Donald Sutherland: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

It's that spectacular voice. Oh and the hair, can't forget about that.

You just have to love Donald Sutherland's voice, it's almost as unmistakable as the fumes from your morning coffee rising into your nostrils. Father to the equally successful and unmistakable Kiefer Sutherland, Donald is no stranger to the world of Hollywood and aside from having some of the most recognisable vocal cords in cinema today, the guy is a damn good actor too. With a career spanning over fifty years worth of film roles, Sutherland has utilised his talents for more varied types of roles than you can shake a stick at. From the undeniably brilliant Don't Look Now, a supernatural film that explores the themes of loss and grief to the science fiction epic classic that is Invasion Of The Body Snatchers (a pretty self-explanatory title if ever we've seen one), Sutherland is undoubtedly near the top of the list where versatility is concerned. Known in equal parts for his piercing gaze, acting talent and crazy 70s hair, you don't have to look hard to find a handful of films from any decade that Sutherland has lent his talent to. But even for actors as well-respected as Sutherland, not everything he does is perfect. Far from it. Yes, his filmography may be littered with famous film titles, but sprinkled between them like a disgusting seasoning are some truly awful films that should never have reached the light of day. Fool's Gold is one of the biggest offenders, a film that, for one reason or another, not only pulled in a large list of famous names, but also thought it was a good idea to have Sutherland play an Englishman, complete with god-awful accent. With other contenders featured in this list being the likes of Shadow Conspiracy, a film so bad that it hasn't even received a DVD release. But let's not spoil all the fun. Read on to discover which of Sutherland's films must be seen and which ones should never reach your television screen...

5 Awesome Performances

5. Klute - Klute (1971)

Klute isn't just a good detective crime thriller film, it's also one that features outstanding performances from both Donald Sutherland and Jane Fonda. The film centres around the suspected murder of business executive Tom Gruneman and the deceased's apparent penchant for prostitutes. As the titular detective and friend of Gruneman's family, Klute (Sutherland) is hired in an attempt to unravel the mystery, eventually coming into contact with Bree Daniels (Fonda) - a call girl who, Klute believes, knows who murdered his friend. Jane Fonda notably won an Oscar for her performance in the film, cited by critics as being one of the most flawless of her career. However, Sutherland didn't receive as much recognition as his co-star in the film, and while Fonda's role was undoubtedly the most deserving of recognition, Sutherland's Klute was just as worthy of praise. Aside from the believable chemistry both he and Fonda shared on-screen, Sutherland's performance was believable, absorbing and intriguing to watch as he unravelled one clue after the other. A great film in almost every way.

4. Michael - Panic (2000)

Donald Sutherland Panic If you've never heard of Panic, don't worry, not many people have. The film was lauded upon its release in 2000 for being an unabashed wryly comic take on the male mid-life crisis. Unsurprisingly compared to the almost universally-loved American Beauty, Panic follows the life of Alex (William H. Macy), a man who was reared at an early age by his father to be part of a family-run hit man business. The film largely focuses around Alex as he becomes infatuated with a younger woman and contemplates leaving his wife, all the while trying to escape his domineering father's grasp. Sutherland may only be a supporting cast member in the film, but his performance is no less memorable than any other of his more well-known films. In every single scene where Alex visits his father Michael, Sutherland performs the character so well that the audience progressively starts to understand why Alex dislikes his father and how he became such an efficient killer. If you're wondering what kind of father would start training their child to be a killer as a toddler, look no further than Sutherland's performance as Michael in Panic - the ruthless, controlling and psychological hold he has on his son is a treat to see acted.

3. General Donald McClintock - Outbreak (1995)

Prior to the current craze of the The Hunger Games films, it was a rare occurrence to see Donald Sutherland take up the mantle of the unflinching, obsessive villain. Most of the entries on this list are roles that show off Sutherland's kinder side in film, but in Outbreak, he was simply just a soulless arse. After discovering a deadly African disease not too dissimilar to the Ebola virus in an African jungle, Donald McClintock and his colleague Billy Ford (Morgan Freeman) eradicate any trace of the village and the virus after taking samples home with them to America. Fast-forwarding 28 years into the present day of the film, the virus resurfaces and takes hold on a quiet American town. By this time, McClintock has become a general, and the main antagonist of the film as he takes it upon himself to once again hide the existence of the virus in an effort to make it a potential biological weapon at the disposal of the American government. Unlike Freeman's repentant nature as Ford, Sutherland takes his character in the complete opposite direction, making McClintock an obsessively controlling senior army official concerned only with concealing the truth. Sutherland's character may be a little too one-sided in his personality (and slightly shallow because of it), but the actor's performance is no less brilliant because of it.

