Batman: Every Live-Action Gotham City Ranked Worst To Best
From the 1943 serials to R-Patz's The Batman.
In the world of comic books, few cities are as infamous as Gotham City. The home of Batman, Gotham has often been just as much of a character as the Dark Knight himself or the countless other characters who have walked the city's streets.
While Superman's home of Metropolis is famed for its vibrancy, it's the polar opposite for Gotham. Dark, menacing and seductive, Gotham City is the sort of place that thrives on corrupting those who decide to live there.
Throughout the decades, there have been so many different versions of Gotham to make it to screens both big and small. As is often the case, some of those have been great, some of these have been utterly dreadful. Of course, we all know that the real correct answer is that Batman: The Animated Series has the absolute best Gotham City, but hey, this list is all solely about the live-action iterations of this most iconic and infamous of places.
With that in mind, then, here are the very worst through to the very best takes on the city that Batman - and so many other heroes and villains - call home.
12. The 1940s Serials
Way before the days of Pattinson, Affleck, Bale, Clooney, Kilmer, Keaton or even West, Batman was first seen in live-action during the 1940s.
Initially starring Lewis Wilson as the Caped Crusader - with Robert Lowery later taking over the role - these 'serials' were black and white offerings that didn't really acknowledge Gotham City. Sure, Gotham was where the action was taking place, but the locale was barely referenced and so much of the action took place in smoky offices and underground labs.
To give an idea of how different things were back in 1943 when the first 15-part serial - titled simply Batman - was released, the World's Greatest Detective is depicted as a US spy looking to foil the plot of a rival Japanese agent in the backdrop of World War II.
The follow-up to this came with 1949's New Adventures of Batman and Robin, Boy Wonder, where the titular Dynamic Duo battled the nefarious Wizard and his scheme to control all of the cars of Gotham. Even then, though, Gotham itself was utterly nondescript. As such, these serials of the '40s have to rank rock bottom on this list.
11. Birds Of Prey
No, not Birds of Prey (and the Fantabulous Emancipation of One Harley Quinn). Instead, it's The WB's short-lived Birds of Prey TV series that's under the spotlight here.
To be fair, this one-season offering never really stood a chance when it comes to its Gotham City. Well, New Gotham City, that is.
Loosely set in the same world as Tim Burton's Batman movies, Birds of Prey finds a future Gotham where Batman and Catwoman have vanished. Of course, before they disappeared, the pair got together and had a daughter, Helena. Nowadays parading around as the vigilante Huntress, Helena finds herself teaming up with a wheelchair-bound Barbara Gordon, aka Oracle, and a young Dinah Lance, aka Black Canary.
The budget afforded to Birds of Prey meant its Gotham City is barely seen in any notable way bar a few shots of generic streets and misty backdrops, with most of the action instead taking place indoors. Given that the show also premiered in 2002, that also means it's full of horrendous lighting, cheesily brooding imagery, diabolical dialogue, and cringe-inducing angsty songs such as t.A.T.u.'s All the Things She Said.
10. Batman '66 & Batman: The Movie
While these days it's all about brooding, brutal Batmen, that wasn't always the case. Premiering in 1966, ABC's live-action Batman show brought a vibrancy and campness to Batman and Robin that's the polar opposite of Messrs Bale, Affleck and Patterson.
Played by Adam West and Burt Ward, this take on the Dynamic Duo largely mirrored the comic books of the day. Granted, there was an added level of humour to West and Ward's Caped Crusader and Boy Wonder, yet this was at a time when the comic-book Batman and Robin had long been neutered and given ludicrous 'villain of the week' tales.
Due to the very nature of the show and the subsequent spin-off movie, so much of the '66 Batman consists of classic soundstage sets. As such, a lot of the action takes place indoors of rickety sets, or the 'outside' scenes will merely have formulaic backdrops in place rather than take place out in the wild.
There were a few more outside antics and city-covering panning shots in Batman: The Movie, but even then what was seen was simply just the real-life California.
9. The DCEU
The Gotham City of the much-maligned DC Extended Universe isn't particularly bad, it's more that we don't really get to see all that much of it.
Given how Ben Affleck's Batman has yet to - and seemingly will not ever get to - star in his own Bat-flick, that means there's not been a whole bunch of time spent in the DCEU's Gotham. Large portions of Batman V Superman took place in Metropolis, whilst the Caped Crusader's role in 2016's Suicide Squad was an extremely fleeting one consisting of a brief alley fight with Deadshot and then a short mid-credits scene with Amanda Waller.
