Every Peter Jackson Film Ranked Worst To Best

From gory horrors to Middle-earth, which of Peter Jackson's films wears the crown?

lord of the rings the fellowship of the ring
New Line Cinema

Born in New Zealand, Peter Jackson got his start in gory no-budget horror-comedies, many of which are today seen as cult classics. Following this phase, he moved on to more refined dramas and broke numerous records with his epic adaptations of J.R.R Tolkien's Lord of the Rings series. For his work, he has won three Academy Awards.

Jackson is a chameleon behind the camera. On the one hand, he's held in high esteem for his attention to detail and ability to seek out the beauty in his film's most important sequences. On the other hand, he's known for his playfulness and dark sense of humour, as is evident from his first handful of indie horrors.

Over his career, Jackson has directed 15 films, including a documentary on the First World War and six feature films set in the world of Middle-earth.

Here's every movie he has made ranked worst to best...

15. The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies (2014)

The Hobbit Battle of the Five Armies
Warner Bros. Pictures

The final film in the Hobbit trilogy, The Battle of the Five Armies is by no means a terrible movie, but it does feature some seriously maddening issues. For starters, there's the battle scenes, which, whilst exciting and entertaining, are overdone with special effects and never live up to the exhilaration of the Lord of the Rings trilogy.

Then there's the fan service. Legolas (Orlando Bloom) turns up for the second time in the trilogy, despite not appearing in the novel and given little to do outside of reminding fans the film is a prequel to the previous trilogy. Also, the endings to the various plot threads are often rushed and occasionally non-existent, meaning there's no satisfying conclusion drawn as a whole.

Of course, there are some good points, particularly regarding the performance of Martin Freeman and the strong first act, but all told The Battle of the Five Armies is underwhelming and nothing more than your standard loud, sloppy blockbuster. It sits at the bottom of this list simply because it's so disappointing.


14. Meet The Feebles (1989)

Meet The Feebles 1991
Siren Visual Entertainment

Meet the Feebles is almost a clever little comedy, but is let down massively because of its forced humour and a childish tone that isn't half as intelligent as it clearly thinks it is. Telling the story of a group of crass puppets (designed in the vain of Jim Henson's Muppets) as they uncover some shocking truths about fame and show business, the film is zany, but lacks any real artistic point.

Though the ridiculous nature of the characters and plot have allowed Meet the Feebles to become something of a strange cult favourite, it never once challenges itself. Despite this, there are some merits, particularly in regards to the puppet designs and sometimes subtle pop culture references, but even then the whole thing seems to have been made to shock for shock's sake.

Before Lord of the Rings, Peter Jackson was known for this kind of film - the bizarre, over-the-top dark comedy that pushes political correctness out the window - but Meet the Feebles is a mere shadow of his better work.


13. The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug (2013)

The Hobbit The Desolation Of Smaug 7
Warner Bros.

It's hard to pinpoint what exactly makes The Desolation of Smaug so weak, but that's probably down to how much there is wrong with it. Though often cited as the best of the Hobbit trilogy, the film is a tonal misfire, shifting between battles, quests and character interactions with much less care than Jackson is known for.

Of course, there's the special effects issue that plagues its sequel (and its predecessor), a production decision which leaves the whole film feeling rather synthetic, cartoonish, and difficult to immerse yourself in. But it's more than that - it's exciting when it wants to be, sure, and the action is solid, but it's so bumpy and inconsistent that it's hard to remember you're watching a Lord of the Rings film.

The main issue with the Hobbit trilogy is clearly Jackson's choice to make the 300-page novel into three films (applying the same logic to Tolkien's LOTR trilogy would surely have amounted to around twelves movies), and The Desolation of Smaug suffers massively for this decision. It's so-so good fun, and the acting is decent, but that's not enough to save the film from its biggest faults.


12. Forgotten Silver (1995)

Forgotten Silver
Warner Bros

Forgotten Silver is an oft-forgotten addition to Peter Jackson's filmography, a whip-smart if underdeveloped mockumentary that takes a look at fictional filmmaker Colin McKenzie (Thomas Robins), who accidentally created the famous tracking shot and close-up years before they were first documented.

The film is presented as a documentary, featuring interviews from Jackson and Sam Neill. In it, McKenzie is shown as a genius way ahead of his time, and his fictional film "Salome" is scattered throughout the 60-minute movie as the director's "masterpiece." According to reports, when Forgotten Silver was first released, it was mistaken as a real documentary.

And, honestly, it's easy to see why. Jackson perfectly captures the essence of Old Hollywood and the seriousness of documentary filmmaking, and by using real-life Hollywood figures as guests, he creates a world in which McKenzie is real, and his work truly was epic and unfairly forgotten. Despite this, though, the film is too short and ends up feeling like wasted potential, not giving itself enough time to dig into its subject.


