Black Panther Trailer Reactions: 7 Ups & 2 Downs
All hail the King.
Just like that, out of nowhere.
As with the Thor: Ragnarok first trailer, Marvel have chosen not to hype the impending release of the second official Black Panther trailer, instead allowing the Internet community to obsess more about when the Infinity War trailer will land and sneaking Panther out for an added punch. It's a bold move considering the recent trend for trailer teases ahead of them dropping, but it does seem to suggest that the studio has lots of confidence in Ryan Coogler's upcoming stand-alone.
And from the look of both trailers so far, they have a lot to be confident about.
Despite the lack of build, the trailer has caught attention very quickly, and mostly because it's just a great bit of hype-building itself. It sets out the movie's stall perfectly, swaggering to another beautifully chosen musical track and suggesting very much that the embrace of more weird material in the wake of Doctor Strange is in full force.
It's not an entirely flawless trailer, but it's a magnificent one for the most part. And there's a lot in there that deserves praise. So that's precisely the best place to start...
Ups
7. The Delightfully Weird Effects
Considering how easy it would have been for Marvel to make a grounded Black Panther movie, it's great to see that they appear to have channeled some of what made Doctor Strange's visual effects so stunning into it instead.
And it makes a lot of sense that Wakanda would be the key to some visual weirdness because it's always been billed as entirely different to what we've seen before. So we get heavy-duty technology that manifests in a way we've barely seen before (though which references the Vision's powers cleverly), flying machines with strange powers and superheroes with physical abilities that are incomparable to anyone else.
Underpinning all of that are the visual effects at Coogler's command. There are no rag-doll physics even when T'Challa leaps around unnaturally, and everything feels as utterly cutting edge as the technology of this world deserves. And where else would you get to see a human hand peel away to reveal a devastating sonic blaster?
6. The Costume Design (And Multiple Suits)
There's nothing the MCU loves better than putting their superheroes in new threads every time there's a new movie coming out. Iron Man has had more costume changes than an Oscar host (but then that's sort of his gimmick), and the pursuit of endless improvements is very obvious.
That's already bled into Black Panther, where it appears we have a number of suits for T'Challa. He still has the Civil War suit, but it would seem that his sister unveils a new one (with the weird purple glowing powers). And of course, Erik Killmonger ends up with his own suit - a modified version of the Civil War suit (which he may steal and repaint)...
Those variant suits are lovely and all, but they're only a small part in a massive, opulent production with some seriously stunning costume designs that are just as incredible as the superhero outfits. If this film doesn't win production design awards next year something is seriously wrong.
5. The Music
After using Run The Jewels in the first trailer, Marvel's marketing team have pulled off another masterstroke with the second by mashing up Gil Scott-Heron's firebrand political anthem "The Revolution Will Not Be Televised" with "BagBak" by Vince Staples.
In terms of pure impact, it's a stunning choice: that's a hell of a cool track to match to the images and it's far more memorable than simply picking something out of the score.
And more importantly - specifically for a film coming out in Black History month and so tuned into black identity - both songs are political and important. Scott-Heron's became an anthem for the Black Panther movement in '70s America and is soaked in black identity and consciousness politics. And Vance's hip-hop techno fusion just as boldly talks about being black in modern America.
Further, considering Wakanda's marriage of tradtional and futuristic, the mash-up is thematically en point. So it's not just a good tune.
4. The World Building
When they said that Black Panther's aesthetic was heavily influenced by Blade Runner, they really weren't kidding. The cityscapes are just as breath-taking and the colour palette is as rich and glorious as has ever been seen in a Marvel movie. It's like they're messing futurism with a self-conscious pulpy comic book panel feel, and it's a beautiful decision.
Crucially, the trailer really builds a sense of Wakanda's difference: the infusion of Afrofuturism here is as brilliant as it is bold - it's the perfect creative ideology to bring to Black Panther, and Marvel and Coogler should be applauded for going in that direction.
The result is literally like nothing we've seen in this sort of blockbuster before, and it could be just as profoundly impactful on films that follow as Blade Runner's aesthetic was.
3. The Sci-Fi Feel
As well as Blade Runner, it's impossible not to feel a slight Star Wars vibe from some of the scenes shown in the trailer. The communities we see hinted at are pure LucasFilm, and there are aerial battles between futuristic vehicles that could have been ripped from that franchise.
That's not to say there's any copycatting going on here though - Black Panther's feel is much more about payign homage and spinning in new influences (like Afrofuturism) to make something that feels nostalgic and brand new at the same time. Again, that's exactly what Wakanda is all about.
It feels like Black Panther also owes more to the likes of Guardians Of The Galaxy and Doctor Strange than it does to the earlier Phase 1 and 2 movies. And a lot of that comes down to the conscious embrace of the weirder side of life, which we're probably going to see more and more now that James Gunn is in a broader creative role at Marvel.
2. A Deeply Personal Story
Despite all of the flashy effects and the sci-fi elements, the trailer is very clear to outline the fact that this is a very personal story. Sure, there may be some complaints about Marvel once more using a villain who is a dark mirror of the hero (as they've done countless times before), but that is the best way to launch a new property like this. Binary stories work to shine a light on what the characters are and where they want to be.
Black Panther isn't just about a threat to Wakanda and the world (though that's a big part), it's about T'Challa finding his own way to becoming the right sort of leader and man. He will discover that through difficulties like fighting Erik Killmonger - his challenger to the throne of Wakanda - and Ulysses Klaue, while he protects the sanctity of his world's secrets. But it's that part of the story that is the most important when everything else washes away.
And it's that emotional grounding that will make the film succeed most of all.
1. The Action
That comment about the heart of the film aside, the trailer suggests that we're in for a barn-storming time when Black Panther comes out in February with multiple action sequences to add some punch to proceedings.
In just a couple of minutes we get a look at a number of set-pieces (Klaue's arrest, Klaue's escape, the museum heist, trials by combat, Killmonger coming home to fight, aerial spaceship battles...) And all of that means we'll get ample opportunity to see the brilliant fight choreography that's already been heavily hinted at and more of T'Challa's patented "cat-fu".
if you aren't hyped for all of that, there's something wrong with you.
And now the few negatives...
Downs
2. That Transformers Sound Effect
Michael Bay has a lot to answer for - which almost goes without saying, frankly - but it's a terrible shame that we get to get one of his patented Transformers sound effects in a trailer that otherwise seems to avoid cliches so well.
When we see the car flip moment in slow motion, there's a distinct Robots In Disguise feel to the effect used there, and it's distractingly poor. Sure, it's a fairly trivial thing, but why bother to draw a parallel with such an inferior franchise that so many people will immediately pick up on?
1. The Weird Slanted Shots
Obviously, we should all trust Ryan Coogler in making Black Panther, because he's a very gifted film-maker who has so far made two of the best human story movies in recent memory. Neither Frtuivale Station nor Creed were particularly over-stylised, and both focused chiefly on the plights of the central heroes to their credit without artifice.
Obviously, this is an entirely different venture for him, but it's a little jarring to see odd slanty shots used for no reason in the trailer that seem to suggest there may be some more visual trickery going on than is strictly necessary. Let's hope it's kept to the minimum in the actual finished product.
Then again, if the only things we can possibly grumble about are a sound effect and a camera that appears to have fallen over, it's obviously been a great trailer for the most part.
What did you think of this new Black Panther trailer? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.