Cannes 2015: Who Really Should Have Won?

Who really deserved the Palme d'Or? Clue: it's not Dheepan.

There's no bigger award in filmmaking than the Palme d'Or. Cannes highest honour, it's confirms a director as a master of the medium and, importantly, carries much less of the baggage than other high profile prizes. The Oscars are highly political, voted for by people who don't know what they're on about or too disinterested to actually watch the films, and are thus all too often dictated by the press. The Golden Palm, on the other hand, is built around art; it's picked by a Jury of ten people who decide a winner based purely on their own personal and professional interpretations of what the festival represents. This year's winners, chosen by the likes of the Coen brothers, Guillermo del Toro and Jake Gyllenhaal, have just been announced and, almost proving the lack of press input, they're incredibly surprising. What follows is a rundown of who's won in each of the main competition categories and, in most cases (they're pretty out-there choices), who would have been a more deserving winner. One of the strictest rules of the awards is that a film can only win in one award category. This makes coming up with a slate that feels legitimate pretty tricky, but is nevertheless reflected in our alternative picks. For reviews of all the films discussed here (and more), make sure you head to WhatCulture's Cannes 2015 page.


Best Screenplay

Who Won? Michel Franco - Chronic Did It Deserve To Win? No. Chronic was a film buoyed by one thing - its great central performance by Tim Roth. Everything else was a bit muddled, especially the script - with a series of episodic events going over similar ground and an ending that feels like wrapping things up just so the screenwriter can clock off early. Quite how this was decided as the best is perplexing. Who Should Have Won? It would have knocked most critics for six with a win given its mixed reception, but Louder Than Bombs, which uses a variety of dream-like methods to tell its story, is a perfect fit; while much of its ultimate effect comes from Joachim Trier's direction, the underlying key is in the script.

Best Actress

Who Won? Rooney Mara - Carol/Emanuelle Bercot - Mon Roi (shared award) Did They Deserve To Win? Both performances were pretty incredible. It's nice to see Rooney Mara, instead of Cate Blanchett, get the nod for Carol - not only is Mara an actress whose career would be greatly helped by some silverware, her Terese is the more subtle of the two. Bercot (and general love for the underappreciated Mon Roi) is more surprising, but no less deserved - she improvised all of her lines and carries the film's emotional heart. Who Should Have Won? The leading quartet of Our Little Sister, who played off each other impeccably and pretty much made that film.

Jury Prize

Who Won? Yorgos Lanthimos - The Lobster Did It Deserve To Win?The Lobster is a film many have gone crazy for, loving its blend of comedy and romance that work so well yet defy any romcom description, so it's likely to be a popular winner of the festival's third prize. But does enjoyment of concept get in the way of actual execution? Kinda - the second half is a far cry from the first, tonally out of sync and a bit ponderous. It's a nice movie, but hardly one worthy of such an honour. Who Should Have Won?Sicario is another film from a foreign director who's moved into the English language that will live long after the festival, but also would have been a much more impactful winner in terms of festival tradition; it's an action-thriller.

Best Actor

Who Won? Vincent Lindon - The Measure Of A Man Did It Deserve To Win?The Measure Of A Man was a ponderous bore. Of course, a bad film shouldn't waylay love of a great performance (see Chronic), but even then it's hard to say Lindon excelled. The painfully-long takes were intended to emphasise his representation of a regular man struggling with money and internal problems, but they merely led to his performance tiring alongside the film. Who Should Have Won? Michael Caine for Youth, who transfers that much-imitated slowing speech into a highly recollective, personal performance. This decision could potentially be rectified come the Oscars.

Best Director

Who Won? Hou Hsiao-hsien's - The Assassin Did It Deserve To Win?The Assassin looks great, but aside from that doesn't offer up much. There's some room for argument that crafting a consistent, interesting world is integral to a director's job, but that ignores how totally lacking in narrative sense Hou Hsiao-hsien's film is. An incredibly overrated film, it's at least a relief to see it didn't get awarded anything higher. Who Should Have Won? Justin Kurzel for Macbeth. His Shakespeare adaptation may boast great performances from Michael Fassbender and Marion Cotillard, but what really sells it is the recreation of 1100's Scotland and measured edit of Shakespeare's play.

Grand Prix

Who Won? László Nemes - Son Of Saul Did It Deserve To Win?Son Of Saul could have won any award here and it'd be totally deserved - any problems it may have become negligible in the face of its realised vision and totally unique shooting style. Injecting new life into movies about the Holocaust, a sub-set of cinema that all too often relies on contextual emotion, it's a shocking debut from Nemes. That it bags the Grand Prix, the festival's second highest honour, is hard to grumble about. Who Should Have Won? Given how the other awards should have gone, it's refreshing that the Grand Prix is a perfect fit for Son Of Saul - the only case of the Jury getting it spot on.

Palme d'Or

Who Won? Jacques Audiard - Dheepan Did It Deserve To Win? And so it is that the film a bunch of critics walked out of so they could make Gaspar Noé's Love takes home the big prize. Dheepan is a great story, with excellent performances from first-timers and wonderful underlying message, but it's hardly the most exciting or challenging film of the festival. An out there choice that will leave many people scratching their heads. Who Should Have Won?Carol - it is, quite simply, the best film of the festival (in competition at least). Mara is more than deserved of Best Actress, but to focus just on her (and Cate Blanchett's) performance undercuts the stellar work done by Todd Haynes and Phyllis Nagy in adapting Patricia Highsmith's complex work. Of course, all of this discussion is somewhat moot; if Disney could have been restrained enough and not pre-screened it, then Inside Out could have been entered. And that would be a totally deserved recipient of such a prize. Which Cannes 2015 film are you most looking forward to? Shout out how the awards have altered your expectations down in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.