Every Evil Dead Movie Ranked Worst To Best

Which movie did Deadites, The Necronomicon and ungodly violence best?!

Evil Dead
New Line

If you want a franchise that will make you laugh your guts out, choke on your food in horror, and then vomit that food back up after seeing some grotesque gore, you've got a winner in The Evil Dead.

Sam Raimi's Evil Dead series is a cult classic that forever changed the horror industry. If you like cabin in the woods movies, you can thank Evil Dead for perfecting the trope. If you like gore on gore on gore, you can thank Evil Dead for its over-indulgence in violence. And, if you like low-budget horror flicks becoming major successes, you can thank Evil Dead for showing it can be done.

To date, there have been five movies in the franchise. The first three were a makeshift trilogy, with the second film being a resequel of the first. Fans then got a full reboot years later. Then, there was a kind of remake, sort of sequel, maybe spin-off, released this year.

It's a good time to be an Evil Dead fan, so let's assess each movie based on its influence, quality, enjoyment factor, and more.

--

Note: This list will only focus on the films, so Ash vs Evil Dead will not appear.

5. Evil Dead (2013)

Evil dead 2013
Tristar

Words like remake, reboot, and reimagining can scare film fans more than running into Michael Myers down a dark alleyway. Seeing one of your favourite franchises turned into a dull, money-driven, hollow shell of a movie is a painful experience. So, how did Evil Dead fair in the process? Well, despite being at the bottom of the list, it did an excellent job.

Fede Alvarez's 2013 Evil Dead takes the same narrative as the first movie, following a collection of friends as they spend the weekend at a remote cabin, only to summon parasitic demons. It re-explored the franchise in a nostalgic yet fresh way, and only fell to this position because of one or two setbacks.

The movie certainly gets the atmosphere and violence right; the ungodly gory sequences in the flick feel like true Evil Dead horror. However, there are a few downsides, with one being the pacing. It takes a little too much time to get going, causing the first act to drag. The premise also feels too familiar, with the setting and concept feeling like a full rehash of the original with few new ideas bar incorporating addiction into the tale.

Overall, it's a stellar reimagining, but still just a reimagining.


4. Army Of Darkness (1992)

Army of Darkness
Universal Pictures

Many people will be upset at seeing Army of Darkness this low on the list, which is understandable. The movie is an absolute delight, with a big fan following, and some might even call it the most fun chapter in the franchise. But, that being said, it definitely feels the least Evil Dead out of all the flicks.

Army of Darkness follows on from Evil Dead II with the iconic Ash being transported into the past, landing in the Middle Ages. There's a lot to love about the film, with Bruce Campbell at his absolute campiest in his iconic role. The bizarre setting also makes way for plenty of surprising moments. For example, the scene where "Evil Ash" grows out of Ash's shoulder is a real highlight. Sadly, Army of Darkness ranks low simply because it feels out of place within the initial trilogy.

You have to respect Sam Raimi for taking a big risk in this film, and it certainly paid off if you want an enjoyable historical horror adventure. But Army of Darkness relies so heavily on comedy and fantasy that it lacks any of the scares the series had previously thrived on.

Goofiness is a big selling point for Ash and the Deadites, but it works best when it's balanced with pure horror.


3. Evil Dead Rise (2023)

Evil Dead Rise
Warner Bros.

Seeing one of your favourite movie franchises returning after years of inactivity is always stressful. Evil Dead fans were lucky enough to have made it through the 2013 redo okay, but they had to experience the same anxiety ten years later. Thankfully, it worked out alright!

Evil Dead Rise follows a small family forced to contend with the Deadites after the mother is possessed. The first thing to note is that it's a bloody film! You'll see all sorts of depraved stuff here, like a cheese grater on a leg, folks eating glass, and even an elevator scene that makes The Shining look like child's play -- as in, the phrase, not the Chucky movies.

But Rise isn't just another gorefest; it also made some big changes to the formula without altering too much. For example, like Army of Darkness, it's not set in a cabin in the woods. The traditional setting is swapped out for an LA apartment complex, and this new location works perfectly as it ties a contemporary sting to the Deadite threat.

The movie also tugs at the heartstrings, as rather than a group of friends, it focuses on an unwilling mother attacking her children. Seeing this vulgar brutality performed on kids is disturbing enough, but watching them have to accept their mother's death simultaneously is diabolical.


2. The Evil Dead (1981)

The Evil Dead 1981
New Line Cinema

Here it is, the film that started it all!

One of the best things about The Evil Dead is that you can still show it to people nowadays and get a great reaction from them. Fans of the horror genre have been spoiled and desensitized thanks to years of growing changes in the industry, with many older movies losing their power. But this Sam Raimi classic holds up surprisingly well.

There's no denying the visual effects certainly are dated, but the depravity makes the visuals incredibly charming, as there's a sense of the practical work and passion that went into making them. Plus, the intense atmosphere and pacing still packs a spooky punch. Overall, the film also thrives on being simple. It doesn't muck around with subplots, set-up, or complicated relationships. It just goes in and gives you a scary time.

It's mind-blowing to think that this was Sam Raimi's first movie, as his expertise as a director is evident. His visual language and frantic camerawork, which would become his signature style, are noticeable from the first minute. This is another reason why The Evil Dead holds up so well.

The Evil Dead deserves its reputation as a horror classic, though one thing the movie does lack is the franchise's signature humour. But don't worry, that's coming next.


1. Evil Dead 2 (1987)

Evil Dead 2 Ash Laugh Bruce Campbell
Rosebud Releasing

Evil Dead 2 captures everything that made the previous film brilliant but irons out some of the kinks. It also brings comedy into the forefront in a way that the franchise would adopt wholeheartedly, making this easily the most well-balanced between horror and comedy the series has ever produced.

The sequel re-explores the first film by focusing on Ash and his girlfriend Linda as they go on a short vacation to a remote cabin. Linda is possessed after Ash listens to a recording of The Book of the Dead, and away we go. The film, again, doesn't bother with set-up or character-building; it just gets right into the nitty gritty. From there, it's a non-stop thrill ride full of violence, charming stop-motion VFX, and hilarity.

This is also the movie that birthed the Ash Williams fans know and love. While Bruce Campbell's character certainly shined in the first film, it was this flick that turned him into the raving, wild, and captivating madman he would become. Overall, Evil Dead 2 launched the series into even greater cult-classic status.

It's got the horror, the violence, the comedy, and Ash. The film is the purest form of Evil Dead's best elements.


Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!