Every MCU Director Ranked Worst To Best
Which bring the comics onto the screen the best?
In the ever-growing MCU franchise, there have been 14 directors of its feature films to date. They will soon be joined by the directing duo of Anna Boden and Ryan Fleck, who are directing Captain Marvel together, but how do the other directors to date stack up?
They are a highly interesting and varied bunch, with TV-show creators, famous screenwriters, indie filmmakers and even a horror maestro in there, making this maybe the most diverse franchise director line-ups of them all. The MCU films have been criticized for their 'flat' visuals and their director is praised less than other elements, but is this criticism deserved? Not at all.
The criticisms of the MCU's direction aren't actually particularly fair, since most of these directors have done a fine job at bringing these adventures to life. There are a few notable exceptions, but for the most part the MCU has proven to be very well-directed and in recent times, with more and more interesting choices being brought on-board, the directing line-up is only getting better and better.
But who are the MCU directors to beat? It's time to find out...
14. Peyton Reed
Directed:
Ant-Man (2015) and Ant-Man and the Wasp.
Edgar Wright's much-publicized departure from Ant-Man was a huge disappointment; had he stayed, a list like this would rank him highly. Unfortunately, he departed and we got... Peyton Reed instead.
It's a bit of mystery that Marvel thought the best way to replace a comedy auteur was with a random director of mediocre studio comedies, but they went ahead and did it anyway.
Ant-Man has some nice shots in the miniaturized scenes, but visually it's definitely one of the least-interesting Marvel films. If one wanted to argue the MCU has a problem with flat visuals, this would be a good example to use. Reed's direction isn't awful, but it really isn't very interesting and considering how much fun the film ultimately is, it's the shame the film is so disappointing on a directing level.
To be honest, it feels like a bit of a shame they couldn't have brought in someone else in for Ant-Man and the Wasp.
13. Jon Watts
Directed:
Spider-Man: Homecoming (2017).
Spider-Man: Homecoming was a flat-looking Marvel movie that, while overall strong, had distractingly uninspired direction. Given that this is the third incarnation of Spider-Man in 15 years, we'd already seen Sam Raimi and Marc Webb direct the hell out of their movies, so the lackluster, TV-Movie style visuals of this one did stick out like a sore thumb.
Jon Watts' direction is not bad or anything; rather, it's just fairly bland. Give that the rest of the film was so good there was more than enough to overshadow the uninteresting visual style, but compare this to Sam Raimi's epic, comic book-like visuals and Marc Webb's brilliant cinematography and unforgettable tracking shots (despite the overall lackluster nature of his films) and it can't be denied that this shortcoming was disappointing.
Jon Watts is coming back for Spider-Man: Far From Home. Hopefully he can add a bit of panache to things next time.
12. Alan Taylor
Directed:
Thor: The Dark World (2013).
We all know what Alan Taylor is capable of on the small screen; he is a veteran of shows such as Game of Thrones after all. Unfortunately, his temporary move to Hollywood was something of a disaster, with him making a much-loathed Terminator movie and this, the worst MCU film, in the space of three years. Ouch.
Taylor has said subsequently that his original work was butchered by studio interference and that he did not enjoy working with Marvel. He's not alone in that since seemingly everyone hated working on Thor 2. This film's failure is not Taylor's fault but what can be seen of his work on the film isn't great.
Thor 2 is another one of the least interesting MCU films on a visual level and lacks any sort of flair or visual invention. Compared to Taylor's fine work on TV, this feels like the work of an amateur and it's far below his normal standard.
11. Louis Letterier
Directed:
The Incredible Hulk (2008).
This is where the good directing jobs start.
Louis Letterier might have directed terrible films such as Now You See Me and Clash of the Titans but he himself is a solid visual stylist who has, unfortunately, been stuck with a lot of underwhelming movies.
His work on this largely forgotten though still enjoyable origin story is fine, although he's not given the chance to really do much since this is a fairly low-key and by-the-numbers movie. There aren't even many big action sequences, so this film wasn't really a good opportunity for any director to show off their cinematic chops.
That being said, Leterrier was an absolutely solid director for the film and although he doesn't bring an awful lot of cinematic style or visual invention to proceedings, he directed the action in a coherent, engaging manner and did a thoroughly serviceable job with the movie.
10. Joe Johnston
Directed:
Captain America: The First Avenger (2011).
