Arnold Schwarzenegger: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

From 'Let off some steam, Bennet' to 'Ice to see you'... we're glad Arnie is back.

There are thousands of bad actors working in Hollywood right now who you€™ll never, ever see. Why? Because they€™re bad. They might get a role in a short film, hell they might even show up in the odd feature or two, in a minor role. Maybe they€™ll even rise to the status of €˜what have I seen him in before?€™ But they€™ll never make it out of obscurity €“ they just don€™t have the ability. If Arnold Schwarzenegger were anyone also but Arnold Schwarzenegger, he€™d fall under this category. But as you€™re probably aware, he€™s Arnold Schwarzenegger, and it€™s all but impossible to keep the man down. Hailing from the tiny village of Thal in Austria, he was laughed at throughout his youth for his dream of mainstream Hollywood success, but now who€™s laughing? Ahnie, that€™s who! Thanks to his unique look, his weird yet unforgettable delivery and his unbeatable ability to play cold, emotionless, tough sons-of-bitches (and pretty much an inability to play anything else), Arnie has managed to pull himself out of obscurity to the point where today he€™s a household name. With Ahnold back once again for another shot at the Terminator series, what more perfect time could there be to remind ourselves of Arnie€™s unique, often wonderful and sometimes painful career to date...

5 Awesome Performances€

5. John Matrix - Commando (1985)

If you enter into Commando looking for realism, looking for plausible cause and effect, then you€™re going to leave this one shaking your head in disappointment. But if you go in looking for a ridiculously over-the-top eighties action extravaganza, then you€™ve found your promised land. When an evil Freddie Mercury impersonator kidnaps Arnie€™s daughter, you know that what he does next is going to ensure that for Bennett, the show most certainly will not go on. In Commando, Arnie can €˜smell€™ enemies coming, he can tear car seats out of their housing in seconds and he can generally dispense one-man-army justice without so much as breaking a sweat. Schwarzenegger is perfect in a role like this, and it€™s a role you€™ll have seen him in many times in the past, but Commando is arguably the pinnacle of his genius as an unstoppable army of one.

4. Harry Tasker - True Lies (1994)

True Lies is without a doubt one of the funniest performances of The Governator€™s career. Revel at the scene in which Harry Tasker first realises his wife (played by Jamie-Lee Curtis) may be having an affair; at the look of sheer shocked insanity on his face €“ it€™s a moment that he really sells as an actor, proving that there is something within that he can offer to the camera in terms of performance. Again, Arnie is suited perfectly to a role like this. True Lies is enough of a spoof-comedy that he doesn€™t need to be the finest actor in the world to pull of the role, but it€™s serious enough in parts that he€™s able to get tough, and deliver some signature Arnie one-man-army moments. True Lies isn€™t going to win any awards for class; it€™s brash and crude and unashamedly so. And with that being said, Cameron picked the perfect leading man, who shares much of the same qualities as the movie itself.

3. Douglas Quaid - Total Recall (1990)

Arnie has been in a handful of iconic movies, that have since been committed into the annals of legend, and Total Recall is without a doubt one of them. Total Recall is almost unmatchable in terms of sheer entertainment value and Arnie, here playing the amnesiac super-spy Douglas Quaid, is as indomitable a presence as ever. You might think Colin Farrell would give a better performance in his take on the character, considering that Arnie can€™t actually €˜act€™ very well, in the traditional sense of the word, but that€™s just not the case. There really is a place for an actor like Schwarzeneggar, and it€™s in a movie like Total Recall. And if it weren€™t for this picture, we€™d have never have gotten several absolutely classic Arnie one-linrs; including €œSee you at de paahty, Richter€ and €œConsider it a divorce€. And that just wouldn€™t do.

2. Terminator - Terminator 1 & 2 (1984)

In terms of sheer pop-culture factor, the Terminator series would probably take the number one spot. I€™m not going to patronise you by going into the plot; you know it by heart, and if you don€™t you need to sort out your movie collection. Terminator 1 & 2 prove that to have a range, you don€™t necessarily have to have a range. Arnie plays the same character, in almost the exact same way in both of the first Terminator movies. The only difference: in one he€™s a bad robot and in the other he€™s a good robot. Yet it€™s surprising just how subtly different these two characters actually are. The Terminator is a low-budget, gritty, nightmarish chase movie, and the second is more of the same, with added Hollywood factor €“ but it€™s amazing how different they both feel with just that slight tweak to Schwarzenegger character. Fair enough, you can probably thank director James Cameron for that, but still you can€™t deny that the first two Terminator movies represent two of Arnie€™s greatest roles to date.

1. Dutch - Predator (1987)

There have been a few movie specific monsters over the years that have become iconic - The Xenomorphs, The Terminators, honestly it€™s a relatively short list €“ and The Predators are unquestionably one of them. He€™s almost in a reprise of his role in Commando here, albeit with a much more serious face on. He plays, again, a Commando, who€™s sent on a mission in a Central American jungle, only to find that he and his team are being hunted by the Universe€™s apex hunter. You know by now that the Predators as a race respect the hunt, and will bow to those they deem superior €“ would you have believed that any human character could be physically superior to a Predator if it wasn€™t Arnie? Let me put it this way, did you believe it when it was Danny Glover? Again, you can€™t say Arnie gave the most powerful performance ever with Predator, but then again he€™s not that kind of actor. What he did though was bring us another character that, for better or worse, has seeped into modern movie iconography forever. Click "next" below for the sucked...

