Back To The Future: 10 Giant Plot Holes You Probably Missed

Where we're going... things don't have to make sense.

Back to the Future Back To The Future is potentially my favorite movie of all time. As a kid, I would design my own flux capacitor powered time machines in my room and only enjoyed playing with train sets when I could put a car in front of them to be pushed up to 88 mph. And yes, I did try to make my own hoverboard using a vacuum cleaner. Back To The Future is my "trilogy," and it is for these reasons that I feel most critical of it - it is close to my heart, like that family member I can make fun of and no one else can. So that's why I find it important to pick up on the points that blemished the otherwise exceptional film series. With any time travel movie, one must suspend disbelief and allow the film to function within the rules it sets for itself, and it is therefore key for those rules to be consistent, and not to be full of holes. Sadly, the BTTF trilogy was never quite as committed to that agenda as it should have been. So, I present the following portrait of Back To The Future's plot holes out of love, having watched the films somewhere north of 500 times...

10. Marty's Parent Remembering Him

BTTF 1955 As we live our lives, many of people touch us, and some can have more impact than others. One person I consider to have touched me most is the person who introduced me to my wife: I will remember that face and name until the day I die. That is why I find it a bit hard to swallow what 1985 George and Lorraine have yet to realize that their son looks exactly like the young man that was strangely motivated to bring them together in their youth. Marty spent a large amount of intimate time with each of them, kissing one of them before she was rather unforgettably almost raped, and saving the life of the other one. Sure, I can believe that they named not their 1st, not their 2nd, but their 3rd child after him as an homage, but when they are spitting images of one another that would be bound to raise some eye-brows around the dinner table. At the very least Lorraine must have blushed a bit when she bought Marty his first pair of Calvin Klein underwear before she put it together.

9. Marty Disappearing

In the original BTTF, when Marty prevented his parents from originally meeting he jeopardized his very conception and put himself in danger of being erased from existence. Marty was in 1955 from November 5th - 12th. Over those first several days, Marty's brother and sister were gradually erased, as indicated on the photo that Marty so quaintly carried with him before smart phones. But when it came to Marty, he began to disappear on the stage with Marvin Berry and company at the Enchantment Under the Sea dance, but all at once and very rapidly. Talk about inconsistency. Poor Marty, what did he ever do that the cosmic forces of space and time would wipe him out with one fell swoop instead of over several days like his siblings? Perhaps they knew that it was all he needed to be inspired into introducing the world to rock n' roll?

8. Alt-1985

Back To The Future The Back to the Future Saga began when teenager Marty McFly and his kooky friend Doc Brown were experimenting with a time machine one night and Marty accidentally went back in time and prevented his parents from meeting. This ultimately resulted in a much more positive present for Marty in 1985 - his parents were successful and in love, he had a nice car, and his family wasn't still being pushed around by the same familiar bully. Nice story. This raises the question, if Marty changed his life for the better, why was he hanging out with Doc the night he went back in the first place in the "better" timeline? Furthermore, why are they still living in that house and neighbourhood? Doc clearly acted as a friend and father figure to a troubled teen, but now that Marty's real father is a bit more confident, why did Marty and Doc ever meet to go back in time that night? Not to mention, they even state that he was supposed to be at the lake that night with Jennifer. Somehow the same set of circumstances that brought this lower-middle class boy to create a friendship with a scientist that lead them out to Twin Pines mall ALSO happened in this much happier version of his life? One would imagine that Marty would have led a much different life after changing it.

7. Biff The Rapist

Biff Tannen Is it just me or was there a lot of borderline rape in BTTF? Let's forget the Oedipal implications of Lorraine seducing her son in 1985 and focus on the fact that Biff all but raped her in the parking lot when he foiled Marty's attempt to make George look like a hero. Fortunately George rises to the occasion and knocks Biff out cold, and as a direct result of this, we later find Biff in 1985 to be a passive flunky of the McFly family, doing chores and running errands. Now, I'm all for reforming criminals, but I personally make it a policy not to hire rapists to work for me and potentially be alone with any member of my family at any given time, especially someone they had previously tried to rape. Why would George subject his family to a violent bully that brought him nothing but pain? This never sat well with me, but I hate bullies.

6. Doc's Clocks

BTTF Clocks BTTF has a beautifully subtle opening scene that tells us almost everything we need to know about the main characters. The camera pans over Doc's apartment - littered with kooky inventions, piles of uneaten dog food, and a number of clocks. Marty enters for a quick jam session before class only to discover that he is running late because the clocks were all set slow. It is only when Doc calls his own house for some reason that Marty discovers this fact. Cue Huey Lewis and the News. But why were all the clocks set slow in the first place? We are to assume that it had something to do with Doc's time travel experiment, but how? Furthermore, Marty spent about 5 minutes in there before Doc called, so would he not be presumably late for school before he even arrived?