2. Matthew Bennell - Invasion Of The Body Snatchers (1978)

If ever a case needed to be put forward to support the idea that film remakes aren't always a bad idea, then Invasion Of The Body Snatchers would most certainly be proof that good ones do exist. A remake of the 1956 film of the same name, Philip Kaufman's adaptation of the original film was almost universally praised for its cast, innovative film techniques and expanded subject matter. While the film features an all-star cast of actors (most notably Jeff Goldblum and Leonard Nimoy), it's Sutherland's performance (and trademark 70s hair) that pushes the film's narrative forward. Sutherland's character, Matthew Bennell, is a health inspector that slowly comes to the realisation that the friends, loved ones and population around him are slowly being copied by an extraterrestrial race of gelatinous blobs. As more and more people start to exhibit strange behavioural patterns, Bennell accepts that he has to escape and gathers the last real humans together and legs it out of town. Sutherland's performance is not only relatable, but believable. His reaction to the terrifying events that unfold before his very eyes (people crumbling to dust to name just one) and portrayal of a character losing hope of survival are all so brilliantly personified purely through his facial reactions. And let's not forget the final scene...even thinking about it still makes us shiver.

1. John Baxter - Don't Look Now (1973)

Widely considered today by many to still be Sutherland's greatest performance, Don't Look Now is quite possibly one of the greatest British films ever made, let alone of the '70s. Following the accidental death of their daughter, John and Laura Baxter travel to Venice when the former is commissioned to start work on restoring a church. Upon meeting two elderly sisters in their new home, Laura is told by the strange siblings that their deceased daughter is not only trying to communicate with them, but that they can communicate with her directly. What follows is a film that appears, on the surface, to be a run-of-the-mill thriller, but is actually an emotional story about coping with loss, fatality, and the premature death of a child. All of these concepts are perfectly encapsulated in Sutherland and Julie Christie's performances, and their characters are so authentic that some even claim that the iconic sex scene between the two characters in the film were actually real and not simulated. Aside from that though, it's Sutherland's portrayal of the initially sceptical John that steal the show. As stranger and stranger events start to unfold around him and his wife, he starts to believe what the two sisters are telling him, and the emotional journey that he subsequently finds himself on is one that Sutherland nailed perfectly. Unfortunately though, there's always two sides to a coin...

And 5 Performances That Sucked...

5. Jake Conrad - Shadow Conspiracy (1997)

Donald Sutherland Shadow Conspiracy You don't have to look far to discover how bad of a film Shadow Conspiracy is. Not only does it have the rare honour of holding a zero per cent rating on Rotten Tomatoes, its also practically impossible to find a copy of the film on DVD in its country of origin, the United States. As of 2014, the only way to watch the film in America (as if you would really want to), is by watching it on VHS; you know, those big plastic rectangles that were replaced by discs almost twenty years ago. The film begins on the premise that Jake Conrad (Sutherland) is behind a conspiracy that's attempting to usurp the presidency in a power grab and that Charlie Sheen's character must race against time to reveal and stop the secret plan. Yes, it's a flimsy plot, yes it features some talented actors, but oh yes it features some very bad acting. Sheen himself was noted as being the worst performer in the film upon its release, critics pointing out that he had no conviction behind his lines whatsoever. Sheen was awful, but even Sutherland and Linda Hamilton as the other main cast members gave wooden performances that betrayed their backgrounds as very talented actors. If, for some reason, you want to read up on the film after this, good luck to you. The film is so unremarkable that nobody can even be bothered to write up a full synopsis on the internet.

