Captain America: Civil War Ending - 12 Big Implications For Phase 3

More friction, more personal issues and a hell of a Spidey...

Civil War Amalgam Poster.jpg
Marvel Studios

So, after months of hype, tempered by a nagging suspicion that there was no way the Russos could balance everything, Captain America: Civil War was yet another triumph for Marvel. It's pulling in big money already on the back of astonishing critical performance that has seen it widely heralded as among the MCU's very best and it was such an impressively dense story that we've now got even more narrative threads to tie in to Phase 3.

Even without Thanos' big moment at the end of the arc, the build of Phase 3 was already going to be busy - with new heroes introduced, old questions (like Peter Quill's patronage and what Loki did to Odin) answered and serious gaps (like the remaining Infinity Gems) explored - but Civil War's open ending now opens a world of other opportunities.

If it weren't for Marvel's notorious forward planning, you'd actually be forgiven for thinking that some of the implications of Civil War's ending would require their own movies. But then slates change, and Marvel do have two mystery unnamed movies up their sleeves yet, so it's possible there's a few surprising twists in their tale yet to be revealed.

However they're resolved, here's what we can learn for Phase 3 from how Civil War ends...

12. Spider-Man Is Going To Be Awesome

Spider-Man Homecoming.jpg
Marvel Studios

Despite being a late entrant to the fight, Tom Holland's Spider-Man is arguably the best bit about Civil War. He's hilarious and the effects work on his swing physics are perfect, but it's the balance between snark and charm that really works and which offers so much promise for Spider-Man: Homecoming.

Already we've seen why Sony gave creative control to Marvel: Spidey's original parent company was always going to know the character best (and boy did they have to prove it after the costly negotiations with Sony). And if they build on what was teased in Civil War - Spidey's geeky cockiness, his need to balance heroics and homework and the contradiction in his fundamental desire to show-off and his responsibilities to remain hidden - we're all in for a treat.

Even without an origin story, the Russos managed to write complexity and charisma into Spider-Man and Peter Parker in what was basically an extended cameo and the promise of his own stand-alone has quickly become even more exciting.


11. The Secret Avengers?

Secret Avengers.jpg
Marvel

It would seem that the cinematic Avengers are in the same sort of position as their comic book counterparts at the end of the first Civil War arc: they're split into two discernible groups.

Though Tony Stark's loyalists are probably a little thin on the ground, he can still count on Spider-Man, what remains of Rhodey, Vision, SHIELD's remnants including turncoat Agent 13, possibly either Hulk or Thor (or both) and incomers Captain Marvel and maybe Doctor Strange (though he's unlikely to be pro-registration). So he could still have a roster for his Mighty Avengers.

But it's the others who offer the more interesting picture. With Cap and his team driven underground (and the possibility of teaming up again with Black Widow and Nick Fury), we could see an Underground/Secret Avengers team operating off the grid like Luke Cage's post-Civil War New Avengers. Hopefully that's the situation we'll see throughout Infinity War, with Thanos' plot ticking over in the background until the climax of the first part.

And sooner or later, General Ross is presumably going to realise that there's a need for super-teams who are actually willing to bend the rules to get things done. Which could mean we'll see either a Secret Avengers team sanctioned by the government but off the books, or a more sinister possibility...


10. General Ross Remains Active

General Ross
Marvel Studios

We already know Thunderbolt Ross wants to know where Hulk and Thor have suddenly disappeared to, but he's now also got Team Cap and Black Widow to deal with separately as well. He surely can't imagine that relying on Tony Stark again to deliver all of the rogue heroes is a good idea after so many high-profile foul-ups on his watch?

The alternative then, could be that Ross takes a leaf out of Amanda Waller's book and follows the Civil War Hero Hunters arc, establishing a team of villains to find his targets. He could already count on Zemo - who he knows has a personal reason to see the Avengers defeated - and it wouldn't be too much of a stretch to call on the likes of Abomination and Justin Hammer (who are among the only living villains) to boost out the ranks with their special skills. And then calling in some lower-level villains for their debuts would fill the roster.

It would be an extremely brave move on Marvel's behalf, but if they're ever going to introduce a Thunderbolts movie (or a villain ensemble), this is the perfect time, and they should be strongly urged to do so.

Even if they don't General Ross will presumably spend Phase 3 attempting to bring the rogue Avengers to justice.


9. Vision Will Struggle With His Humanity.. And Wanda With Her Powers

The Vision Paul Bettany Avengers
Marvel Studios

Though they weren't given a great deal of screen time compared to some of the other more central characters, it seems inevitable that the Vision/Scarlet Witch dynamic will play a big part in the start of Infinity War.

