Fantastic Beasts: 21 WTF Moments

11. Nobody Takes The Beasts Off Scamander

Swooping Evil Fantastic Beasts
Warner Bros.

Why is it that when Newt Scamander is arrested inside Magical Congress and taken to be interrogated by Graves, he is at no point searched?

This is a known criminal who is literally known to associate with magical creatures and known also to be carrying them at the precise time he is arrested. And while they are clever enough to take his suitcase off him, they don't waste the literal seconds it would take to search his pockets, where they would have discovered Picket the Bowtruckle who can pick locks and Swooping Evil who can do all sorts of useful magic for battle situations.

They're idiots, in other words.


10. "These Animals Are Endangered: Let's Let Them Eat Each Other"

Fantastic Beasts Creature
Warner Bros.

Newt Scamander is very clear on why he's trying to raise awareness about Fantastic Beasts - they're being exterminated by wizards and witches who don't understand them needlessly and they need to be protected and preserved.

So why exactly does he keep them in an environment without enclosures between the animals that are delicious and the animals that want to eat them? If they're all so precious, shouldn't the site of a slightly larger animal eating one of the smaller ones worry him some? Isn't allowing that to happen precisely the opposite of what he is trying to achieve?!


9. Door Spells Don't Work

Fantastic Beasts 37.jpg
Warner Bros. Pictures

In the Wizarding World, magical rules are subject to change seemingly at the drop of a hat when the plot requires it. So, areas of magical importance or which should be scrupulously defended aren't protected in any way by spells, and some spells don't work as they always have (see the upcoming obliviate section)...

The worst of this comes when Queenie attempts to break into one of the Magical Congress offices in her and Kowalski's attempt to save Newt and Tina from extermination. She uses the age-old Alohamora spell to beat the lock, but unsurprisingly is thwarted by a charm protecting forced entry.

It should come as a surprise to everyone watching at that point that Kowalski is simply able to kick the door down, rendering all magic absolutely pointless in the process to make him look a bit good.


8. Occamy Grows/Shrinks To Fill Size... Sometimes

Occamy Fantastic Beasts
Warner Bros.

There's an excellent sequence in the middle section of the film that sees Newt and his new allies attempting to capture an enormous Occamy, which has grown to fill the attic of the house it is nesting in. The rule here is that the creature - classified as a choranaptyxic - will always grow to fill whatever vessel it is housed in. That results in a great scene in which the wizards trap it in a teapot.

But all spectacle aside, the film ignores its own rule AGAIN when it clearly shows several Occamy inside the enchanted suitcase. Surely they should be kept in individual cages to stop them growing? Not just left in their nest. Or that might be a consideration if the science of choranaptyxicity weren't completely avoidable when the plot doesn't need it.

Like when the Occamy is born inside the bank and doesn't grow to fill the bank, for instance.


7. Queenie Has Difficulty Reading English Minds... Then Doesn't

Queenie Fantastic Beasts
Warner Bros.

When Queenie is doing her parlour trick of reading Kowalski's mind and seeing all the dirty things he's thinking about her, she claims she can't read what Newt is thinking because she "has difficulty with English people - maybe it's the accent"...

Except then a matter of minutes later (well, not that long anyway), when Newt has invited her into his suitcase and she discovers the picture of Leda Lestrange, she has mysteriously managed to overcome the barrier and can read his every thought flawlessly (even when she's not really intending to).

Without rules we are no mroe than savages.


6. Congress Has No Security

Fantastic Beasts American Ministry
Warner Bros.

One of the more annoying niggles in the Harry Potter movies comes with the revelation in The Deathly Hallows that nowhere in the magical world really has any security protecting them against charms designed to deceive to gain access. It's basically like having no password protection on your account, and allowing anyone access, particularly since spells like Confundus and the Imperius Curse exist. And you know, since anyone with the right materials can make Polyjuice Potion.

The same lax security is on show at Magical Congress too, where Graves is able to rise to a lofty position despite being a magical disguise.

