Ben Affleck: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Great Batman. Shame about the Bruce Wayne.

People just can't seem to make up their mind on Ben Affleck. Fellow comeback king Matthew McConaughey had a very simple up-down-up trajectory, but Affleck has flip-flopped back and forth so many times He burst on the screen playing generic tough guys, but working with buddies Kevin Smith and Matt Damon developed serious nerd and artistic cred, something he managed to trample with a string of mindless action roles. Then we got Bennifer, which is a whole arc in itself, with the public switching from loving to hating the couple in no time at all and their break-up (along with a string of duds) seemingly burying Affleck. But not so: he came roaring back, this time in the director's seat and in just three films showed a hitherto unseen intelligence and put another Oscar on his mantle. Whew, even Universal Studios doesn't have a rollercoaster as turbulent as that. Heck, the actor-director-writer-producer's reputation fluctuates so much people couldn't even keep consistent about a singular role; when he was announced as Batman the response was overwhelmingly negative (he has the chin, isn't that all that matters?), but gradually fans have come round, to the point where many went into Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice expecting him to be the best version of the Dark Knight ever. Now that movie's arrived and we finally get to have a look at his Caped Crusader, it's time to go back through his filmography and pick out some of the most noteworthy performances in the rise-and-fall-and-rise-and-fall-and-rise of Ben Affleck. These aren't Affleck's worst or best performances, but they're some of his most remarkable and, with him now Batman for the forseeable, are definitely worth a revisit.

5 Awesome Performances:

5. Batman - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice

The whole "actor is cast in a Batman film to massive fan backlash, only to turn out quite good" thing is becoming a cliche right of passage, and while Affleck is no Michael Keaton (or Christian Bale), there's no denying his Batman is great. From the Arkham school of action, this is a violent, no-holds-barred take on the Caped Crusader with incomparable strength and an agility despite "getting slow" in old age. Like Bale's take there's a strong understanding of Batman as a symbol, but he brings the other comic aspects with him too (he even does a bit of detecting at one point). You buy this man would be bale to go up against a god and not have his neck snapped after to minutes. Of course, like everyone in the film Affleck suffers from Zack Snyder's direction, especially when it comes to the "no kill" rule - put bluntly, this Bats doesn't care - but Affleck has enough grounding and understanding to make the superhero work regardless. The greater detectives of you may have noticed that this was all about the superhero side of the performance. And that's for a reason that will become apparent later on.

4. Fred O'Bannion - Dazed And Confused

Ben Affleck only has a small part in Richard Linklater's seminal, oddly timeless coming-of-age drama - he's a hazing senior, chasing around new freshmen trying to paddle them, eventually getting his comeuppance in the form of a dousing of paint - to the point where it's easy to forget (compared to the more prominent likes of Matthew McConaughey and Milla Jovovich) he's even in the film. However, I'd still say it's a pretty essential piece of his filmography. In his early career (especially before winning the Oscar for writing Good Will Hunting), it was very easy to disregard Affleck as being only able to play brutes, with only his friendship with Kevin Smith a clue to his deeper smarts. And yet here, in one of his earliest screen roles, is a sense of astute understanding; O'Bannion isn't just a bully, even though that's all he needed to be. Instead, Affleck injects the moments where he's not trying to beat kids several years his junior (half a deacde if we're going by real age) with an affability - he's pally with Wooderson and when just chilling with his friends has no sense of coiled anger. Even the biggest, older bully still has an underlying humanity.

3. Doug MacRay - The Town

Ben originally planned to star in Gone Baby Gone, but wound up casting younger brother Casey instead, making The Town his first time of directing himself. And, as we'd see subsequently, he's pretty damn good at that, one of those rare actors who can actually get more out of himself than a removed filmmaker. A proper Boston movie, director Affleck does the typical "City is character" trick, and does so very well, but his personification Beantown is nothing compared to the humans involved; Jeremy Renner's psycho Jem in particular, but his own lead too. Affleck is Doug MacRay, a bank robber who falls into a relationship with a former hostage and subsequently into a conflict between his job and his life. It's not the most original arc, but. as with his direction, the actor endeavors to to make it as truthful as possible, attempting to capture reality rather than sensationalise for entertainment purposes. This is both why The Town was praised on release and hasn't had quite the longevity it deserves.

2. Tony Mendez - Argo

Remember what I said about sensationalism with The Town? Well with Argo Affleck isn't quite as restrained, especially in its third act where convenience gets in the way of reality. But it works because what the director brings in addition is a real grasp of building tension, balancing historical authenticity with making a great film. However, while Argo is certainly a more spectacular film than his previous examples, he maintains that previous subtlety within his own performance. Once again the lead, he's Tony Mendez, the CIA operative behind the Canadian Caper - a daring rescue of US Embassy personnel from Tehran during the Iranian Revolution by masquerading as location scouts for a cheap Star Wars rip-off. For decades a classified operation that left Mendez an unsung hero, this is expertly reflected in his hunched demeanor and the similar struggle he has with connecting with his son. In fact, while as a period thriller Argo is enticing, it's the character's emotional arc that really sells it. Affleck's Mendez grounds the political and filmmaking swipes, making it all feel incredibly personal.

