Casting Star Trek: The Next Generation Reboot
Going where a few people have gone before.
When it comes to the inevitable passage of time, resistance is futile. People grow old. Things become forgotten. And franchises get rebooted.
Star Trek: The Next Generation is now over 30 years old, fondly remembered by fans, but relatively stagnant otherwise, drifting through the media void like a ship without power. In a culture chock full of superheroes, Star Wars, and weirdly unfunny action comedies, there seems to be little room for a smart little sci-fi show.
Yet the hunger is there. With the success of the new Star Trek: Discovery series, there's clear evidence that Star Trek can survive in this brave new world, and what better way than a reboot to bring forward the Next Generation of Starfleet explorers? Er, the Next NEXT Generation, that is.
And just like the original TNG, any reboot will likely live or die by the quality of the characters. The Bridge crew on TNG were memorable and likeable, with interesting storylines more concerned with exploring other cultures than it was about blasting CGI creatures.
And to portray the best characters, you need the best actors.
So let us boldly go through these casting picks together, in the hopes that this time whoever plays Riker can sit on chairs properly.
10. Natasha Yarr/Sela - Zazie Beetz
While Star Trek has never been the most physical of franchises, Natasha Yarr is (was) the Head of Security aboard the enterprise, so if anyone's going to be getting into fights, it's her.
So to fill the curb stomping boots of such a character, you need an actress who can be tough when she needs to be. You need an actress like Zazie Beetz.
With roles in films like Deadpool 2 and Geostorm, Beetz is an expert in playing tough talking and snarky characters, though she'd have to tone down the snark when on the bridge - chain of command and all that. Hopefully she'll be able to do more than just that weird two handed punch, though.
Beetz is also a regular of serialised television, meaning she'd know exactly how and when to flesh out the character over weeks rather than hours.
What's more, a fresh look at Natasha Yarr would be a good chance to develop the character and give her more to do in general. Disappointingly, Yarr was little more than set dressing in most of her appearances, which is what led to her being killed off before the end of the first season. But if history does repeat itself, Beetz can always come back as Sela.
9. Guinan - Whoopi Goldberg
Every reboot needs someone from the original to carry the torch, and who better than the centuries old, alien barkeep?
Much like Picard, Guinan is an older, advisory figure, and Goldberg (now older herself) is arguably even better suited to the role now than she was back in 1988. With her soft, smooth voice and whip smart sense of humour, she could easily slip back into her old character.
This would be even more effective if a younger actor was chosen to play Picard this time around, as Guinan's wise and experienced counsel would be all the more necessary.
Plus Whoopi's actual experience of being on Star Trek would be a massive benefit to all the cast and crew involved, especially since she knew (and was reportedly close friends with) Gene Rodenberry before his passing.
An older Guinan would also serve as a great introduction to several of TNG's famous antagonists as well, having had personal experience with both the Borg and Q - a great excuse to bring back John de Lancie, by the way - and could act as the show's expository lead. It'd beat having to get a certain android to explain everything again.
"That's enough, Data!"
8. Wesley Crusher - Tom Holland
Ah, Wesley Crusher. The young, scientific genius who had big hopes about saving the galaxy. If only there was a young actor who could play such a character.
Well, considering Wesley Crusher is basically Peter Parker in space, there's always Tom Holland.
He's already shown he can play intelligent and likeable characters, and with his wealth of experience in massive blockbuster franchises, handling Star Trek should be no trouble. At least the Romulans never threatened to wipe out half the universe.
While Holland may arguably be a little old for the role, this may play to the show's benefit, as an older, cockier Wesley would be great as a comedic foil for the rest of the crew.
Puberty's hard, after all, but it's even harder when you're confined in a floating box with the space military.
While part of TNG's charm lies in its visionary nature, with humanity having grown out of its infancy, it would be an intriguing change to see a character that's less than perfect, and the young and impressionable Crusher would be the best choice for that. With his recent role in The Devil All The Time Holland has shown he's up to the task.
7. Dr. Beverly Crusher - Paget Brewster
As Chief Medical Officer, Beverly Crusher served as Science expert for the team aboard the enterprise, and her skills as a doctor formed many of the episode resolutions throughout TNG's tenure.
Whoever takes up the mantel, therefore, must be keen, discerning, and intelligent. Or at least be able to act like it.
Paget Brewster could do that with ease.
Due to her naturally authoritative presence, Brewster would be a great choice for the principled and proper Doctor, and after a six year stint on Criminal Minds, Brewster has proven she can play the clever and commanding professional.
Plus she's probably more than capable of spouting reams of technobabble on command.
Not only that, but Brewster has some serious comedic chops, with her role as Frankie Durt on Community showing she's the master of deadpan delivery. Considering Crusher had more than her fair share of lighthearted moments on TNG, a good mix of dramatic and comic skills would serve the actor well as the ship's doctor.
And you never know, all that playful banter could finally lead to the Picard/Crusher romance thing becoming canon.
6. Worf - Djimon Hounsou
Whilst recently appearing in films like Guardians of the Galaxy and King Arthur: Legend Of The Sword, Djimon Hounsou always seems relegated to the background. Which is a shame, since he's an award winning actor who's been nominated multiple times by both the Academy and the Screen Actors' Guild. But hey, the pay's probably good.
That being said, it's time for Hounsou to take on a leading role... albeit one in an ensemble cast. And coming in at a whopping six foot two, he's definitely physically capable of playing the towering Klingon Lieutenant Worf.