11. Bad Taste (1987)

Bad Taste
Endeavour Productions

The first feature film of his career, Bad Taste is Peter Jackson's most bizarre film - and as you'll see that's saying a lot. A sci-fi comedy-horror in which a race of aliens arrive in a small rural town to harvest the locals for food, the film shifts between over-the-top gore and violence and hilarious character interactions.

Made on a shoestring budget, the film stars Jackson as both the film's hero and one of the aliens, with his off-screen friends not only co-starring, but helping him with funding. The result is a fast-paced, grotesque gore-comedy that is as strange as it is compulsively watchable.

Watching Bad Taste, you can't help but notice it's a film made by a filmmaker trying to break out into something bigger, but having one hell of a time in the process. The film lives up to its title, offering up some nasty visuals and absurd plot-points, and though it doesn't really have much to say outside of "Watch this! It's gonna be gross!", it's still good fun.


10. The Lovely Bones (2009)

The Lovely Bones Stanley Tucci
Paramount Pictures

Based on Alice Sebold's acclaimed novel of the same name, The Lovely Bones is at once one of Peter Jackson's most visually stunning and narratively obnoxious tales. The film is about a girl called Susie (Saoirse Ronan) who is murdered by her neighbour (Stanley Tucci) and is forced to watch her family (Mark Wahlberg, Rachel Weisz) from Heaven whilst they mourn.

There are moments of genuine greatness scattered throughout the film, including Jackson's typical eye for striking, beautiful visuals, and the powerhouse performances of Ronan and Tucci. But between these sparks of brilliance, there are some issues, primarily with the constantly shifting tone.

One minute, you're watching a thoughtful meditation on grief and family; the next, everything is dark and all the hope is gone, and all that's left is violence and death. The tone is off to such an extent that the whole film is let down in its wake, despite the film's most effective moments hinting at a brilliant film never realised.


9. The Frighteners (1996)

The Frighteners
Universal

After the death of his wife, an architect called Frank (Michael J. Fox) gains the ability to communicate with the dead, and uses his newfound abilities to make money as an exorcist. After the ghost of a serial killer (Jake Busey) hits the scene, though, Frank decides to put his talents to better use and stop the evil murderer before it's too late.

A silly premise with a sillier execution, The Frighteners is visually delightful and darkly funny. Fox is on top form as the film's eccentric protagonist, and there are a few solid scares thrown in for good measure, but there are problems with the finished product.

Most of the issues come down to the messy narrative and a frequent lack of restraint on Jackson's part, but with its flash visuals, odd humour and crazy plot, it makes for a fun if too-surreal-for-its-own-good cult comedy-horror.


8. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012)

THE HOBBIT  AN UNEXPECTED JOURNEY Bilbo
New Line Cinema

Despite suffering from many of the same issues that plague its two sequels, the first of the Hobbit trilogy makes for an excellent example in worldbuilding. Fans get a chance to see Bilbo Baggins before the events of the Lord of the Rings, and with some compelling dialogue, effective action and great performances, the results are quite striking.

In An Unexpected Journey, Bilbo finds himself joining Gandalf (Ian McKellen) and the Dwarves through Middle-earth, to retrieve ancient riches from the dragon Smaug.

Though the film is let down by a slow first act and an overindulgence in CGI, it still works well as the beginning of a grander tale. The creatures and new characters are, for the most part, great additions to the franchise, and Freeman and a returning Andy Serkis are particular standouts. If more care had been taken with the effects and narrative flow, An Unexpected Journey would have made for a far better film, but even with its faults it's a decent and ambitious ride let down by its sequels.


7. Braindead (1992)

braindead lawnmower
Trimark Pictures

Even today, Jackson's insane comedy-horror Braindead is seen as one of the goriest films ever made, and the biggest cult favourite of all the director's other movies. The plot follows a guy called Lionel (Timothy Balme), who has to think fast when his mother becomes a zombie and starts infecting the whole town with her disease.

Darkly humorous and featuring some startling practical effects, Braindead cost $3 million to make - and it wouldn't be too far to assume most of that money went to the blood and gore of the film's most madcap moments. No spoilers here, but the lawnmower scene in particular is one of the most nuts scenes in any zombie film of the 90s.

Braindead is Jackson at his most uncaged, creating the most visually disgusting and action-heavy horror possible but also taking a step back and giving audiences a great host of characters and some surprisingly emotional beats. It's bonkers in every way, but Braindead is also certainly one of Jackson's most fully-realised projects.


6. King Kong (2005)

King Kong
Warner Brothers

The most underappreciated film of Peter Jackson's career, the director's attempt at remaking the 1933 classic King Kong is a startling achievement in big budget filmmaking. Starring a great ensemble rounded out by Jack Black, Naomi Watts, Adrien Brody, Kyle Chandler, Jamie Bell and the big ape himself, Andy Serkis, the film seems split into three distinct storylines, and each of them work wonders to create an epic fantasy drama.

The effects here are staggering, with Kong being brought vividly to life by Serkis and offering up some seriously amazing action sequences. There's also a great grasp for scares running through the film, allowing King Kong to be at once a striking adventure film and a deeply unsettling survival horror.

