An American Pickle Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs
Seth Rogen shines in this deliriously weird comedy.

Seth Rogen's new fish-out-of-water comedy An American Pickle hits screens both big and small this week, as HBO Max's first original film while also on limited theatrical release in the UK.
The movie's barmy premise sees Polish ditch-digger Herschel Greenbaum (Rogen) accidentally falling into a pickle barrel in 1920, which preserves him until he's unearthed in 2020, whereby he attempts to connect with his great-grandson Ben (also played by Rogen).
Even for the standards of Rogen's off-kilter comedy vehicles, An American Pickle is an especially left-field outing, and one that Sony Pictures was probably smart to offload to HBO earlier this year, given that this thing clearly would've tanked as a wide theatrical release.
But that's not to call the film bad, because it isn't, simply that it lacks the broader, more uproarious appeal of Rogen's typical studio fare, and feels far more at home as a more modest, low-key streaming offering.
Though certainly not one of Rogen's smartest or funniest films to date, An American Pickle is a divertingly weird time, and Rogen absolutely delivers in the dual central role. But first, here's what didn't quite work about the movie...
Downs...
4. It's Low On Big Laughs

Easily the most disappointing thing about this movie is the shocking lack of major, gut-busting laughs. Though Rogen's films have a tendency to meld hysterical one-liners with affecting storytelling, here the humour feels a little more measured.
Even accepting the general lack of profanity - which is at once both odd and refreshing - it feels like Simon Rich's script doesn't do nearly enough to mine the full comedic potential from its intriguingly bizarre premise.
Those used to howling with laughter at the crude gags and spot-on pop-culture references in Rogen's prior films will likely find themselves only smirking and politely chuckling for the most part here, unfortunately.
3. The Underused Supporting Cast

Another lacking element compared to most Seth Rogen comedies is the piecemeal supporting cast. The movie is focused quite singularly on the central Rogen two-hander, while the smaller roles ultimately feel rather thin and underwhelming.
The brilliant Sarah Snook plays Herschel's wife Sarah in the establishing scenes but is given virtually nothing to do, while brief bit-parts from comedians such as Jorma Taccone, Eliot Glazer, and Molly Evensen hold plenty of promise, yet are just too miniscule and malnourished to satisfy.
If you're expecting the movie to be jam-packed with ridiculous cameos from Rogen's Hollywood pals, prepare to be bitterly disappointed that it's really not much of an ensemble film at all.
2. It's A Simplistic Social Satire

At its core, An American Pickle is a satire of modern America, using the whole "pickled in brine for 100 years" shtick to underline how absurd the United States in 2020 truly is.
For the most part the film's satirical through-line is really quite shallow, taking easy pot-shots at modern conveniences we take for granted, from seltzer machines to fridges and the iPad.
There's also a good deal of shade thrown at consumerism and humanity's general wastefulness, not to mention hipster culture, our optics-obsessed society, and of course, social media.
Unsurprisingly, Rogen eventually carves out a decent chunk of the film to take some thinly-veiled jabs at Donald Trump and his populist platform, which while certainly relevant, doesn't really add anything fresh or clever to an already overdone conversation. Trump sucks, who knew?
Though the setup clearly offered fertile ground for a biting, angry satire about American immigration policy and the generally fraught state of the U.S. today - if not the world - in the end it just isn't clever enough conceptually to be truly effective.
1. The Underwhelming Third Act

As compellingly odd as that first hour is, things start to fall off somewhat in the final reel, as the script diverges into more familiar and predictable studio comedy territory.
Of course, Herschel and Ben are inevitably driven apart following a major argument, and there's one especially zany narrative turn which feels like it belongs in a different movie entirely.
But ultimately everything ends exactly as you'd expect, awash in gooey family truisms after every conflict is neatly resolved. It really just feels like Rich ran out of good ideas two-thirds in and basically just leaned back on typical genre tropes to see him through.
These gripes aside, though, there's plenty to like here. Here's what Rogen and co. got right...
Ups...
6. Seth Rogen's Terrific Dual Performance

