Black Widow: Every Main Character Ranked From Worst To Best

A mixed bag of characters from the MCU's return to cinemas.

Black Widow Taskmaster
Marvel Studios

It has been two very long years, and though fans have been somewhat satiated with the release of WandaVision, The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, and Loki, there is nothing quite like an MCU movie. Black Widow can finally, officially be counted as the MCU's 24th release, and it's about time.

Set between the events of Captain America: Civil War and Avengers: Infinity War, Black Widow has a very specific story to tell. As it shows Natasha on the run from the US government before being brought back into her old life, this was very much a stand alone story.

As such, this meant that there were no gratuitous cameos from any other Avengers. Instead, Black Widow was able to bring in and introduce to the MCU a whole cast of new characters from Natasha's past.

Some of these were more developed, and simply stronger characters others, with certain ones already on the path to having long and glorious careers in the MCU. However, at the other end of this spectrum, the movie also included some instantly forgettable characters, and one of the worst casting decisions the franchise has ever made...

8. Dreykov

Black Widow Ray Winstone
Marvel Studios

It's no secret that the MCU has had something of an antagonist problem, particularly throughout Phases One and Two. Phase Three went some way to correcting this with the likes of Thanos, Killmonger, and the Vulture, but the first movie of Phase Four has introduced possibly one of the worst MCU villains ever.

Black Widow saw Nat come up against Dreykov, an adversary she thought she had killed years before, but their reunion was worthy of very little awe or sense of occasion. In all honestly, it was boring. He was built up as this indestructible threat that needed Natasha to bring her whole family back together, but he was frustratingly underwhelming.

Dreykov ran the Red Room, and trained his Widows to start and end wars at his own command. To ensure their unwavering compliance, he literally controlled their minds. The villain that was first mentioned by Loki in The Avengers had the potential to be great, but he ultimately left a lot to be desired.

Marvel Studios rarely ever misses the mark when it comes to casting, but Ray Winstone as Dreykov was a wide miss. He simply doesn't have the acting chops to carry such a villain, and the Russian accent with the constant Cockney twang made him impossible to take seriously. A different casting decision may have helped the character, but as it was, Dreykov could be the weakest MCU villain since Malekith.


7. Taskmaster

Black Widow Taskmaster
Marvel Studios

Marvel Studios has no control over the fan theories that come around in the build up to the release of a new movie or series. Fans will always try to figure out what they are about to see, but this was true for Black Widow more so than most other properties, simply because of the amount of time they had to wait.

The biggest mystery going into the movie was the true identity of the villainous Taskmaster. Theories ranged from it being Clint Barton, Rick Mason, or even a clone of Natasha behind the mask, but with all of these possibilities running through fans heads, the reveal that Taskmaster was Dreykov's previously unseen daughter was slightly underwhelming.

Even aside from the big reveal, the villain that can copy the fighting style of anyone she comes up against had the potential to be at least an intriguing MCU character, but she was criminally underused. Ironically, the fact that her fighting style was always copied made her unique, but there just wasn't enough of her in the movie, and what made her different ended up having zero relevance or impact on her character or the story.

She was essentially relegated to being a mindless henchman of her father's, the same as any of his Widows just with a tragic backstory linked to Natasha. There were echoes of Bucky in her character after she was freed of her mind control, but even with the connection to the titular hero, there just simply wasn't enough development to make her anywhere close to an interesting character.


6. Thunderbolt Ross

Black Widow Thunderbolt Ross
Marvel Studios

Thaddeus 'Thunderbolt' Ross went eight years without appearing in the MCU between The Incredible Hulk and Captain America: Civil War, but since his return he has become an important character in the franchise. He initiated the Sokovia Accords that ultimately drove the Avengers apart, and hunted Cap and co. into hiding for two years.

When he was seen in the Black Widow trailer fans got excited at what that could mean. In one scene he looked de-aged, so had Natasha worked with him in the past? Other scenes showed him looking older and more frail than before, suggesting a potential future scene, possibly even setting up the Thunderbolts.

However, his role in the movie was inconsequential and pointless. He had a very brief interaction with Natasha once the movie moved out of 1995 and into 2016, that served more to set the scene of the titular character being on the run, and he showed up at the end to confirm that she was still on the run once Dreykov was defeated.

His appearance in the movie offered nothing other than telling audiences what they already knew. His exposition was redundant, and there was really no need to bring him back just for that. However, he still ranks above Dreykov and Taskmaster, because while he didn't add anything to the movie, at least he didn't actively detract from it.


5. Rick Mason

Black Widow Rick Mason
Marvel Studios

When O-T Fagbenle's character was suspiciously absent from all of the Black Widow promotional materials, with the exception of one poster, there was an air of mystery about him. Surely there was a reason Marvel weren't showing him, so could he be the man behind the Taskmaster mask?

