Batman V Superman: 10 Theories About Lex Luthor

Could Jesse Eisenberg's Lex Luthor be a secret Kryptonian?

Jesse Eisenberg will play Lex Luthor Jnr in the 2016 DC movie Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice. This, we know for a fact. We also know that he€™ll have the iconic bald headed look at some stage. And, thanks to the trailers, we even know that he€™s got his hands on Zod€™s corpse and plans to experiment on it, likely creating that Doomsday-esque creature that was briefly glimpsed at the end of the most recent trailer. However, there are plenty of things we don€™t know about The Social Network star€™s take on the DC Comics Lex Luthor mythos. We don€™t know exactly what his plan is, what tricks he has up his sleeve, who he might be in allegiance with, or what happened to his dad. Of course, we also don€™t know if Lex will survive this movie and live on in the DC Extended Universe. All these gaps in our current knowledge are good for one thing €“ fan theories. In recent months, the internet has been ablaze with ruminations on Batman V Superman€™s version of Lex Luthor. These speculators have come up with some interesting ideas, it must be said...


10. His Creation Is Not Doomsday

So, the latest trailer for Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice makes it pretty clear €“ if it wasn€™t already €“ that Jesse Eisenberg€™s Lex Luthor does some scientific meddling with Zod€™s corpse, which Kal-El presumably just left lying around at the end of Man Of Steel. It€™s not too much of a jump to assume that the big grey beast that turns up at the end of the movie is the result of said experimentations. Due to some clear visual similarities, many have quickly assumed this creature is Doomsday, an almost-unstoppable force from the comics. Others, though, aren€™t so sure. Perhaps Lex€™s creation isn€™t Doomsday at all. Perhaps it€™s simply Zod reincarnate, with a new Abomination-like form. Or, as some quarters strongly believe, this monstrous menace could be Wraith, another seriously powerful character from the comics. Wraith €“ who traditionally has something of a red glow beneath a cracked black exterior €“ is actually a hero, not a villain. Heralding from outer space, Wraith predated Superman€™s time on Earth (he arrived in 1938) in the comics, and traditionally uses his powers of enhanced strength, speed and energy manipulation in the employ of the US military. This is best considered a long shot, though, because that much-screenshot still from the trailer of the beast looks much more like Doomsday from here.

9. He€™ll Kidnap Martha Kent

One shot from the Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice trailers that lacks much context is that brief glimpse of Henry Cavill€™s Supes kneeling before Lex Luthor. The reasons for this defeatist gesture are currently entirely unclear. That hasn€™t stopped the fans from speculating, though. One online fan theory suggests that Jesse Eisenberg€™s Lex Luthor could kidnap Martha Kent, Clark€™s sole remaining adoptive parent portrayed (by Diane Lane in the DC Extended Universe). By snatching and threatening Clark€™s only parental figure left alive, Lex could perhaps blackmail Superman into obeying his orders. This theory seems plausible, but there isn€™t much to back it up just yet. At this stage, Diane Lane has only appeared in the trailers to impart advice to Clark. So, if she has a larger role to play, Zack Snyder and co. have it firmly under wraps. There are also other reasons that Superman could begrudging bow down to Lex, of course. We€™ve already glimpsed both Kryptonite and that Doomsday-esque creature in the trailer. It seems pretty clear that Lex is looking for ways to defeat Superman. Perhaps, rather than kill him, Lex is actually looking to control him using the threat of death as Supes€™ motivation. Only time will tell exactly why Superman kneels before Lex.

8. He's A Kryptonian

In the comics, Lex Luthor and his son Lex Luthor Jnr €“ of which Jesse Eisenberg is playing the latter incarnation €“ are both humans. Lex€™s power traditional comes from his villainy, his business smarts, and sometimes a big robotic suit invented to even the odds in his many battles against Superman. In Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice, though, all of that could change. According to one fan theory, Zack Snyder€™s latest superhero movie could resurrect an idea from J.J. Abrams€™ unproduced script Superman: Flyby. Therein, a UFO-obsessed Lex Luthor was later revealed to be a Kryptonian. There are a few ways to incorporate this idea into Batman V Superman. Although it would mean ignoring a few prequel comics, perhaps the open pod in the giant Kryptonian spaceship Clark found was actually once home to a young Lex, who was adopted by Lex Snr in his youth. Even if the powers that be are saving that pod for something else, it wouldn€™t take long within the film to weave in a unique backstory for Jesse Eisenberg€™s Lex. This one sounds surprisingly plausible. Giving Lex Kryptonian abilities would make for a fairer fight in the third act, after all, as well as injecting a big twist reveal into the movie. We've looked at this theory in more detail, here.

