Every DCEU Film Ranked From Worst To Best

From Man of Steel to The Suicide Squad, which DCEU film stands out as the best?

Wonder Woman 2017
Warner Bros.

Few franchises have been more inconsistent than the DCEU.

There have been some absolute stinkers in Warner Bros.' infamously troubled cinematic universe, but some of the other films have been far better, and this series also contains some of the most interesting and unique superhero films of the last ten years.

Looking behind the scenes, this inconsistency isn't exactly surprising. After all, these films have generally had a very talented group of people behind the camera and in front of it, meaning they've had plenty of great stuff in them, but hit-or-miss screenplays and studio interference have also held the various instalments back.

In this sense, the inconsistency of the DCEU is understandable, but that doesn't make it any less jarring.

With the eagerly-anticipated The Suicide Squad finally out, it's a great time to rank the DCEU films and see how they stack up. So, which one is the very best? And which is the worst? One thing's for sure: when you rank these films, you really do cross a chasm of quality between spots eleven and one...

11. Suicide Squad

Suicide Squad
Warner Bros. Pictures

Suicide Squad is a shockingly bad movie and there really is little benefit to this one beyond its undeservedly excellent cast, who all nobly do their best despite the awful material.

This movie is infuriating on two main levels. Firstly, taken on its own terms, it's a hollow, ugly, badly-edited, plot hole-ridden and abysmally-written mess of an action film with one of the worst finales and worst villains the superhero genre has ever given us.

But secondly, and more importantly, when you consider how much promise this movie seemed to have before its release, the underwhelming final product feels even more painful.

The strong marketing campaign suggested something different, something funnier and something a bit more adult. Instead, we got a PG-13 film that was honestly just a very typical, boring and unexciting cliche-fest that concluded with yet another beam-in-the-sky finale and also reduced the much-hyped new iteration of the Joker to a glorified cameo.

So yes, this is the worst DCEU film so far. Will it ever be knocked off that podium? Well, given that the DCEU has a nasty habit of alternating between successful instalments and duds, never say never.


10. Wonder Woman 1984

Wonder Woman 1984
Warner Bros.

Yikes.

There didn't seem to be any reason to be too sceptical about this one prior to release; after all, the same crew behind the original were all back and the trailers were very solid.

So, when the film arrived and turned out to be a cinematic train-wreck, it was a very nasty surprise, especially since this is one of the only blockbusters that actually came out during 2020.

Where to begin? Both of the villains are beyond cringe-worthy, many interesting ideas are mishandled, that whole body-swap thing was incredibly problematic, the script is a complete mess and perhaps most insultingly of all, there's pretty much nothing in the way of compelling spectacle.

In fact, I think the body-count of this movie might've literally been zero.

And yes, this is worse than Batman v Superman. At least that movie actually had some action. Thanks to strong direction and typically good acting across the board (aside from Pedro Pascal and Kirsten Wiig), it's superior to Suicide Squad but it's still among the worst superhero films of the last ten years.


9. Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice

Batman vs superman
Warner Bros.

It always seemed very likely that this would be a dud and those pre-release predictions were right. This has been a real punching bag over the years for both fans and critics, but what does the film do right?

Well, the performances from Ben Affleck, Henry Cavill and Gal Gadot, as well as (most) of the rest of the cast, are right on-point. Affleck's Batman positively annihilates every other live-action version of the character and Zack Snyder is, as ever, a very strong visual stylist. It's a well-made and occasionally interesting blockbuster, so what's the problem? Pretty much everything else.

The script is mostly terrible, Jesse Eisengerg's Lex Luthor is embarrassingly awful and the whole thing makes for a generally soulless collection of fight scenes that are so full of plot holes it's nigh-on impossible to take seriously.

It's not irredeemable and thanks to Zack Snyder's direction and the generally good acting, it's better than Suicide Squad or WW84. Still, it remains a disappointing film whatever way you cut it.


8. Man Of Steel

Man Of Steel Superman
Warner Bros.

Man of Steel is the definition of a mixed bag.