In reality, there was nothing worth hiding for the character, he was simply an old friend of Natasha's that helped her stay hidden from the US government. He procured her a trailer to live in off the grid, he got her the plane used to break Alexei out of prison, and finally a Quinjet at the end of the movie.

There was a certain level of comedy value to him and his dynamic, first with Natasha, and then with Yelena, but over the course of the movie, he added very little. He didn't really have enough screen time to impact the movie in any meaningful way.

In the comics, Rick was known as The Agent, and had a richer history with SHIELD, however none of his backstory could be shown in his MCU debut. Should the franchise continue however, Rick has the potential to be an asset moving forward with a little more development.


4. Melina Vostokoff

Black Widow Rachel Weisz
Marvel Studios

Black Widow told the story of Natasha's first family. Before she was an Avenger, during her childhood she had three years in Ohio as part of a fake family, the mother of which was Melina Vostokoff. While she acted as the matriarch of the pieced together family, her importance to Dreykov and the Red Room can't be understated.

She was the brilliant scientific genius that perfected the technology that overtook the Widows' minds, making them completely and utterly compliant to their commands. She ran a similar programme with pigs at her home, but she still worked as hard as anyone to bring the Red Room down.

Though the movie didn't particularly show her in action in terms of hand-to-hand combat, she had graduated the Black Widow programme four times, and so likely could have taken on more than her fair share of Widows herself. However, it was instead her intellect that she utilised to help Natasha.

No matter what happened to her, she never got flustered or worried. She simply took a second to think about the scenario, and adapted to the situation. She was a very strong presence, and her level-headedness and calmness under pressure acted as the perfect counterpart to the man who played the part of her husband in Ohio...


3. Alexei Shostakov

Black Widow Red Guardian
Marvel Studios

The father of the fake deep cover Russian family in Ohio had no right to be a likeable character. He was the one who gave Natasha and her sister away to Dreykov and the Red Room without so much as a second thought, and even years later, didn't feel any kind of guilt or remorse.

This was not the only regard in which Alexei was delusional. He enjoyed regaling his fellow prisoners with stories of how he fought Captain America, despite the Star Spangled Man still being frozen during the year his story was set. Yet, by the end of the movie, his blind optimism made him more likeable than he deserved to be.

He was obsessed with his past as the Red Guardian, and the USSR's only ever super soldier felt like he could have been even more famous than Steve Rogers. This allowed for some wonderful comedic moments that David Harbour delivered perfectly, like trying to talk to Natasha without an earpiece, but it wasn't all laughs with Alexei.

His best scene was when he poured his heart out to Yelena after telling her how bored he was all those years ago. Their rendition of American Pie together was a moment of quiet acceptance, and though it wasn't quite forgiveness, Alexei was at least able to prove to his adopted daughter that he did, and still does deeply care about her.


2. Natasha Romanoff

Black Widow Scarlett Johansson
Marvel Studios

It took 11 years for Natasha Romanoff to finally get a solo movie of her own, and while most fans can agree that it should have come much sooner, and that the movie itself probably won't be going down as among the best the franchise has to offer, the titular character herself was excellent.

Prequels are always tricky, particularly this one, since the character's future is already set in stone and well known, and so it could have been difficult to feel any real tension or emotion throughout the movie. However, this was more about exploring Natasha's past than her future, and it was an exploration that was long overdue.

There were two very different, very distinct sides to Natasha in this movie. The badass Avenger everyone has come to know and love was very present, but there was also a vulnerability to Nat that has never been shown before. The Earth's Mightiest Heroes may have turned into a family for her, but this was the first time she could truly be seen as a daughter and a sister.

She was able to carry this movie as a main character without having to rely on any cameos or appearances from her fellow Avengers, with Scarlett Johansson's performance begging the question, why didn't Marvel give her her own solo franchise before the character had been killed off?


1. Yelena Belova

Black Widow Florence Pugh
Marvel Studios

Black Widow may have been the long overdue full stop on Natasha Romanoff's story in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but she was ever so slightly outshone by her little sister, Yelena. Florence Pugh's character stole the entire show, and if Marvel Studios are smart, they will do everything they can to keep her around for as long as possible.

Naturally, Yelena shared many traits with her Avenging sister. She was hilariously sarcastic, had a no nonsense attitude towards just about everything, and thanks to her training in the Red Room and the life she was forced to life since, she is an absolute badass. She wouldn't have looked out of place with the Avengers herself.

It may have taken Natasha some time to truly become a great part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but Yelena has been able to enjoy a very, very strong debut without suffering the over-sexualisation that Natasha did. From minute one she has been taken seriously, and even made fun of her sister's poses.

Florence Pugh's incredible acting chops also allowed her some truly emotional moments, striking a perfect balance between being funny and genuinely moving. Even before Valentina showed up in the movie's post credit scene, it had been reported that Yelena will be making an appearance in Hawkeye on Disney+. Hopefully, this is the first of many more times MCU fans can enjoy the wonderful Florence Pugh.


In this post: 
Black Widow
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.