Jumanji director Joe Johnston was not blessed with one of the better MCU films, but he himself added quite a lot to it. Released at the height of the insufferable 3D craze, this one actually used 3D rather well (such as the shot in which Steve Rogers brings the flag-pole down) and Johnston managed to bring plenty of punchy intensity to the film's retro set-pieces.
Joe Johnston hasn't returned to the MCU and doesn't appear to be planning any sort of return, but if he did that would be no bad thing. He is a veteran of blockbuster directing and while his direction of The First Avenger was a little workmanlike, it was still overall good and managed to avoid being visually uninteresting.
Judging by Joe Johnston's solid work on The First Avenger, the upcoming Chronicles of Narnia reboot is in good hands.
9. Joss Whedon
Directed:
The Avengers (2012) and Avengers: Age of Ultron (2015).
Joss Whedon differs from most MCU directors as he was sole writer and director of both the films he helmed for Marvel. Of course, Whedon is more of a screenwriter than a director and most of his previous directing work was in TV, which does show a little in both the Avengers films
Especially in the first Avengers film, the cinematography was somewhat TV movie-like at times and his direction wasn't massively memorable, but on the whole Whedon did a reasonably good job as director, although his incredible screenwriting work in the MCU was considerably more impressive. His direction in Avengers: Age of Ultron was better and more confident.
He did also have a knack of doing incredible long-take shots. He's responsible for three of the best shots in the entirety of the MCU: the spinning hero shot in The Avengers and two notable floating tracking shots which went from hero to hero during a battle, one during the Battle of New York and one during the Age of Ultron opening.
8. Shane Black
Directed:
Iron Man 3 (2013).
In what was only his second directional outing, Hollywood screenwriter Shane Black did a fine job with Iron Man 3. Iron Man 3 is still one of the MCU's best films and this is largely thanks to Shane Black.
While the film's success rested more on his excellent screenplay than his direction, Black still proved himself a thoroughly capable director here. Black directs the film well, especially in the action sequences and the film is generally nice to look at; in particular, the aerial rescue sequence was superbly done. Also worthy of note is the scene in which Stark destroys his suits, which remains one of the most cinematically strong MCU moments to date.
Largely thanks to Black's efforts, Iron Man 3 is still the best Iron Man solo film and was an MCU film with a distinct flavor of a buddy-cop movie, meaning Black created an entertaining MCU product while also leaving his creative fingerprints all over the film.
7. Scott Derickson
Directed:
Doctor Strange (2016).
Scott Derickson has mainly worked on horror films and was a highly unusual choice to direct Doctor Strange. This was, come to think of it, quite a gamble, but it luckily it ended up being a smart move; his horror sensibilities and the psychedelic mania of Doctor Strange made for a good match.
Bringing a genre filmmaker with a different sort of visual style was a smart move and, while aided by the incredible special effects, Derickson's work on Doctor Strange was excellent. Thanks to his stylish and hallucinatory cinematography Doctor Strange was a delightfully weird and trippy experience that brought out a real artistry that's often been lacking in previous MCU outings.
Doctor Strange might be one of the weaker MCU movies, but Scott Derickson certainly shouldn't have the slightest bit of regret about his work on the film. In fact, thanks to his strong direction he's arguably gives Benedict Cumberbatch competition as the film's MVP.
6. Jon Favreau
1331154Directed:
Iron Man (2008) and Iron Man 2 (2010).
The very first MCU director, actor and director Jon Favreau had only directed two big-budget films before Iron Man but he did do a terrific job with the movie. As well as star Robert Downey Jr, we have Favreau to thank for getting the MCU off to such an incredible start.
The original MCU film, Iron Man, is very well shot and is absolutely full of tight, tense and coherent action sequences that feel genuinely thrilling but never over-the-top or exhausting, proving Favreau a natural blockbuster director. Watching the first Iron Man back now, it confirms the upcoming Lion King remake is in safe hands.
Iron Man 2 was unfortunately a disappointment ruined by studio interference. Favreau's directing is fine and it wasn't his fault, but nevertheless he was unhappy with the film and left the MCU after that. That was very unfortunate, since not only did the franchise lose a skilled director but the next thing Favreau did was the ill-judged Cowboys and Aliens.
Favreau has also given a good performance as Happy Hogan. It's a shame he left, but he'll always be an important figure in the MCU's history.
5. Kenneth Branagh
Directed:
Thor (2011).
Yes, Kenneth Branagh directed a Marvel movie. He was an odd choice, but Marvel does have a great knack of making oddball director picks work out well.
