Batman: Every Live-Action Riddler Ranked Worst To Best

Riddle me this, riddle me that, who fought best against the big bad bat?!

The Riddler Jim Carrey Paul Dano Batman Forever The Batman
Warner Bros.

It's no secret that Bruce Wayne's rogues gallery is one of the most iconic collections of baddies in fiction. If you were to make a list of the best comic-book villains of all time, then the Caped Crusader's biggest enemies would be all over it like crime to Gotham City. Still, fans tend to see a lot of the same when it comes to live-action.

Despite his ever expansive collection of baddies, there isn't much variety in Batman's live-action endeavours. Viewers have gotten used to seeing the likes of Joker or Catwoman again and again, with other compelling antagonists being left on the bench.

However, Edward Nygma himself, otherwise known as The Riddler, sits between overdone and underdone. This Gothamite is best summed up as an unstable genius, as he's always three steps ahead of Batman, thanks to his incredible intellect. Adding even more fuel to this fire is his obsession with puzzles and - you guessed it - riddles.

There have been five live-action Riddlers (thus far), and they certainly vary in degrees of quality. Of course, they all have a charm to them, but some are certainly better than others.

5. John Astin - Batman (1967)

John Astin The Riddler Batman 60 S
20th Century Fox

This entry should start by stating that John Astin is an excellent actor, famed for being the first person to play Gomez Adams in The Adams Family. The man is a legend, but his time in Gotham City is far less iconic than his turn as the head of that Gothic household; in fact, many people forget it even happened.

During the original Batman TV series, Astin was brought in for two episodes to replace Frank Gorshin (a name you'll need to remember). Accounts differ as to why this happened in the first place, with the most popular theory stating that there was a dispute after Gorshin requested a pay rise.

Regardless of why it happened, it's easy to see this version of The Riddler as the weakest. The iteration lasted only two episodes, and while Astin brought a suitable wackiness to the role, it was hard to shake off the legacy of Gorshin. Overall, it seemed like Astin was delivering on a lacklustre impression, leading to the character falling flat.

It was a tough job, and sadly, Astin didn't quite solve this riddle.


4. Jim Carrey - Batman Forever

Batman Forever Jim Carrey Riddler
Warner Bros. Pictures

An acquired taste, to say the least, but one thing is for sure, this version of The Riddler is heaps of fun.

Batman Forever needs no introduction. As one of the most reviled Batman flicks, it's easy to write it off as a real dark spot for the DC Comics icon. But, despite how poorly it handled the Dark Knight, there's no denying that watching Jim Carrey bring his signature energy and wackiness to the role of The Riddler was a blast.

This Edward Nygma was chaotic, silly and entirely self-aware. Carrey went full-in on the character and played him with an insane amount of irreverence, which was easy to laugh along with. However, this was also the character's biggest detraction.

Overall, while this iteration is fun, it's simply too, Jim Carrey. You never get the impression that you're watching the masterminding criminal at work here; instead, you're sitting through Ace Ventura in green spandex.

There is a thrill to be had in The Riddler's physical comedy, but this version falls behind compared to others who took the role a little more seriously.


3. Frank Gorshin - Batman/Batman: The Movie (1966)

Frank Gorshin Riddler
20th Century Fox

First impressions count, and while the original Batman series (and the subsequent movie) might not hold up well by today's dark Batman standard, it still shined a massive spotlight on good old Edward Nygma.

As the first person to take on this role, Gorshin deserves plenty of credit. He played into the part with the theatrical campiness that you would expect from the Adam West series. Still, he had a creepiness to his facial expressions, manic mannerisms and unblinking eyes, which gave this Riddler a more sinister edge.

Overall, Gorshin's Riddler is a two-pronged attack. He's got the typical goofy fun of the early Batman series but an uncanniness that makes him believable as a terrifying villain. This helped to bring The Riddler's popularity right up and even saw him painted as one of Batman's arc-villains.

Gorshin even managed to score an Emmy nomination for the episode "Hi Diddle Riddle", proving that while this version played into campiness, it still got the job done. This performance truly set the benchmark for all future Riddlers.


2. Cory Michael Smith - Gotham

Edward Nygma Riddler Gotham Season 5 Portrait
FOX

Gotham is a show that very much divided the DC fanbase. Many found it an enjoyable holiday from the regular Batman canon, whereas others thought it was a cheap and often poorly executed mess. Still, one thing it certainly got right was casting Cory Michael Smith as a young Riddler.

One thing that Smith captured for arguably the first time in Edward Nygma was his genius intellect. The other iterations played up more to his goofiness and love of puzzles than his high intelligence, but that wasn't the case here. You could fully believe that he was a mental foil to Gotham City's police force, even though he was in his early stages. Plus, having him start out as a forensic scientist working for Gotham City PD was a solid move.

Of course, as with many things in Gotham, *cough* Jerome *cough*, the character wasn't as realised as he could have been, and the show dropped the ball with him many times. However, Smith's performance still toed the line wonderfully between a creepy criminal, goofy nerd and charming bad guy. Thus, he's very deserving of this, almost, top place.


1. Paul Dano - The Batman

The Batman Riddler Paul Dano
Warner Bros.

A lot was riding on this performance, as this was the first time viewers saw a severe version of The Riddler on the big screen. Gone were the days of spandex suits and questions marks; instead came murder, mystery and frights. Naturally, this led to Edward Nashton being easily the scariest version of the character thus far.

Dano managed to juggle the scary and goofy sides of the character really well. His maniacal facial expressions and peculiar mood shifts made you wish he'd taken the mask off earlier in the film. Plus, the not-so-subtle allusions to the Zodiac Killer gave the character a fundamental grounding in reality, even during his goofier moments.

Another major part of what made the character so terrifying was that he was so unassuming once he took the mask off. Edward Nashton looked like the kind of person you could sit next to in a diner and never give a second glance to. But, his innocent and ordinary appearance was a mask for the machinations of a brutal serial killer - a wolf in sheep's clothing indeed.


Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!