Fantastic Beasts: 21 WTF Moments

Two words: Anus Flames.

Fantastic Beasts WTF
Warner Bros.

Fantastic Beasts is almost as surprising as it is brilliant. Where else could you hope to see a family-friendly film in which Eddie Redmayne performs a sexy dance for a rhino-slug monster? Where else can innocent non-magical folk be threatened with anus fires and having their lives ruined by kleptomaniac mole creatures or memory erasing giant eagles? This is not a world for No-Majs.

Perhaps more surprising is how great it is: the film might be different from the Harry Potter films (and that really ought to be classed as a good thing, regardless of what any grumps tell you), but it captures the magical spirit of the original series and opens new, exciting doors that haven't been open before. And if you can't get hyped for Johnny Depp playing a peroxide blonde wizard Hitler, there's something wrong with you.

But for all of its great moments, the film is still full of plot-holes, weird narrative conceits and flat-out jaw-dropping weirdness that will stay with you long after it finishes. And nit-picking at them is precisely why we're all Harry Potter universe fans - as if JK Rowling didn't know that!

Here are the biggest WTF moments from Fantastic Beasts And Where To Find Them...

21. The Worst Customs Official (With The Weirdest Voice)

Fantastic Beasts 25.jpg
Warner Bros. Pictures

As the film opens (after Johnny Depp's brief first appearance killing some random victims with a single swoop of his incredibly powerful wand he then forgets), we see Newt entering America with his suitcase of wonders in tow. He stands in the customs queue, switches the case to Muggle-Friendly and hands it over for inspection to what must surely be a thorough official guarding the border.

Except he's clearly not that thorough, given that he doesn't at all inspect the suitcase. He just looks at the top layer, failing quite impressively to do his job, despite having suspicions that Newt might be a bit odd. There's obviously no way he could be hiding anything in there, because everything he can see is nondescript and non-suspicious.

Couldn't this customs official - who for some reason was overdubbed with a comedy gruff voice at some point in post-production - just have been confunded? It would at least make him look less idiotic.


20. Newt Scamander And The Inadequate Suitcase

Fantastic Beasts 19.jpg
Warner Bros. Pictures

Speaking of the suitcase, what exactly possessed Scamander to believe that a suitcase with a faulty clasp that massively dangerous, hugely valuable magical creatures in didn't need to be in full working order?

He should easily know how to fix things, given that the Reparo charm is LITERALLY easy enough for a child born to Muggles who hasn't yet gone to Hogwarts is able to wield it (as Hermione does in The Philosopher's Stone). And yet he allows the catch on the case to be broken, knowing full well not only that the creatures could escape but also that he will be checked by Muggle customs officials.

Or you know, he could have had some sort of door inside the enchanted space within stopping the creatures from just being able to walk out of it when they're unguarded. It's almost like he isn't a responsible adult.


19. Interdepartmental Mail That Kills Each Other

Paper Mouse
Flickr

Here's a great idea: use an enchanted interdepartmental memo system with the tiny flaw of the memos fighting each other and ripping to unreadable shreds. That way nobody will get their memos and people presumably lose their jobs for gross negligence and dereliction of duty. But at least they look cute, eh?

Obviously in the British Ministry they use paper airplanes when Harry visits with Mr Weasley, but that came after they used owls, which pooped everywhere. But surely someone in Congress MUST have noticed that their memos kept disappearing? They can't all be that stupid...?


18. "Anus Flames"

Kowalski Fantastic Beasts
Warner Bros.

Was there any need for Newt to drop the delightful bomb-shell that one of the side-effects of being bitten as Kowalski is is "flames out of the anus"? It's all a little bit puerile and the kind of thing you'd probably hope this sort of franchise would be above.

Poor guy. It doesn't bear thinking about.

And how on earth does anyone survive from that sort of thing?


17. Niffler's Strange Stealing Habits

Niffler Fantastic Beasts
Warner Bros.

Niffler is easily one of the most charming parts of the film thanks to an irresistible blend of charisma and rascal-like, nonchalant behaviour. it also helps that he's one of the cutest creatures in the entire thing too. it's established firmly early on that the creature is a kleptomaniac, irresistibly drawn to shiny objects with such compulsion that it becomes a walking ball of chaos.

