Alan Rickman: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

The late, great actor had his misses as well as his hits.

alan rickman eye in the sky
Entertainment One

Let there be no mistake right away: there's only one thing that truly sucks about Alan Rickman, and that's the fact that he's no longer with us. When the British acting legend died in January, just over a month shy of his 70th birthday, the mass outpouring of grief that ensued had more than a hint of anger about it. Cancer had robbed us of yet another great. This man had brought so much joy to the world, and he surely had so more left to give.

Movies, it should be emphasised, were only a part of his body of work. Having initially enjoyed a successful career in graphic design, it wasn't until his mid-20s that Rickman opted to pursue the actor's life, studying at RADA and working extensively in theatre. Appropriately for a relative late bloomer, he didn't make his first movie until he was 42 - and that big screen debut would prove to be the role he is most fondly remembered for.

With Rickman's final live-action performance in military drama Eye In the Sky now in cinemas, and his final voice performance in Disney's Alice Through The Looking Glass on its way, what better time to look back over his filmography? And as you would expect of a national treasure, it's mightily impressive. Even in his perhaps less worthy cinematic endeavours, Rickman found a way of bringing his anarchic sensibilities into play, remaining inherently fun to watch even when much of what was going on around him was operating at a lower level.

Still, like any prolific jobbing actor, Rickman didn't necessarily manage to hit the nail square on the head every single time. Sometimes he took roles which were really too far beneath him, in films that didn't work. There were even a few instances in which he was simply miscast. He may have undeniably been one of the greats - but that doesn't mean everything he ever did was good.

With the release of Eye In The Sky in UK cinemas today which features his final live-action performance (he does voice the Blue Caterpillar once more in the forthcoming Alice Through The Looking Glass), let's first take a look at the true jewels in Rickman's celluloid crown, before contemplating the mud on his shoes.


5 Awesome Performances...

5. Snape - Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows Part 2

snape harry potter deathly hallows part 2
Warner Bros.

What a rollercoaster ride the Harry Potter movies proved to be. When Rickman was first cast as Professor Snape in 2001, it was easy to assume he'd yet again been typecast as a villain. JK Rowling was still only four books into the series at the time, and as such there was a lot we had left to learn about the sour-faced ex-Death Eater.

Rickman himself famously contested the charge that he constantly played villains, preferring to consider them 'unsympathetic characters' with greater complexities than your standard, clear cut good guy/bad guy material. This is most emphatically the case with Snape - and it's in Deathly Hallows Part 2 that the character's true face is finally revealed.

While he may never have been what anyone would call a nice guy, it packs a real emotional punch to finally learn what has been motivating Snape the entire time, and the unthinkable decisions he forced himself to make in the name of the greater good. These scenes might easily have veered toward sentimentality, but in the very capable hands of Rickman and director David Yates, things never get too gooey.


4. Metatron - Dogma

alan rickman dogma
Film4

One of Rickman's greatest strengths was his openness to taking risks, and it's fair to say it might have been deemed a risky move for a respected big name actor to take a supporting role in a satirical fantasy from a writer-director best known for ultra lo-fi indie comedies. And that's to say nothing of how controversial the subject matter proved to be.

1999's Dogma was Kevin Smith's fourth film, and 15 years on it remains one of his strangest (although man-walrus horror Tusk has surely pushed it back into second place). Drawing heavily on Smith's Catholic upbringing, it casts Rickman as the angel Metatron, who comes to Earth to charge Linda Fiorentino's Bethany with a holy crusade to stop Ben Affleck and Matt Damon's exiled angels from re-entering Heaven.

In many respects, Rickman's casting is yet another instance of an American movie casting a British actor to deliver all the exposition, because those limeys always seem so good at it. Happily, this being a Smith film, Rickman is given plenty to have fun with, with a fair quota of ribaldry mixed in among the Biblical portends. And considering that Metatron's official title is 'the voice of God,' it's very pleasing indeed that Rickman opted to bring him to life with vocal mannerisms highly reminscent of British comedy legend Frankie Howerd.


3. Harry - Love Actually

alan rickman love actually
Universal Pictures

One of the great 'what ifs' of Rickman's career is the question of how differently his career might have played out if he'd accepted the lead in Four Weddings and a Funeral. It's hard to imagine now given how synoymous Hugh Grant is with the role, but Rickman had been the first choice for Charles. Instead, his first and only Richard Curtis rom-com role would be in the 2003 ensemble piece Love Actually, in what would prove one of the stand-out threads in the multi-protagonist tale.

