Every Batman Movie Ranked From Worst To Best

How does The Batman stack up?

Batman and Robin The Dark Knight The Batman
Warner Bros.

There are of course few superheroes more popular or inherently cinematic than Batman, whose tendency to prowl around punching criminals at night has made him an alluring figure for filmmakers and audiences alike over the last few decades.

Though Batman's first major theatrical film was 1966's Batman: The Movie, the Caped Crusader wasn't truly outed as a mega-budget commercial entity until Tim Burton's ground-breaking 1989 blockbuster, cementing the character as an immovable Hollywood mainstay.

To date Batman has starred in twelve major theatrical films - not including cameos or ensemble appearances - yet there's no denying that Bats' cinematic tenure has been defined by its share of ups and downs.

The superhero has been reinvented on the big screen screen more than just about any other, continually being re-shaped as a reaction to how the prior portrayal of the character has been received.

And so, how do Batman's various cinematic forays shake out? There are some obvious fan favourites and one near-universally despised Batman film, but in-between there's a lot of room for debate.

And of course, where exactly does Matt Reeves' The Batman land? It's time to find out...

12. Batman & Robin

Batman And Robin
Warner Bros. Pictures

You won't find many willing to argue the toss on this one - Joel Schumacher's follow-up to the divisive Batman Forever was a Razzie-winning critical and commercial failure.

Where to even start? George Clooney may be a great actor, but an inspired replacement for Val Kilmer he wasn't, and Alicia Silverstone's casting as Batgirl similarly felt like a cynical calculation above all else.

In an effort to appeal to children and sell as many action figures as possible, Batman & Robin cranks the saturation knob past breaking point, along with an overdose of camp and outrageous homoeroticism.

Arnold Schwarzenegger and Uma Thurman give more knowing, fun performances as villains Mr. Freeze and Poison Ivy, but a toilet paper-worthy script from future Oscar-winner (!) Akiva Goldsman renders so much of the runtime shockingly boring.

To make such an energetic, colourful film so dull takes concerted effort - Schumacher was channelling all of his energies in the wrong direction here, and the result is a film as fascinating as it is terrible.

On the plus side, without Batman & Robin's failure Warner Bros. wouldn't have greenlit Christopher Nolan's gritty reimagining, Batman Begins. A necessary evil it is, then.


11. Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice

Batman V Superman
Warner Bros.

Batman v Superman was the massively anticipated big-screen slug-fest between Ben Affleck's new iteration of the Caped Crusader and Henry Cavill's mopey Man of Steel.

On paper this seemed pretty tough to screw up, and yet Zack Snyder's operatic, visually stunning spectacle collapses under the weight of its bloated, convoluted storytelling and the simple fact that there's precious little Batman v Superman to speak of.

The machinations that set the titular fight in motion - at the behest of a scheming Lex Luthor (Jesse Eisenberg) - are such a stretch you can practically hear the film itself straining if you listen closely.

The brief mid-movie battle itself is fun for a moment, but once Batman hears the name Martha, it's all over.

Predictably, the rest of the film is concerned with the pair teaming up to stop Luthor and his CGI abomination Doomsday, with a fan-serving cameo from Wonder Woman (Gal Gadot) thrown in to boot.

Though the Ultimate Edition of the movie is certainly an improvement (if also longer), Batman v Superman needlessly complicates a basic concept with its tiresome, over-egged script.

Affleck is fantastic as Batman and the film's easy highlight, even if seeing the Dark Knight flat-out murder criminals left many fans feeling queasy.


10. Batman Forever

Batman Forever Val Kilmer
Warner Bros.

There's perhaps no more divisive Batman movie than this - for many its elevated aesthetic and more child-friendly pivot from the gothic darkness of Batman Returns was just too much, while others praised Joel Schumacher's stylised maximalism and its solid cast.

Batman Forever is an unmistakably jarring sit following on from Batman Returns, but its psychological approach to Bruce Wayne as a character - played here by Val Kilmer, admittedly no match for Michael Keaton - and Jim Carrey's mile-a-second performance as The Riddler make it well worth the price of admission.

It's certainly a corporate Product of a movie rather than a slice of blockbuster art and suffers from all the compromises that suggests, but its striking neon-soaked aesthetic and enthusiastic zaniness make it tough to dismiss out of hand.


9. Batman: The Movie

Batman 1966
Twentieth Century-Fox

Though the Adam West Batman era is often perceived as an object of ridicule by modern audiences, it's important to remember that it was totally in on the joke.

