Captain Marvel: 12 Rumours That Were Utter Bull
No, Nick Fury wasn't a Skrull all along.
Captain Marvel has finally arrived, and there's no denying that it's been one of the most intensely speculated-about recent MCU movies.
Between introducing audiences to Carol Danvers (Brie Larson), explaining her origins and setting up next month's Avengers: Endgame, the film had a lot to juggle, and largely did a solid(ish) job of it.
More to the point, most of fans' burning questions were paid off in interesting and satisfactory fashion, and it's safe to say that many of the most prominent rumours turned out to be - shocker - absolute nonsense.
Still, speculating about superhero movies can often be more fun than the actual movies themselves, and as ardently convinced as many were that these 12 theories were true, not a single one of them turned out to be.
Whether you were suckered in by the suave rumour-mongering or not, these are the theories - from weirdly plausible to hilariously outlandish - which set the fandom alight ahead of the film's release.
And of course, SPOILERS WILL FOLLOW...
12. Jude Law Is Secretly Playing Mar-Vell
The Rumour: Marvel Studios was suspiciously unwilling to name Jude Law's character in the movie for quite some time, prompting many to suspect that he would end up playing Carol Danvers' mentor Walter Lawson aka Mar-Vell.
Even when Marvel announced that Law would be playing a re-imagined version of the comic villain Yon-Rogg - here serving as a mentor for Carol - fans weren't convinced, and couldn't escape the feeling that Law would reveal his secret identity in the third act of the movie.
The Truth: Though Law's character did turn out to have a secret - the not-so-shocking surprise that he's actually a bad guy - there's no big twist or reveal related to his identity.
He remains Yon-Rogg throughout, though it is later revealed that Dr. Wendy Lawson (Annette Bening) was in fact the Kree scientist known as Mar-Vell and Carol's true mentor.
11. Carol's Powers Come From The Quantum Realm
The Rumour: One of the movie's biggest mysteries was the precise origin of Carol's powers.
Though it could've easily just been some random Kree nonsense ass-pulled out of nowhere, some fans were convinced that Captain Marvel would (somehow) earn her abilities from the quantum realm.
The Truth: Despite Kevin Feige stating that the quantum realm is of enormous relevance to Captain Marvel as a character, it had zero involvement in the character's origins nor any part to play in this story.
Rather, it's revealed late in the film that Carol obtained her powers after a Tesseract-powered energy core exploded (after she shot it to escape from Yon-Rogg, of course).
Few were likely expecting the Tesseract to show up in the movie, so this was a fun little surprise.
10. Nick Fury Is A Skrull
The Rumour: A ludicrously persistent rumour stated that Nick Fury (Samuel L. Jackson) would be revealed as a Skrull imposter at some point in the movie.
Silly though this might sound, it has a more credible backing than most of the film's more outlandish rumours, what with Samuel L. Jackson himself posting a picture to Instagram of him getting a plaster cast of his face.
After all, why else would a cast be needed other than if Jackson himself would be disappearing underneath some Skrull makeup?
The Truth: The movie as a whole does surprisingly little with the paranoia-filled potential of the Skrulls' abilities, and no, Fury is not a Skrull nor is he impersonated by a Skrull at any point in the movie.
We're left to assume that the lifecast was most likely a reference for the VFX department, but even then, it's a bit strange. Jackson probably knew exactly what he was doing when he posted it, though (especially with the plaster being coloured green).
9. Doctor Strange Warns Carol About The Decimation
The Rumour: An outlandish but amusing fan theory from Reddit suggested that Doctor Strange (Benedict Cumberbatch) would have a cameo appearance in the film, astral-projecting himself into the past in order to warn Carol and Fury about Thanos' (Josh Brolin) Decimation.
This would of course occur during Avengers: Infinity War when Strange was busy sifting through the 14,000,605 possible outcomes of their battle with Thanos, and in addition to examining the future, he'd drop off a handy hint in the past.
The theory continues that this would explain why Fury knew to hold off paging Carol until the Decimation happened, rather than calling her for help during, say, the Battle of New York or any other prior catastrophe.
The Truth: It's a cute idea, but it doesn't really hold up to even basic logical scrutiny, and so unsurprisingly, the Sorcerer Supreme was nowhere to be seen in the film. It already had plenty going on without him, so it was definitely for the best.
8. Rick Jones Is In It
The Rumour: A casting call put out in late 2017 sparked rumours that frequent Marvel Comics sidekick Rick Jones would make an appearance in the film.
In the comics, Jones caused Bruce Banner's gamma-induced transformation into The Hulk and served as a confidante to not only Banner but also Captain American and Captain Marvel.
The casting call was for a "supporting lead male (35-59)" who "may be tied to a well-known character", and given both his friendship with Captain Marvel and his vital role in the Kree-Skrull War in the comics, the (admittedly vague) description certainly fit the bill.
The Truth: That's a negative. There's not even the slightest hint of Jones, and it makes one wonder exactly what role this casting call was for.
Curiously, the character was originally intended to appear in the 2008 Edward Norton-starring The Incredible Hulk, but Norton's script re-write removed Jones completely, and so he was relegated to a cursory name-drop in the film's opening titles. Shame.
7. Nick Fury Loses His Eye To A Skrull Imposter
The Rumour: Probably the most widely-believed rumour on this list was that Nick Fury would likely lose an eye due to Skrull shenanigans, where one of the Skrulls impersonates Agent Coulson (Clark Gregg) or somebody else close to him.
The Truth: As much sense as this made, the movie surprisingly - and hilariously - plays the sight loss for laughs.
After teasing Fury's ocular impairment in the film's opening Los Angeles chase, he ends up losing an eye outright after his new pet cat/Flerken Goose scratches him in the eye.