As for Justice League, both cuts of that picture spent minimal time in Gotham as Steppenwolf and his Parademons provided a truly global threat to DC's finest. Unfortunately, that means that the DCEU take on Batman's home city has to rank low down on this list.
To its credit, the gargoyles, architecture and colouring of this Gotham City look impressive. It's just a shame we haven't really had a proper opportunity to fully revel in this take on the famed locale. Then again, some fans absolutely hate this version of Gotham for the simple fact that it is located right next to Metropolis - which is something that differs from what's been seen in the pages of DC Comics over the decades.
There was at least a smidge more of Gotham showcased in 2020's Birds of Prey, of course.
8. Joker
Prior to, and after, its release in 2019, Todd Phillips' Joker was compared to Martin Scorsese offerings such as Taxi Driver and The King of Comedy. While that is indeed a fair comparison in some regards, that also makes Gotham City feel not very, well, Gotham City-like.
Joker's Gotham could well have Travis Bickle parading around in his yellow cab, but this grim, sleezy city doesn't feel all that Batman-esque. Of course, the movie is set at a time when the Dark Knight is merely a young child and at a time before the outrageous capes 'n' tights villains of DC Comics were running roughshod.
On the picture's commentary track, director Phillips even states outright that 1981 New York City was the inspiration for his Gotham City. This very much works for those Taxi Driver vibes, but the end result is a Gotham that doesn't feel particularly familiar. Then again, the original mantra was that Joker was a standalone film that had nothing to do with Batman and absolutely would not be getting a sequel.
Here we are, though, with Joker 2 currently in tentative development. If and when that sequel does arrive, here's hoping that Gotham gets an upgrade to be more in tune with what we know and love from this most infamous of cities.
7. Batman Forever & Batman & Robin
Much like Tim Burton maintained the same vision for Gotham City across Batman and Batman Returns, Joel Schumacher likewise engrained his own preferences into his Gotham in both Batman Forever and Batman & Robin.
Moving away from the darker tone of the two Burton pictures that had predated it, Schumacher's Batman Forever purposely brightened things up. Rather than atmospheric gargoyles up in the darkened Gotham skyline, the Independence Day helmer opted to embrace a neon palette.
Instead of gargoyles, we had ludicrously-sized statues. Instead of rich, deep visuals, we had garish, luminous light shows. Instead of muted character designs for our villains and their goons, we had eccentric, outlandish cornball get-ups to match the tone of this version of Gotham City.
If anything, Schumacher's duo of Batman films owned more to the likes of Akira and the Golden Age of Comics than to the likes of Tim Burton's Batman and Frank Miller's seminal Batman: Year One graphic novel; a graphic novel that Batman Forever was at one point going to be based upon.
Of course, the light 'n' bright nature of Gotham City was only further amped up by the time Schumacher brought Batman & Robin to the silver screen in 1997.
6. Batwoman
Like certain other spins on Gotham City, the Batwoman version of Gotham seems to be one that we'll now never get a chance to revisit.
For those who missed it, The CW formally cancelled Batwoman last month, with the decision made not to renew this particular corner of the network's shared Arrowverse of shows after its third season. Similarly, DC's Legends of Tomorrow was canned at the same time after five seasons, which follows the concluding of Arrow, Supergirl, and Black Lightning in the past two years. Added to that, it looks as if the next season of The Flash could well be the series' last.
Whether the Arrowverse ever delves back into Gotham City remains to be seen, but the chances of any major Gotham happenings seem slim now that the axe has swung on Batwoman.
Throughout Kate Kane and Ryan Wilder's respective times as the Scarlet Knight, the shady side of Gotham often shines through, with Batwoman's spin on the city one very much full of scum and villainy as the titular heroine looks to drag Gotham City out of the gutter following the absence of the Caped Crusader.
5. The Dark Knight Trilogy
The Gotham City of Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy is, for better or worse, very much in tune with the tone of those three movies. By that, it means that Nolan's Gotham is extremely real and extremely grounded.
Of course, this Christian Bale-headlined trio of pictures took a more realistic, tangible approach to the Dark Knight. Rather than the fantastical, fantasy or outright cheesy tone of those Batman films that had preceded it, Nolan's trilogy presented itself as showing how Batman could exist in the real world with real gadgets, real vehicles and extremely real villains.
While this approach clearly worked in bringing a sense of validity and authenticity to Gotham City, it also meant that some of the unique charms of the comic-book Gotham were lost. Pulling inspiration from Chicago, New York City, New Jersey and even Tokyo, this Gotham very much felt like a city we could all find ourselves in at some point, but in doing that it lost some of the otherworldly gothic tones so synonymous with the Gotham City of the comics.
