Every Pixar Movie Ranked Worst To Best

You've got a friend in them. Lots of friends, in fact.

Every Pixar Ranked
Pixar

Almost 25 years ago, Pixar changed the world of film-making. They might not have been the first to use computer generated imagery, or the first to aim animations firmly at an audience spectrum of both children and adults, but their simple, magical answer to the question of whether toys come alive proved to be the foundation stone for a generation of cinematic adoration.

Back in 1995, their technology was incredible, so it's stunning to note how far the studio has come since then, constantly innovating the capabilities of their chosen medium at the same time as offering spell-binding, universally appealing stories. They are both tech company and imagineers at the same time.

Over the years, they've created some of cinema's greatest characters, made us all shed some serious tears and left impressions that few other cinematic brands have managed. But which of their 21 movies to date is the best?

21. Cars 2

Cars 2
Pixar

Pixar don't make bad movies and Cars 2 would absolutely be counted as a middling animation by any standards other than theirs, but next to the other Pixar movies, it definitely sticks out as limited.

The inferior Cars sequel was always going to happen because of the ridiculous merchandising money Disney pulled in from the first movie, but it's just a shame the studio didn't try a little harder to make a compelling, charming story. The sequel's biggest crime is that it's forgettable and that's pretty disastrous for a brand this big.

It's unfair to assume that every Pixar film will be faultless, but they absolutely shouldn't be making anything this mediocre.


20. The Good Dinosaur

If you're looking for positives for The Good Dinosaur - which is a vastly better movie than Cars 2, by the way - it's arguably the most stunning of all of them in terms of environments. Because it's set closer to nature than any other later Pixars, the landscapes are sweeping and beautiful and the effects behind them are simply incredible.

It's just with the story and the film's substance that it begins to fall down. The story isn't terrible by any means, and it has some of Pixar's usual emotional pillars in there - death, identity, finding ourselves - but it's just not very substantial. Sure, there are tear-jerking moments, but once again it's mostly just forgettable.

This could well be because Pixar had to drop their initial story and reset partway through production, of course, but it's difficult to accept excuses. Particularly when their replacement story feels so familiar.


19. Brave

Brave MOVIE
Pixar

Like The Good Dinosaur before it, Brave is actually a beautiful film and you cannot fault Pixar for its design. It's also probably vastly more appreciated in Scotland than anywhere else in the world. But it's definitely one of the lesser Pixar movies, because it doesn't quite feel like it belongs. Ironically.

The story bears some of the Pixar narrative hallmarks, such as an identity crisis, mortality fears and such, but it's a lot more like a Disney Princess movie. That may be because it's a fairy tale or it may be the historical period setting, but either way it sits slightly to the side of the other Pixars.

The story is still good and the characters well-drawn, but it's just a little... conventional and tends to be held up as evidence that Pixar's human-focused stories are never QUITE as good. Mostly.


18. Cars 3

Cars 3
Disney Pixar

After the first sequel misunderstood what made the original Cars more than just a vehicle for selling toys, Cars 3 seemed to understand it a hell of a lot more. Rather than it being a silly excuse for more Mater nonsense, the film returned to its Days Of Thunder influence and explored a darker story for Lightning McQueen.

This was a more mature reflection on redundancy and the existential dread of death - just as lots of the Pixar films were in the wake of Toy Story - and while it's more lightweight because of the demographic of its audience, there's a surprising smartness to the story.

Ultimately, it's still a little forgettable, but it was nice to see McQueen's story rescued from the scrap yard after the mostly awful second movie.


17. Cars

Cars Pixar Movie 2006
Pixar

If you're lucky enough to have seen Michael J Fox's charming Doc Hollywood, you probably never needed to see Cars, given how similar the storylines are. But there is something to be said for Pixar's take on the tale of a big shot trapped in small town America, and Cars arguably has Pixar's most pronounced moral code of all the studio's films.

Arcs matter, and watching Lightning McQueen going from being a greedy, conceited kid with a thirst for glory to a far more levelled, altruistic one is as well-drawn a story as Woody's development in Toy Story.

