Aliens vs. Predators: Ranking The Films From Worst To Best

This year marks the 35th anniversary of Ridley Scott’s Alien, but which in the saga is the best?

It€™s hard to believe, but this year marks the 35th anniversary of Ridley Scott€™s Alien. Since giving birth to one of cinema€™s most iconic creatures, the franchise went on to spawn three more sequels, a prequel and two crossovers with another iconic creature: the Predator. That series, which kicked off in 1987, was followed by two sequels of its own, while both franchises, separately and together, have churned out comic books, novels, video games and countless other merchandise. Fans still debate over the films€™ positives and negatives, can spout out quote after quote and continue to imagine what the future may hold. With their popularity still strong, it€™s only a matter of time before both series rear their heads again. Across ten films, both franchises have had their ups and downs, with the gems shining bright and the duds being nothing short of explosive disasters. So with 35 years of film history since it all began, what better opportunity to pit the two franchises together to see which one comes out on top?

10. Aliens vs. Predator: Requiem (2007)

Disappointing isn€™t the right word to aptly describe the release of 2007€™s disastrous Aliens vs. Predator: Requiem. With the bar for the potential of crossover films starring the titular creatures having been set pretty low by 2004€™s Alien vs. Predator, it€™s amazing how Requiem succeeds in setting it even lower, effectively ending the spinoff franchise before it ever really took off despite its inherent prospects. Armed with an R rating allowing for the series to embrace its gorier aspects and with someone having been bound to notice what worked and didn€™t work in its predecessor, Requiem should€™ve been able to step up as a sequel to provide a grittier, nastier and far more epic battle between the Predators and the Aliens in comparison by virtue of the fact it had nowhere to go but up. Unfortunately, taking the film down a darker path simply meant turning the lighting almost completely off, obscuring large portions of the film from even being visible. Chances are, unless you happen to be watching the film while reading this or you€™re one of the film€™s three or four fans, you probably don€™t remember much about Requiem beyond how it squanders the intriguing Predalien introduced in the first film€™s closing moments. It€™s a neat design and an interesting concept wasted in an abysmal film that doesn€™t even manage to offer a single unforgettable moment or character to at least contribute something of value to either franchise. Requiem is an apt subtitle for marking the death of a franchise that could€™ve and should€™ve been so much more.

9. Alien vs. Predator (2004)

After gestating for years at 20th Century Fox in the wake of the popular comic book series that brought the two icons together and a brief appearance of a Xenomorph skull on the Predator ship in 1990€™s Predator 2 having led fans€™ imaginations to run wild for over a decade about the possibility of seeing the two onscreen together, Alien vs. Predator finally hit theaters in 2004 to a lukewarm response. Although the film attempts to nobly take a slow-burn approach early on to set up its human characters and premise, including the presence of Alien franchise vet Lance Henriksen as a way to tie Weyland Industries into the affairs, none of it is interesting or endearing, which makes the anticipation of getting to the action overshadow everything. When the Predators and Aliens finally step into the picture for good, there's an inherent novelty to it all that makes it entertaining for a little while before quickly wearing off as the film struggles to go wild with the concept. The Predators are quickly reduced to one and the pairing between the last one standing and the film€™s heroine is undermined by some awkward shots between the two that lead to several chuckle-worthy moments when the two seem to be on the verge of sharing a kiss. While some of the designs are cool, the film ultimately seems to be working under restraints, trying to be scary without actually being scary while also trying to be an action film afraid to go balls-to-the-wall, with neither aspect balancing out effectively like the best films in the standalone franchises.

8. Predators (2010)

On paper, Predators has an engaging concept. Taking place on an alien planet where game from other worlds, including Earth, are brought to be hunted by the Predators, the possibilities for what the film could do and where it could go were endless. With 20 years having passed since the last film in the franchise was released, it seemed the next logical step in the series€™ development beyond simply rehashing the same plot from the first two films in a different Earth-set location. Although the film embraces its R rated roots, showcases some slick designs for the Predators, takes a peek into their social hierarchy and even brings in the always-entertaining Danny Trejo and Walton Goggins, it€™s cut down at the knees by some disappointing choices. Beyond some minor involvement of other alien game, the film doesn€™t dive headfirst into its premise to pit the human characters against a vast universe of species locked into their survival instinct while trying to avoid their demise from their hunters. Laurence Fishburne is absolutely wasted in a role that serves only to provide exposition and an unnecessary twist, Adrian Brody is miscast as the lead hero, nearly bringing the film to a screeching halt every time he opens his mouth to share his €œBale-voice€ Batman impression and a last-act twist involving Topher Grace€™s character is woefully misguided. After two decades of waiting to see where the Predator franchise could go, Predators instead tried to play it safe, stumbling three steps back for every positive step it took forward.

