Every Pixar Movie Ranked Worst To Best
Toy Story? Wall-E? Finding Nemo? Soul? Which Pixar film is the best of them all?
Blowing everyone away in 1995 with their debut release Toy Story, Pixar has over the years become one of the most beloved animation studios in cinema. They've done everything from family-driven dramas, post-apocalyptic adventure flicks, and even a movie in which a rat ends up the best chef in Paris.
In 2020 - despite the various roadblocks in their path - Pixar released two new original adventures, including the ode to jazz music Soul and the Tom Holland-led fantasy Onward. Shortly before these releases, they won an Oscar for Toy Story 4, a film that certainly wasn't expected to but nonetheless continued Pixar's streak as one of the most celebrated animation studios in the world.
All of this begs the question, though: Which Pixar instalment is the best of the best? None of their films are outright bad, all sporting fantastic animation and strong levels of heartfelt themes such as family, friendship and identity, but it's fair to say that a handful haven't been quite up to scratch when compared to their most remarkable achievements.
With that in mind, from Toy Story to Cars, Up to Soul, here is every Pixar movie ranked worst to best.
23. Cars 2 (2011)
If there was one thing Cars didn't need, it was a sequel focused on Mater and his sudden, accidental involvement in international espionage. There can be no denying the animation pops and the action sequences are typically outstanding, but Cars 2 is glaringly devoid of its predecessor's charm.
Mater is the kind of over-the-top, offensively cliched character who works best as a sidekick and not much else, but Cars 2 spends the whole film trying to convince its audience that he deserves the spotlight.
If that wasn't enough, Lightning McQueen himself feels unfairly sidelined by Mater's off-the-wall adventures, and the ensemble of oddball characters from the first film are missing for the vast majority of the sequel's runtime.
Cars 2 is a visually appealing romp, but when it comes to the heart and soul that characterises other Pixar efforts, it's a brutal misfire.
22. Monsters University (2013)
There is no reason that Monsters University should even exist, so it's little surprise that it sits as one of Pixar's lesser films. Ignoring the infamous plot holes of the movie, its biggest issue is that it has no hook.
Being a prequel, the characters aren't as complex as they were in the previous film, and without Boo as the emotional core of the story, it is both predictable and narratively thin.
As ever, the animation is a startling success, and the voice work of Billy Crystal and John Goodman shines just as it did twelve years previously, but between the off-putting retcons, blasé storytelling and lukewarm humour, Monsters University serves as a classic example of a sequel-baiting cash-grab that doesn't really do anything new.
21. Cars 3 (2017)
Despite being almost unanimously their worst film to date, Cars 2 generated a large enough profit to warrant a sequel. This time, though, Cars 3 got back to basics with a tale of Lightning McQueen coming to terms with his inevitable retirement.
Cars 3 has a fairly predictable plot reminiscent of the original film, and the film's slick new adversaries make for some entertaining additions to the fold, but between Lightning's latest journey of heartfelt self-discovery and a solid voice cast rounded out by Chris Cooper, Kerry Washington and Nathan Fillion, the film is surprisingly forgettable overall.
Like many of Pixar's latest adventures, Cars 3 looks good and makes for some decent entertainment at the time, but offers very little to make itself stand out.
20. The Good Dinosaur (2015)
The Good Dinosaur was a nightmare to make behind the scenes. There were delays, a brief spell in development hell, and script rewrites that caused some key members of the creative team to bail from production.
In the end, what Pixar were left with was a sweet and visually triumphant tale in which a dinosaur goes on a journey with a young caveman, in a world where the dinosaurs were never wiped out by a meteorite. This setting in particular is spectacular, allowing the animators to really let loose their imaginative powers with a brilliant "what-if" story.
The finished product is let down by a far too inconsequential plot, where the stakes are disappointingly low for a Pixar adventure about unlikely friendship and family woes, but thanks to the visuals and the likeable characters, it stands up pretty well.