The characters are great, the designs are immediately (and rather cynically) appealing to kids and it's still way more than just an opportunity to sell millions of dollars worth of merch to susceptible children because it understood the need to grip adults too.


16. Monsters University

Monsters University
Pixar

It may have taken a while to come out, but there was always enough charm in and goodwill for Mike Wasowski and Sulley to warrant a return to their world. And that world - and the wonder behind it - that really captured everyone's imaginations first time out.

Rather than following on with Sulley and Boo's story, or finding out whether Mike excelled as one of the new breed of Non-Scarers, Pixar chose to expand the world by looking beyond the workplace. Instead, we got a look at the college fraternity system as a backdrop to learning how the odd couple of Monsters Inc ever became friends in the first place.

The film lacks the villainous hook of the first and there's no real sense of threat (because we know everything works out ok), but getting to spend more time in Mike and Sulley's company is no bad thing at all. It's not quite as charming, but it's in no way a redundant follow-up.


15. Incredibles 2

The Incredibles 2
Pixar

It took a long old time for Pixar to bring out the much-anticipated Incredibles sequel (so long, in fact, that the studio forgot that it once used "The" in the title), but there was always going to be one. This is, after all, the age of superhero movies and the nostalgic, smart take on the post-superhero moment did what the DCEU and the MCU would years earlier as well as giving us the Fantastic Four movie we always deserved.

Mercifully, the studio decided against a time jump that would have seen the Incredi-kids grown up and instead we got a direct continuation of the first movie's story, including the Underminer's attack on the city. That decision meant we got to see the same dynamics further explored, including the revelation of Jack-Jack's latent powers, which is delightful.

There's a timely comment on gender roles in there too and more of a look at superhero accountability, but that's a little familiar and the villain slightly lacks the oomph of Syndrome. It's entertaining, but it's not up there with the best.


14. A Bug's Life

A Bug's Life is a rare case of a film with a very familiar story - we've seen it in the likes of Seven Samurai, Galaxy Quest and The Three Amigos among others - working because of the new spin on it. And it's all down to how charming the characters are.

Looking back at the film, the effects have worn quite a lot, but in the context of its release time, it was an incredible achievement that delivered on Pixar's promise to open up a whole new magical world. Sure, Antz is a more complex story and more adult-oriented, but A Bug's Life has more magic, more charm and more humour to it.

It also, crucially, has a very good villain (who actually deserved his horrific death), which always goes a long way in Pixar movies.


13. Finding Dory

Finding Nemo Dory
Pixar

For more than a decade, Ellen DeGeneres was basically a one-woman campaign to get a Finding Nemo sequel made and her commitment paid off with her elevation to the main character of the follow-up.

12 years after the original, we got more of a look at what had made Dory what she was and the results include some of the most heart-wrenching Pixar moments.

Back in the original, the only hint at Dory's past was her wondering almost casually where her family was having clearly forgotten them (which is the kind of mind-worm horror that really, REALLY grows when you give it time), so there was definitely space to explore that more.

And though it's a film about a forgetful fish, like the best Pixars, Dory explores some deeply fundamental human fears - chiefly of abandonment - in a way that never compromises its accessible entertainment factor.


12. Monsters Inc

Monsters Inc Boo
Pixar

Looking back on the marketing of Monsters Inc, it was clear that the studio was delighted with their advances that had made animating every individual strand of hair on Sulley possible. It's almost charming how little that sort of technique means now.

Monsters Inc is not just a vehicle for digital fur though: it's a charming, heart-warming portrait of parenting with an odd couple dynamic and the right balance between threat and humour. Remember, the stakes of this film very much come at the potential cost of Boo's life.

Thanks to brilliant casting, the characters are incredibly successful, the humour works beautifully (thanks in no small part to Billy Crystal's delivery) and you really root for the monsters. Which is a sentence in itself that shows the absolute genius of Pixar's transformative look at the "reality" of the monster universe.


In this post: 
Pixar
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.