The single aspect of this movie which undeniably lives up to expectations is Seth Rogen's impressively nuanced dual performance as Herschel and Ben.
It would've been easy for Ben to simply be an adjacent version of Rogen himself - as his protagonists so often are - with Herschel being basically the same thing but with an accent, yet the two characters do indeed feel like distinct people.
Though cinema has long mastered the art of having an actor play two characters at once, sometimes the audience never quite loses sight of the trick they're seeing, whereas in this case, it's surprisingly easy to accept these characters as individuals.
Rather than make Herschel a trite or potentially offensive caricature, it's clear Rogen wanted to portray him respectfully, and while Ben is hardly much of a stretch for the actor, he's nevertheless personable and relatable in his own way.
That the two can banter and interact so convincingly without drawing attention to the obvious tricks employed to make it happen is a testament to both Rogen's pair of performances and Brandon Trost's restrained direction.
5. The Knowingly Ridiculous Plot

The movie's plot is one of those premises which, on paper, could clearly go either way.
It's easy to picture An American Pickle as one of Adam Sandler's Netflix vehicles which fails to find any sort of tonal compromise between its sillier and more serious elements.
But thankfully in the hands of Rogen and his collaborators, this ridiculous story works precisely because it knows how utterly daft it is, and even draws attention to this fact.
Only a single scene is spent explaining how Herschel managed to survive 100 years inside a pickle barrel, yet the punchline ultimately is that the method doesn't really matter - it's simply a means to a dramatic end.
Though things get a little too wacky in act three, throughout there's no attempt made to shy away from how patently insane the entire scenario is, and that's a good thing.
4. It's Surprisingly Heartfelt

Despite its prevailing absurdity, there is an unexpected sincerity and earnestness to the story, a tale of Jewish prosperity which Rogen clearly has something of a personal stake in.
Both Herschel and Ben are reeling from very real pain throughout the movie - Herschel having lost his family to time and Ben still grieving the untimely deaths of his parents - and though the film doesn't linger on it unnecessarily, it's palpably felt nevertheless.
Beyond mourning their respective losses, it also has something to say about family obligations, and the expectation that one should achieve more than their ancestors.
If it perhaps gets a touch too sentimental in the final stretch, for the most part it strikes an appealingly sweet and heartfelt note, which for a movie about a guy who gets pickled for a century is pretty impressive.
3. The Sharp Cinematography

If modern comedies catch plenty of flak for typically being visually unremarkable, Rogen's films tend to stand out as exceptions, with many of them actually looking cinematic rather than like grossly overlit sitcoms.
An American Pickle is the directorial debut of Brandon Trost, who has served as cinematographer on some of the better-looking mainstream comedies of the last decade, including This Is the End, The Interview, Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping, The Disaster Artist, and both Neighbors movies.
Trost has a real eye for making even basic scene setups look rich and vibrant, and though he passed lensing duties off to John Guleserian (Love, Simon) here, his knack for enticing visuals has served him well.
The opening 1920-set scenes are especially evocative, though for its entirety the film avoids looking like just another identikit studio comedy.
2. It's Short & Snappy

This is a movie which smartly knows its limitations and sprints its way to the finish-line in a breezy, easily digestible 88 minutes.
Spending just a few short scenes to set up its madcap premise, it's a film which absolutely benefits from never sticking around in one place for too long.
Though far from the funniest of Rogen's movies, it avoids the typical modern Hollywood comedy pitfall of feeling overly reliant on improvisation and letting scenes drag on for far too long. Looking at you, Ghostbusters 2016.
There's a tightness to the movie's pacing which suggests some disciplined cuts were made, rather than Trost simply throwing in every sliver of available material just because.
This helps ensure that, despite its low quotient of big laughs, it's an easy, relaxing sit of a movie and never anywhere close to a chore.
1. Nami Melumad's Folksy Musical Score

Another area where so many comedies fall short of the mark is with their original music, often opting for generically whimsical soundtracks or, more frequently, just relying on existing pop hits to fill the void.
But An American Pickle is blessed with a jaunty folk score from Nami Melumad (with themes provided by Michael Giacchino), which combines an orchestral swell with instrumentation actually practised by the Ashkenazi Jews 100 years ago.
The score does a subtle yet effective job of accentuating the overall mood, switching from peppy and sweeping to downcast and tragic as the material calls for it.
Considering that a solid 90% of comedy movies have no memorable original music whatsoever, Melamud's work here is basically a low-key miracle.