For Batman Begins, The Dark Knight and The Dark Knight Rises, the Gotham seen was perfect. To top this list, though, this Gotham was maybe a little too real for its own good.
4. Titans
It took a while for Gotham City to fully take centre-stage in Titans, but it was pretty darn marvellous when this most iconic of locales was delved into in the show's third season.
Prior to Season Three, Titans had only spent a small amount of time in Gotham, with a good chunk of that coming via flashbacks. For the series' third year, though, the action was largely focussed on a Gotham City that had now completely gone to the dogs. With Jason Todd murdered by the Joker, Batman had in turn killed the Clown Prince of Crime before departing his home city. In his place, it's Dick Grayson and the Titans who rock up to serve as the protectors of Gotham - with Jason resurfacing as the clinical, sinister Red Hood.
With 13 episodes to play with in this season, we got to see the true underbelly of Gotham fleshed out in a way rarely seen before. Sure, FOX's Gotham show spent five seasons set in its titular city, yet the adult tone of Titans meant we really got to see the brutality of Gotham City.
Making this depiction of Gotham particularly refreshing, is how Batman's largely out of the equation for most of Titans' third season - leaving the city's Bat Family focus to revolve around Dick, Barbara Gordon, Jason Todd and Tim Drake.
3. The Batman
If the Joel Schumacher movies went for neon extravagance, and Tim Burton's pictures went for rich gothic charm, Matt Reeves' The Batman served up its Gotham City as an unsettling, sombre backdrop for Robert Pattinson's Batman to fight the good fight.
Due to the extensive runtime - hey there, three hours! - audiences actually get to see a fair old bit of The Batman's Gotham. Whilst often dark and ominous, this is a city that very much feels alive - even if its alive with all kinds of underhand, nefarious deeds.
Here, Pattinson's Dark Knight doesn't necessarily have a fondness for his home city, but more he's dutybound to crack skulls and stop others from making Gotham even more of a cesspit than it is. Grandiose yet intimate, beautifully lit yet depressingly dim, this is a Gotham City that very much matches its version of Batman.
Tonally, this is a Gotham that feels like it was directly pulled from the pages of Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo's work on the Bat-books of the past decade or so - and let's face it, that unequivocably is not a bad thing.
2. Gotham
Given its very title and premise, no movie or TV show has spent as much time in Batman's home city as FOX's Gotham.
For a cumulative 100 episodes across five seasons, audiences got to see the murky, seedy corners of Gotham City, its inhabitants, its growing number of insane rogues, the corruption laced throughout the GCPD, and of course the slow ascension of a certain young Dark Knight.
While there were obvious budget restrictions in place due to being a TV production, Gotham's eponymous locale was absolutely a character in and off itself. Across that centenary of episodes, this Bruno Heller-created series highlighted the many, many pitfalls of Gotham City and delicately - or not so delicately, at times - showed the debilitating, life-altering path this place can put its citizens on.
One could argue that Gotham's, err, Gotham has somewhat of an advantage over the other iterations of this city, but the show completely made the most of its home location. Never before or since has Gotham City felt like such a drain, such an all-powerful force trying to desperately drag its people down to its own murky level.
Marv of Sin City fame once quipped, "Walk down the right back alley of Sin City, and you can find anything". Change out Sin City for Gotham City and you get the idea.
1. Batman & Batman Returns
The famed gothic charm that Tim Burton forever brings to his work made him the perfect fit to tackle Gotham City in his pair of Batman pictures in 1989 and 1992. Bringing in Anton Furst to oversee the production design, Burton crafted a Gotham that was beautifully ugly.
This version of Gotham was dominated by crime, with every smoky alley having some goon or wannabe criminal mastermind lurking in the shadows. Of course, all of this played out in front of some utterly stunning architecture that brilliantly captured locales such as Wayne Manor, the Gotham City Police Department, the offices of the Gotham Globe newspaper, the Gotham Cathedral, and the infamous AXIS Chemicals plant.
Burton managed to capture the otherworldly insanity and industry of Gotham City in a way that really did - and still very much does - bring to life the Gotham that had so often been seen within the comic books. Not just did these two films do an excellent job of bringing the streets and skyscrapers of Gotham to live-action life, mind, for '92's Batman Returns also did a wonderful job of taking a peek under the streets of the city when it came to plot points involving Danny DeVito's Penguin.
To this day, Michael Keaton is Batman to many fans. Likewise, for those same fans and beyond, his Gotham City is the Gotham City.