While we might not necessarily class Harry as a villain, he absolutely fits Rickman's 'unsympathetic character' category, as the happily married man tempted into an affair with his younger secretary. No excuses are made for his behaviour, and it's made abundantly clear his wife (an also brilliant Emma Thompson) has done nothing to hurt him, and yet Harry is never painted as a bad person; he's only human, with all the flaws that entails.

Given how accustomed we are to seeing Rickman in showy, scenery-chewing roles, it's quite striking seeing him tackle something so grounded, with his trademark sneer notable by its almost complete absence.


2. Sheriff Of Nottingham - Robin Hood: Prince Of Thieves

alan rickman robin hood
Warner Bros.

By all rights, Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves is not a film people should still be talking about 25 years later. It's a trashy, overblown Hollywood take on a classic tale with a bland central performance from a painfully miscast Kevin Costner, and almost everyone involved seems to be taking it all far too seriously.

Note that I said almost everyone. Happily, the one key figure treating the whole endeavour with the respect it deserves - i.e. none - is Alan Rickman. His gloriously cartoonish performance as chief villain the Sheriff of Nottingham is quite rightly held up as one of his best, and it saves the movie completely.

Famously, Rickman turned down the role several times, before accepting on the condition that he have carte blanche to reinterpret the character and change his dialogue as he saw fit. This he did, reportedly rewriting chunks of the script over pizza with his friends Ruby Wax and Peter Barnes; and it's that meal we have to thank for so many of the Sheriff's unforgettable barbed-tongue witticisms. ("Call off Christmas!" "I'm gonna cut your heart out with a spoon!" And so on.)


1. Hans Gruber - Die Hard

20th Century Fox

Yes, as hard as it may be to believe, the key role that made Rickman a movie legend was his first ever feature film. But while he may have been a novice on a Hollywood film set, few of us could have any doubts that he knew exactly what he was doing.

28 years on, Die Hard remains one of the greatest action movies ever made, for many good reasons: the simplicity of the set-up, the heightened tension of the one night setting, and the humanity and vulnerability of Bruce Willis' John McClane. But if you're going by the maxim that an action movie is only ever as good as its villain, there's no truer example of that than Rickman's Hans Gruber.

The softly spoken, well-dressed, cultured and intelligent terrorist-turned-large scale thief is a magnificent nemesis for Willis' all-American blue collar hero, and Rickman's relish in bringing him to life positively oozes off the screen. Much as the movie provided a blueprint for most of the action cinema to follow in the 1990s, Rickman's performance set a benchmark for big screen bad guys which few have even come close to meeting since.

Read on for Rickman's 5 that sucked...


And 5 That Sucked...

5. Shabandar - Gambit

alan rickman gambit
CBS Films

Colin Firth, Cameron Diaz and Alan Rickman, working from a script by the Coen Brothers? Sounds like a slam-dunk, wouldn't you say? Sadly no. While it's hardly the worst movie you'll ever see, Gambit winds up bitterly disappointing because it's simply nowhere near as good as it should have been, on any level.

A remake of a 1966 Michael Caine movie, Gambit boasts a promising enough set-up, as Firth's put-upon fine art consultant, tired of getting abuse from his megalomaniacal media tycoon boss Rickman (yes, another kind-of bad guy role), plots an elaborate revenge on his employer involving a fake Monet and Diaz's Texan cowgirl. It all hinges on broadly drawn caricatures, and old-fashioned farcical humour which simply doesn't gel somehow.

It isn't necessarily that Rickman's performance as the despicable billionaire is really all that bad; it's more of a let-down that his natural charisma isn't enough to elevate the material. When the bulk of his big comedy moments hinge upon him being naked with his most intimate parts humourously concealed by random objects, it's clear that the film probably isn't aiming high enough - and considering the calibre of talent on board, that's a tremendous shame.


4. Marvin - The Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy

marvin hitchhikers guide
Buena Vista Pictures

Another instance of a movie which cast Alan Rickman in a supporting role, and didn't wind up being anywhere near as good as it should have. Douglas Adams' much-loved sci-fi satire had been realised brilliantly on radio, television and in novels, and a movie version had been long overdue, but faced with such a legacy to live up to, director Garth Jennings' film struggled to find its own identity.

