Fifty Shades Darker Review: 2 Ups & 8 Downs

The funniest film of 2017.

Fifty Shades Darker
Universal Pictures

The second entry into the movie franchise adapted from E.L. James' inexplicably popular erotic trash novel has arrived, and soccer moms everywhere are rejoicing. Arriving on a tidal wave of hype, it's time for things to get "darker" ahead of next year's third (and hopefully final) offering from this baffling series.

Prepare to be shocked: it's a terrible movie with few redeeming qualities, a disastrously bad film that's sure to win a heap of Razzies next year. And you thought Rings already had it all sewn up.

Still, it would be silly not to recognise Fifty Shades as the massive global phenomenon it is, a monstrous box office success despite its widely-derided lack of quality.

You're either going to genuinely enjoy the film no matter what the critics say, you'll hate-watch it for irony's sake, or you'll avoid it like the plague and soak in something that's actually good, like The Lego Batman Movie or the widely-praised John Wick 2.

Either way, here are 2 ups and 8 downs from Fifty Shades Darker...


Downs...

8. It's Not Sexy. Like, At All

Fifty Shades Darker Jamie Dornan Dakota Johnson
Universal Pictures

Much like the first movie, the biggest issue with Fifty Shades Darker is that it's just not very sexy at all, clearly made with repressed middle-aged housewives in mind, who would apparently shudder at the sight of an actual penis or vagina in a movie.

The sex scenes here are tasteful to the point of inertia, where there's very little in the way of nudity or eroticism: you see an errant boob or butt every now and then, but anything else is strictly off-limits.

Hell, Jamie Dornan even keeps either his shirt or trousers on during most of the film's sex scenes, and there are numerous implied sexual encounters that take place off-screen.

Seriously, if you're going to make a movie like this, why not swing for the fences and go all-out? Instead it's sanitised for as big a market as possible, and categorically fails to titillate all but the most meek and timid as a result.


7. Most Of The Male Characters Are Huge Creeps

Fifty Shades Darker Eric Johnson Dakota Johnson
Universal Pictures

Almost every single man in this movie is a colossal creep, with the exception of Christian's (Jamie Dornan) brother Elliot (Luke Grimes). For starters, Anastasia's (Dakota Johnson) friend-zoned pal Jose (Victor Rasuk) is back, and when he invites Ana to his new art exhibit, she's shocked to find that it features six gigantic pictures of her, which he used without her permission. It's...hilarious.

Then there's Ana's new boss, Jack Hyde (Eric Johnson), who stares creepily at Ana on more than one occasion and ends up coming onto her aggressively in his office with a distinctly rapey vibe. The very end of the movie then suggests he'll be back for more in the sequel.

And finally, there's the paragon of creepiness himself, Christian, who spends most of the movie attempting to dictate what Ana does with her life, while staring a hole through her in a way that says he'd gladly wear her skin if given half the chance.

Yes, this is a woman's story, but do almost all of the guys need to be such repellent a**holes?


6. It Takes Itself Way Too Seriously

Fifty Shades Darker Dakota Johnson
Universal

The first film was at least smart enough to lean into its own silliness on occasion, but Darker sadly takes itself much more seriously, which is a huge problem when you consider that it's a lot more ridiculous than the original.

The tone is dead-serious for the most part, which ironically makes it even more difficult to actually take seriously, adamant that all the drama is important and nourishing to its audience rather than just accepting that it's straight-up hot garbage.

People complain about Batman v Superman not being fun enough, but few films have drained a potentially campy good time at the movies as efficiently as this one. There is little intent for the film to be fun, with a tone verging on downright funereal at times.

Plus, a plot that revolves around drug overdoses, stalkers and near-death experiences isn't exactly the best one to get viewers in the mood now, is it?


5. It Wastes An Insanely Talented Cast & Crew

Fifty Shades Darker Kim Basinger
Universal

Sweet baby Jesus there are a lot of talented artists who sold their soul for this movie. First up, Dakota Johnson and Jamie Dornan are solid actors left stranded with a pathetic script, written not-so-coincidentally by author E.L. James' husband Niall Leonard.

Then there's director James Foley, who previously helmed the fantastic drama Glengarry Glen Ross and more recently numerous episodes of House of Cards, slumming it here for an easy payday (and having already filmed the third movie, Fifty Shades Freed, too).

On top of that, the legendary Danny Elfman provides the score, cinematographer John Schwartzman (who will be lensing Star Wars: Episode IX) shot it, and Oscar-nominated editor Richard Francis-Bruce cut it all together.