The tail-end of the movie reveals that Fury decides to obscure the precise nature of his injury, with Coulson believing that it was burned out by a Kree torturer.
As much as it undermines the meaning of Fury telling Cap, "The last time I trusted somebody..." in Captain America: The Winter Soldier, it also emphasises just how embarrassed Fury was to lose an eye to something as adorable as Goose.
Plus, Goose did technically betray Fury's trust, so it's not like the Winter Soldier line was a lie or contradicted by the events of this movie.
6. Carol Gets Trapped In The Quantum Realm At The End
The Rumour: Ever since Avengers: Infinity War, fans have anguished about the location of Captain Marvel and exactly what she was up to while Thanos launched his crusade on Earth.
Some assumed that Carol was in some form of hibernation which was only interrupted by Fury's pager call, though many came to believe that she had somehow become trapped in the quantum realm by the end of her solo movie.
This would presumably lead to her bumping into Scott Lang (Paul Rudd) either in this film's post-credits scene or at the start of Endgame, and together they'd find a way out.
The Truth: Again, the quantum realm is pretty much a non-entity as far as this movie is concerned, and that's probably for the best. Plus, wouldn't it seem a bit lazy to have two Avengers trapped in the quantum realm together?
Still, there isn't a huge effort made to explain Carol's absence from Earth beyond her simply exploring the galaxies and presumably helping whoever needs to be helped.
Given the size of the known universe, it's a decent enough hand-waive, even if some fans were probably expecting a more substantial explanation.
5. It Sets Up The Secret Invasion Storyline
The Rumour: As soon as the Skrulls were confirmed to appear in Captain Marvel, it was accepted by many that the film would either serve as a direct adaptation of the much-loved Secret Invasion comic book storyline or, more likely, lay the foundations for an adaptation further down the line.
In the comics, the Secret Invasion saw the Skrulls assuming the identities of iconic superheroes as they planned to take over Earth, fuelling a toxic air of paranoia among The Avengers.
The Truth: Surprisingly, the whole paranoia angle is weirdly downplayed aside from a few quick "gotcha!" moments, and in fact, it turns out that the central Skrulls aren't even particularly bad guys.
Granted, the fact that Talos (Ben Mendelsohn) and co. are simply refugees seeking a new home doesn't mean that bad Skrulls aren't out there. But one gets the feeling this was a one-and-done story rather than something that will be picked up in the next phase of the MCU.
4. The Movie Takes Place In An Alternate Timeline
The Rumour: And now for one of the more outlandish theories that did the rounds ahead of Captain Marvel's release.
This theory suggest that in order to explain the Los Angeles public seeing Carol blatantly using her powers during the Los Angeles chase, the movie actually takes place in an alternate timeline/dimension to the Earth-199999 seen in the rest of the MCU.
The Avengers would then visit this timeline during Endgame and find Captain Marvel, the first superhero revealed to society in this reality, and bring her back to Earth-199999 to help destroy Thanos.
The Truth: This was always a fun tinfoil hat theory and nothing else, and to the surprise of nobody, it turned out to be complete bunk.
3. John C. Reilly Cameos As Rhomann Dey
The Rumour: After the January release of Captain Marvel StarForce Mission Log, a novel written from Carol Danvers' perspective, the book's inclusion of Nova Corps member Rhomann Dey prompted speculation that John C. Reilly might reprise his role as the character from Guardians of the Galaxy.
The Truth: As fun as a Reilly cameo would've been - especially as Rhomann was quite possibly killed when Thanos sacked Xandar in pursuit of the Power Stone - this sadly didn't come to pass.
Fingers crossed we might finally learn one day what happened to him, and it might not be the terrible news we're all suspecting.
In fact, if Marvel Studios ever pulls the trigger on a Nova movie, there's a pretty strong chance we will see Dey again (as Nova inherits the title from him). Here's hoping.
2. Captain Marvel Is A Skrull
The Rumour: Alright, laugh it up. This theory caught a surprising amount of traction online, that the movie's biggest twist would be the reveal that Carol Danvers is neither Kree nor human: she's in fact a Skrull.
The theory posits that, with the messy nature of Carol's memories, they could've all been implanted by the Skrulls for some sort of nefarious reason. This would line up with Carol's knowing claim in the trailer, "I'm not what you think I am."
The Truth: It's an interesting idea that riffs on notions of identity and good and evil, but this would've just been too extreme a change of the character's mythology to be accepted by the hardcore crowd.
Granted, Marvel Studios has gotten away with some pretty radical rug-pulls in the past - the Mandarin twist, anyone? - but re-configuring the precise nature of the MCU's most powerful character is a whole different kettle of fish to reinventing a villain we'll probably never see again.
As it turns out, Carol is a human granted powers by the Tesseract and brainwashed into believing she's a Kree courtesy of Yon-Rogg. That's it.
1. Carol Gets Dusted At The End...But Reverses It
The Rumour: Another nifty Reddit theory here, which claimed that the film would end with Carol receiving the pager message from Fury, only to start disintegrating as a result of the Decimation.
But the big twist? She'd use her superpowers to reverse the effects of the dusting on herself, before blasting off into space and heading to Earth, ending the film on one hell of an epic cliffhanger.
The Truth: This probably could've worked, but it also ran the risk of making the snap seem too inconsequential and depicting Captain Marvel as over-powered before she's even faced off against Thanos.
Instead, the film doesn't really invoke the Decimation much at all, beyond the mid-credits scene where Carol is shown meeting up with some of the surviving Avengers in the present.
Did you buy into these rumours and fan theories? Shout it out in the comments!