Rickman's voiceover work as Marvin the Paranoid Android is a symptom of this overall problem, rather than a cause. While it's not hard to see why he would be deemed a good fit for the perpetually depressed artificial intelligence, he ultimately doesn't do much beyond delivering the lines in a standard Alan Rickman voice, and this doesn't prove enough to make the character as truly funny as it had the potential to be.

This is by no means the only disappointing movie to which Rickman lent his pipes either: he also voiced the Blue Caterpillar in Tim Burton's bloated live-action Alice in Wonderland (a role reprised in the upcoming Alice Through The Looking Glass), and even featured in the supremely substandard 2000 animation Help! I'm A Fish, AKA A Fish Tale.


3. Ed - The January Man

alan rickman january man
MGM

Sometimes, as in Dogma, throwing lots of weird stuff together makes for a fascinating and enjoyably off-the-wall movie. Other times, it makes for something as plainly and simply dumb as 1989's The January Man.

A peculiar mix of generic police procedural and broad comedy, it casts Kevin Kline in the lead as the cop on the trail of a serial killer with a ridiculously complex and specific pattern which somehow manages to incorporate prime numbers, star charts, calendars and old show tunes. Rickman co-stars as his comic relief roommate, a predictably quirky and wine-sozzled artist, who conveniently proves a dab hand at computers which aids Kline's investigation in an improbable way (not that anything about the film is especially probable).

Rickman isn't given much to do beyond standing in Kline's shadow, and despite the obvious talents of both men (not to mention Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio, with whom Rickman who reunite two years later in Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves), it just doesn't work at all. Roger Ebert might have been a tad harsh in declaring it "one of the worst movies of all time," but it certainly isn't very good.


2. Phil Allen - Blow Dry

alan rickman blow dry
Miramax

I'll admit, there's a clear pattern here: it isn't that Alan Rickman is necessarily that bad in Blow Dry, but rather it's the film itself that's the problem.

The Full Monty screenwriter Simon Beaufoy attempts to create a similar crowd-pleaser by telling the story of a national hair-dressing contest set in West Yorkshire, with a cast of actors from elsewhere putting on mostly unconvincing accents, amomg them two young pretty Americans (Josh Hartnett failing abysmally to sound Yorkshire, and Rachel Leigh Cook not even trying), for no discernible reason but the hope of selling more tickets. All things considered, Blow Dry is indicative of everything that was wrong with the British film industry in the early 2000s (and it has by no means completely redeemed itself since).

Still, as Rickman was always a risk-taker, it's not entirely surprising he'd be up for playing a Yorkshire hairdresser caught up in a bitter rivalry with a flamboyant Bill Nighy, but it all just comes off as a rather tepid retread of innumerable similarly themed movies, from the aforementioned Full Monty to Strictly Ballroom and countless others.

But at least Rickman got the accent right, which is more than can be said for most of his co-stars. (I'm from Yorkshire myself, which might explain why I'm particularly picky on the subject.)


1. Elliot Marston - Quigley Down Under

quigley down under alan rickman
MGM

He's fondly remembered as one of cinema's best bad guy actors, but as we've seen Rickman actually didn't play the bad guy many times. Back in March 2015, he reportedly told Den of Geek that he'd only been a villain twice, presumably referring to his best known roles of Gruber and the Sheriff. However, it would seem Rickman himself had forgotten one other villainous role: that of Elliot Marston in 1990's Quigley Down Under.

And if Rickman had indeed forgotten all about that, we certainly shouldn't hold it against him. It's entirely understandable that he might have wanted to erase this particular film from his memory.

As previously stated, one of Rickman's greatest strengths was his unwillingness to play it safe, and his preference for nuanced characters. Seeing him in this film, then, as a completely two-dimensional bad guy facing off against a hero who clearly outmatches him in every respect, is disheartening in the extreme.

It's a rather odd film to begin with, casting Tom Selleck in the title role as a sharp-shooting cowboy who travels to Australia at the promise of a job from Rickman's Marston, but finds himself at odds with the tyrannical British landowner.

Rickman just seems bored out of his mind throughout, and one suspects that his later reluctance to play the Sheriff of Nottingham - and his insistence on being allowed to make that role his own - may have had something to do with what a dull, thankless part he got laboured with in this dull, thankless movie, which has long since been quite rightly confined to the landfill site of film history.


Contributor
Contributor

Ben Bussey hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.