The film starts off very well with a soulful, well-edited and refreshingly quiet first half that focuses on the people in the story instead of action. This first half comes shockingly close to actually making Superman, who's always been a hard character to feel invested in since he's practically invulnerable, interesting.

Then, around the midway point, the film completely falls apart.

It devolves into a series of painfully overblown action sequences that don't have the slightest semblance of tension, and all the strong work of the first half is buried under the weight of those seemingly endless scenes of characters punching each other through walls.

As well as this, the film's romance is completely chemistry-free and Jonathan Kent's (Kevin Costner) death was just a bit dumb.

While Man of Steel certainly isn't a bad film, it still represents the DCEU at its most frustrating. It's given lift by the excellent cinematography and music, not to mention the solid cast, but the script needed quite a bit of work.


7. Justice League (Theatrical Cut)

Justice League
Warner Bros.

The original cut of Justice League is not a terrible film when taken on its own terms. Set aside all the hellish production troubles and the knowledge that this isn't the film Zack Snyder intended it to be, and Joss Whedon's Justice League is pretty solid.

It's visually stunning and thrilling, it has a sharp score from Danny Elfman, the cast are as good as ever, the team have a nice dynamic and there are even a few good character moments in there too.

Of course, it's also a safe, inconsistent and unadventurous film that doesn't feel like the endgame it should've been, but given just how troubled the film's production was, maybe playing it safe was the way to go.

As it should go without saying, the Snyder Cut is definitely better but the Whedon Cut does a couple of things better than Snyder's version. The humour is far, far better and so is the dynamic between the team; it's also nice that the group actually debate resurrecting Superman in this version, which they didn't in the Snyder Cut.

It's deeply flawed and there's little reason to ever revisit this given that the Snyder Cut is out, but Whedon's Justice League was never a bad movie, just a disappointing one.


6. Birds Of Prey

Birds Of Prey Margot Robbie
Warner Bros.

Birds of Prey is deeply flawed, but it's also pretty awesome in many ways.

Cathy Yan's visually stylish direction is genuinely fantastic, the action sequences are tremendous and the cast is uniformly terrific (although Mary Elizabeth Winstead is underused). Margot Robbie is sublime as Harley Quinn, but it's actually Ewan McGregor, who gives a masterful villainous performance as the sadistic Black Mask (arguably his best screen work since Trainspotting), that steals the entire film.

It's also the DCEU's first R-rated film and while this was risky, it mostly paid off. The film can be quite ugly, but the adult vibe does lend it a nice, brutal punch all the same.

Messy as it is, Birds of Prey is overall a thoroughly entertaining and charismatic superhero flick that largely delivers the goods. It seems to have faced some backlash online but that isn't a fair reflection of the film (and said "backlash" was mostly driven by the film being female-led anyhow).


5. Aquaman

Aquaman Poster
Warner Bros.

Aquaman was one hell of a pleasant surprise. It might be formulaic, predictable and overlong but this movie does actually have quite a bit going for it.

The film is absolutely mesmerising on a technical level; James Wan's direction is legitimately brilliant, the underwater environments are beautifully realised and the film also has some terrific music (bar that dreadful Pitbull cover of Toto's 'Africa', of course).

As well as this, the movie benefits from a largely strong cast, especially Jason Momoa as the title character, although Willem Dafoe is wasted and Patrick Wilson is a little dull as the main villain.

As for the screenplay, while it's got its issues it does still make for a heart-warming story about Aquaman becoming a hero and learning to believe in himself. The world-building is very assured and the central romance is actually good, which is rare for a superhero film.

Flaws and all, Aquaman is very enjoyable and it's not surprising that this rejuvenated the DCEU.


4. Shazam!

Shazam Billy
Warner Bros.

One of the franchise's most critically acclaimed films, Shazam is a supremely effective superhero comedy.

Not only is it a delightful, funny and endlessly charming story of wish-fulfilment with loveable characters and cracking jokes galore, the film is also, crucially, a surprisingly scary, dark and emotional ride.

Thanks to its well written script, Shazam is a remarkable blend of light and dark, which allows it to be a lot of fun without it ever feeling frivolous. The cast (bar Mark Strong, who's uncharacteristically bad as the main villain) is also excellent, with some strikingly talented young actors stealing the entire film away from the adult cast.

