Ben Affleck's Batman: What Went Wrong?

Hello darkness my old friend.

Ben Affleck Batman
Warner Bros

Batman is dead. Long live Batman.

After years of speculation, toing and froing, coming and going, and 'he's in...he's out' reports, Ben Affleck's tenure as Batman really is over. Matt Reeves' The Batman (which it may or may not end up being called) has been scheduled for release on June 25, 2021, a new, younger actor will be cast in the title role, and Affleck has signalled the passing of the torch with a tweet about how excited he is to see it.

It completes a huge turnaround in fortunes for Affleck who, after initial scepticism and typical outrage to his surprise casting way back in 2013, managed to win some DC fans around. Initially planned to be a Batman for the long-term, he's starred in Batman v Superman and Justice League, alongside a cameo in Suicide Squad, but it now seems very unlikely we'll ever see him anywhere in the DCEU again.

He's gone from the Oscar-winning talent behind Argo to the man unwanted in the cape and cowl, so what exactly happened along the way for things to get to this stage?


5. Sad Affleck & Batman V Superman's Failure

Batman V Superman Batman
Warner Bros.

After the initial scepticism, there was some promise ahead of Batman v Superman's release. The trailers weren't great, but they did do a pretty decent job of showcasing Affleck's take on the Dark Knight.

Unfortunately, then the reviews hit, which a then blissfully unaware Affleck was asked about during an interview for the film, his forlorn look getting the meme treatment. Yes, Affleck was saying hello to his old friend darknes as, after being so reluctant to take on another comic book role after Daredevil, he was getting panned for a superhero performance yet again. Although that wasn't exactly a disaster, with the internet quickly moving on, it was indicative of how things would go from then on out.

Batman v Superman released in March 2016 after said negative reviews, and while it wasn't a complete bomb at the box-office, it was a big disappointment. The previous two Batman movies had grossed over $1bn, so for a movie that had Bats AND Supes in the title to take in $873m (against a budget of $250m) just wasn't good enough, especially not when combined with the poor reception.

In fairness, though, the fault wasn't with Affleck, but more the overall grimdark tone of the movie, its muddled plotting, a lack of actual Batman v Superman action, weak villains, and Snyder's themes not quite meshing with making an entertaining blockbuster of the ilk people had come to expect from a Batman film. Even four years on, the spectre of Christopher Nolan's take loomed large, and that didn't help the movie's performance any either. Suffice to say, even for fans of the movie, it wasn't an encouraging start to his time in the Batsuit, nor the DCEU as a whole. Still, it wasn't as though Batman v Superman released and Affleck suddenly started questioning his entire involvement, but the beginning was also the beginning of the end given how the DCEU failed to truly launch.


4. Stepping Down From Directing The Batman

Batman Ben Affleck
Warner Bros.

Along with being the star of Batman v Superman, Ben Affleck had also been tapped to direct a solo outing for the Caped Crusader. Even more than his performance as Bruce Wayne, this was particularly exciting, because through Gone Baby Gone, The Town, and Argo, Affleck had proven himself as a far better director than he is actor (and that's supposed to speak volumes of his directorial talents, rather than his acting shortcomings).

Affleck's reputation as a director took a hit after the release of Live By Night, which bombed critically and commercially upon release in December 2016, and a month later he announced that he was stepping down as director on the solo Batman film, although he remained attached to star and produce.

It was made clear at the time that Live By Night wasn't the reason, although it must've had some impact upon his frame of mind and confidence in his ability to do Batman justice. Matt Reeves was then brought in to direct, and while everyone reiterated Affleck's commitment, it was here that the almost neverending chatter of him potentially leaving the role really started. Reeves had his own ideas for what to do with a Batman film, his own favourite comics to pull from and personality to inject, so there was always going to be doubt over Affleck fitting in.

Not only that, but it looked as though the writing was on the wall. If you've been set to write and direct a film, would you be content to simply star in it? If you're coming on-board to write and direct, would you want an actor who had been the first choice to do your job? Not to doubt the professionalism of either individual, but that's a lot of baggage that would be better off avoided for all concerned, not least the movie itself.


3. Justice League And The End Of Snyder's Vision

DCEU Zack Snyder
Warner Bros.

For all the talk of his solo film, Affleck was still contracted to star in Justice League, which was then wasn't under the control of Zack Snyder, the man who'd signed him up to the DCEU in the first place.

