Eric Bana: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Australia's forgotten leading man...

Jerry Bruckheimer FilmsJerry Bruckheimer FilmsToday sees the Stateside release of Deliver Us From Evil, a new horror-thriller which sees Eric Bana returning to prominence. Directed by Scott Derrickman, who helmed Sinister and the remake of The Day The Earth Stood Still, the film stars Bana as Ralph Sarchie, a New York street cop who is drawn into a case with renegade priest Mendoza (Edgar Ramirez). Ostensibly a man of no religious belief, Sarchie is forced to confront his lack of faith as New York heads for destruction... However well the film ends up faring with critics and audiences, it presents a good opportunity to re-examine Bana's career. Since making his big-screen debut in 1997's The Castle, Bana has slowly built himself a reputation as one of the most consistent yet underrated actors in the business. While he's brushed with mainstream success on several occasions, he's never quite attained the stratospheric levels of fame enjoyed by fellow Aussie exports Hugh Jackman and Hugo Weaving. So, in time-honoured fashion, we're going to give Bana's career the once-over this week, selecting five of his greatest performances and five occasions when he dropped the ball. Bana is so consistent that it's hard to pick out any performance as having 'sucked'; suffice to say, most of these examples are occasions where he fell short but is often not the worst thing about the film. We'll begin our countdown with Bana's recent trip to the final frontier, courtesy of a certain Mr. Abrams...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Nero - Star Trek (2009)

Paramount PicturesParamount PicturesIt's very popular to hate on J. J. Abrams' rebooted Star Trek franchise. Star Trek Into Darkness angered fans for being essentially a bad re-write of The Wrath of Khan, and the announcement that Roberto Orci will be directing the third film didn't exactly inspire much confidence. But whatever your views on Abrams as he embarks on Star Wars Episode VII, there were a few things about the first new Trek film that were good - and one of them was Bana's turn as the villain. In case you need reminding, Star Trek completely reboots Gene Roddenberry's franchise after the Next Generation cast ground to a halt in Nemesis. Beginning in the year 2233, James T. Kirk (Chris Pine) is born in flames as his father George's ship, the Kelvin, is destroyed by the Romulan commander Nero (Bana). Twenty-two years later, the young tearaway is advised to join the Starfleet Academy, where he encounters the young Vulcan Spock (Zachary Quinto), the cynical Dr. Leonard McCoy (Karl Urban) and a host of other characters who will eventually form the crew of the USS Enterprise. While the jury is still out as to whether it constitutes a proper Trek film, Star Trek is a very enjoyable experience which succeeds in introducing to a new audience the characters and institutions that hardcore fans have loved for decades. Bana may not have enjoyed the same fame that Benedict Cumberbatch earned by playing Khan, but he does make the character feel rounded and avoids disappearing under all the make-up. It's a good solid performance from which to start our countdown - and it's also not the last we'll see of Romulus on this list...

4. Erik Heller - Hanna (2011)

Focus FeaturesFocus FeaturesI talked about Joe Wright quite extensively in my article on Keira Knightley six months ago. Knightley and Wright have collaborated to date three times, all in period dramas: Pride and Prejudice, Atonement and Anna Karenina. But while Knightley seems increasingly content to be typecast in period dramas, Wright has always retained the ability to surprise us - all of which brings us onto Hanna, which reunited him with Saoirse Ronan and brought another good performance out of Bana. Hanna is an action thriller with prominent fairy tale elements which takes place in Finland. Bana plays rogue CIA agent Erik Heller, who has gone into exile with his daughter Hanna (Ronan) and is being hunted by senior CIA officer Marissa Wiegler (Cate Blanchett). Since the age of two, Erik has trained his daughter to be an assassin, and with their enemies beginning to close in he sends her out into the wider world for her own safety. A chase across Europe eventually leads to a woodland confrontration, in which Erik's dark secret is revealed... While not always certain of its generic identity, Hanna is an interesting and memorable effort which includes some of Wright's most eye-catching work. While most of the plaudits have rightfully gone to Ronan, Bana manages to take this most unorthodox of fathers and still imbue him with a lot of believable emotion. Rather than play up his unusual circumstances, like the parents in the Spy Kids series, he dials everything down and lets his rapid delivery do the talking. This makes his more active scenes all the more memorable, with the subway fight being one of the best-shot fight scenes in the last 10 years.