1966's Batman: The Movie couldn't have its tongue lodged any further in its cheek without burrowing through: this is a shamelessly campy farce of a superhero movie, and one that's tremendously entertaining every step of the way.

Adam West and Burt Ward are again fantastic in the roles of Batman and Robin, even if the show is categorically stolen by the bevy of villains - The Joker (Cesar Romero), The Penguin (Burgess Meredith), The Riddler (Frank Gorshin), and Catwoman (Lee Meriwether).

This is a film where Batman battles a shark with bat-shark repellent and runs down a pier with an oversized bomb - to sneer at it for being silly and earnest is really to miss the point.

It may seem like a dusty relic in our more cynical, nihilistic present, but accepted within its own context it holds up extremely well.


8. The Lego Batman Movie

The Lego Batman Movie   Batcave Teaser Trailer Screen Shot  H 2016
cdn3.thr.com

If 2017's The Lego Batman Movie quickly came and went without making much of a pop-culture impact - despite netting an impressive $300 million worldwide - that's no real indicator of its quality.

Following The Lego Movie's irreverent, visually creative lead, this Bat-centric spin-off manages to be a love-letter to both the titular building blocks and the Caped Crusader without feeling like a totally crass branding exercise.

Will Arnett is again terrific as his firmly parodical take on Batman and Zack Galifianakis kills it as The Joker, but what really makes the movie sing is its clear, unabashed fondness for just about every era and iteration of Batman - yes, even the Schumacher years.

It's never above ribbing even the better Batman films, and manages to incorporate an assortment of other pop-culture characters without ever becoming a tireless exercise in nostalgia-bait.

Given the sheer volume of visual details crammed into every single frame - including a pile of smart Easter eggs - repeat viewings are basically mandatory.


7. Batman: Mask Of The Phantasm

Batman Mask Of The Phantasm Joker
Warner Bros.

While at the time of its release Batman: Mask Of The Phantasm wasn't given much attention - in part due to Warner Bros. deciding to release it theatrically at the last minute - it went on to become a cult classic once it hit home video.

Despite clocking in at a lean 78 minutes - basically half the length of a Christopher Nolan Batman movie - Mask of the Phantasm remains one of the most deft and richest character-driven stories in the Dark Knight's cinematic oeuvre.

Much like the animated series it spawned from, the art direction is gorgeous throughout, and matched by mesmeric vocal performances from Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill as Batman and The Joker respectively.

If some might dismiss it as not being a "proper" Batman film because it's not live-action, they're missing out on what was the most purely comic-faithful Batman movie until Batman Begins came along.


6. Batman (1989)

Batman 1989
Warner Bros.

The importance of Tim Burton's 1989 Batman cannot be denied - it forced Hollywood to accept the big-screen viability of comic books, even if the 1990s were admittedly crammed with lazy cash-ins to that effect.

Even so, Batman '89 remains a towering example of how to capture the essence of a character even if it not nailing all the details.

Yes, Batman flippantly kills the bad guys, and the decision to make The Joker the murderer of Bruce Wayne's parents is a little too extra for its own good, but Burton otherwise gets so, so much right.

For starters, this is a lavishly handsome picture in every moment, Burton putting his love for German expressionism to good use with Gotham's angular cityscape, while set to Danny Elfman's indelible musical score.

Michael Keaton, a widely-protested casting choice at the time, is a revelation as both Bruce and Bats, arguably nailing the outright weirdness of Bruce Wayne better than any other actor.

Jack Nicholson is of course an all-timer hoot as The Joker, committing fully to even the more divisive aspects of Burton's film - that is, those incongruous Prince songs.

It may be imperfect, but Burton's original Batman proved the large-scale appeal of one of pop-culture's most enduring superheroes.


5. Batman Returns

Batman Returns Catwoman
Warner Bros.

Batman Returns does what most great sequels do - it goes bigger and swings harder than what came before, even if Burton's madcap vision certainly alienated those expecting a more child-friendly superhero film.

Ambition drips from every pore of Burton's deeply strange sequel, which reconciles the inherent, unerring goofiness of villains like Catwoman (Michelle Pfeiffer) and The Penguin (Danny DeVito) by basically positioning them as horror movie characters.

Grotesquery runs rampant throughout Batman Returns as does an intense, burning sexuality: this is by far the horniest Batman film ever made, best elicited by the red-hot chemistry between Pfeiffer's Catwoman and Keaton's Batman.

