Black Widow Movie: 10 Things It Must Include

So... what DID happen in Budapest?

Avengers Infinity War Black Widow
Marvel Studios

That's right folks, it's finally happening: Black Widow is finally getting their own film, almost eight years on from those initial calls from fans for one to happen.

It's been a long wait, and an unnecessarily long one at that, but the Black Widow solo film everyone's been waiting for moved a step closer to production last week with the announcement that Jac Schaeffer - of Blacklist fame - is writing the script. Nothing is known about the film other than the fact that Scarlett Johansson will reprise her role as the title character; it could be a sequel, prequel, or even something else entirely.

Irrespective of whatever path Marvel choose to take with the film, there are a few things that it needs to include. Of all the characters in the MCU Nat's past is the one most shrouded in mystery, and while Marvel have divulged the occasional detail here and there, it's clear that she's in major need of some exploration. Add to that the fact that Scar Jo's been fantastic in the role, and you have as strong a case as any for a solo outing in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, one that's remained the same for the last eight years.

With a chequered past and an undetermined future, Natasha Romanoff looks set to command the most exciting Marvel movie in years. But what should the studio look to include?


10. Childhood Memories And The Red Room

Black Widow Red Room
Marvel Studios

Avengers: Age of Ultron might've made a few missteps in its story (why oh why does Hawkeye need a family?), it did provide an interesting snippet of Black Widow's past, in particular her time spent in the infamous 'Red Room'.

The Soviet Union's top destination for conditioning their assassins, Natasha Romanoff was known to be among their most talented operatives. Training their spies to be proficient in combat and deception, the Room was notorious for producing the Soviet Union's best and brightest assassins, falling behind in terms of infamy only to the Winter Soldier program concurrently conducted by the same government.

Nat was likely to have spent her time in the program in the years preceding the collapse of the USSR, making her one of the last assassins to have emerged from its doors. While it might be a case of 'the less we know, the better', the chance to see the internal workings of this program - having already been provided a glimpse in Agent Carter and Age of Ultron - would undoubtedly strengthen any solo Black Widow film.

Add to that the fact the character's most recent comic book outings have taken that premise and ran with it wholeheartedly, and it's not difficult to see the appeal in taking the film in the same direction.


9. Her Time As A Russian Spy

Black Widow Red Room 2
Marvel Studios

While it'd be a brave choice to depict Nat in a more ruthless light, owing to the fact she's a leading figure in the Avengers and a hero at that, any Black Widow film would be daft not to refer to her time as an actual spy.

The timeframe for Romanoff's days as an assassin is still up in the air, but there's no denying the appeal of seeing the Widow working as a spy in the twilight of the Soviet Union. Not that it'd form the crux of a film, seeing as how people are quite rightly looking forward to seeing Romanoff fighting as a hero, but the MCU is still in need of some ambiguity. The Winter Soldier and Civil War benefited from that approach, and Bucky - who's undoubtedly gearing up to take over the reigns as Captain America - has illustrated that fans love seeing a hero with a shady past.

We know for a fact that Romanoff has a lot of red in her ledger. If we were to see that in the solo film - even in a small way - it would only add more depth to a character that benefits from that mystery.

Plus, it would make good competition for Fox's upcoming totally not a Black Widow rip-off we swear Red Sparrow, which will centre around a Soviet spy defecting to the West during the Cold War. Get on it, Marvel.


8. Meeting Hawkeye

Hawkeye Black Widow Abidjan Operation
Marvel Studios

Speaking of defection, if any Widow film were to root itself primarily in prequel territory, then seeing her cross paths with Hawkeye for the first time would make for a fantastic sequence.

While the details surrounding Widow's defection are light, we do know that Clint Barton was responsible for convincing her to join S.H.I.E.L.D. Having been assigned a kill-order on Black Widow, Hawkeye instead chose to bring Nat (then Natalia Romanova) back to the United States, forming a partnership that would span years both on and off the books - militarily speaking, of course.