Even with Wanda underground, Vision's affection for her - which ultimately led to him accidentally doing in Rhodey will turn him into even more of a wildcard. Vision already expressed his desire to be able to control the Infinity Gem in his head (rather than it controlling him), and it seems his quest to become more human will fit in with that personal journey.

Unfortunately, both of those things seem to spell disaster for the robo-Jesus figure. Even if he's able to see what Thanos' plans for the Gems are, he could be seduced by the villain's promise of revelation. The Mad Titan could offer Vision the means to control the Gem and understand his place in the human race as a pretence to crack his head open. Because Vision's powers are such that surrendering the Gem seems the only likely means for Thanos to get his hands on it.

Scarlet Witch's arc looks like it's going to be pretty similar, with her powers continuing to cause her problems as they grow stronger. She's already seen as a significant threat to the general public and her underlying emotional scars make a situation like Avengers: Disassembled or House Of M a distinct possibility.

Captain America Civil War Scarlet Witch
Marvel

8. The Accords Remain In Place - Everyone Is Underground

Captain America Civil War Trailer Sokovia Accords
Marvel

For fans who expected to see a nice, tight resolution to Civil War, the fact that the Sokovia Accords remain in operation and that the War wasn't won probably came as something of a shock. But it's for the best: Civil War is too big of an idea to restrict to one movie, and the expansion throughout Phase 3 is a much smarter, potentially more rewarding approach.

We now get to see the fall-out of the Accords' philosophies happening in all of the Earth-bound MCU movies, and a more gradual realisation by the public that they probably shouldn't have driven their heroes away with bureaucracy. Tying that into the rise of Thanos' power and his proximity with Earth enriches the narrative context even more.

So far, all we've seen is the question of what happens when there are heroes: what are the costs, collaterally and morally, and how they can be controlled. Now, even more intriguingly, we get to see the other side of the coin: what happens when there aren't any heroes? Obviously Cap and his team will operate from underground, but that fundamentally turns them into cult and anti-heroes. And crucially, we get the next logical step in the narrative, rather than more moral outrage and hand-wringing over the cost to innocents - because that was getting a little tiresome.


7. Is A Black Widow Movie Now Possible?

Captain America Civil War Trailer Black Widow
Marvel

The last we saw of Natasha in Civil War she was clashing with Iron Man over her decision to interfere with Black Panther and allow Bucky and Cap to escape to Siberia. She flees with the promise that General Ross and his over-zealous hero hunters are on her case, and while she has potential allies underground, she might be drawn to her own mysterious past after the events of The Winter Soldier.

The Ideal approach would be to have Black Widow follow the threads back to The Red Room, building on the slightest hint in Civil War that she already knew Bucky (I don't really buy that she'd be hurt at him not recognising her after The Winter Soldier, given that they barely meet) and tying them into a continuation of The Winter Soldier story.

Obviously, there would be some grumbles at Widow not being allowed her own solo project, but having Bucky and perhaps Hawkeye and Nick Fury involved as support would work. And that wouldn't mean she had to surrender top billing at all. Plus it gives those three something to do, while we unpick more of the other most interesting origin story in the MCU.


6. Rhodey Is Retired, Hawkeye Can't See His Family

Captain America Civil War Machine Rhodey
Marvel

Few would begrudge Rhodey his retirement after what he went through in Civil War. He legitimately should have died after falling out of the sky from around commercial airline height and the fact that some of his bones shattered makes it remarkably odd that the rest of him wasn't turned into a War Machine milkshake inside the suit. But anyway, he was largely turned into the butt of the film's violence as the Russos struggled to really give him anything to do, so him shufflin off in his new Wallace & Gromit style trousers suits his increasingly uninspiring arc.

Perhaps he could pop up in Iron Man 4 (if it's coming) as a grounded (literally) ally to continue Shane Black's buddy cop dynamic, but beyond that he surely has to be done.

Hawkeye, meanwhile has basically made it impossible for his family to see him again. His safe house has been rumbled, thanks to its revelation in Age Of Ultron and it's likely to be the first place Stark looks (if he's bothering) or General Ross checks. So, what, is Hawkeye's family also going to go underground to jon the New Avengers? There's not much call for pre-teen heroes yet.

Rather worryingly, the most appropriate arc at this stage would probably be to kill them off as they were in the Ultimates comics, as a means to drive Hawkeye out of cover. That would particularly work in a Thunderbolts/Black Widow cross-over with a slightly darker edge, but Kevin Feige claims there won't be such darkness in his MCU, so temporary alienation seems more likely.


5. Zemo Lives To "Fight" Another Day

Baron Zemo Captain America Civil War
Marvel Studios

For once Marvel decided not to kill off their villain like their usual Monster Of The Week approach to bad guys.