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Det. John Kimble - Kindergarten Cop (1990)

For those of you who wonder why Arnie always goes for the standard action fare, Kindergarten Cop is your answer. Schwarzenegger is awesome, when he€™s in the right role, performing the right script and under the supervision of the right director. Kindergarten Cop, however, inserts him awkwardly into a role that clearly exists far outside of his comfort zone for no more valid a reason than the pursuit of a funny gimmick. For that reason, he can€™t help but fail to hit the mark. But can you blame poor Arnold? The idea was ill-conceived all around, and although it does certainly present a moment or two of note €“ €œWho is your daddy, and what does he do?€ €“ both the film, and Schwarzenegger himself fail to ever really get going.

4. Adam Gibson - The 6th Day (2000)

It€™s tough to blame Arnie for a bad performance, because he essentially turns every role with that same broad, broken up delivery. Sometimes it works phenomenally well, but getting the best from Arnie usually requires that perfect script/director combo. The 6th Day definitely didn€™t have either. Arnie€™s character is universally uninteresting here, and I don€™t know if it€™s just me, but he seems to be really half-assing it throughout, which is saying something, consider he€™s half-assed just about every other role he€™s had that wasn't Commando or a James Cameron movie. In all honesty, 6th Day has Schwarzenegger written all over it, but just didn€™t quite have the cutting edge necessary to elevate Arnie above mediocrity.

3. Gordy Brewer - Collateral Damage (2002)

If you saw this movie, then you and anyone you were with were the collateral damage the movie title is hinting at. It€™s just so painfully routine that even Arnie, who would normally excel in a movie such as this, feels like he grew bored of the role about 10 years previously and is just in it for the paycheck. And in all honestly, that€™s entirely the case, without a doubt. I wouldn€™t even consider Collateral Damage to be a worthwhile watch for even a hardcore Arnold Fan. It€™s like Commando, but made 10 years too late and by a much inferior storyteller, and even with the whole vigilante twist, it never seems to manage to get itself off the ground.

2. Howard Langston - Jingle All The Way (1996)

I€™m not a huge follower of Christmas at the best of times, and especially so when a movie forcibly rams it down your throat like it€™s trying to murder you with it. In a straight action role, Arnie is (or at least was in his day) you€™re prime choice. But I doubt a role like Howard Langston in Jingle All The Way could have been saved even if Orson Welles was somehow cast, so Arnie has literally no chance. It€™s not the he€™s bad €“ he€™s just the same as he always is, it€™s Arnie €“ but there€™s nothing in the script, or in the direction, for him to use with his skill as a muscle-bound action veteran and so he€™s often awkward and unbelievable, like he€™s not comfortable in his own skin. A bad performance, but then again, it€™s a terrible movie too so can he blamed?

1. Mr. Freeze - Batman & Robin (1997)

If a comic book character, who€™s main deal is Ice, says the phrase €œIce to see you€ without any sense of irony, then you may as well turn it off there, as it€™s not likely to get any better. If I recorded myself taking a dump on a Batman graphic novel and posted it on YouTube for the world to see, then I€™d have achieved what Schumacher achieved with Batman and Robin. Again, I can€™t fully blame Arnie for his erroneous performance as Mr. Freeze, but I still can€™t help but fill with rage whenever I think about it. I mean, €œIce to see you€? Are you f*cking for real Schumacher?! Schwarzenegger is at his very poorest here €“ the more you try to force the man into a gimmick he€™s not comfortable with, the worse he gets. He€™s great at showing up, kicking major ass, jotting down a few names, and spitting out a one liner over a room full of corpses in army uniforms. That€™s what we pay for after all. But trusting with the subtlety required to make a comic book movie villain believable, to toe that line between realistic and supernatural, without it descending into the banal, is a biiiig ask for a performer like Schwarzenegger. In the end, he fails as Mr. Freeze, but then again everyone in that movie failed as whoever they were playing. We can€™t fully blame Arnie, or Clooney or Chris O€™Donell €“ the blame gun must be levelled directly at Schumacher. For shame, Schumacher. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SRH-Ywpz1_I So there you have our 5 favourite - and 5 least favourite of course €“ Schwarzenegger performance, from throughout his unique career. Did we miss any of your picks off the list? Let us in on it won€™t you? 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked Previously; 5 Awesome Ed Norton Performances and 5 That SuckedNatalie Portman: 5 Awesome Performances and 5 That SuckedColin Farrell: 5 Awesome Performances and 5 That SuckedChristian Bale: 5 Awesome Performances and 5 That Sucked

Contributor
Contributor

Stuart believes that the pen is mightier than the sword, but still he insists on using a keyboard.