Any Black Widow film needs to make Nat the primary focus, and while the story of Black Widow and Hawkeye's first encounter could form the basis for a film of its own, it might make more sense for it to take a back seat in a film centred around Widow herself. Not that it's not worth including of course; just that - if it is - it's important to keep the spotlight on Natasha.

A cameo wouldn't go amiss though...


7. Coming To America

Captain America Black Widow Civil War
Marvel Studios

Further to those sentiments, a story centred around the fallout of Natasha's defection would make for a fantastic film, especially if it takes the same kind of historical angle as the upcoming Captain Marvel movie.

Those brief conversations we've seen where Nat's opened up about her time following her defection haven't always been as illuminating as audiences would've perhaps hoped, so it would make sense to go back to her formative years as the spy we know today for a full-length film. Doing so wouldn't just make sense in terms of expanding the character's backstory, but also in returning to the themes that made The Winter Soldier such an enjoyable project when it first released.

Espionage, treason, mistrust - all are elements central to and emblematic of Black Widow's character. They're also what made the Russo bros' first Marvel film so great, and while I wouldn't bank on them returning for yet another Marvel project, any film that elaborates on S.H.I.E.L.D's shady credentials is bound to be a hit, particularly if it places Nat's transition from Soviet spy to S.H.I.E.L.D. Agent front and centre to its proceedings.

We're yet to find out if Widow will make it out of Infinity War alive, but even if she doesn't, returning to her formative years as a S.H.I.E.L.D. Agent would make for a great character study. One that's way, way overdue.


6. A Proper Hallway Fight (Ala Daredevil Or John Wick)

Scarlett Johansson S Black Widow
Marvel Studios

While there's no denying that the MCU has had its fair share of memorable action sequences, particularly in terms of scale alone, those smaller, more down-to-earth set-pieces haven't been as forthcoming. Winter Soldier had plenty, and no one could possibly forget the final fight from Civil War, but we're short on those Netflix-style sequences the Defenders have so elegantly managed to trademark these last few years.

A Black Widow film is the perfect outlet to lift those sequences from, however. The long take is having a resurgence, exemplified best - yes - by those shows, but also by productions like John Wick and, more recently, Atomic Blonde.

The latter two examples in particular lend themselves well to a Widow tale, and while the chances of an R-rated spy thriller starring the eponymous hero are admittedly slim, there are ways of getting around that issue. Iron Man 2's own hallway sequence showed flashes of what we'd later see in the Netflix shows, and while guns are the Widow's weapon of choice, those stingers on her wrists aren't just for show.

In fact there are plenty of tools at her disposal, and while R-rated comic book adaptations are themselves on the rise, there's nothing to stop Marvel from testing the limits of that PG-13 rating, much the same way Paul Greengrass' Bourne films did towards their end.


5. Winter Soldier-Style Espionage

Black Widow Winter Soldier
Marvel Studios

Captain America: The Winter Soldier is still the MCU's best film, and a lot of that comes down to its brilliant emulation of classic Cold War drama.

Mirroring classic seventies conspiracy films like Three Days of the Condor and All the President's Men, TWS roots itself primarily in a tacit kind of paranoia that defined those earlier works, displaying it with a nod and a wink right down to the fact that Robert Redford, the star of both those films, plays the villain. It's just brilliant, and while no one wants to see just another Winter Soldier, there are certainly lessons the film can provide going forward.

Black Widow is a spy first and foremost, and to date, the Russo bros' first Marvel film has done the best job of portraying that element of the character. It's as much Nat's film as it Steve's, and it's that same kind of tone any Widow film should look to emulate whether it's set in the past, present or future.

It's all well and good making yet another superhero film, but that portion of the Marvel Universe has always worked best as a genre in and of itself, blurring the lines between heroism and villainy with a boastful emulation of classic Cold War conspiracy.


