Christopher Eccleston: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Thor Dark World Malekith For many, Christopher Eccleston is one of those actors who people tend to forget about until he turns up in a movie with the unbridled intention of showing them what real acting actually looks like. That he hasn't quite established himself as a constant presence or force in Hollywood goes without saying - he's better-defined by the variable and unpredictable nature of his work. One minute Eccleston might turn up as the villain in a huge blockbuster, and then all of sudden he's treading the boards somewhere, or helming a brand new mini-series for American television. What remains consistent, though, is Eccleston's stature as an actor of undeniable talent, confidence and respectability. A true thespian in every sense of the word, there have been very few instances of this deftly underrated actor phoning it in for a quick buck, though there are certainly performances that one could argue fall into such a category. Truth is, though, as with so many unconventional actors trying to find their place (or is it unconventional-looking actors?), there's a sense that Hollywood doesn't know exactly where to put somebody like Eccleston. It's not unfair to suggest that Christopher Eccleston remains best-known for his brief turn as Doctor Who and less for his motion picture roles, then, many of which have gone relatively unnoticed. But it's impossible to ignore Eccleston's filmography entirely - small as it is, over the course of his career, he has gifted movie-goers with performances that might best be described as "masterful" (even if some of them only amount to extended cameos). To celebrate his villainous role in Marvel's newest offering, Thor: The Dark World, released this week, join us as we take a look at 5 awesome and 5 not so awesome Eccleston performances....

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Major Henry West - 28 Days Later (2002)

Christopher Eccleston 28 Days Later You could certainly argue that Christopher Eccleston's appearance in Danny Boyle's seminal horror flick 28 Days Later amounts to nothing more than one of those extended cameos I mentioned in the introduction, but to do so would be to overstate an audiences's familiarity with the actor: this is Eccleston taking on a role as any working actor in need of a gig might, but in doing so he provides the entire second act of the film with a sense of horror and uneasiness that a lesser performer would not have been capable of conjuring up. The plot of 28 Days Later concerns the infection of the UK population by way of an virus which renders its victims as rage-inflicted monsters. Having survived long enough to escape London, Cillain Murphy's hero Jim and his ragtag group make it to Major Henry West's compound, where Eccleston does his best job of making us feel like something is seriously wrong. The success of this character is in Eccleston's delivery: his horrifying decisions are made for - in West's eyes, anyway - entirely pragmatic reasons, though the actor never overplays his hand. It's a surprisingly accomplished performance, one that feels real - and researched - despite its size.

4. Thomas Howard, 4th Duke of Norfolk - Elizabeth (1998)

Elizabeth Christopher Eccleston Though many people probably see him as incredibly well-suited to playing villainous Englishman in period-inclined films, Christopher Eccleston has said that it was considered something of a risk casting him as a nobleman in 1998's Elizabeth, which also starred Cate Blanchett as the titular queen. At the time, though it sounds rather bizarre in retrospect, allowing Eccleston to play a character of extreme entitlement was seen as somewhat odd. And according to the actor himself, nobody but director Shekhar Kapur would allow him to give roles like this a go. Needless to say, as Thomas Howard, the 4th Duke of Norfolk, Eccleston is mesmerising and utterly immersed in his role - as he delivers his lines, it's hard to take your eyes off of him. Convinced that Elizabeth I is entirely ill-suited to her position as queen of England, he sets about trying to stop her accession to the throne and it's delicious to watch unfold. Given Eccleston's theatrical training, it's no wonder that he thrived in this part. And though it introduced him to a wider audience, it also pegged him as an "actor who does villains" - for better or worse.

