Dustin Hoffman: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

So many great performances, so little time.

If you ask any actor or actress today about the performers who inspired them, the odds are probably pretty good that Dustin Hoffman will show up somewhere on their list. Over the course of a fifty-year career he€™s racked up an awe-inspiring list of credits, and he€™s shown himself capable of playing just about any character; from romantic leads to sleazy villains, wise mentors to talking cartoon animals. Despite his acclaim Hoffman is known to be incredibly self-critical of his own work, and his perfectionist nature has seen him clash with a lot of filmmakers. He gets deeply involved with the creative process €“ including scripting and editing - and demands numerous takes until he feels satisfied. This approach might rub collaborators the wrong way, but the results can€™t be denied. At least not in most cases. He also likes to take risks with his choices, and while they usually pay off a few of them have gone disastrously wrong. When a movie sucks there€™s little even a pro like Hoffman can do to help, but even when the ship is sinking he€™ll still give it his total commitment. With the forthcoming release of Kung Fu Panda 3 it€™s time to look back over Dustin Hoffman's legendary career and examine his best work; plus a few movies that definitely won€™t be included on his personal highlight reel.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Thomas Levy - Marathon Man (1976)

Marathon Man is a thriller with tension so thick it€™s almost suffocating, and is best remembered for the harrowing scenes of dental torture Hoffman€™s character endures. The story centres around a nerdy student who gets caught between his spy brother and a brutal Nazi war criminal, and must man up in order to survive. Hoffman makes Levy easy to root for; he€™s not some macho action hero out to save the world, he€™s just a normal man pushed to his absolute limits. He looks constantly exhausted and edgy during the later stages of the story, and even when he has a gun in his hands there€™s something incredibly vulnerable about him. There€™s a famous story about Hoffman going without sleep for a few days to prepare for a scene, and then being mocked by co-star Laurence Olivier, who said: €œWhy don€™t you try acting instead?€ It turns out Hoffman had stayed up because he was partying all night in Studio 54, proving that even with a roaring hangover Hoffman could still deliver the goods.

4. Michael Dorsey - Tootsie (1982)

It€™s not everyday a comedy about an actor in drag is nominated for Oscars, but it speaks to the overall quality of Tootsie that it was positively showered with nominations. Hoffman goes meta to play an actor who€™s known for his volatile relationship with directors (ironically enough, he had clashes with director Sydney Pollock over Tootsie too), who must dress up as a woman for a role. The role could easily have been laughable, but Hoffman manages to infuse it with heart and wit. The movie is a satire and comment on everyday sexism, in addition to being a laugh out loud comedy. Hoffman€™s character is kind of a jerk to start with, but he makes a believable transformation throughout the story when he learns to view the world from a different perspective; he makes for a surprisingly credible woman too. Hoffman spoke emotionally about the experience of Tootsie years later, when he realised he€™d missed on conversations with smart women during his youth because he didn€™t find them €œbeautiful.€ He credits the movie with teaching him to value a person€™s brain over their appearance.

3. Raymond Babbitt - Rain Man (1988)

Possibly the role Hoffman is most famous for €“ it€™s definitely his most quoted €“ is Ray Babbitt, the autistic brother of a shady yuppie played by Tom Cruise. While the film has been parodied to death by the likes of The Hangover and Family Guy - and credited with the sudden upswing of actors playing mentally challenged characters in search of Oscar glory - that€™s ignoring just how great Hoffman€™s performance is. Everything from his speech pattern to his body language feels believable; he spends the movie walking with a hunched over limp, and refuses to make eye contact with anyone. His screaming fit over hot water is a terrifying feat of performance, and is all the more distressing for how real it feels. We€™ve all seen bad examples of actors overplaying these types of roles, but Hoffman€™s turn is beautifully judged and respectful. Even though the film itself can be a little mawkish at times, the quality of the acting €“ Cruise€™s turn is unfairly overlooked €“ is where it shines.

2. Ratso Rizzo - Midnight Cowboy (1969)

Hoffman wanted to break away from the typecasting he received after The Graduate, so he went in the complete opposite direction for Midnight Cowboy, where he plays a ratty, nasally voiced con man. Hoffman wanted the role so much he slicked back his hair, dirtied up his face and wore homeless clothing for his first meeting with the director; he won the role on the spot. He completely inhabits the character of Ratso, who is a sickly hustler with dreams of making a better life for himself. The relationship he forms with Jon Voight€™s character comes out of necessity for both of them, but it becomes genuinely touching the more their friendship develops. The final scenes on the bus to Miami are the most heartbreaking of the film, and showed Hoffman€™s critics he was capable of playing any role he put his mind to. It says a lot that Ratso€™s most famous line €“ €œI€™m walkin€™ here!€ €“ was improvised in the moment, and has since been voted one of the most popular lines in cinema.

