.

From his dynamic coverage of the musical numbers to his fearless decision to linger long on extensive dialogues in-between, it's the furthest thing from a phoned-in directing job, and it's hard to imagine him not scooping a Best Director nomination as a result.

Given the heaps of praise his filmmaking has already earned, hopefully we won't be left waiting too long for him to get back behind the camera.


4. The Sharp Commentary On Fame & The Music Industry

Ally Studio A Star Is Born
Warner Bros.

It would've been a majorly missed opportunity for a film like this not to take some shots at the celebrity condition, and that it most certainly does.

As Jackson talks to Ally about the weirdness of people only referring to him by his full name and we see people taking "creepshots" of him with their phones, one suspects there's more than a little truth stemming from Cooper's own experiences with fame.

Once Ally's success takes hold, the film also riffs in a broad sense on the soullessness of the pop music industry, with Ally's enterprising manager Rez (Rafi Gavron) cementing just how superficial and trend-focused it can be. This is juxtaposed against the weathered, cynical mindset of Jackson, who has already been in Ally's position years before, and wants to pry her away from it.

It's especially interesting as Gaga herself is of course part of the pop music sausage factory - undeniably talented though she is - so it lends the film an added layer of self-reflexiveness.


3. Sam Elliott's Excellent Supporting Performance

Jackson and Bobby Maine A Star Is Born
Warner Bros.

Though Gaga and Cooper are basically guaranteed Oscar nominations at this point, hopefully the Academy won't forget the wonderful supporting work from the brilliant Sam Elliott.

Elliott plays Bobby Maine, Jackson's older brother and manager, and while he doesn't have a huge part in the movie, he makes every second of his screen time count. He has several emotionally charged encounters opposite Cooper throughout the film, and they're among the finest work the actor's ever done in his storied career.

It'd be great to see him recognised with a Best Supporting Actor nomination, especially as the 74-year-old acting legend has somehow never been nominated before.


2. Matthew Libatique's Fantastic Cinematography

A Star Is Born Lady Gaga
Warner Bros.

This will likely see veteran cinematographer Matthew Libatique score his second Best Cinematography nomination, after scooping his first for Black Swan in 2011.

Libatique, who made a name for himself working with Darren Aronofsky, does a splendid job making the film feel visually dynamic despite the obvious familiarity of the story and the environments within.

The lighting during the musical performances is especially splendid, yet even the most simple, stripped-down dialogues are ravishingly filmed. Libatique and Cooper also ensured to have the lighting reflect Jackson's mood and sobriety (or lack thereof) throughout the film, yet it's done in a subtle, unpretentious way that doesn't draw overt attention to itself.

It's not showy cinematography on the level of, say, any film lensed by Roger Deakins, so it probably won't win the Oscar outright - Alfonso CuarĂ³n probably will for Roma - but a nomination seems pretty damn likely.


1. The Emotionally Devastating Third Act

A Star Is Born Bradley Cooper Lady Gaga
Warner Bros.

If you've seen any of the prior versions of this story, you'll know that it ends on a heartbreaking note, and Cooper does a fantastic job delivering arguably the most affecting finale from any of the iterations to date.

Tying together Jackson and Ally's relationship, Jackson's substance abuse issues and Ally's rise to fame, the climax is a work of impeccable tonal balance, going to some incredibly unsettling places but still finding hope in the power of music and the human spirit.

It's an ending which bolsters the movie as great rather than merely very good, committing firmly to the darker aspects of the original story and refusing to scale things back for commercial reasons as you might've expected.

Needless to say, you might wanna bring tissues to this one.

Are you excited for A Star is Born? If you've seen it already, what did you think? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.