Batman vs Superman: 10 Reasons Jesse Eisenberg As Lex Luthor Is All Wrong

Casting Jesse Eisenberg Lex Luthor The internet exploded on Friday, literally exploded and out of the debris crawled the Batman Vs Superman trolls. Why the sudden controversy? Was Ben Affleck cast as Superman as well as Batman? Well, not quite. Instead, Warner Bros. announced Mark Zuckerb... Jesse Eisenberg has been cast in the upcoming blockbuster as Lex Luthor, Superman's arch nemesis. The fanboy reaction has been extremely mixed, ranging from positively gushing to angrily resentful to just plain meh, but at the end of the day, no one knows what will really come of this unusual casting choice until 2019, when the film will be finally released after its 39th delay. I for one am extremely dubious about this recent development. Does Eisenberg have what it takes to face off against Superman and Batman? I doubt it. If you're thinking along the same lines as me, then read on for some reasons you may not have thought of and if you don't agree, I'm here to change your mind. Let me know your thoughts in the comments section below, just as long as you're not one of those pesky Batman Vs Superman trolls who are negative just for the sake of it. No one wants that.

10. Eisenberg Is WAY Too Young

Fans who are against this casting decision have cited a number of reasons for their discontent, but one of the most popular reasons given is that Eisenberg is just too young for the role. Gene Hackman and Kevin Spacey both played Luthor in their late 40's, so at just thirty years old, Eisenberg may be too baby-faced to pull this off. Yes, I am aware that Henry Cavill is only thirty years old too, but Lex Luthor has always been portrayed as an established business tycoon and it's hard to imagine someone as young as Eisenberg act believably in that role. Sure, Mark Zuckerberg was successful at an even younger age, as portrayed by Eisenberg in The Social Network, but we're talking about Luthor here, an iconic character that's been knocking around for over seventy years in the world of comics. You don't mess with the fanboys. Poor Jesse. If only he'd been born ten years earlier.

9. Eisenberg Is Too Geeky

When you think of Lex Luthor, what's the first thing that comes to mind? Yes, obviously apart from bald. Smart, ruthless, arrogant... I have no doubt that Eisenberg could play these attributes and maybe he'd do a good job of it, but would he nail the part? I think not my friends, for you see, Eisenberg is just a bit too geeky.

I know, I know, geek chic and all that, but is that what we want from our new Lex Luthor? A wealthy, power-hungry sociopath... who looks like he plays dungeons and dragons in his parents basement on weekends? Hmmmm... perhaps not. I can just see Batman and Superman quaking in their boots at the every thought!

8. Eisenberg Is Not A Box Office Draw

We all know Batman Vs Superman will be one of the biggest films released this decade, regardless of quality, but Zack Snyder's unusual casting choices have unsettled many fans. Casting a big, reliable Hollywood name for the role of Lex Luthor would have reassured audiences that there is at least some quality control on this thing.

Eisenberg's most successful film to date is The Social Network. Did people go see that movie for Eisenberg? No. Did audiences flock to follow up films like Now You See Me and 30 Minutes Or Less to get a glimpse of their new favorite star? Hell no. I understand Eiesenberg is more of a character actor, but Henry Cavill isn't exactly a household name either and the whole Batfleck drama has already destroyed lives. Batman Vs Superman is relying too much on peoples love of the comic book properties. Snyder needs a big name to draw in the skeptical audiences.

7. Eisenberg Has No Physical Presence

Super villains of Lex Luthor's stature emanate a presence. When they walk into a room, everyone knows it. Jesse Eisenberg is 5'7 and looks about 20. What's that going to look like in comparison to Henry Cavill who's 6'1 tall and Ben Affleck who comes in at a whopping 6'4?

I know Luthor is more about the brains, but Eisenberg doesn't even sound menacing. Give me Clancy Brown any day, the voice actor who played Luthor brilliantly in the numerous animated DC shows. Brown has more presence and gravitas with just his voice alone than Eisenberg does in his entire body, messy hair and all. Audiences need to believe that a non-powered business mogul has the balls to take on two of the world's most powerful heroes and win. I'd be surprised if Eisenberg could even convince in an arm wrestling contest against Krypto the dog.

6. Eisenberg Has Big Shoes To Fill - Kevin Spacey

A number of actors have played Lex Luthor since he first debuted in Action Comics #23, each to varying degrees of success. One of the more popular interpretations in recent years was Kevin Spacey's take on the role for Superman Returns, Bryan Singer's reboot from 2006. Sure, many fans thought the film sucked beyond all reason, but Spacey was singled out as a highlight of the movie for his more sinister interpretation that stayed true to the comics.