Though Keaton is once again fantastic as the Bat, the show is categorically stolen by Pfeiffer and DeVito, who deliver a dimensional anti-hero and tragic villain respectively.

That such a bold, boundary-pushing superhero movie was made 30 years ago remains absolutely mind-boggling, though its resulting commercial under-performance is ultimately what led to the lesser, more colourful Batman Forever and Batman & Robin.


4. The Dark Knight Rises

The Dark Knight Rises Batman
Warner Bros.

If you buy into the online hyperbole, then The Dark Knight Rises is a sacreligious finale to Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Saga, rather than a flawed but mesmerising mega-budget blockbuster.

Given the rather credibility-straining particulars of the script - namely John Blake (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) learning Batman's identity and Bane (Tom Hardy) trapping the entire GCPD underground - it's clear that Nolan is far more interested in bombastic narrative heft than outright realism this time around.

But if you can accept some of its sillier plot points, The Dark Knight Rises is an evocative epic about a Bruce Wayne desperate to be Batman no more, but who dons the cape and cowl one last time to liberate Gotham.

Intoxicatingly operatic from its opening introduction to Bane all the way through to its fist-pumping finale, it's certainly not Nolan's strongest work in the franchise, but picks up The Dark Knight's impossibly weighty mantle with literary gusto.


3. The Batman

the batman
Warner Bros.

Matt Reeves' The Batman finds a unique, deeply compelling niche for itself in the pantheon of Batman movies - in some respects bleaker and more "realistic" than Christopher Nolan's films, but in others keener to indulge the pulpier comic book aspects of the character's lore.

While many will understandably gripe with its epic three-hour runtime and almost relentlessly downcast tone, this is a mighty origin story for this new Batman (Robert Pattinson), assembled with mesmerising skill by Reeves and performed with grungy aplomb by Robert Pattinson.

Though unlikely to become the pop-culture monolith that Nolan's films were, the film's willingness to push its PG-13 rating to the limit and engage with some extremely ugly aspects of human nature is to be commended.

It's easy to see this becoming many fans' favourite Batman movie, even if when taking a step back it doesn't quite boast the razzle-dazzle and genre-redefining inventiveness of the better two films in Nolan's trilogy.


2. Batman Begins

Batman Begins
Warner Bros.

It's easy to take Batman Begins for granted almost 20 years after its release, but there's no overstating the breath of fresh air that Nolan's gritty franchise reboot was back in 2005.

Paradoxically "back to basics" and yet infinitely more robust and complex than any Batman film before it, Nolan delivered a stridently "realistic" take on the Caped Crusader that eschewed heavily stylised art direction and VFX in favour of a more grounded, psychologically-powered Batman movie.

The result is basically the blueprint for a superhero origin story, which capably onboards newbies while delivering nourishment for long-time fans of the franchise.

Christian Bale is excellent as both Bruce and Batman, Michael Caine matches him as Alfred, the action sequences are magnificent, and Nolan strikes a tone that's just serious enough without forgetting to be humorous.

The only major ding against it is the sometimes choppy editing during action scenes, though Nolan thankfully never repeated this issue in either of his sequels.


1. The Dark Knight

The Dark Knight Bike
Warner Bros.

The Dark Knight remains one of the most singular and influential achievements in both superhero movies and blockbuster cinema as a whole - a theoretically ridiculous tentpole film that convincingly styled itself as an elevated crime thriller in the vein of Heat or The Departed.

For all of its jaw-dropping action sequences - most of them achieved with minimal VFX - the most slyly impressive aspect of The Dark Knight might well be Nolan's masterful tonal control.

Despite revolving around a clown-faced terrorist who does battle with a billionaire who dresses up as a bat, the audience is urged to take all of this seriously, and rooted in such a recognisable urban aesthetic, it totally works.

Heath Ledger's Oscar-winning portrayal of The Joker of course speaks for itself, though basically everybody's fantastic here - especially Aaron Eckhart as Harvey Dent/Two-Face, who doesn't get nearly enough credit.

It's with good reason that so many countless blockbusters have attempted to ape the movie's style in the 15-ish years since - even James Bond did it in Skyfall - because Nolan so ingeniously split the difference between high-wire popcorn thrills and deep-dish character-driven storytelling.

It's nigh-on impossible to consider the sort of Batman movie that could decisively unseat something so brilliant.


In this post: 
The Batman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.