3. David Stephens - Shallow Grave (1994)

Shallow Grave Christopher Eccleston was still something of an unknown when he turned up in Danny Boyle's masterful debut Shallow Grave, playing an obnoxious chartered accountant who, along with flatmates Ewan McGregor and Kerry Fox, finds himself entangled in a turbulent situation: when their new tenant dies of a drug overdose, the friends discover a suitcase filled with cash in his room. Though at first they consider telling the police, the ultimately decide to take it for themselves. Let's just say the whole ordeal doesn't end particularly well for anybody. In one of his first major roles, then, Eccleston thrives: he makes David Stephens, who is originally set on informing the authorities about the death of his tenant, a believable individual. Playing David as something of an asshole and a voice of reason all at once, Eccleston's performance provides a perfect example of an actor bringing weight and authority to an character who might have felt paper thin. Though we don't necessarily like David, with every line of dialogue, Eccleston demands you pay attention. It's an incredibly assured turn - the film's best, perhaps.

2. The Doctor - Doctor Who (2005)

Christopher Eccleston Doctor Who Unless you're a die hard fan, it's easy to forget that, once upon a time, Christopher Eccleston played the first incarnation of Doctor Who when the series was "rebooted" by the BBC in 2005. At the time of his casting, Doctor Who was thought of as something rather silly - all rubber monsters and naff storylines. I mean, audiences weren't anywhere near as into it as they are nowadays. Which brings us to Christopher Eccleston, whose ninth Doctor layed down the tracks for a more dramatic, serious and respectable Doctor Who. That's not to say he didn't bring fun to the franchise, but there was an added weight with Eccleston that really gave the BBC room to develop the show for the 21st century. Rather sadly, Eccleston only got to play the Doctor for a measly thirteen weeks before he moved on to other projects. Given that lots of Who fanatics regard him as the best Doctor ever, that's a real shame - one could certainly argue that Eccleston was one of very few actors who seemed to nail the Doctor's persona. He was somebody we could take seriously whilst remaining utterly charming, too.

1. Derek Bentley - Let Him Have It (1991)

Christopher Eccleston Let Him Have It Christopher Eccleston's first filmic role still might be his best: that's not to say that he hasn't done better since, but that everything that is great about this actor seems is on show in 1991's Let Him Have It, a movie based on the true story of the case against Derek Bentley, a teenager who was hanged in 1953 for the murder of a police officer during a burglary. Interestingly, Bentley did not commit murder himself, but rather instructed his accomplice, Christopher Craig, to do so. Because Craig was still a minor, he was not hung. This dramatic ground would have provided great opportunities for any budding actor, but Eccleston nails it and proves that he was the right man for the job from the very first frame. Eccleston portrays Bentley in a simple, child-like way, and his performance is deep and ripe with emotion, allowing the complicated, morality-based issues inherent to the plot to come to the surface with ease: as a result, Let Him Have It remains one of the best ever movies to deal with the subject of capital punishment. And thanks to Eccleston, you won't forget it in a hurry - if ever.

5 Performances That Sucked...

5. Wolf - The Invisible Circus (2001)

The Invisible Circus

This little-seen movie remains little-seen for a reason: it's pretty darn terrible. Based on the novel of the same name by Jennifer Egan, The Invisible Circus tells the story of a teenage girl who travels to Paris in the 1970s to learn more about her sister's recent suicide, only to find herself falling in love with her dead sister's boyfriend - and that's where our main man Christopher Eccleston comes in, playing a character called - brace yourself - Wolf. If you think this all sounds a bit artsy and naff, you'd be right. And Eccleston can't save it - he's dull. Did I mention that this movie also stars Cameron Diaz? Yep. And though she's not exactly bad, nobody contained within the frames of this feature comes out looking particularly good - put it down to the script. As Wolf, Eccleston doesn't quite seem on the same wave length as his character. Worst of all, during parts he's wearing a terrible-looking wig that - even today, over a decade later - he must look back on and cringe. Heck, I'm cringing, and I'm nothing to do with the movie (phew!). Overly sentimental and boring, this remains a pallid addition to Eccleston's filmography.

