Encanto Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs

Another gorgeous winner from Disney.

Encanto Disney
Disney

After audiences were deprived of a Walt Disney Animation Studios release last year, 2021 has seemingly made up for it with the one-two punch of Raya and the Last Dragon and, now, Encanto.

Given the hot streak of quality pictures Disney's in-house animation wing has been on in recent years, it shouldn't surprise anyone that their latest, the studio's 60th animated feature to date, is another strong effort fit for kids and adults alike.

While falling slightly short of Disney classic status, Encanto is a rich stylistic feast of a movie packed to the gills with toe-tapping tunes and touting an intriguing cultural specificity.

It's difficult to imagine many being left disappointed by what is another highly respectable, visually gorgeous entry into Disney's animated canon.

Though this is absolutely a film worth marveling at on the big screen if circumstances allow, it's also set to release globally on Disney+ on Christmas Eve, so if you'd prefer to watch it at home you certainly haven't got long to wait.

With all that in mind, first here's where Encanto comes up a little shy of greatness...


Downs...

3. The Sometimes Clunky Story

Encanto Disney
Disney

While it seems like Disney has basically mastered the marriage of humanist themes with magical hooey by this point, that is probably Encanto's weak suit overall.

The frantic opening sequence delivers a rushed introduction to the Madrigal family and the magical house which grants them their diverse array of superpowers, the filmmakers basically telling us not to sweat the finer details of the internal logic because, apparently, it doesn't really matter.

The script never lays out a clear set of rules for the family's powers or the presence of the magic house - you really just have to roll with it and accept that it's a foundation on which the emotional familial story is told.

While the narrative admirably avoids Disney tropes in a number of ways, there are also times where it lurches from one revelation to the next in slightly clunky fashion, in large part because these supernatural affectations don't always cohere with the more relatable generational story.

It's certainly not bad, but compared to the film's other spectacular elements the beat-by-beat story is fairly surface-level and straight-forward.


2. The Thin Supporting Characters

Encanto Disney
Disney

Encanto boasts a large and enticing supporting cast of characters, what with the Madrigals basically being presented as a family of superheroes each with their own unique magical powers.

This includes the super-strong Luisa (Jessica Darrow), to Isabela (Diane Guerrero) who can make flowers bloom anywhere, and protagonist Mirabel's (Stephanie Beatriz) mother Julieta (Angie Cepeda) who can heal injuries with her cooking.

It's a fun setup, and yet the majority of the supporting characters are only thinly drawn sketches, most of whom aren't much defined outside of their wacky superpowers.

Considering that the emotional spine of Mirabel's journey is about learning to not be defined by her specialness - or lack thereof, it seems - it's a shame that most of the surrounding family members feel a little on the two-dimensional side.

It's not like the film is excessively overlong at 99 minutes, so throwing in a few more character development scenes for the Madrigals would've absolutely been to the movie's narrative benefit.


1. The Massively Rushed Ending

Encanto Disney
Disney

Though Encanto maintains a calm, confident canter for the most part, it needlessly rushes through the emotional climax, such that audiences might feel a little short-changed by it.

Without going into detail, the movie's ending is hinged on several impactful revelations and one major reconcilliation, and yet the later is speeded through with such dispassionate efficiency that it doesn't land nearly as affectingly as it could have.

It feels like we needed a little more to really cement what was happening to the characters, and so as presented here it just feels a bit too easy and tidy for a situation filled with complicated emotions and perspectives.

Given that much of the ending is hinged around one of the movie's more under-served characters overall - Mirabel's estranged uncle Bruno (John Leguizamo) - it's a shame that the enormity of his situation wasn't milked for a few more scenes as it easily could have been.

These gripes aside, though, there's a lot to love about Encanto. Here's what it gets right...


Ups...

7. The INCREDIBLE Animation

Encanto Disney
Disney

Even when the story doesn't reach its full potential, basically everyone will agree that Encanto is one of the most visually stunning animated films Disney has ever produced.

From first minute to last, this is an absolutely lush feast of a film, making the sure most of its exotic setting by ensuring practically every frame of the film is awash in vibrant colours.

Beyond that, the characters are wonderfully expressive, and the environments - particularly the river near the Madrigals' home - look startlingly photorealistic at times.

If there's any one reason to watch Encanto on the big screen as opposed to on Disney+ in a month, it's the eye-wateringly beautiful visuals, which are some of the most breathtaking of any animated film released in recent years.


6. It Tackles Mature, Ambitious Themes

Encanto Disney
Disney

While Encanto is focused on the broad theme of family as most all Disney movies are, it goes much further than that and examines it through the specific lens of Colombia's cultural past.

The dramatic crux of the story is centered around generational trauma, and how a victim can become blinded by their anguish and inadvertantly inflict that pain upon their descendents.