5. Old Biff And Young Biff Chatting

Biff Tannen "So Doc Brown invented a time machine..." I gotta hand it to old Biff, that was always a clever plan for a dim person. BTTF often stated the rules of their universe in a garrulous plea from Doc ending in consequences for their actions that were either very minor or wildly catastrophic. The ridiculousness of these diatribes was probably the reason we embraced them. One of the most memorable is that when a younger version of a person sees their older counterpart, they will either faint from shock, or the space-time continuum will unravel. One or the other will happen. Lucky for us, the audience finds out that it was the former when Jennifer ran into herself. Later, Older Doc helped Only Kinda Old Doc when prepping for the sequence that took place at the end of the first film, but made sure not to make eye contact so he must still not be totally sure of the effects. All this trouble, yet old Biff had no problem chewing the fat with his younger self when he stole the DeLorean to deliver the almanac? I mean Biff is a tough guy and all but he neither passes out or causes a catastrophe in the space time continuum. Why don't the rules apply to him?

4. Memories In Future

BTTF GEorge If I were to ever travel though time resulting in an entirely different existence, the dates that I was in the future would be eternally etched into my mind. It appears that future Marty (and future Jennifer for that matter) have no recollection of their adventure through time ever taking place. Wouldn't it cross 2015 Marty's mind that the day his father threw his back out on the golf course and Jennifer passed out on the porch was the same day that there was a younger version of himself running around his property? Most people would have marked these days on their calendar and written a note to not make a deal with Needles that would get them both fired. I would imagine that traveling through time ranks right up there with life events like graduations and wedding days.

3. Old Biff Stealing The DeLorean

Biff While Marty and Doc are retrieving Jennifer from her 2015 home, Old Biff steals the time machine to travel back and give his younger self the almanac. This is potentially the most problematic part of the entire trilogy for me, which is troublesome as it is a huge turning point. First of all, how does old Biff know how to use the DeLorean, program it to such a specific date, and then return to that exact moment in 2015 all upon first glance? I am no scientist, but I would assume Doc Brown's life work would be complicated enough where an old man that cannot get a pun straight would need an instruction manual. Furthermore, once he returns to 2015, he is in a great deal of pain and breaks his cane in the car. Clearly the plot device of the cane head was necessary for story points later. It is true that there is a deleted scene where it is explained how he has been shot by future Lorraine and is then ultimately erased from existence. Even incorporating this deleted scene, it makes no sense! Even if he was shot by her, why would that erase him? Perhaps it could be the actions of 1955 Biff with the almanac, but nothing else is changing. Regardless, that scene was cut and should not count as cannon, which causes it to be an even bigger plot hole.

2. DeLorean Gas

delorean gas In spite of 1985 Doc's clear instructions, Marty enlists the help of 1955 Doc once again to help him rescue 1985 from his fate in 1885. Got all that? In spite of Doc's guarantee, Marty runs head on into the Indians once he hits 88 and makes the jump to 1885. Unfortunately, the gas line of the DeLorean is conveniently hit with an arrow and they spend the next 30 minutes of the movie trying to come up with a suitable replacement for gas. The thing is, there is another DeLorean in 1885! Doc hid it for Marty to use in 1955 after it was hit by lightning. No it does not run, but there must be enough gas in there to siphon some out and gun it up to 88 one time. They wouldn't even be risking the often overlooked paradox as when it is unearthed in 1955, they have to tow it away anyways. A brilliant scientist who figures out how to make fire burn hotter should be able to realize this.

1. Marty's Hand

Neeldes At the end of the first movie, Marty opens his garage to find the truck he has coveted just a week prior in the original timeline. After he uses that car to pick up Jennifer once he returns from 1885, he runs into Needles who baits him into a race by calling Marty "chicken," (a character flaw that was not present in the first film). We learned in BTTF 2 that Marty stopped playing the guitar when he hurt his hand in this very accident. Fortunately, Marty has learned a lesson about pride from his journey so the race does not happen and he does not hit the Rolls Royce. This raises the question: in the original time line how would Marty have been racing Needles if a) he was not picking up Jennifer and b) did not have the truck? Throughout the entire movie, Marty's life is somehow still the same in many elements even after he changes it. Do you have answers that Back To The Future didn't quite answer? Share them below in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

David is an educator and writer from the Philadelphia area. In spite of loving parents, he was largely raised by television and movies.