4. References To Newer Storylines

Black Widow Shield's Most Wanted
Marvel Comics/Chris Samnee

Although Black Widow has mostly featured as a supporting character off the screen, having formed partnerships with the likes of Daredevil, Hawkeye, Captain America and more, her newly found popularity has galvanised the character's comics. As such, there's plenty of source material to look to when plotting a Widow film, particularly in Mark Waid, Chris Samnee and Matt Wilson's run on the character.

Kicking things off with 2016's S.H.I.E.L.D.'s Most Wanted, the creative trio set about telling a story that revitalised Romanoff's origins, taking inspiration from the Red Room of the MCU and going one step further with a tale befitting of not only their reputation, but of Nat's as well.

It's a stellar run, and while it would appear as though there's little chance of seeing Nat and Bucky get together on the big screen, the way Waid handles their romance in the comic is fantastic, further building upon the threads set up in Ed Brubaker's seminal Captain America series a decade earlier.

Winter Soldier already took the best bits of Brubaker's comic in constructing its tale of Bucky Barnes' resurrection, so if the Black Widow film were to spin a similar thread in Waid and Samnee's direction, it'll only be stronger because of it.


3. Susanne Bier As Director

By Les Kaner [CC BY 3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

It's only a matter of time until Susanne Bier gets the chance to direct a comic book film, having made waves most recently with the seminal adaptation of John le Carré's The Night Manager, and it's precisely for that reason that she should direct Black Widow.

Apart from the fact that the BBC series was itself an espionage-themed tale, Bier's command of the source material was fantastic, and more than illustrative of why she should take the reigns on a Widow project should the opportunity arise. As an Academy Award winner, Bier would also be ideally suited to take Marvel to the next level, provided they give her the room to do so, of course.

Marvel have a lot of ground to make up in terms of gaining parity in regards to their directorial choices, with Patty Jenkins having left Thor: The Dark World when it was in pre-production, and with Anna Boden the only confirmed woman director working on a Marvel project. Hiring Bier would be a step in the right direction, and while Joss Whedon has reportedly been in contact with Scarlett Johansson for a potential Widow film, after Age of Ultron's controversy, a different choice is called for.

And again, The Night Manager was fantastic. Transfer that tension to a Black Widow film, and you have a surefire hit in waiting.


2. Actual Acknowledgement That It's Overdue

Black Widow Winter Soldier
Marvel Studios

Since 2010 and perhaps before, fans have been crying out for a Black Widow film. Those calls always seemed to fall on deaf ears though, with Marvel falling further into hot water when the character was blatantly omitted from merchandise for both Avengers films, despite the fact she's easily one of the most popular heroes out there.

There's no denying Marvel have been particularly poor in that area, and while no one is looking for an apology per se, the studio would be wise to acknowledge that Nat hasn't always had it good these last few years, whether that be in the statement announcing the film for good, or with a nod and/or wink from the character herself in the actual film itself.

It might be difficult to do so in the film, depending on when it's set, but there is a way of addressing the fact the character's been overlooked in an organic and timely manner, particularly when Marvel are now playing catch-up with DC after Wonder Woman.


1. A Grounded Storyline

Black Widow Winter Soldier
Marvel Studios

With Marvel having focussed primarily on the cosmic side of things in recent years, there is something to be said about the lack of semi-realistic (he says, hesitantly) films in the studio's filmography. Not realistic in terms of believability, but in terms of the actual concept itself. Those other-worldly storylines are great fun to watch, but there is something to be said about those smaller, more down-to-Earth stories as well.

The comics themselves manage to get the right balance, and while Black Widow works in both of those contexts, the character lends herself more to that grounded side.

The kind of style we've seen in Winter Soldier, Jessica Jones and Daredevil would benefit the character in a plethora of ways, especially if any story featuring Nat is character-driven and does what Marvel do best by placing its biggest personalities at the forefront of its narrative.

Scarlet Johansson's Black Widow has deserved so much more from the MCU. Hopefully a solo film can go a long way in making up for lost time.

What do you want to see in the Black Widow film? Be sure to let us know in the comments below!


Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.