While Zemo's personal story means he's not quite on the same scale of super-villainy as his comic book counterpart, there's no real reason he can't blossom into a more substantial figure who would work alongside Thanos for Infinity War. We already know there were some plans to have Ultron call on existing villains (Abomination, specifically), and the idea of Thanos again recruiting underlings (as he has before) to include familiar villains would be a smart move.

It's less likely that Zemo would escape and somehow summon Red Skull from wherever the Tesseract banished him to, given his disdain for HYDRA, but there's always a chance that Thanos will charge him with doing just that, given his knowledge of the organisation.

Whatever the case, it would be silly to assume this is the last we'll see of Zemo.


4. Black Panther Has Bucky

Captain America Civil War Bucky Black Panther
Marvel Studios

And it presumably won't just be Klaue playing the antagonist in his stand-alone...

The fact that T'Challa not only gave protection and technological comfort to Bucky but also pledged to fight off anyone coming to claim him suggests that The Winter Soldier story is going to continue into Black Panther's stand-alone. Otherwise it would seem like Marvel had simply put Bucky on ice and dropped the ball with him.

That's plainly not going to happen, and it seems that Ryan Coogler's film will balance the story seeded in Age Of Ultron (of Ulysses Klaue wanting to plunder Wakanda's resources) with General Ross (or someone else) coming for Bucky. It might slightly close the space for narrative originality, but if it stops Black Panther being an Avatar clone about the ethics of mining natural resources (yawn) it's got to be considered a good thing.


3. Cap Has No Shield, Bucky No Arm

Captain America's Shield
Marvel

They might not have actually been disassembled, but the end of Civil War wasn't far off leaving the Avengers in bits.

Though he wasn't killed off, Captain America's surrender of his iconic shield was a hell of a symbolic moment (just as Bucky's arm being removed - as a sign of his oppression as Winter Soldier - was similarly important). Cap is now operating without his single greatest weapon, and it seems likely that we might see Steve Rogers operating in Infinity War (at least at the start) without a Captain America costume entirely.

After all, just as the Winter Soldier was a Soviet/HYDRA symbol, Cap is a government construct, and it would be remarkably strange for Rogers to adopt not only a symbol of his own oppression but also a hugely recognisable costume while he's in hiding.

So it wouldn't' be too much of a stretch to see Steve Rogers appearing throughout Phase 3 in civilian threads.


2. More Giant Man?

Ant-Man Giant Man
Marvel

After Scott Laing's giant sized game-changer during the airport sequence, it surely has to be inevitable now that we'll see more of him in full Giant Man form. The effects in that sequence proved that such "silly" sequences are possible, and while the time spent in his massive form was limited by his own experience, continued experimentation could mean we get to see Ant-Man going big again.

Hopefully, if Ant-Man is called upon again in Infinity War by the Avengers, it will be precisely because of his powers - whether that's growing or shrinking - rather than simply boosting numbers. It's one of the only poor decisions in Civil War that he's basically just called in because he answered the phone - rather than being identified as the key part of a heist or ops team because of his very particular powers.

Personally, if Thanos does call in Tim Roth's Abomination to help deal with Hulk (Roth did say he was open to returning for Age Of Ultron after all), the idea of seeing the two monsters and Giant Man brawling would represent a step up even from the exceptional airport scene in Civil War.


1. Could There Be An Iron Man 4? Does There Need To Be?

Iron Man 4.jpg
Marvel

In light of the news that came out from Robert Downey Jr's camp just ahead of Civil War's release, the sequence in the film where Tony Stark talks with reticence about his inability to give up being Iron Man now seems particularly pertinent.

But after Civil War, would there even be space or scope on the current slate for an Iron Man 4 that follows the unresolved plot details? Seeing Stark as a deflated government stooge is something no-one wants, but if he was to lead a team of sanctioned heroes (like the post-Civil War Mighty Avengers of the comics) against the still pressing threat of the Ten Rings, there's huge potential.

It's more likely that Stark is actually black-listed himself by General Ross after his failure to bring in Captain America and the other "terrorists", which would allow a more personal story without having to call on other existing heroes. And that would still be possible if Marvel made the right choice to deal with the unresolved Ten Rings/real Mandarin threat. Because that surely can't just fizzle out?

That sort of arc-ending approach would be a hell of a lot better than trying to make a film about Fin Fang Foom, and it would take Tony's arc full-circle. Given the success of that sort of narrative structure for The Winter Soldier trilogy, Marvel would be crazy to ignore the potential.

What do you want to see from MCU Phase 3 in the wake of Captain America: Civil War? Share your own suggestions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.