19. Onward (2019)
Onward's biggest selling point was the vocal pairing of Tom Holland and Chris Pratt, and when the film was released it was easy to see why. Holland and Pratt are on top form throughout the picture, working off one another brilliantly as elf brothers out to bring their father back from the dead for one last day.
It's a very familiar, Pixar-esque tale of family and brotherly spats, and for large swathes of the runtime it certainly struggles to make the most of its fantasy setting. But Onward is still a great little film, tugging at the heartstrings, offering some solid laughs, and ending on an undeniable high.
It's just too inconsistent for its own good, letting itself down when compared to Pixar's other, more accomplished works.
18. Brave (2012)
Watching Brave almost ten years on from its release, its weaknesses are more noticeable than ever. It suffers from a problematic plot that really brings new meaning to the phrase "leave your brain at the door," and some of the humour is far too silly to be completely effective.
But underneath the plot issues, slapstick jokes and wonky tone, Brave is nonetheless Pixar's first female-led adventure, and takes a look at a mother-daughter relationship with some striking moments of real, teary-eyed heart.
Like Onward, the medieval/fantasy setting isn't utilised as well as it maybe could have been, but all told Brave is able to work with its family themes of love and acceptance alone, and deserves to be dug back up for a re-watch.
17. A Bug's Life (1998)
Pixar's second film, A Bug's Life famously went head-to-head with Dreamworks' Antz in 1998, and though (for your writer's money, at least) Antz is the stronger of the two, A Bug's Life is still an undeniable blast of an animation.
The film follows a typical accidental hero type in Flik; a young ant who forms a gang of insects to protect his colony against a troupe of evil grasshoppers. The animation is charming for the time, but it's easily one of Pixar's least re-watchable efforts since it's so geared toward a younger audience rather than the whole family.
Between its iconic characters and top tier voice work from Dave Foley, Hayden Panettiere and Julia Louis-Dreyfus, though, A Bug's Life remains one of the studio's most recognisable instalments, and deserves props for solidifying its popularity.
16. Cars (2006)
The first of the Cars trilogy is pure bliss front to back, even if its plot isn't quit as imaginative or out there as other films in Pixar's back catalogue. Despite being about a world inhabited only by humanoid vehicles, it's still a quiet slice of realism that takes a look at fame, small towns ruined by the march of progress, and identity.
A constantly engaging comedy that uses the voice work of Owen Wilson, Michael Keaton, Bonnie Hunt and Paul Newman (in his final acting role) to perfection, Cars crafts a smart and endearing story out of Lightning McQueen's journey from arrogant boy racer to lovable champion - both on the track and off.
As noted, it's far from Pixar's most imaginative project, but Cars is without question one of its most timeless and beloved classics.
15. Incredibles 2 (2018)
Perhaps the only Pixar sequel that had more twenty-year-olds in the audience than young children, Incredibles 2 came out fourteen years after the original, picking up right where it left off with that epic final cliffhanger.
Luckily - even in a world now characterised by a major superhero movie boom - Incredibles 2 does a lot to live up to expectations. As Elastigril goes full hero and takes on a powerful supervillain, Mr Incredible stays home to look after their youngest son, Jack-Jack.
It's not as groundbreaking or even as exciting as its predecessor, but Incredibles 2 makes for a fun, nostalgic ride that sports some great laughs and a wholesome family vibe.
Could it have been better? Yes, probably. But was it also great to see the family again after so long apart? A thousand times yes. Here's to hoping we get to see them more in the near future.
14. Soul (2020)
Pixar's most recent film is an emotional, existential film about a jazz musician whose soul gets sent to the Great Beyond, and then sets him up for an adventure in which he attempts to right his wrongs and get a second chance at life.
If that sounds like a particularly heavy addition to the Pixar fold, Soul continuously surprises with a goofy sense of humour and shifting themes that allow for some solid laughs amongst the plot's more dramatic beats.
There are some issues, namely the occasionally infuriating tonal inconsistencies and a sense that the film doesn't fully know what it really wants to be, but as a whole Soul is a moving and silly portrait of one man's visually sublime journey of self-realisation, and will probably go down as a studio classic in the years to come.