Spacey has always been highly respected, particularly since he won an Academy Award back in 1999 for American Beauty and his sinister onscreen presence is almost unparalleled in cinema today. Will Eisenberg manage to make the character his own so soon after Spacey nailed the role? This fan is doubtful.

5. Eisenberg Has Even Bigger Shoes To Fill - Gene Hackman

More big shoes to fill I'm afraid. Many fans still hold up the original Superman movie from 1978 as the best adaptation so far and therefore see Gene Hackman as the definitive Lex Luthor, despite his more light-hearted take on the role. Sure, his comedic approach may not have aged particularly well, but Hackman's performance is now legendary amongst fans of the franchise. Today, Gene Hackman is one of the acting greats, yet even by 1978, Hackman already had an Oscar for Best Actor and another two supporting actor nominations under his belt, bringing a huge amount of credibility to a film many would have seen as childish at the time. Comic books have since gained a more mature audience, but does Eisenberg have what it takes to match the respect that Hackman brought to the role? Once again, this fan is doubtful.

4. Eisenberg Has Too Much Hair

I know what you're thinking. Slap a bald cap on Eisenberg and he's ready to go, but you've got to think to yourself, can Eisenberg pull it off? I know that might not sound important to some of you, but Luthor's look is defined by that gleaming noggin and if Eisenberg looks ridiculous without hair, the entire performance will instantly lose all credibility.

I don't care how realistic the bald cap might end up looking: Eisenberg's appearance is memorable because of that curly mop of hair on his head and without it, audiences will be completely distracted during the all-important villains monologue, looking for the seam where the forehead ends and the bald cap begins.

3. Eisenberg Is Not Bryan Cranston

Bryan Cranston This may come as a shock to some of you, but the internet doesn't always tell the truth. As soon as Batman Vs Superman was first announced, hordes of fans and journalists claimed that man of the moment Bryan Cranston was in the running for the coveted role of Lex Luthor. This made perfect sense as Cranston proved in the Emmy Award winning show Breaking Bad that he could convince as a man of dubious morals with the charisma and dark screen presence that the role requires. Also, he's bald. Unfortunately, when Warner Bros. announced Eisenberg had been cast in the role, the majority of fanboys everywhere heaved a huge sigh of disappointment. Cranston fits the bill in every way, so many fans saw his eventual casting as a given. Eisenberg now has a lot to prove in a role many assumed had already been reserved for someone else. From the moment his casting made the headlines, Eisenberg was fighting a losing battle. Damn you Cranston! You would have been so awesome!

2. Eisenberg Is The Same In Every Role

Even before he was cast in the role, I always thought that Eisenberg was a one trick pony. Let's face it; his entire career is based on him playing the same anxious, socially awkward character in every role. The Squid and the Whale, Adventureland, Zombieland... Eisenberg is literally the exact same in every film. They might as well have given his character the same name in each. I'm not saying Eisenberg is a bad actor per se, but when Batman Vs Superman is eventually released, I won't see Lex Luthor on the big screen. I'll see Jesse Eisenberg in a bald cap. The biggest problem here is that Eisenberg's mannerisms and tone of voice are very distinct, so even if he does pull out a strong performance, all I'll be thinking is "Damn you Zuckerberg! Andrew Garfield deserved some credit!"

1. Eisenberg Is Just Not Good Enough

If I haven't convinced you yet that Eisenberg will be disastrous as Luthor, this final point certainly won't, but I felt it just needed to be said. Eisenberg isn't quite there yet as an actor, he's not ready to take on a role of this magnitude. His Academy Award nominated performance in The Social Network was certainly a step in the right direction, but it's too soon in Eisenberg's career to play such a huge character. Give him another five, maybe ten years or so to demonstrate some versatility and perhaps he'd be more suited to the role. Whether you agree with my views or not, only time will tell whether Eisenberg will be disastrous as Luthor. I'd love to hear your opinions on what you think of the casting choices Snyder has made and more about the the film in general, but remember guys; Even if you don't agree with me, remember to respect mine and other people's opinions. Trolls aren't welcome.

Contributor
Contributor

David is a primary school teacher who tries his best to turn every math lesson into a discussion on the latest Pixar film. Passions include superheroes, zombies and Studio Ghibli. In between going to the cinema, moving to South Korea and eating his body weight in KFC, David writes for a number of movie sites, http://becarefulyourhand.blogspot.co.uk/