3. Romulus - Romulus, My Father (2007)

Dendy FilmsDendy FilmsOne of the things that can fill a film buff with dread is when actors turn their hand to directing. As good as many actors are, they don't always have enough discipline and a good enough grasp of visual storytelling to do a project justice, resulting in talky, mopey pieces like We Don't Live Here Anymore. But as with everything in filmmaking, there are exceptions to this rule, and one such exception is the sadly all-too-little-seen Romulus, My Father. Directed by Richard Roxburgh (the Duke in Moulin Rouge!), Romulus, My Father is an all-Australian production based on the memoir of the same name by Raimond Gaita. It depicts the troubled early life of the author (Kodi Smit-McPhee from The Road), who emigrates to Australia from his native Romania after World War II with his father Romulus (Bana) and mother Christine (Franke Potente - Run, Lola, Run). The family soon begins to disintegrate as Christine moves in with another man and Romulus' mental health takes a turn for the worse - all of which leaves Raimond trying to hold things together. While it's not always the most cinematic offering, Roxburgh's directorial debut achieves a good balance of darkness and light, resulting in a poignant and ultimately uplifting piece. Bana has great chemistry with Smit-McPhee, carrying off the accent and managing to summon up huge quantities of frustration and heartache which eventually eat away at his calm exterior. If you enjoyed Colin Farrell's recent performance as the alcoholic father in Saving Mr. Banks, you'll find a lot to like in Bana's performance here, which is a more independently-spirited examination of a similar decline.

2. Avner Kaufman - Munich (2005)

UniversalUniversalIn 2005 Steven Spielberg released two very different films, which represent the two opposing aspects of his career. One was his take on War of the Worlds, which used its blockbuster spectacle and gloomy visuals to make a well-developed point about the aftermath of 9/11. The other was Munich, an historical drama which was so obsessed with being balanced that it got bogged down dramatically. But while Munich is the weaker film, it does have one big saving grace: Bana's performance. Munich takes place in the aftermath of the 1972 Olympics, at which 11 Israeli athletes were kidnapped and eventually murdered by the Palestinian terror group Black September. After news breaks of the athletes' death, Mossad (the Israeli secret service) begins Operation Wrath of God, sending in German-Jewish agent and assassin Avner Kaufman (Bana) to hunt down and kill all individuals believed to have been involved in the massacre. During the mission Avner questions the morality of what he is doing, eventually becoming disillusioned about both the mission and his superiors. While Munich is presented with the very best intentions, it's far too preoccupied with not taking a side to really dive deep into its subject matter. It's a very safe, mediocre thriller, albeit one with good production values and a good leading role for Bana. He makes the best of an occasionally trite script, and convincingly portrays a man whose clinical commitment to his country is gradually broken down by his own personal circumstances. While the film as a whole is a bit of a slog, it's worth it for every second that Bana is on screen, with the phone call to his baby daughter being a highlight.

1. Mark 'Chopper' Read - Chopper (2000)

First Look PicturesFirst Look PicturesBack in 2009, a then-unknown Tom Hardy appeared in Bronson, Nicolas Winding Refn's electrifying drama about notorious prisoner Michael Gordon Peterson. The film drew widespread critical acclaim and gave Hardy a springboard, from which he would go on to become a mainstream star in the likes of Inception and Warrior. Nine years before Bronson, a similar fate befell Bana when he took on the title role in Chopper. It's the role which made the world take the former comedian seriously as an actor, and it remains his finest performance. Chopper is based on the autobiographical accounts of real-life prisoner Mark 'Chopper' Read. Having been in and out of jail since the age of 16, Chopper begins the film serving a 16-year sentence for kidnapping a judge in an attempt to extort his friend's release from Pentridge Prison. Upon being released from jail in 1986 (after losing both his ears), he goes on a violent rampage against friends and enemies alike, eventually ending up back in jail and writing a bestselling book about his life in Melbourne's underworld. Chopper is the debut feature of Andrew Dominik, who went on to helm the brilliant Killing Them Softly and The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford. Each of his three films to date explore the brutal repurcussions of violence and how criminality can corrupt individuals beyond recognition, and Bana conveys this corruption with extraordinary panache. Read suggested Bana for the role having seen him on the sketch show Full Frontal, and Bana completely throws himself into the part, transforming his physical appearance and going so far as to live with Read for two days so he could better mimic his behaviour. The highest praise of all, however, came from Roger Ebert, who said quite rightly in his review: "He has a quality no acting school can teach and few actors can match." Having seen Bana at his absolute best, now let's move into choppier waters and look at some of his weakest work...