1. Benjamin Braddock - The Graduate (1967)

The film that made Hoffman a star is a timeless comedy from the sixties, crammed full of iconic scenes and featuring one of the best soundtracks of all time. In the film Hoffman plays a student who has an affair with a married older woman, only for things to get downright awkward when he falls in love with her daughter. The role is in many ways a defining performance by Hoffman, and while he€™s played a vast array of characters, people still tend to think of him playing the role of a nervous, slightly nebbish character. That€™s probably because he€™s so convincing in the role, and he manages to make Benjamin sympathetic even when he€™s being a selfish jerk. The wordless final scene is the highlight of his performance, with Ben and his girlfriend sitting in the back of a bus, and his smile fades to an unreadable expression. It€™s a master class in screen acting, rendered all the more impressive by the fact it was one of his earliest performances.

...And 5 That Sucked

5. Bernie - Meet The Fockers (2004)

While Meet The Parents was a fun exercise in cringe-inducing comedy, the sequel Meet The Fockers wasn€™t nearly so entertaining. This witless rehash of the original has Ben Stiller introducing his future father-in-law (Robert De Niro) to his hippie parents, played with maximum quirkiness by Dustin Hoffman and Barbara Streisand. Hoffman is clearly having a blast acting opposite Streisand and De Niro, but his relentlessly upbeat and horny character is comic marmite. The laboured script forces him to embarrass himself constantly for the sake of cheap laughs and while he€™s clearly game for it, it€™s tough watching someone work so hard for such little return. He€™s not much better in Little Fockers either, but at least his number of scenes were cut way the hell back; which was good news for him, and the audience.

4. Norman Goodman - Sphere (1998)

There was a brief point in the nineties, after Jurassic Park, that anything written by Michael Crichton €“ be it a book or a shopping list €“ was optioned for a movie. This explains how duds like Disclosure, Congo and Sphere came to exist, with the failure of the latter cooling Hollywood€™s enthusiasm for all things Crichton. In the movie, Hoffman plays a scientist brought on to explore a mysterious Sphere at the bottom of the ocean, which soon drives the crew to madness with murderous hallucinations. Sphere is the closest Hoffman ever came to a horror movie €“ discounting Ishtar €“ and there€™s a discomfort to his performance that really shines through. He looks out-of-place in such a b-movie setting, and really stumbles over some of the clunky exposition he has to deliver. The main issue is he doesn€™t appear to be having any fun, remaining deathly serious despite all the silly crap happening around him.

3. Chuck - Ishtar (1987)

Ishtar is one of the most notorious big-budget flops in film history, and is often featured on worst movie ever lists. It€™s not quite that terrible, but it€™s definitely not the underrated masterpiece Quentin Tarantino rates it as either. It's a horribly stilted comedy that tries to emulate the classic Bob Hope/Bing Crosby road movies, but Hoffman and co-star Warren Beatty don€™t have the chemistry to pull it off. They play a talentless singing duo who get caught up in a Cold War plot in Morocco, and the laughs fail to ensue. The movie tries to subvert expectations by having Beatty play the bumbler and Hoffman the ladies man, but in no version of reality is anybody going to buy that. Hoffman is clearly aiming for awkward laughs, but it just comes off plain awkward instead; just like the film. Ishtar gets points for trying to be unique, but the movie is still a sorry mess that drags Hoffman and Beatty down with it.

2. Mumbles - Dick Tracy (1990)

It may rank as one of the weirdest cameos ever, but Mumbles is still one of the most annoying performances Hoffman has ever given. Mumbles is an informant Dick Tracy comes up against a few times and, like the name suggests, he mumbles incoherently through all of his lines. Hoffman did the role as a favour for his old mate Warren Beatty, but while they might have been had fun working together the same joy isn€™t shared by the audience, who have to endure Hoffman mugging furiously for the camera. His incessant jabbering is damn near unbearable, but Beatty seems to think he€™s mining comedy gold so the Mumbles scenes run longer than they ever should have. It was nice to see Hoffman cut loose and do a silly little cameo for his friend; too bad it had to be in such an annoying part.

1. Edward Magorium - Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium (2007)

One of the funniest jokes in Breaking Bad comes from the penultimate episode, where Walter is on the run and brought to a remote cabin to hide out. He doesn't have access to the internet or television, and he only has two DVD copies of Mr. Magorium€™s Wonder Emporium for entertainment. Zack Helm €“ the writer/director of the film - agreed the movie would serve as fitting punishment for Walt€™s crimes. Mr. Magorium is a Technicolor kids movie in the vein of Willy Wonka, only much more irritating. Hoffman is the title character, a hyperactive cartoon of a man who grates fiercely on the nerves from his very first scene. Both he and Natalie Portman must have had severe muscle aches from the amount of forced smiling they had to do, and the shop itself is a nightmarish clash of garish colours and CGI creatures. The movie has its heart in the right place, but like the director himself has said, it€™s a train wreck not even Dustin Hoffman could save. What are some of your favourite Dustin Hoffman performances? Do you disagree with any of the choices on this list? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Handsome. Charismatic. Intelligent. Noble. Witty. I'm none of these things, but I'm a half decent writer, I guess.