7. Alien: Resurrection (1997)

Unnecessary but inevitable, Alien: Resurrection was the film that put a pin in the forward continuation of the standalone Alien franchise that hasn€™t been pulled out by 20th Century Fox since. Released in 1997, Resurrection feels like a brightly-colored, less-morose response to David Fincher€™s Alien 3, haphazardly assembling parts of its three predecessors in an attempt to clone their successes but failing to be even half the film they were. Love it or hate it, Alien 3 brought a sense of closure to Ellen Ripley€™s story that didn€™t need to be tampered with. Any future Alien film, though undoubtedly having to live under the shadow of what came before it, could€™ve gone anywhere and to any time with its titular creature, but Resurrection instead chose to bring Ripley back into the fold through the power of cloning. Sigourney Weaver does give it her all and she€™s joined by a mostly decent supporting cast, such as Ron Perlman, Brad Dourif and Winona Ryder, who all fight to try and make it work. The film also has several bright spots, including a great sequence where Ripley discovers the previous failed cloning attempts, a chestburster sequence that stands as one of the series€™ craziest and a neat sequence in which the Xenomorphs coordinate to escape their holding cell. Unfortunately, the bad outweighs the good, with the CGI creatures looking pretty bad, the Xenomorphs being inexplicably €“ and humorously €“ wet and slimy, the existence of the €œnewborn€ and a general feeling that the film was made for the sole purpose of keeping the franchise bringing in the money rather than an attempt at making a genuinely worthy installment.

6. Prometheus (2012)

Of all the films on this list, 2012's Prometheus seems to be the one that divides people the most. As much a prequel to the original Alien as it is an attempt at launching a new, unshackled franchise, Ridley Scott's film was met with a generally positive critical response as well as a quite vocal group of people who hated it. If anything, most can agree that the film is visually stunning, highly ambitious and that the performances of Noomi Rapace and Michael Fassbender help to make the whole thing palatable. However, it stumbles in its plotting, character work and dialogue, a fine example of which is seen in the illogical hypocrisy of the crew's biologist, who was afraid of dead remains yet happily interacts with a dangerous, living alien creature shortly after. The film also aims to play with many intriguing concepts, raising a number of questions in the process that it fails to suitably answer for a large number of viewers. Free of its obligation to link up to the Alien series, the upcoming sequel has a chance to improve upon the foundation laid down by Prometheus and enjoy its freedom of not having the audience wondering when the Alien is going to show up. It may not have lived up to the expectations of many, but its merits help it from becoming the abysmal disaster it's so often made out to be by "the Internet."

5. Alien 3 (1992)

For some fans, the Alien franchise ends with 1986's Aliens and those fans have every right to feel that way. Mere moments into David Fincher's sequel, the events of Aliens and the struggle Ripley went through are rendered moot as Hicks and Newt are killed and Bishop is left irreparably damaged. Understandably, by spitting in the face of James Cameron€™s excellent story and the characters it gave birth to, Alien 3 immediately alienated its invested audience and earned itself perpetual scorn. But strip away the opening and one will find that the rest of the film is surprisingly solid. In stark contrast to its predecessors, the film offers a much bleaker visual pallet, full of warm colors, grime and smoke and an infusion of general glumness, using its setting in the penal colony to mirror the hopelessness of Ripley€™s journey through the series. Despite the well-documented studio interference, Fincher at least pulls off the feat of giving the film its own unique visual and thematic identity. Alien 3 is not as tense or gripping to watch as the original film or as fun and exciting as Aliens, but its attempt at shaking up the franchise to keep it from becoming formulaic is noble and it offers some neat twists, such as the Xenomorph adopting traits of its host, the use of POV shots from the creature€™s perspective and how it interacts with Ripley. Despite everything she€™d gone through in the films, Ripley€™s journey comes to a close in a big bummer ending, which hasn€™t pleased and will continue to not please a lot of people, but it€™s that exact mindset that sets it apart from its predecessors and helps define itself as the underrated film that it is.

