Doctor Strange: 25 WTF Moments

Open your third eye...

Doctor Strange WTF
Marvel Studios

Doctor Strange and WTF elements go hand in hand like Stan Lee and hilarious cameos in MCU movies. He is after all the conduit to the stranger elements of the Marvel universe, and indeed the key to opening those odder doors for future movies, and it's inevitable that even greater oddities lie behind them.

Marvel could have actually played it safe with the Sorceror Supreme's debut in the MCU: they could have toned down his mysticism and the supernatural elements of his universe (as they did with Scarlet Witch and to a lesser extent Thor), instead seeking a more grounded version that would slot in with the rest of the films. But the fact that Kevin Feige drove a pure adaptation of the comics that has delighted newcomers and old fans of the comics alike is just brilliant.

Inevitably, that means that the film is a strange affair, but not always in the way Marvel intended. Sure, it's great overall, but it has some pretty big blemishes, plot holes and flat-out WTF moments that emerge as soon as you start scratching the surface.

Here are the biggest WTF moments in Doctor Strange...

25. Doctor Strange Is A Dick

Doctor Strange Window Before.jpg
Marvel Studios

What has been quickly established since the first viewings of Doctor Strange is that Stephen Strange is very much the heir apparent to Tony Stark. He's an arrogant, thoroughly charming roguish playboy who is petulant, snobbish and aloof, but he has a loveable streak that is first introduced - weirdly - by his encyclopedic knowledge of obscure pop music.

Except some of his actions actually imply he's an outright villain, and not just a bit of a Stark-style douche. Where Stark's complicity in his family business' weapons trading was more out of privileged ignorance than anything else, Strange wilfully ignores cases in order to preserve his perfect record. He's very possibly a monster through inaction and at no stage does he really atone for it.


24. When The Hell Is It Actually Set?

Avengers Tower Doctor Strange
Marvel

Now, this probably wouldn't actually be so much of a problem if it wasn't for the fact that the film-makers seem intent on confusing matters with their answers whenever the question comes up.

There are hints that Doctor Strange could be set at the same time as Iron Man 2 - the mention of the injured colonel who was paralysed in a test flight of experimental armour for instance, and the general lack of any mention of The Incident (or any sign of it in the wide shots of New York). That would have been pretty smart as it would have negated the need to wonder why the government wouldn't be more concerned about magician sightings in post Superhero Registration times.

It would also get over the fact that by the time Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Doctor Strange was already on a SHIELD watch-list. Sure, it was an Easter Egg, but why the hell would an arrogant prick surgeon be on a watch-list? And if it is indeed set in 2016, why wasn't his sudden disappearance to Tibet not cause some alarm (there's no way the government would throw out SHIELD's watch-lists when they were INCREDIBLY useful for registration monitoring purposes).

It's just dumb to set the film in early 2016, particularly as it means Strange had his accident, lost all of his money, partially healed, exhausted all medical avenues, gave up entirely, went to Tibet, trained to be a Sorceror and stopped Dormammu all in a matter of months. Why not just go with the hints it's earlier and avoid all the unnecessary probing?


23. Nic West - Utterly Pointless

A Serious Man Michael Stuhlbarg
Focus Features

The idea of a professional rival for Doctor Strange before his accident is not the worst idea at all, and using comic character Nic West to fill that gap is smart too, but in the end the prologue to the Strange story hurtles by so quickly that West is relegated to an utterly forgettable side-kick who does no more than distract from the narrative.

It's not possible to dislike him or feel much affection for him either way: he's just a sort of beige character who represents the uncool mirror image of Strange who the good Doctor bullies needlessly. It's not entirely clear whether we're supposed to feel bad for him or to laugh alongside Strange, particularly as Strange straight up seems to steal his girlfriend later on and nobody makes any mention of it whatsoever.

The biggest crime is casting someone as talented as Michael Stuhlbarg and giving him literally nothing to do. But then this is the same film that cast Meera Syal and Transparent's Amy Landecker and basically canned them entirely in the edit.


22. The Rag-Doll Physics

Doctor Strange Benedict Cumberbatch
Marvel Studios

For 98% of the time, the effects in Doctor Strange are flat-out incredible: not only are they some of the most inventive sequences ever committed to film (let alone this genre), they also actually suit 3D presentation rather than making everyone feel sick. They're trippy, they're incredibly imaginative and they deserve to win several Oscars when that time comes around.

Unfortunately, the other 2% of the time is reserved for what can best be described as Matrix Rag Doll effects. As in the Matrix sequels, the attempt to completely computer render human figures and have them jump or fall great distances produces a horrible, unrealistic effect that drags you relentlessly out of the film. It's in no way ruinous, but the effect of having such great effects next to such poor ones (as in the opening of Civil War, actually) is horribly off-putting.


21. The Ancient One Just Sort Of Gives Up On Kaecilius

Doctor Strange Ancient One Tilda Swinton.jpg
Marvel Studios

The opening sequence sees Mads Mikkelsen's Kaecilius breaking into the library in Kamar-Taj, killing the unfortunate (and horribly under-equipped librarian) and running off with the precious pages of the mystical text explaining how to access the Dark Dimension. The Ancient One gives chase, but he evades capture.

You might assume at this point that the Ancient One - knowing the potentially catastrophic impact those stolen pages could have on all of existence - might do something to chase them down. She can see multiple possible futures, after all, so she can probably work out where Kaecilius might reappear and where he might be found, so it probably wouldn't be all that hard. Particularly as she's basically the most powerful entity in the universe (since even Dormammu seems to fear - or respect - her power).