And 5 That Sucked...

5. King Henry VIII - The Other Boleyn Girl (2008)

Sony PicturesSony PicturesNon-British actors have a very bad record when it comes to pulling off a British accent of any kind. Examples range from Dick Van Dyke's infamous turn in Mary Poppins to Keanu Reeves' dismal performance as Harker in Francis Ford Coppola's Dracula. Bana's attempts at playing one of the most (im)famous British kings has tended to slip below the radar, much like the film as a whole. But lack of public outcry is no excuse for leaving this example off the list. Based on the popular novel by Phillipa Gregory, The Other Boleyn Girl is a romanticised account of the lives of Anne Boleyn (Natalie Portman) and her sister Mary (Scarlet Johanssen). With the marriage of King Henry VIII (Bana) and Catherine of Aragon (Ana Torrent) failing to produce a male heir, the Boleyn family plot to install their eldest daughter Anne as the King's mistress. But during a visit to the Boleyn estate, Henry is injured in a hunting accident and takes a liking to Mary. So begins a series of events while will lead to the creation of the Church of England and Anne gaining the throne, only to lose her head. The Other Boleyn Girl is a frothy and melodramatic affair which seems more interested in its pretty trappings than political intrigue and the role of women in Tudor society. Despite boasting a script by Peter Morgan (Rush, Frost/Nixon), it's strangely devoid of tension with all three main performers seeming uneasy in their given roles. Bana is particularly inert, barely managing the accent and either brooding or shouting through all of his dlalogue. He has none of the boyish charm and fearsome rage that Robert Shaw provided in A Man For All Seasons, which is a far superior look at the monarch's tumultuous reign.

4. Bruce Banner/ Hulk - Hulk (2003)

UniversalUniversalThe casting of Eric Bana as Bruce Banner may sound like the lead-in to an Abbott and Costello routine, but back in 2003 it was big news. After years of associating the Incredible Hulk with silly green rubber suits, the new live-action adaptation promised a serious treatment of the character, and was a chance for Ang Lee to break into the mainstream after his Oscar win for Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. Had things turned out differently, Bana might now be in The Avengers where Mark Ruffalo stands, but instead the film was a disappointment that did him no favours as an actor. In case you need reminding, Hulk revolves around scientist Bruce Banner (Bana), whose experiments involving nanomeds and gamma radiation bring him to the attention of the US military. Through a glitch in a lab computer, Banner is exposed to both radiation and the nanomeds, causing his DNA to mutate. Soon he receives a visit from his father (Nick Nolte), who experimented on Banner as a child, and who warns him to control his temper. Suffice to say, he doesn't, and transforms into the Hulk, endangering his former sweetheart Betty (Jennifer Connelly) and putting the world at risk. While Lee deserves praise for trying to emphasise character development over non-stop pyrotechnics, Hulk remains a curiously ponderous outing. Bana does his best as Bruce, but he seems ill at ease with Lee's direction, and like many actors in action movies he looks far too glamorous to pass off as a scientist. He's equally ill at ease when it comes to the special effects, with whatever nuances he brings to the Hulk failing to be carried over in the poor CGI. While the film still has many defenders, it's clearly not Bana's finest hour.