No, it's not entirely perfect - Jack Black and Adrien Brody are a bit out of place - but between the epic scope, spotless imagery and great narrative structure, Peter Jackson's King Kong is a truly brilliant film that everyone should really re-visit.


5. Heavenly Creatures (1994)

Heavenly Creatures
Miramax Films

Not only was Heavenly Creatures Jackson's first foray into serious Hollywood filmmaking, but it was also the feature film debut of Kate Winslet and Melanie Lynskey. Based on the infamous murder of Honora Parker by her own daughter, Pauline, and Pauline's friend, Juliet. Despite the source material, the film is never exploitative, and captures the horror of the murder perfectly.

Both Winslet and Lynskey shine in the lead roles, whilst the true standout remains the script, thoughtfully penned by both Jackson and his long-time partner Fran Walsh. Between the script and the acting, the film makes for a captivating and intelligent character study, and a near-perfect assessment of tragedy, murder and social consciousness.

With the brilliance of Heavenly Creatures, Jackson set himself for some big things in Hollywood, and though he reverted to comedy-horror type with The Frighteners a couple of years later, it wasn't long before Jackson was ready to hit fans with the project that would make him one of the best directors of his generation.


4. The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King (2003)

The Lord Of The Rings The Return Of The King Frodo Baggins Elijah Wood
Warner Bros. Pictures

Despite winning eleven Oscars, as well as three for Peter Jackson, the concluding chapter to Jackson's spotless fantasy epic has more weaknesses than the other two films in the trilogy. What The Return of the King is slightly let down by is the weirdly sudden end to the final battle, and the script's slight over-reliance of expositionary dialogue.

Of course, these are very minor scruples, as Return of the King really is a remarkable end to perhaps the greatest film trilogy of all time. The way the film moves between characters and sub-plots is phenomenal, as is the acting of principal stars Viggo Mortensen, Ian McKellen, Elijah Wood, Sean Astin and, best of all, Andy Serkis.

The visuals, too, are insane, and even today hold up throughout the film. Also, who can argue with that ending? Some might find it too long for its own good, but given how epic the tale had been up until those final moments, it wouldn't have been fair on the narrative to end any earlier. It's epic, slow-burning, action-packed, near-perfect - and still isn't the best film Jackson has ever done.


3. The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring (2001)

lord of the rings the fellowship of the ring
New Line Cinema

The first installment in the Lord of the Rings trilogy, The Fellowship of the Ring is a perfect introduction to Middle-earth on the big screen. With the stunning set pieces, sweeping cinematography, instantly iconic characters and effortless narrative flow, the film moves with remarkable ease between battles, characters and crushing twists.

Starting off in the Shire and introducing audiences to the peaceful lives of the hobbits, Frodo, Sam, Merry and Pippin are uprooted so violently you can't help but hold your breath with them. As the mythology begins to take shape around them and the stakes are raised, Fellowship of the Ring really becomes a vicariously intense experience.

From Gandalf's sacrifice to Boromir's (Sean Bean) final stand, from the opening firework display to the sequence in which Aragorn takes on almost an entire army, Fellowship is one of the best fantasy films ever made, and a perfect example of what makes Peter Jackson such a great filmmaker when he slows down and thinks things through.


2. They Shall Not Grow Old (2018)

They Shall Not Grow Old
Warner Bros.

They Shall Not Grow Old was Jackson's first (and so far only) documentary feature, a striking and visceral look at the First World World. Using old wartime footage acquired from the Imperial War Museum, Jackson uses the latest in filmmaking technology to colourised the 100-year-old footage and bring the war to life like never before.

The documentary is staggering in its technical achievements, and its emotion is close to unrivalled as it recounts some of the war's most troubling and affecting stories, brought together from over 600 hours of interviews from real-life soldiers who fought during the conflict.

With its respectful approach to the subject matter as well as its factual accuracy and daring assessment of war and its consequences, They Shall Not Grow Old is as emotional intense as it is a must-watch for anyone wishing to know more about the Great War. Jackson pulls no punches, leaves no stone unturned, and the results are simply divine.


1. The Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers (2002)

Lord of the Rings The Two Towers
New Line Cinema

In the end, though, it could be only one, and for this list Peter Jackson's best film has to be the second installment of the Lord of the Rings trilogy. The Two Towers is just as character driven as its predecessor, but ups the intensity of the battles and Frodo and Sam's journey to Mordor with the proper introduction of Gollum.

Gollum may be the best character in the film, closely followed by Sam and his scene-stealing "the tales that really mattered" speech, but the reason The Two Towers beats the other films in the series is all down to the Battle of Helm's Deep. A dark, dangerous, epic and engaging conflict, Helm's Deep remains the best battle in the series.

Between the emotional musical score, Jackson's sweeping direction, the next-level battle scenes, Gollum's introduction and the hopeful ending, The Two Towers is Peter Jackson's true masterpiece, perfectly balancing the strengths of Return and Fellowship into one undeniably perfect film.


Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/