It doesn't avoid all of the DCEU's common problems. As with other movies in this franchise, the CGI is inconsistent, it's too long and yet again, the villain sucks. Accusations of a villain problem are still thrown at the Marvel Cinematic Universe but the DCEU has a far, far bigger villain problem than that franchise ever did.

Still, Shazam is a very fun and well-executed film that proved Aquaman was no fluke and that the DCEU's course-correct was still on track.


3. Zack Snyder's Justice League

Justice League
Warner Bros.

The best way to describe Zack Snyder's Justice League is that it's a satisfying and beautiful mess.

It is wildly uneven, the dialogue is inconsistent, not all of its plotlines feel properly structured or developed and it is self-indulgent, but it's also an incredibly interesting and sometimes brilliant four-hour superhero epic.

Not only is it an absolutely stunning work on a technical level (aside from some atrocious CGI), it's filled to the brim with imagination, terrific spectacle and a genuinely fascinating narrative that's full of brilliant ideas and effective emotional beats. In particular, everything to do with Cyborg (Ray Fisher) is superbly done.

Even though not all of the character moments work, the film hits far more often than it misses and culminates in a sensational climax.

Snyder's Justice League might not be a great film, but it's still pretty awesome and it is most certainly an incredibly satisfying and largely triumphant realization of Zack Snyder's original vision for the DCEU.


2. The Suicide Squad

The Suicide Squad
Warner Bros. Pictures

If there's one word to sum up James Gunn's eagerly anticipated sequel it would be... joyous.

It's an utterly hysterical, giddily creative and obscenely enjoyable blast that delivers one subversive, wickedly smart scene after another and never stops coming up with new, unexpected ways to entertain the living daylights out of you.

Ultimately, it culminates in one of the greatest final acts in superhero movie history, thus cementing its status as the DCEU's second great movie (and it's about time).

With his visually stunning direction and beautifully-written script, James Gunn is unquestionably the film's MVP but the fantastic ensemble cast also deserve special praise, for they do absolutely incredible work, especially Idris Elba and Margot Robbie.

The film isn't a complete home run. Peter Capaldi is heavily under-utilised, the film occasionally feels frivolous and the second act sometimes drags, but it compensates many times over for these issues. It ends flawlessly and it does actually have some nice character scenes and some pretty haunting third act reveals, so it's not all style and no substance.

Insane, inventive, messed-up yet beautiful and just delightful all around, The Suicide Squad is arguably 2021's finest blockbuster yet and a triumph for all involved.


1. Wonder Woman

Wonder Woman
Warner Bros.

The Suicide Squad was really, really good, but Wonder Woman remains the crown jewel of the DCEU's line-up.

A dazzling combination of an exhilarating action blockbuster and a heartfelt, surprisingly brilliant character journey for Wonder Woman herself, the movie is a seamless mixture of style and substance that's both viscerally thrilling and emotionally satisfying.

On a technical level the film rocks and it has many smashing set-pieces (although the third act is a little OTT), but it's really taken to the next level by just how well-written it is. The character moments are beautifully-done, the film has the greatest superhero movie love story of all time and even though the finale is too CGI-heavy, the movie still has a wonderfully emotional ending that might move some viewers to tears.

In other words, it's a thrilling blockbuster with real heart and soul, and that's what makes the movie so great.

It's not a five-star film. The villains are pretty weak, some of the CGI is dodgy and there's the occasional jarring tonal shift here and there, but for the most part this is one of the 2010s' finest superhero films, an exemplary superhero origin story, and the DCEU's greatest achievement.


Watch Next


DCEU Quiz: How Well Do You Remember Wonder Woman?

Wonder Woman Justice League
Warner Bros.

1. What Is Wonder Woman's Name?

Contributor

Film Studies graduate, aspiring screenwriter and all-around nerd who, despite being a pretentious cinephile who loves art-house movies, also loves modern blockbusters and would rather watch superhero movies than classic Hollywood films. Once met Tommy Wiseau.