But then towards the end of the film, when Newt reveals that the Occamy babies in his care are hatched from solid silver eggs, in a nest about 4 feet away from the Niffler's own nest. And yet the thieving little might didn't bother to take the abandoned shells? Is he somehow cured? Does his compulsion have a blind spot?

And not only that, but Niffler's little den is absolutely chock-full with things he actually did manage to steal. So presumably lots of people are massively out of pocket somewhere.


16. Queenie Makes A Sex Joke

Queenie Goldstein Fantastic Beasts
Warner Bros.

There are a couple of weirdly sexy adult jokes hidden in the film. First, when Scamander and Kowalski are taken back to Tina and Queenie's apartment, the latter reveals she's a Legilimens by excusing Kowalski for whatever he thinks when he sees her ("it's okay, most men think that when they meet me"). The dirty devil.

Isn't this a family friendly movie? Shame on you: just imagine the number of children turning to their parents innocently asking for an explanation of what her line means. And in the run up to Christmas as well.

And then there's the bit where a giant animal attempts to have sexually assault Kowalski. Oh, the LOLs.


15. That Sex Dance (And Potential Erumpent Rape)

Fantastic Beasts Eddie Redmayne
Warner Bros.

There are some things I legitimately never thought I would ever write as a film fan: the subject of Eddie Redmayne performing an enticing sex dance for a giant mutant cross between a slug and a rhinoceros to make it horny enough to recapture it is definitely one of them.

The whole sequence showing the attempted capture of the aggressively sexual Erumpent is a particularly odd one, not only because of Newt's dance (try scrubbing out the rather charming image of Redmayne wiggling his backside at the camera like some sort of bumbling baboon, I dare you), but also because the unspoken climax of that scene would be horrific. We're encouraged to laugh as the creature chases poor Kowalski, but surely the likely end-goal would see it have its wicked way with him without so much as a hint of consent.

In 2016! Tumblr should be furious.


14. Who The Hell Eats Apple Studel WITH POTATOES?!

Kowalski Strudel
Warner Bros.

The sequence that shows Queenie "baking" for Newt and Kowalski is a particularly contentious one, since it inspires a lot of questions. For instance, what if Kowalski had asked for pie instead of studel? Were both ingredients just lying about?

And how on Earth is the thing being baked in mid-air? This seems like weird new magic (which is weirdly specific), and it makes the fact that there's an oven in the Weasley's home at The Burrow seem a little odd.

But even more importantly, the strudel is apple-filled, and thus sweet. So why the hell is it being served with carrots and potatoes?!


13. The Worst Boss Ever

Seraphina Picquery Fantastic Beasts
Warner Bros.

Magical Congress President Seraphina Picquery is not the greatest character in Fantastic Beasts: she doesn't really have a great deal to do and she's sort of relegated to the background, popping up to make devastating decisions like choosing to have Credence Barebone killed on site rather than taken to trial, and generally being a bit of a rubbish President.

She's not Cornelius Fudge bad, but she's bad.

And worse, she's also a terrible boss, accusing Tina of not reporting the fact that Newt Scamander had magical creatures on his person (some of which had escaped), despite the fact that the disgraced Auror had literally tried to do exactly that to her face not a day previously. And oddly, Tina never brings up the fact, simply accepting the dressing down she receives unfairly before she's passed on to Graves for sentencing.


12. EXECUTION?!

Fantastic Beasts Eddie Redmayne
Warner Bros.

After Graves gets his hands on Scamander and Tina and interrogates them (giving away his actual plan for the world in the process and foreshadowing who he really is), the film takes a serious turn to the dark side, turning up the adult material to 11.

The revelation that Magical Congress has a built in Execution Chamber that literally dissolves anybody selected for extermination might be the most outrageous moment in the entire film. How on Earth are they getting away with that? Where is the court system? Why are all the white-robed employees so creepily cheerful? What is this nightmare?!

And were Newt and Tina not entitled to a trial in front of a jury of their peers? Does the Constitution not extend to magical people? They're basically ruling like the Nazi party.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.