4. Raymond Calitri - Gone In 60 Seconds (2000)

Christopher Eccleston Gone In 60 Seconds Eccleston isn't exactly terrible in the modern remake of Gone In 60 Seconds, but it's nearly impossible for him to raise the bar with the dialogue he's forced to spurt out here. Still, even Oscar-winning actors like Nicholas Cage, Angelina Jolie and Robert Duvall couldn't pull this thing out from the depressingly bog of mediocrity that it ended up sinking back into, so it's no surprise. Christopher Eccleston is the villain here, of course (c'mon - he's British), and though the performance itself is fine, it still comes across as entirely lame. That's to say, the premise and the dialogue is made out from serious bottom of the barrel stuff. Take the scene where, as bad guy Raymond "The Carpenter" Calitri, Eccleston is forced to say - purely because the hero's surname is "Raines" - the Godawful line: "When it rains, it pours." There's no context to this line - it's just a throwaway they give to the villain because aren't villains supposed to have funny little sayings? Which means it's impossible for Christopher Eccleston to come out looking good - and going by his facial expressions throughout, he knows it.

3. The Rider - The Dark Is Rising (2007)

Eccleston The Dark Is Rising The Dark Is Rising (also titled The Seeker in some parts of the world) sets around the story of a young boy who finds out that - through his unexpected magical abilities - he's destined to save the world. Based on a series of novels by Susan Cooper, The Dark is Rising makes absolutely no attempt to tell a proper, fully-formed story and wastes every single member of its cast in the process, including our man Christopher Eccleston. You know those movies where you just spent the entire time listening to characters explain the plot? That's what happens here. Oh, no. A movie that wanted to do something along the lines of Harry Potter and failed every step of the way. It's probably only fair to say that Christopher Eccleston's performance is one of the best things in this movie, but when you sit down to watch it you'll realise that this doesn't really work as a compliment - he only seems partly invested in the story, walking that fine line between "trying to care" and "definitely phoning it in." The worst thing about his turn here is that he's supposed to be scary, but fails entirely to generate any fear.

2. Destro - G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra (2009)

Christopher Eccleston Gi Joe When you're featured in a movie called "G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra" and you're playing a character called "Destro," it's presumed that you didn't take on the role because you were planning to win a ton of awards or anything. So whether or not Christopher Eccleston took a part in the first G.I. Joe movie because he just need the cash or because he genuinely thought it might turn out to be a good movie doesn't really matter - what matters is that he's in the movie. So how does he fare? Well, rather badly to be entirely frank. But what did we expect from G.I. Joe? As Destro, Eccleston provides a forgettable villain for much of the movie's first half, a weapons supplier intent on ruling the world. Is he doing bad acting here? It's hard to tell, given the subject matter and the bizarre accent that he adopts for much of his screentime - is that supposed to be a Brooklyn accent? What is that accent, Chris? The role, of course, is way beneath the actor... and it doesn't help that his face is encased in a layer of metal for most of the film. I'd like to say that he plays it with some self-awareness, but I'm not entirely sure that he does.

1. Malekith - Thor: The Dark World (2013)

Thor Dark World Malekith What went wrong here hasn't really got much to do with Eccleston himself - had the actor been allowed to actually... well, "act," Malekith might have found affection with Marvel Cinematic Universe fans for years to come. I mean, the prospect of Christopher Eccleston playing a villain in this kind of movie is an exciting one - he's a proper actor, you know? Unfortunately, Malekith remains one of the more undeveloped and most generic villains in recent blockbuster movie memory. He spends the entire runtime mumbling in a different language, and that's it. The problem is that there's no depth to Malekith: we don't learn anything about him and he isn't afforded a real motive, which makes him about as interesting as an unbuttered slice of bread. And the layers of make-up and the fact that he speaks - for the most part, anyway - in a strange foreign tongue do nothing to help Christopher Eccleston out of what very soon establishes itself as a worryingly restricting performance. Did Eccleston himself feel like he managed to convey anything worthwhile here? Perhaps not. Still - at least it's a Hollywood movie, Christopher! Like this list? Agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

Jack Allen hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.