Thor isn't very good, but Kenneth Branagh has nothing to regret in regards to his work on the film. Thor was the first MCU film with truly striking visuals and Branagh did a great job in bringing out a real sense of awe and wonder to proceedings, with the setting of Asgard being rendered in a truly epic manner.
While much of the film takes place on Earth, Branagh ensures the film remains an interesting visual piece through and also frames it like a comic book, which brings some much-needed panache to an otherwise dull film. It's a real shame he didn't return for Thor: The Dark World.
Branagh was also the one who brought Tom Hiddleston on-board, having worked with him on BBC's Wallander, so we have that to thank him for as well.
4. Taika Waititi
Directed:
Thor: Ragnarok (2017).
This New Zealand director of quirky, random comedies was an excellent choice to bring in for Thor: Ragnarok, since this is an auteur with a clear creative vision who could bring something different to the table. Thor: Ragnarok is far from the best of the MCU films but Waititi himself didn't disappoint and did one of the best directing jobs in the MCU to date, allowing Ragnarok to be one of the artiest Marvel films.
Although Ragnarok's color palette is somewhat messy, it's still visually stunning and boasts some incredible shots, such as Hela's take-down of the flying horses and the tracking close-up of Thor's hammer attack during the unforgettable opening fight soundtracked to Led Zeppelin's Immigrant Song.
Ragnarok was overall a delightfully stylish entry full of colorful cinematography and a wonderfully quirky vibe. Unfolding in a brilliantly designed environment that mixed epic classical architecture and geeky, retro designs, Ragnarok proved once again that the MCU is not a conveyor belt franchise and is constantly exploring new styles and genres in a very clever manner.
3. Ryan Coogler
Directed:
Black Panther (2018).
Ryan Coogler, with Fruitvale Station, Creed and now Black Panther under his belt, is really on a roll. Black Panther is now, with good reason, one of the most successful and well-loved MCU films and Coogler's accomplished work is a huge part of why the film works so well.
Unlike other directors such as Josh Trank, Coogler did not mess up the transition from low-budget to big-budget in the slightest and, despite all the bad CGI, it's easily one of the best MCU films on a visual level. It's full of artistic and stunning cinematography, with Killmonger's death before the sunset being one of the best MCU shots to date, but Coogler never forgot he was directing a blockbuster and truly brought out a sense of visceral intensity and kinetic energy to the film's set pieces.
When the inevitable Black Panther 2 comes around, it'd be madness not to bring Coogler back since he did such a good job and proved he could direct an exciting blockbuster while also making it a satisfying artistic piece. His muse, Michael B. Jordan, was the film's MVP as well.
2. James Gunn
Directed:
Guardians of the Galaxy (2014) and Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 (2017).
James Gunn has recently been fired from the MCU after some old tweets (read at your own risk, they're NSFW) resurfaced. Whether or not this sacking is deserved, Gunn's departure is unfortunate since he did a great job with Guardians of the Galaxy and its equally awesome sequel.
Like many of the best MCU directors Gunn gave his films a real artistic identity. Full of colorful, quirky and borderline hallucinogenic visuals, crazy cinematography and imaginative production design, the GOTG films are by far the most visually stunning MCU films to date. In particular, with scenes such as the incredible funeral ending, GOTG 2 was a visual artwork. Gunn was also a great director of action and delivered some incredible set-pieces.
The peak of his directing was the one-take opening of the second film, which was a perfect superhero movie scene if there ever was one. Gunn said he wanted to make one of the best movie opening scenes ever. He legitimately did.
Recent events have perhaps marred his reputation, but they won't affect his MCU legacy.
1. Anthony And Joe Russo
Directed:
Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014), Captain America: Civil War (2016) and Avengers: Infinity War (2018).
Who could've known that two guys best-known for directing sitcom episodes would turn out to be the golden boys of the MCU?
Sure, these two have directed the three best MCU films so that helps, but all three of the films owe a lot to the Russo Brothers.
They are genuinely great at filming spectacle. As shown in set pieces such as the incredible finales of The Winter Soldier and Civil War, the duo's tight editing, visceral cinematography and genuine sense of awe and scale make such sequences incredibly thrilling, but the thing which makes these two so skilled is that they never go overboard. There's no overly distracting style and their direction has always been smooth and grounded. Their ability to create brilliant comic book movie action while also making the spectacle feel real is the main reason Marvel should never let these two go.
The three MCU films the Russo Brothers have directed are genuinely great cinematically, even outside of the set-pieces, making them the MCU's best directors the MCU to date. The untitled Avengers 4 is in good hands.