7. He's Wearing A Wig

We know two hard facts about Jesse Eisenberg€™s hairstyles in Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice. For one, we€™ve seen that floppy dirty brown barnet countless times throughout the trailers. In official pictures released to the press (see above), we€™ve also seen Jesse Eisenberg sporting a traditional Lex Luthor bald-headed look. A lot of people are assuming that Lex €“ being quite young €“ will go bald over the course of the film, perhaps as a result of all these weird experiments he€™s been dabbling in. However, showing how minute a detail can inspire fan theories these days, some fans have been quick to speculate that Lex is wearing a wig from the start. According to this theory, Eisenberg€™s villain went bald ages ago, and is now trying to hide it with a trendy wig. This, presumably, would be a metaphor for the supervillain persona that Lex is attempting to hide beneath the veneer of being a young entrepreneurial whizz-kid. Of course, if this theory turns out to be true, Lex€™s wig could also become a comic relief feature in the film. Like Gene Hackman before him, we could see Jesse Eisenberg flapping around attempting to keep his hairpiece in place while chaotic situations unfold around him. Post-Man Of Steel, the DC movies could do with a few comedic beats, so this wouldn't be entirely unwelcome.

6. His Hyperactive Tendencies Are An Act

In the trailers, we€™ve seen Lex Luthor played in a very Jesse Eisenberg-y way. Clearly, The Social Network star was asked to bring some of those manic, hyperactive tendencies from his memorable Mark Zuckerberg biopic role to the part of Lex. However, perhaps this is just an act. Maybe Lex acts in this awkward, unsettled way to distract other characters from his true intentions. Maybe, we€™re being led to believe that Lex Luthor is a familiar sort of character (essentially an evil twist on the social media magnate Zuckerberg), in order to throw us off the scent of what he€™s really like. Underneath this hyperactive exterior, there could well be a cold and calculating character underneath. This, at the very least, would allow Eisenberg to try something that we haven€™t seen him attempt before. That wouldn€™t be unwelcome, by any stretch of the imagination. Presumably, whether or not this theory ends up being true depends on how the movie plays Lex€™s villains origins. If he€™s a business wonder-kid who suddenly turns evil, it seems unlikely that he€™d have a secret second personality ready made. But if Lex has always been a villain, perhaps the Zuckerberg-esque behaviour is just a front?

5. He's Working For Darkseid (Or Similar)

So far, one thing that the DC Extended Universe lacks is an equivalent to the Marvel Cinematic Universe€™s big bad Thanos €“ a lurking threat in the background to help the overarching arc of the shared universe along. Every time Thanos pops up €“ even for a seconds-long post credits sting - the internet explodes in reaction. DC, surely, will want to get in on that. The easiest way to achieve this would be for DC Entertainment/Warner Bros to bring in their own massive supervillain. Darkseid €“ a godlike creature from the comics, who constantly threatens to destroy planets and take over the universe - seems like a logical choice. In the comics, Darkseid predated Thanos and actually inspired his creation. As Lex Luthor is the most prominent villain in Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice, the easiest way to introduce Darkseid €“ or another overarching baddie €“ would be to reveal that Lex is in their employ. Maybe that€™s how Lex gets hold of Kryptonite, learns about Zod€™s corpse and manages to create his big grey monster. Should this turn out to be the case, it wouldn't be unprecedented - it€™d be a similar arrangement to Loki working as Thanos€™ lackey in The Avengers, or Ronan doing his bidding in Guardians Of The Galaxy. So maybe don't rule out a Darkseid-unveiling credits sting just yet.