Instead, she just sort of shrugs and lets him get away. She doesn't even attempt to use the Eye Of Agamotto to turn back time and catch Kaecilius in the act, despite her knowing how to use it and having no qualms about messing with the "natural order of things". In the end, it just looks careless.

Luckily though, Kaecilius just buggers off quietly for a few months while the Ancient One trains up the Chosen One. It's pretty handy that he didn't attack before Strange was perfectly ready...


20. Another Justin Hammer Reference...

Justin Hammer Gun.jpg
Marvel Studios

Are Marvel preparing to reintroduce Justin Hammer to the Marvel universe?

The mention of a soldier being injured testing out experimental armour might not be an intentional call-back to Iron Man 2 (unless you choose to ignore the director, like me), but it immediately inspires the image of Justin Hammer, that film's under-appreciated villain.

And this is the second time that's happened this year already in Marvel projects, after his company's cameo in Luke Cage. It's almost like the wannabe-Stark clone is being primed for a return to the MCU... Perhaps in an Iron Man 4 that may or may not be in the pipeline?

But surely not, right? He probably ranks as one of the worst received villains so far, thanks to the overall quality of the film. So isn't bringing him up just inviting the fans to rake over a pretty bad time for Marvel?


19. Was That Captain Marvel's New Origin?!

Bree Larson Captain Marvel
Boss Logic

Here's something we definitely know: Marvel don't want to do the comic book origin of Captain Marvel because it's way too similar to the stinking Green Lantern movie, and nobody wants to attract poor publicity by proximity to garbage. So it seems we're going to get a whole new origin for Carol Danvers.

And oddly, it looks like the media are intent on insisting that the origin has already happened, in a throw-away comment in Strange. Because that's how Marvel would introduce their first bona-fide leading lady...

During Strange's fateful car journey, he talks to a colleague about possible cases and she mentions a woman in her 20s who was struck by lightning, with the interesting sidebar that she has a brain implant to keep her schizophrenia in check.

Having heard the line EW (via /Film) asked director Scott Derrickson if that might be Captain Marvel's new origin. His reply set the Internet into a spiral...

Remember that Brittany Murphy movie where she goes ‘I’ll never tell…’

That's not a yes, no matter how anyone spins it. But it's intriguing.

Even more intriguing - and more WTF worthy - is the fact that IF it's really her origin, it's basically hinting at Captain Marvel borrowing some of Sentry's origin from the comics. The idea of a superhero "trapped" in the body of a normal and accidentally being "awoken" is pretty much a mongrelisation of that iconic story. I don't know whether to be excited or appalled.


18. Strange's Skepticism Is Stupid

Doctor Strange Open Mind.jpg
Marvel Studios

A real world character being dropped into a universe of weird mysticism and supernatural power entities would inevitably cause that character to doubt what they were being told about or being shown. It stands to reason, because a normal human brain wouldn't have any frame of reference for such things.

But Doctor Strange lives in New York in 2016 (apparently), a city which has been ravaged by invading aliens led by a magic sceptre-wielding space sorceror with shape-shifting powers, who was stopped by his Norse God half-brother, a thawed super-soldier and a Hulk. This is the same New York that now has a magical robo-Jesus and a real life witch living in it, who have been all over the news. SO WHY THE HELL IS HE SKEPTICAL AT ALL?!

And not only that, but Strange is literally enticed to go to Kamar-Taj by Jonathan Pangborn, who tells him point blank that the injury Strange himself said was a lost cause was healed using Eastern spiritual medicine. So why when he gets there and is told that's exactly what could heal him does he scoff and act like a belligerent, skeptical moron? He was literally JUST wowed by the evidence.


17. Wong - Worst Guard Ever

Doctor Strange Benedict Wong
Marvel Studios

When the first Kamar-Taj librarian is killed, The Ancient One naturally turns to one of her most skilled Sorcerors to guard the library, because she has to thanks to her strange policy of not putting any security at all on some of the universe's most powerful magical artefacts and texts. She must have had incredible confidence in Wong.

She shouldn't have, though, should she? Because he basically has his pants pulled down by a trainee magician who takes advantage of him listening to Beyonce to open portals in the library and steal the books he's not allowed. So, we're supposed to accept that the ONLY security measures on the most important vault of magical knowledge is a slightly bumbling man who doesn't pay attention to his duties?

Are there no magical shields to stop people teleporting in and out? No curse counter-measures? It's ludicrous and it's only like that for a cheap gag. And maybe putting actual locks on the FORBIDDEN MAGICAL BOOKS might have been an idea too...?


16. The Ancient One Basically Tries To Kill Strange

Doctor Strange Mountains.jpg
Marvel Studios

This is not the right kind of tough love lesson: it's not like Strange has actually shown any real aptitude up to this point for magic, because of his utter reluctance to get over his ego. Dropping him into a situation that will kill him within minutes absolutely shouldn't have worked.

That fact even dawns on The Ancient One even as she's enacting it: Mordo challenges her and she seems to accept it was careless. Almost as if SHE HASN'T EVEN THOUGHT IT THROUGH.

Except she must have, because she's seen the future - or several possible ones - which means rather grimly that her slight flicker of doubt comes from somewhere very real. In other futures, in other words, she killed him. And yet she still does it, dropping him into a swimming pool he can't hope to swim out of without the safety net of the Mirror Realm. Even Morpheus took Neo back into the Matrix to train him - this is just careless.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.