It's certainly a heavy and unexpectedly ambitious theme for a cute and colourful Disney animation of all things to tackle, and while hardly a deep-dive meditation on the subject, adds depth and shade to what could so easily have been a simple crowd-pleasing story about a magical family.

As the stories Disney tells continue to become more diverse, it makes sense that they tackle throughlines which have been generally under-explored by filmmakers to date. This is an encouraging step in the right direction to that end.


5. Lin-Manuel Miranda's Catchy Songs

Encanto Disney
Disney

While Encanto's best original songs probably won't end up as iconic bangers on the level of Disney's finest, this is another solid effort from songwriter Lin-Manuel Miranda, whose signature creative stamp is all over these catchy tunes.

Picking a single standout is difficult, but some of the stronger tracks include "Surface Pressure" (when Luisa sings about her stress and anxiety), the hilariously self-explanatory "We Don't Talk About Bruno," and the fantastic "Dos Oruguitas," which plays during the film's most emotional sequence.

That's not to ignore the sublime bookending earworms "The Family Madrigal" and "Colombia, Mi Encanto," ensuring the soundtrack boasts a diverse mix of breezy toe-tappers and more thoughtful songs.

It's easy to imagine any of these songs ending up with a Best Original Song Oscar nomination next year, really.


4. The Refreshing Lack Of A Villain

Encanto Disney
Disney

So firmly regimented are the conventions of the Disney movie formula that it's a genuine surprise that Encanto doesn't actually have a central villain to speak of.

A film less confident in its vision would have made quirky uncle Bruno the surprise baddie or thrown some mysterious supernatural evil into the mix in the third act, but mercifully neither ends up happening.

That's because Encanto isn't a film about vanquishing a foe - it's a film about learning from a traumatic past and opening your heart to embrace differences.

As such, despite lacking an outright antagonist Encanto isn't a film that wants for conflict, as all that dramatic friction is contained within a family unit whose differing perspectives are completely understandable, if not relatable.

Honestly, it'd be great to see more Disney movies go this route in the future, because an emotional internal conflict free of silly magical fights and convoluted misunderstandings can be so, so much more satisfying.


3. The Fantastic Voice Cast

Encanto Disney
Disney

Shocking not a single person is the fact that Encanto is another Disney movie with a fantastic voice cast.

Brooklyn Nine-Nine's Stephanie Beatriz gives a soulful and thoroughly expressive performance as Mirabel, who frankly couldn't sound much less like Brooklyn's Rosa Diaz if she tried. Her singing voice also packs a mighty punch, too.

Elsewhere we have John Leguizamo, who as Bruno isn't in the movie all that much, though is perfectly cast to inject some madcap energy into the story just when it needs it.

Then there's Orange Is the New Black and Doom Patrol's Diane Guerrero, who is an inspired casting pick for Mirabel's "perfect," prissy sister Isabela, and perhaps best of all MarĂ­a Cecilia Botero as the Madrigal family's matriarch Abuela Alma.

Given that Alma's tragic past is the lynchpin of the entire story, it's absolutely vital that Botero brings a gravity and truth to it, and she absolutely rises to the occasion.


2. It Avoids A Few Disney Movie Cliches

Encanto Disney
Disney

Outside of the very best Disney animations, they have a tendency to be well-crafted comfort food that don't shade much outside of the established lines - you know what you're going to get, and that's basically fine.

Encanto is a little different, though. Sure, it's not entirely free of the Disney formula, but between its aforementioned lack of a villain and some creative calls made in the third act, this isn't quite the totally predictable, sentimentally over-indulgent story it could've been.

It would've been so easy for screenwriters Jared Bush and Charise Castro Smith to just swing for a "have your cake and eat it" ending that does everything for every character, but instead Encanto demonstrates restraint and is in turn all the more satisfying as a result.

It sure would be nice to see Disney take the less-traveled dramatic path a little more often in future.


1. It's Probably Going To Win A Deserved Best Animated Film Oscar

Encanto Disney
Disney

While the Oscars are still many months away, you can probably make a pretty safe bet now that Encanto will end up winning the Best Animated Film Oscar.

Though it certainly faces competition from Pixar's Luca and Netflix's The Mitchells vs. The Machines, given that Luca's reception was more broadly positive and released much earlier in the year, its chances don't feel quite so hot.

As terrific as The Mitchells vs. The Machines is, the typical Netflix bias combined with the film's more hyperactive style will ensure older Oscar voters won't be quite so charmed by it.

Encanto conversely ticks all the awards-friendly boxes yet without being a soulless, hollow piece of work - it's a beautiful movie that's teeming with great ideas even if not everything totally works.

It's difficult to imagine the Academy not rewarding it next year, basically.


In this post: 
Disney
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.