4. Predator 2 (1990)

predator2 While far from being a critical darling, Predator 2 is a great sequel to the 1987 classic. Rather than simply clone its predecessor, Predator 2 twists nearly everything about it, subverting expectations to deliver an enjoyably fresh follow-up that€™s entertaining in all the right ways. Gone are the muscle-bound heroes €“ and victims €“ of the first film, instead replaced by the likes of Ruben Blades, Bill Paxton and, of course, Danny Glover, who gets the chance to play an alternate-reality take on his famous Lethal Weapon character, Roger Murtaugh. Gone, too, is the lush jungle setting of Central America, as this film€™s Predator takes the hunt to the concrete jungle of Los Angeles. Throw in a little subplot involving Gary Busey as a government character with long-time knowledge of the Predator and Predator 2 acts as a uniquely different beast to its predecessor. The film is filled with a number of awesome kills and scenes, such as the great subway sequence, the demise of King Willie and the long final chase and battle where the predator/prey roles are reversed between Harrigan and the Predator. Its differences to the original film are often seen as faults when, in actuality, it€™s those very differences that help elevate it from being a mere been there, done that film going through the motions and stands as a worthy sequel to Predator.

3. Predator (1987)

Immensely quotable and ridiculously entertaining, Predator strikes a perfect balance of horror, suspense and crazy action. From the immediately iconic design of the creature itself to the fact that nearly every single character gets a chance to shine or deliver a memorable line to the awesome final showdown between Arnold Schwarzenegger's Dutch and the Predator, the film continues to deliver on entertainment over 25 years later. The film takes such a simple premise and runs with it, providing an immensely quotable rollercoaster ride of a good time, all to the tune of a slick score courtesy of Alan Silvestri. There's a reason the titular character quickly became popular and it all started here. It's a classic that, despite the existence of one lame sequel and the dreary AVP films, still holds up and is a definite must-see for the six science fiction/horror fans out there who have somehow never experienced it.

2. Aliens (1986)

Ask people what some of the best sequels in film history have been and you're more than likely to hear Aliens pop up again and again. Knowing that attempting to capture the horror and effectiveness of the Alien in the first film for an entire runtime would be near impossible given that the mystery around the creature was gone for the audience, James Cameron shifted gears for the sequel, crafting an excellent end product of science fiction and action-adventure in the process. Sigourney Weaver's return as Ellen Ripley feels natural rather than forced and watching her blossom out of her post-traumatic shell into a maternal warrior is entertaining. Toss in all the other popular elements -- from characters like Hudson, Hicks, Newt and Bishop to the introduction of the Queen Alien into the series' mythology -- and the recipe concocted for Aliens ends up being a perfect second round for the series that goes hand-in-hand with its predecessor. Not much can be said about the film that hasn€™t been said time in and time out over the years since its release and it€™s rare that a sequel can legitimately give an original film a run for its money in the argument about which one is better, but Aliens continues to stand the test of time for what it did to reshape and redefine the franchise.

1. Alien (1979)

The debate over what the best Alien film is usually boils down to the argument of Alien versus Aliens, but the fact that the argument even exists -- and that the two films can lead to such debate €“ owes everything to Ridley Scott€™s original. As great as Aliens is, Alien laid the foundation for a legacy that has lasted 35 years and continues to find and influence new fans. H.R. Giger€™s design for the Xenomorph is nothing short of legendary, Ellen Ripley has become one of cinema€™s most important female heroes and Ridley Scott€™s masterful direction has spawned countless imitators all trying to recapture his effortless balance of sci-fi suspense, creeping dread and outright terror. And let€™s not forget the chestburster scene, a defining moment in the annals of horror history. Even though the creature€™s ability to be scary may seem to have been lost long ago through sequels and crossovers and games and comics and other appearances in popular culture, rewatching Alien in the dark, maybe with someone who hasn€™t seen it, proves that the film hasn€™t lost its effectiveness. Eventually, the Alien will resurface in theaters again, for better or worse, but the original classic will continue to overcome anything thrown at it. After all, 35 years later, we€™re still talking about it and celebrating it for all it€™s given.

Contributor
Contributor

Writer, film enthusiast, part-time gamer and watcher of (mostly) good television located on the fringe of Los Angeles, who now has his own website at www.highdefgeoff.com!