4. He€™s Planning A Cyber Attack

It€™s clear that Jesse Eisenberg€™s villain has it in for Superman, and has been experimenting with Kryptonite and Zod€™s corpse to find a way to bring him down. He€™ll seemingly create that Doomsday-like beast from the trailers, forcing the sparring villains of Batman V Superman to team up and stop it. But what if that isn€™t the only scheme Lex has up his sleeve? Promotional materials for the film suggest that he might be cooking up some form of technological terror as well. This fan theory was spawned by an official tie-in website, all about Lex OS - the world€™s €˜most private and secure operating system.€™ It melds €˜the security you need with the freedom you want,€™ according to a brief video. Knowing Lex Luthor as we do, though, it€™s easy to assume that he€™s actually plotting some sort of cyber villainy under this guise. Perhaps it€™ll be a topical invasion-of-privacy hack, used as a way to gain evil intelligence. Or maybe Lex OS will go off the rails an become a cybernetic villain like Brainiac. Only time will tell. We do know, though, that Lex€™s fictional Fortune profile describes "a product that will protect you, and everyone, from threats you don't even know about yet.€ Whatever those threats are, you can probably bet that Lex will be making them, not protecting you from them.

3. He Killed His Father

Another slice of intel garnered from Lex Luthor€™s fictitious Fortune magazine profile is that Jesse Eisenberg isn€™t the traditional Lex Luthor. He€™s Lex Luthor Jnr, who inherited the iconic villainous company LexCorp from his father, Lex Luthor Snr. €œDad named the company after himself ten years before I made my unexpected entrance into his life,€ Lex Luthor Jnr is quoted as saying during the article, before adding that €œwhatever else he was, he was a good businessman.€ Descriptive words assigned to Lex Luthor Snr that pop up include €˜indomitable€™ and €˜vicious.€™ This paints a picture suggesting that the relationship between Lex Snr and Lex Jnr wasn€™t an entirely happy one. Some fan theorists have gone to the next level with this assumption €“ what if Lex Jnr killed his dad? Lex Snr is said to have €˜unexpectedly€™ passed away in 2000, and that€™s all we know. That€™s certainly grounds enough for speculation. It remains to be seen exacrlt why would Lex kill his own father, though. It€™ll be a while until we find out, but there is one tantalising detail in the article hasn't yet been touched upon: before his death, Lex Snr was obsessed with €˜strange meteorite crystals.€™ That, surely, will become significant.

2. His Father Isn't Dead, And He€™ll Be Back

Alternatively, there€™s also speculation afoot that Lex Luthor Snr isn€™t as dead as the world seems to think. That €˜unexpected€™ death in the year 2000 could have been a cover up, as Lex Snr sought a way to get under the radar for reasons unknown. Perhaps there€™s a bigger €˜legacy of the Luthors€™ arc underway here, that hasn€™t been revealed yet. Maybe Lex Snr left Lex Jnr in charge while he worked on a shady evil project in seclusion somewhere. Exactly what this project would be remains to be seen, but perhaps it has something to do with those meteors that Luthor Snr collected. Maybe, as they both seem obsessed with aliens, the Luthors are cooking up a scheme that€™ll see them using other worldly artefacts and alien assistance to achieve something big. Lex Luthor Snr has been President of the United States in the comics before. Maybe the DC Extended Universe is headed that way. Either way, the idea of the classic-style older Lex returning to the screen at some point is tantalising proposition. Unless we see an open casket funeral in a flashback at some stage, don't rule it out, either in Batman V Superman or a future DC movie.

1. He€™ll Return For Suicide Squad

Whether or not Lex Luthor Jnr turns out to be a Kryptonian, a cyber terrorist, a lackey to Darkseid, or less of an orphan than we€™ve been led to believe, there€™s one thing we can be pretty certain of €“ Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice won€™t be his only appearance in the DC Extended Universe. Indeed, some fan theorists are already suggesting that Jesse Eisenberg€™s Lex will make an appearance in David Ayer€™s August 2016 villain team-up movie, Suicide Squad. If true, this would mark €“ as far as this writer€™s memory can confirm €“ the first time the same villain, played by the same actor, had shown up in two separate live action comic book films in the same year. It€™s certainly not too much of a stretch to believe this one. If Lex ends up in custody at the end of Batman V Superman, a cameo €“ or more €“ in Suicide Squad is entirely plausible, not least because the eponymous squad of that movie is traditionally compiled of incarcerated bad guys. Or if Lex Luthor escapes imprisonment in Bats V Supes, maybe the US government will send the Suicide Squad after him. Either way, you can see how it would make narrative sense €“ within the cross-pollenating DC universe €“ to give Jesse Eisenberg a role in Suicide Squad. It hasn€™t been confirmed or denied yet, but it seems highly likely. What do you think about Jesse Eisenberg€™s Lex Luthor Jnr? Let us know your theories in the comments€

Contributor
Contributor

Film & TV journo. Quite tall.