4. Merrick - Buffy The Vampire Slayer (1992)

Joss Whedon is now known the world over as the mind behind the behemoth that is The Avengers, but for anyone who didn't grow up in the 90s, he's just as well known to vampire-loving audiences as the creator of the Buffy The Vampire TV series, as well as being the writer behind the 1992 film. Unfortunately, Whedon wasn't the director of the film, so it was ultimately out of his hands when script re-writes and dialogue changes were made. Many cite this as the reason for the Buffy film being so poorly received in relation to its TV sister, and Whedon himself has stated in numerous interviews since that Sutherland in particular was a nightmare to work with due to his apparent lack of respect for the source material. How extensively Sutherland re-wrote his own lines in the film is something we'll probably never know, but what is plain to see for everyone is just how cheesy many of his lines in the film are. It's one of the actor's most phoned-in performances, and one that featured a rather large amount of nonsensical and unnecessary dialogue.

3. John Bell Sr. - An American Haunting (2006)

An American Haunting just isn't scary. Billed as a horror film based on a true story (we all know how vague that usually turns out to be), the story follows a modern day mother's discovery of an old binder of correspondence by a previous owner of her 19th century house. What follows is a 90-minute tale of child abuse disguised as one of supernatural hauntings. Sutherland plays John Bell Sr., a man who believes his family has been cursed by a witch after a dispute over land. With his daughter suddenly starting to witness strange events, Bell truly believes a curse has been placed upon his family. While the revelation that the supposed supernatural force isn't evil - it's trying to compel Bell's daughter to remember her father's sexual abuse of her as a youngster - is a plot device that at least tries to be different from other horror films, none of the events really ever come across as even remotely unsettling. Sutherland isn't the only actor in the film to blame, but he's certainly not exempt from the fact that none of the performances in the film feel particularly authentic, and several scenes that feature strange occurrences that should evoke an emotional response just simply fall flat due to some slightly hammy acting. Not a great choice for Sutherland, that's for sure.

2. Nigel Honeycutt - Fool's Gold (2008)

Another film in Donald Sutherland's extensive filmography that you've either never heard of or just repressed into your sub-concious as a bad memory - Fool's Gold is as superficial as superficial films get. Boring characters, a boring plot and boring acting, the only praise critics afforded the film upon its release was that its shooting locations were spectacularly captured on camera. Sutherland plays a wealthy yacht owner in the film, and the employer of Kate Hudson's character, Tess Finnegan. Tess' ex-husband Ben (Matthew McConaughey), a treasure hunter, employs the help of Tess and her boss in an attempt to find some lost treasure trove before some almost comic book-esque villains beat them to it. Sutherland's performance is by no means the worst in the film, but there's one, single quirk about his character that just makes it cringeworthy to watch. For reasons probably unbeknown to anyone, Sutherland puts on an English accent in the film, and it's just... well, it's laughable. The film as a whole is an example of what happens when you waste some extremely talented actors, and it deserves its place in obscurity until the end of time.

1. Dr. Sid - Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within (2001)

Donald Sutherland Final Fantasy Still notable thirteen years after its initial release for being the most expensive film ever made based on a videogame franchise, Final Fantasy: Spirits Within tragically became the catalyst for Square Picture's closure and the absence of any CGI feature film based on the series since. That is, if you ignore the spectacular Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children, but that film wasn't released in cinemas like Spirits Within. Donald Sutherland voices Dr. Sid,, a scientist and mentor to the film's main protagonist, Dr. Aki Ross. As is the case with many animated films, it can always be difficult to find a voice that matches an animated character, and The Spirits Within, while being a landmark in terms of technological spectacle, did little to put those concerns to rest. Sutherland was part of an all-star cast to lend his vocal cords to the film, but his performance never quite matched up with the character of Dr. Sid. The film as a whole received average reviews upon its release and barely made half of its budget back at the box office, ensuring that it would only ever be remembered by die hard fans of the games. What other films of Sutherland's have you seen that you think are absolutely brilliant or just plain awful? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a freelance games journalist who, while not spending every waking minute selling himself to websites around the world, spends his free time writing. Most of it makes no sense, but when it does, he treats each article as if it were his Magnum Opus - with varying results.