Plus, Oscar winners Kim Basinger and Marcia Gay-Harden appear in supporting cameo roles too. This movie is an embarrassment of riches as far as talent goes, so it's basically a crime against art that the resulting movie is so damn terrible.


4. The Subplots Are Outrageously Bad

Fifty Shades Darker Bella Heathecote
Universal

This film makes you feel most of its 118 minutes because it is absolutely packed to the gills with superfluous subplots, none of which are actually entertaining, interesting or remotely fleshed-out.

There are flashes back to Christian's troubled childhood, the arrival of one of Christian's former submissives (Bella Heathcote) in hilariously creepy fashion, Ana's aforementioned inappropriate boss, a jarringly shoehorned sequence where Christian's chopper crashes and he goes missing for all of about two minutes (literally), and the appearance of Christian's weirdo first lover (Kim Basinger).

It's all an attempt to make the film feel more substantial than the rather meager offerings of the central relationship allow, but ultimately it just makes it feel bloated and comically portentous.


3. It's Got A Horrible Message For Women

Fifty Shades Darker Jamie Dornan Dakota Johnson
Universal

This franchise continues to perpetuate a rather disturbing message for women, romanticising a deeply unhealthy relationship where Ana frequently allows herself to be commanded by a domineering a**hole with deep-seated mental health issues.

The movie mostly treats it as cheeky and kinky, ignoring the fact that it's putting out a damaging message to women of all ages, that this is something to strive for, hammered home by an ending that implies their relationship is going the distance.

It's apt, really, considering that the franchise Fifty Shades spawned from, Twilight, has a similarly repugnant message, but is much more irresponsible as it's targeting young girls who haven't yet come of age.


2. Dakota Johnson & Jamie Dornan Have No Chemistry

Fifty Shades Darker Jamie Dornan Dakota Johnson
Universal

The first film released amid rumours that leads Johnson and Dornan didn't get along, and scenes were reportedly re-shot in order to enhance their perceived chemistry.

Their chemistry wasn't really that bad in the first film, but here it feels off for the most part, perhaps a product of both actors feeling the derisive backlash from the first time and not really having their hearts in it beyond a contract and a paycheck.

This surely contributes to the "sexy" situations not feeling that stimulating, and it probably doesn't help that the pair are given so little to work with writing-wise or sex-wise. It's either hilariously bad or soporifically tame.


1. It's Actually Worse Than The Original

Fifty Shades Darker Dakota Johnson
Universal

And finally, all this considered, Fifty Shades Darker is actually somehow worse than the first one. Really. It holds itself in a far more stern regard, the cinematography's not as lavish, the actors care less, and everything that sucked about the original just feels amplified this time around.

The first movie scored an unremarkable-but-not-horrendous 25% on Rotten Tomatoes, while Darker has nailed an impressively awful 8% at the time of press. On the flip-side, it's hard to imagine the next one being even worse, but then again, many thought that about this movie, so you never know.

But it's not all bad! Here's the little that actually works in the movie...


Ups...

2. It's Unintentionally Hilarious

Fifty Shades Darker Dakota Johnson Jamie Dornan
Universal

In terms of pure entertainment value, Fifty Shades Darker is an enjoyable movie to a point, because there's just so much here to laugh your a** off at.

A few choice zingers include Christian telling Kim Basinger's Elena, "You taught me how to f***, but [Ana] taught me how to love", Ana mentioning "kinky f***ery" and her agreeing to go on a date with Christian not because she's interested, but because she's hungry.

The film is so demented in its intent, tone and delivery that you'd need to be an actively miserable soul not to glean some laughs out of it, even if you'll probably be cringing just as much as you chuckle.

Once the movie's out on home video, the inevitable cringe-cut someone posts to YouTube is going to be a glorious masterpiece (and will save about 100 minutes of your life).


1. It's 7 Minutes Shorter Than The First

Fifty Shades Darker
Universal Pictures

Small mercies are mercies nonetheless, and Darker is a whopping seven minutes shorter than its predecessor, even if it's still grossly overlong and super-fans are basically forced to sit for a few more minutes anyway in order to catch the Fifty Shades Freed trailer crammed in half-way through the credits.

These films really don't need to be more than 90-100 minutes max, but anything that shears even seconds off the first film's brutal 125 minutes is something worth championing. Given how much blatant padding there is in this movie, though, it really could've been much, much shorter (like 80 minutes).

Have you seen Fifty Shades Darker yet? What did you think? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.