This, coupled with the makeup he'd undoubtedly wear, would mean he'd able to effectively disappear into the character. Whether Hounsou would enjoy being strapped into a makeup chair for four hours every day however, is another matter.
If that's a dealbreaker, chances are the OG Michael Dorn's still hanging around somewhere.
5. Geordi La Forge - Lakeith Stanfield
As the curious and courageous Helmsman (and later engineer) for the enterprise, Geordi La Forge was always full of a youthful energy and optimism that many of his crewmates lacked.
While Lakeith Stanfield usually plays more low energy characters like his run in Sorry To Bother You and Uncut Gems, his natural eloquence and his ability to convey vulnerability would make him ideal for the young and intelligent Geordi.
Considering Lakeith is experiencing something of a rise in fame after stints in both Get Out and Knives Out, a good run on an acclaimed show like Star Trek would be a wise decision for the up and coming actor.
As a blind character who "sees" through the help of a visor, La Forge was an important figure in showcasing characters with disabilities in media, and as Stanfield has previously been open in addressing issues around such stigmatic subjects like mental health, character and actor would go hand in hand.
Also, thankfully, with advancements in special effects, Stanfield probably won't be subjected to long, head squeezing hours in a visor like LeVar Burton was, it'll just be a few quick clicks in post. 24th Century, here we come.
4. Deanna Troi - Gal Gadot
Serving as ship's counsellor, Deanna Troi forms the emotional backbone of the Enterprise's crew. It helps that being half-betazoid, she can sense the emotions of others, which allows her to compile psychological profiles of characters with uncanny accuracy.
On paper, this sounds absolutely terrifying. A being that is constantly aware of your innermost thoughts and feelings would work very well as the monster in a horror film, but it is in Troi's natural benevolence, and actress Marina Sirtis' talent for portraying empathy, that makes Deanna seem comforting rather than unnerving.
This is remarkably similar to Gal Gadot's portrayal of Diana Prince, a superhuman Amazon who believes in the superiority of her race and solving her problems through combat. Yet Gal Gadot is able to make Wonder Woman relatable and, well, wonderful.
This talent for making the strange seem normal would make her perfect to play the alien therapist.
The only problem casting Gal would be finding time in her schedule in between the twenty DC films she's currently shooting. But as Captain Picard himself would say: "Make it so."
3. Data - Doug Jones
As one of the most beloved and recognisable characters in all of Star Trek, choosing the right person to play the soft spoken android Data would be no mean feat.
In theory, Data can be played by anyone, man or woman, as according to the character himself, gender is just another construct to him.
But for a choice that is as close to the original as possible while adding a little something new, it can only be Doug Jones.
Having starred on Star Trek Discovery, Jones would be a good way to tie the new wave of Star Trek series together. As an incredibly gifted physical performer, Jones would have Data's physical mannerisms down perfectly, from the slight head movements to the childlike expressions.
And chances are, were Jones to be cast, he'd probably go further. As an incredibly talented mime, it's likely Jones would create a whole new style of movement for Data, even choosing to walk differently from the other characters on the show.
Couple this with Jones' naturally amicable demeanour, and you've got the perfect Data. Eerily different on the outside, but intrinsically human within.
Just cross your fingers that we don't see Data do any body horror contortion stuff.
2. William T. Riker - Armie Hammer
While choosing the right Jean-Luc Picard might seem like the hardest decision to make, casting First Officer William Riker is a much harder process.
Picard, as the captain of the Enterprise, is duty bound and commanding, yet doesn't necessarily need to be jovial with the crew.
Riker, on the other hand, has to constantly straddle that line.
Jonathan Frakes' highest accomplishment with the character was portraying a man who was both authoritative (as the second in command), but also warm and likeable; the sort of person you could see yourself sharing a beer with after a hard shift.
And that's a hard contrast to find in an actor.
Enter Armie Hammer, who seems to have made a career off of doing just that.
From his time in Call Me By Your Name and The Man From Uncle, Hammer excels at playing figures in positions of power and high society, whilst his natural charm and easy-going manner never make him too unlikeable, even in films like The Social Media.
While Hammer has a tendency to play upper class characters, an everyman like Riker would allow audiences to see the actor in a different light.
He's also ridiculously tall, like Frakes was. Not that that matters, or anything.
1. Jean-Luc Picard - Tom Hardy
As the most British French person in the Federation, any new iteration of Captain Jean-Luc Picard would have to have that same intrinsic Englishness.
And no one is more quintessentially British than Tom Hardy.
As Captain of the Enterprise, Picard always came off as firm but fair, pushing his crew to greatness but never coddling them. And Tom Hardy's *ahem* harder streak would complement that perfectly. It also makes perfect sense, given Hardy already played a younger clone of Picard's in Star Trek: Nemesis.
Plus he's no stranger to going bald, or playing pop cultural icons, as we've seen from his iterations of Bane and Bronson. On top of that, with Hardy's sheer star power driving the franchise forward, producers would be able to set their phasers to make a killing.
Whilst Patrick Stewart lent a certain suave and sophisticated style to everyone's favourite GIFable Captain, Hardy would be an excellent choice for a younger, slightly rougher Picard, one who's still prone to making mistakes and acting hastily. He's also a good contrast to the more affable Hammer, leading to some excellent story potential.
Of course, the only thing that really matters is how well Hardy can Facepalm. That's the real Picard manoeuvre.
Watch Next
The Hardest Star Trek: The Next Generation Quiz Ever!