1. Nick Dunne - Gone Girl

Gone Girl is a movie all about deception: it comes across as a simple potboiling thriller based on what based on the cover is a flavour of the month novel, yet emerges as a scathing assault on relationships and the sanctity of marriage; what could have been David Fincher on auto-pilot is actually him working at his most darkly scathing; and two performances that seemed easy to lock down from the trailers are actually some of the best their actors have ever given. Of course much more focus is put on Rosamund Pike's Amy, whose meek personality and abusive relationship are revealed as all an act at the midway point, turning a missing person whodunnit into something much darker, but Affleck is just as strong and intriguing as her everyman husband, Nick. Calling Nick an everyman certainly burns, because even though he's the victim he's still a somewhat simple husband who can't deliver on his original promise of marriage, but that's the point of the movie; in relationships neither side is perfect (although psychos are definitely worse). Affleck carries this perfectly, over the course of the movie evolving from happy, out-of-love schlub into a smiling facade that hides a developed anger. Let's just hope it's not based on real experiences. But for every high there's a low, so let's take a look at Affleck's less-than-finest hours.

5 Performances That Sucked

5. Bruce Wayne - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice

I couldn't honestly put Batfleck on the Awesome list without a massive "but", and this is it. Once the initial casting backlash died down everyone kinda assumed he'd be brilliant and, like Johnny Depp's "comeback" with Black Mass, some people have actually taken the pre-release hype as post-viewing analysis, even though that's not quite right. You see, while Affleck's Batman is solid, his Bruce Wayne is a little odd, little more than the Dark Knight sans mask with a very thin facade that struggles to be taken seriously in social interactions. There is no line between Bruce Wayne in the Bat-cave and Bruce Wayne the socialite (as there most certainly was with Keaton and Bale); he is simply a grumpy old man who only changes when he puts on a costume. Maybe Affleck's played it this way, but as there's little point of reference to ground it it never feels like a proper character; there's really only one short scene where he embraces the role, and that is quickly turned back onto the plot without giving a sense of his underlying character. Now maybe later movies will prove this wrong - much of the problem here comes from the direction as much as the performance - but for now I'm not sold on Affleck as Bruce Wayne.

4. Matt Murdock/Daredevil - Daredevil

Taking on Daredevil probably seemed like a genius move to Ben Affleck in the wake of X-Men, but it instead became a career mistake that so offended comic book fans his subsequent successes were rendered moot when he was cast as Batman. He swaggers through the movie, overconfident as Matt Murdock and offensively cliche as his alter ego. To Affleck's credit, the entire movie is leaden, as if it was cut by an actual blind man, and it just doesn't work in conveying any sense of character. His Daredevil is a derivative of Batman (and not the comic character, but the Val Kilmer version) and this choice is what really hampers the film. But it's not even got a stellar performance to ground it. I mean, just look at that face. Oh, and while the director's cut is technically a better movie (if not by as much as some people claim), the central performance is still as drab.

3. Neil - To The Wonder

I should probably preface this entry with the disclaimer that I am not a fan of this newly reemergent Terrence Malick. His movies have become fluid pieces so vague that you can read them as a meditation on just about anything if you try hard enough, but at the same time they are really about nothing. Alongside all this pondering, he's managed to get severely mixed performances out of A-List actors; I will concede that Brad Pitt was excellent in The Tree Of Life, but he shared that movie with Sean Penn who stood in an elevator for most of the movie then strolled on a muddy beach looking drunk. And that's in a movie that has hints of competent filmmaking. You don't want to even get to To The Wonder, an alleged romance starring Affleck and Olga Kurylenko. As Affleck has excelled in the past from having a detailed character to work with, that goes some distance to explaining why what's here is so ambling and detached; he falls four of Malick's distant direction. It's a frustrating performance, because there is a real humanity to it, but between the director Affleck's given and how it's presented that's all crushed.

2. Rafe McCawley - Pearl Harbour

Like Daredevil, Pearl Harbour is another movie that has an awful lot more than just a rubbish Affleck performance at its rotten core, and like To The Wonder you can place quite a lot of blame at the director's feet, but that can't be used as a defence of what he delivered here. So yes, Michael Bay's transparent attempt to replicate the success of Titanic is a terrible movie - overlong, historically confused, incomprehensibly constructed and, well, directed by Michael "F*ck the frame" Bay. And, yes, this is Affleck really flailing in subpar material with little help, but he doesn't help himself. Why he took the project broadly makes sense - at this point Bay was still somewhat well revered, yet to sink to his ultimate, robot balls bottom - but he brings nothing to Rafe, playing straight machismo and preening love triangle corner in a rote manner.

1. Larry Gigli - Gigli

The movie that gave the world Bennifer and DC fans a reason to moan about Affleck as Batman, Gigli is an astounding movie. Critically panned and a seismic box office bomb at the time, its position as an-all out disaster is undisputed, but watching it outside of all the topical jibes it's somehow even more of an awful spectacle. There's something fascinating about films where the two romantic leads wound up dating in real life, especially when they don't appear to share any discernible chemistry on screen, and Gigli stands as a masterwork of the form. Jennifer Lopez is dependably awful in everything she's in and has a distinct talent of being able to drag everyone around her down with her, although even against Jennifer Lawrence Affleck would still be flailing. His Larry Gigli (one of the worst names ever conceived) is a laughable gangster who speaks delicately and looks gormless, not even trying to elevate the material. He's the bull alright. What's your favourite Ben Affleck performance? And what's his worst? Share you thoughts down in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.