And this is despite the fact that a simple Revellio reveals his true nature. Why is that not a defensive charm cast over all magical institutions?! It seems like a fairly major oversight, when the magic definitely exists. It's not like they shouldn't be EXPECTING threats when Grindelwald's activity has put their magical warning level at Orange.


5. Johnny F*cking Depp

Fear And Loathing In Las Vegas Johnny Depp.jpg
Universal Pictures

It might have been effectively spoiled before the film was released, but the presence of Johnny Depp - a bona fide A-lister who can still basically choose what he wants to do (despite an occasionally poor box office record) - in the film is still massively shocking.

That's probably why the reactions to his appearance have been so split. Personally, I think it's great and I think his look was perfect for the image of Grindelwald as the wizarding world's version of Hitler, but a lot of people have reacted negatively before he's even had a chance to build a character.

Considering his recent troubles in the press, it's actually pretty amazing that Warner Bros went near him - not that trial by media is ever to be encouraged.


4. Grindelwald's Convoluted Plan

Fantastic Beasts Grindelwald
Warner Bros.

For all the success of Grindelwald's reveal, it does make you think back to how unnecessarily complex his plan is. Sure, there's probably an element of arrogance in him hiding in plain sight within Magical Congress to track magical activity to his own benefit but it's still a little silly.

He's enemy number one, who apparently has an army of loyal fanatics to count on, and he's incredibly powerful, and yet he's having to wait around doing Graves' duties in Congress in the hope that something happens in Credence's attempt to find out who the Obscurial is. The fact that he knows there's a prophecy and the exact family that it relates to makes the fact that he then continues to infiltrate Congress entirely redundant. Why split his focus?

And where the hell are those fanatics we were led to believe exist? Wouldn't it have been narratively better to have Graves simply revealed to be one of them and Congress infiltrated, rather than have the big bad slumming it in such a strangely demanding day-to-day role? Presumably he had to live as Graves for some time so as not to attract needless suspicion.

Also... how exactly did anyone know to cast Revellio on him anyway? There were literally no hints that he was actually Grindelwald - presumably the MACUSA are just fans of Scooby Doo...


3. Where's The Elder Wand?!

Elder Wand Voldemort
Warner Bros.

JK Rowling may have messed a little with the canon (expelling Newt rather than allowing him to graduate Hogwarts), she seemingly hasn't changed the fact that Grindelwald is the master of the Elder Wand by the time he shows up in Fantastic Beasts. His murderous rampage hinted at at the start of the film seems to confirm as much, given that he's capable of dissolving his enemies and casting a charm to change his appearance (transfiguration doesn't usually involve turning into other people as a rule).

So why is he bothered about anything other than reigning terror over Muggles to pull down the veil between the wizarding world and the normal one? He has the most powerful weapon in the history of magic and he's wasting his time looking for another weapon he doesn't know the extent of which is as temporary as it is volatile (and which could fundamentally be cleared up as a gas explosion much easier).

Also, when he is overcome by the MACUSA and Newt in the finale, where is the Wand there? Why does he rely on "good" spells - he uses what appears to be Stupefy in battle, despite knowing that discovery will be catastrophic - when he cut incapacitate everyone or kill them with the immeasurable power of his wand?


2. The Dumbest Plot Resolution Of All Time?

Frank Thunderbird Fantastic Beasts
Warner Bros.

As soon as the McGuffin of the Swooping Evil venom is revealed, it's pretty obvious that it's going to come back to importance later in the film. The way it does is pretty silly when you think about it.

Sure, a mass obliviate spell put into rain clouds is a nice idea on paper - especially as it gives Frank The Thunderbird a reason to exist - but are we really supposed to believe that an untested venom (which Newt has no idea of the properties of in undiluted form, as he states) would work that perfectly?

And what about all of the people who had witnessed magic but weren't at that exact moment on the streets to be covered in rain, or drinking water (the shot of the family sharing a glass of water is a step too far) or showering? That's a fairly big chance that some witnesses weren't even obliviated at all.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.