When Justice League was released, it was another relative failure for Warner Bros, grossing just $657m against a budget that is estimated to have ballooned to around $300m. Yet again, though, Affleck wasn't the main target of criticism, but more of victim of more macro problems with the film's tone, script, and editing, which stemmed from Warner Bros attempting to quickly course correct after Batman v Superman, and the fact that Justice League was the product of two very different filmmakers.

Those changes had a serious impact not just on Justice League's overall quality (which suffered more from Joss Whedon than it did Zack Snyder), but how Affleck's Batman fit into things. It was clear that Affleck had signed on for a specific vision of the character - the older, scarred Batman we meet in Dawn of Justice, who is able to learn from Superman and become a better, brighter hero, with Snyder's plan believed to eventually end with Batman sacrificing himself to save the world - but with all of the changes to Justice League, that went out of the window.

Of all the characters hurt by Whedon's extensive reshoots, Batman might have come off worst. His arc started to disappear, while the character was injected with more humour to keep with WB's shift to a much lighter tone. That not really being within his character much, though, it often fell quite flat, while the character didn't feel as useful in the action scenes next to the likes of Wonder Woman, Aquaman, and The Flash. Justice League was like two films in one, and Batman was the most evident of that, as though you could see him being pulled in two different directions. After Justice League, Snyder's vision was done with, but that also meant that what Affleck had signed up for had failed too, much like it had with Daredevil many years before. It's no surprise that after that we heard he was looking for "a cool way to segue out" of the role.


2. Matt Reeves Wanted Something Very Different

Matt Reeves The Batman
Warner Bros.

While Matt Reeves largely played coy with regards to who would don the cape and cowl in his Batman movie - alongside persistent rumours that Affleck wouldn't be in the movie - it did become increasingly clear that he had his own vision for the character.

That's to be expected, really. Reeves isn't a hired gun director, but someone who very much likes to inject his own sensibilities into projects to make them as personal to him as possible, as witnessed by the shift in style and tone from Rise of the Planet of the Apes to Dawn and War (and Reeves' films just so happened to be much better too). It needs to be character driven, and that's harder to do when you're coming to a character with two movies worth of development - not to mention the fact this version of Batman has been doing it for 20-years or so - than it is when starting from scratch with your own complete idea.

Reeves didn't mention names, but he did speak of wanting to tell an emotional story with the character, along with wanting to get back to the detective roots, telling a point-of-view, noir-tinged storyline that would really emphasise the focus on the character's billing as World's Greatest Detective. That's a great idea, and the kind that really ought to have been done on the big screen by now, but it also jarred with the original vision for the DCEU's version of the character, especially with Affleck no longer directing or writing the movie either.

Reeves is still being vague on what kind of actor he wants, but the various reports have all stated he's looking for someone much younger than Affleck - around the 25-25 bracket has commonly been mooted - as he looks for not only a dramatic shift to what the DCEU has done. but a real fresh start too, as he's made reference to it not being in the same universe, which just further distanced things from Affleck.


1. A New Future For The DC Universe

Aquaman Billion
Warner Bros

After the release of Justice League, things weren't looking good for the DCEU. Zack Snyder's vision had fallen apart, and out of the movies released up to that point - Man of Steel, Batman v Superman, Suicide Squad, Wonder Woman, and Justice League - only one of them was a success in all senses of the word. There were big changes upstairs, lots of talk about what might happen, various plans thrown at the wall, without a whole lot of action.

Fast forward just over a year, though, and suddenly the future looks a hell of a lot brighter. Aquaman is now the highest-grossing DC film of all time, with James Wan crafting a take on the character that manages to be fun without ending up as a parody-worthy version mocked by things like Entourage. It was reasonably well-received by critics, and clearly cinemagoers were taken with it, which shows a new path forward for the DCEU, or at least DC movies in a broader sense.

Following on from Aquaman, there's Shazam!, which promises to take things even further with regards to tonal difference to what's coming before, leaning even harder into comedy territory. After that there's Joker, which looks like being a King of Comedy-esque black comedy; Birds of Prey, which is full of bright colours and a lighter approach; and Wonder Woman 1984, which should once again be full of the same optimism and inherent goodness as the first.

The newly-announced 2021 releases are in keeping with this too: Matt Reeves' The Batman won't exactly be light, but it will be a very different kind of story to what the DCEU's told so far; James Gunn's The Suicide Squad will hopefully be the movie promised by the original's first trailer. And DC's Super Pets just sounds like an utter joy.

The DCEU is now embracing weirder, lighter, and different kinds of stories and movies, which also means it's moving well beyond Ben Affleck's Batman.

How do you feel about Affleck's time as Batman? Are you said to see him go? Let us know down in the comments.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.