3. Henry DeTamble - The Time Traveler's Wife (2009)

New Line CinemaNew Line CinemaBack in May 2013, I wrote an article for WhatCulture.com in which I selected my top ten favourite films about time travel. Many of the films I included had a prominent romantic element, with Slaughterhouse-Five, Source Code and Twelve Monkeys all getting a look-in. But just because these films married sci-fi and romance so adeptly doesn't mean that putting the two together is always a recipe for success. On that note, I give you The Time Traveler's Wife. Based on the award-winning novel by Audrey Niffenegger, The Time Traveler's Wife revolves around the unusual relationship between Chicago librarian Henry DeTamble (Bana) and his eventual wife Claire (Rachel McAdams). Henry has a genetic disorder which causes him to involuntarily time travel, beginning in the 1970s when he saves another version of himself from dying in a car accident. He develops a relationship with Claire, appearing to her at different periods in her life and eventually attempts to marry her and have a child. Niffenegger's book was considered unfilmable by several critics, and to a certain extent this adaptation proves that they were right. Director Robert Schwentke (Red, Flightplan) feels out of his depth in overly romantic fare, and Bana's performance is very flat and uninteresting. Seeing his character development out of order would have been fine, but Bana gives no indication that he understands the character in the first place. If you want to see this kind of relationship played out properly, go and watch all the River Song episodes in Doctor Who. Steven Moffat has admitted being influenced by Niffenegger, and these episodes are a much better treatment of the story.

2. Martin Rose - Closed Circuit (2013)

Universal PicturesUniversal PicturesThere have been numerous thrillers in recent years which have attempted to cash in on our surveillance culture. We had Vantage Point, which tried (and ultimately failed) to recreate Rashamon around the attempted assassination of the US President. We had Body of Lies, Ridley Scott's underwhelming spy film about the CIA's attempt to apprehend an enemy agent in Iraq. And now we have Closed Circuit, a film which says a lot less about surveillance than it thinks it does and which finds Bana decidedly miscast. Closed Circuit stars Bana as Martin Rose, a British barrister who is selected alongside his ex-lover Claudia Simmons-Howe (Rebecca Hall) to defend Farroukh Erdogan (Dennis Moschitto). Farroukh is suspected of orchestrating a terrorist attack which destroyed a busy London market; the trial involves large amounts of classified information, with even the defending barristers being kept in the dark on certain details. As the former lovers begin to dig around, they uncover a murky cover-up operation involving MI5, double agents and attempted assassinations. In the hands of someone like Roman Polanski, Closed Circuit could have made a great deal more of this set-up, making its Chinatown-like conspiracy of silence all the more labyrinthine and harrowing. Instead, it feels like a strange and uncomfortable cross between Homeland and Judge John Deed, with limp direction from John Crowley and somewhat televisual production values. Bana is between a rock and a hard place, not knowing whether to keep his character refined and controlled or to play on the rising sense of panic brought on by his actions. The result is another flat and confusing performance which goes some way to undermining what tension remains.

1. Huck Cheever - Lucky You (2007)

Warner Bros.Warner Bros.There are a handful of really good films which are either about poker or which involve poker to a large extent. The Sting has all the tricks and double-dealing; Casino Royale has plenty of tension; Croupier is a very underrated British thriller; and Rounders finds a young Matt Damon showing us just how good he is. There are, however, an equal number of poker films which are flimsy and boring, including The Cincinnati Kid, 21 and Lucky You. Lucky You is directed by Curtis Hanson, who previously helmed 8 Mile and the Oscar-winning L. A. Confidential. It stars Bana as Huck Greever, an overly competitive poker player who is trying to win enough money to get a seat at the World Series of Poker Main Event. One night at a party he meets aspiring singer Billie Offer (Drew Barrymore), and the pair start dating despite warnings from Billie's older sister (Debra Messing). The rest of the film sees the pair fall in and out of love as Greever comes closer to his dream, along with a sub-plot about his estranged father (Robert Duvall) Lucky You is a bland and syrupy offering which demonstrates just how far Hanson's career has fallen. The poker scenes are shot without any real energy or dexterity, and everything either side is as formulaic as a Meg Ryan chick flick. Having turned in many performances where he seemed confused, uncertain or just plain miscast, Bana commits the cardinal sin here of being boring. He's neither suave and appealing enough to make us genuinely take an interest in him, nor sleazy enough to have any kind of bad boy appeal. For an actor renowned for his energy and commitment in his best work, this is a damning indictment, and it remains the lowest ebb of his career. Disagree with my choices? Drop me a comment or visit Mumby at the Movies for more reviews.

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance copywriter, film buff, community radio presenter. Former host of The Movie Hour podcast (http://www.lionheartradio.com/ and click 'Interviews'), currently presenting on Phonic FM in Exeter (http://www.phonic.fm/). Other loves include theatre, music and test cricket.