Gary Oldman: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Which performances? EEEVVVVERRRYYYOOO-oh, no, just five a piece.

You're unlikely to see a more star-studded film this weekend €“ unless you go in for your umpteenth viewing of Furious 7, and nobody would blame you €“ than Child 44. Tom Rob Smith's bestelling novel of a few years ago hits the big screens thanks to future Assassin's Creed director Daniel Espinosa, who tells a story of child murder in Stalin-era Soviet Russia with Tom Hardy, Vincent Cassel, Noomi Rapace, and Gary Oldman as General Timur Nesterov. After spending a good couple of decades as an €œactor's actor€, the sort of performer whose best work is done on the stage or in smaller films (whilst occasionally dipping into the mainstream to pay the bills), Oldman has comfortably settled into the Golden Middle Age of his career. His talent is universally recognised, he's a household name, and he's getting more work than ever. Between Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy and Dawn Of The Planet Of The Apes he's carved out a niche for well-realised roles in Hollywood blockbusters. It's a far cry from his start as the titular doomed punk in Alex Cox's Sid & Nancy biopic and his semi-autobiographical, unrelentingly grim kitchen sink directorial debut Nil By Mouth. He's an actor who's tried his had at everything the acting profession has to offer, and rarely has that resulted in disappointment. He's undoubtedly one of the best actors of his generation, but he's managed to fit a couple of stinkers in there amongst the roses. And boy, do they smell. Here are Gary Oldman's five best performances...and five that sort of sucked.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. James Gordon €“ The Dark Knight Trilogy (2005-2012)

For many, Christopher Nolan's down-to-earth (well, relatively) Batman films were their first exposure to Gary Oldman. The actor was part of a stunning ensemble of primarily British throughout the trilogy of Dark Knight movies, alongside the likes of Tom Hardy, Michael Caine, Liam Neeson, Tom Wilkinson, and Christian Bale as the Caped Crusader himself. In his role of Detective (and later Commissioner) Gordon, Oldman worked much like the hero on the €œright€ side of the law did in the classic Year One graphic novel that Batman Begins took some inspiration from. Whilst the Dark Knight has his own methods and operates outside the law, Gordon struggles to make a difference within the mostly corrupt Gotham City Police Department. Oldman does well to highlight the dichotomy between the sexy, angsty Batman and the more prosaic, grounded and pragmatic Gordon. He too makes sacrifices €“ such as faking his death, at the upset to his family, to catch The Joker €“ but at the end of the day, he's just a man doing his job. A job that Oldman's performance evokes with weary perfection.

4. Rosencrantz €“ Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead (1990)

Veteran playwright Tom Stoppard is best known for his theatre work, but has been known to dip into Hollywood from time to time. He provided draft scripts for WWII thriller Enigma, the inexplicably Oscar-winning Shakespeare In Love, and even provided the final rewriter of Indiana Jones And The Last Crusade. Just once has he directed a film himself, though. And it was in an adaptation of his own play, the celebrated Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead, a playful look at a couple of minor characters from Hamlet. In Shakespeare's original play the pair are childhood friends of the Danish prince brought along to keep his mind off of madness and murder €“ with varying results €“ and spend a relatively small amount of time on stage. Both Stoppard's play and film casts them as the heroes of their own story, unaware of the larger plot machinations of Hamlet and their place in it, instead bumbling across the Danish (in fact Yugoslavian) landscape chatting nonsense. And Oldman is perfectly cast to dispense said nonsense, his Rosencratz accidentally inventing the hamburger and discovers gravity...without ever realising it. Some perfect comic timing and theatrical line delivery.

3. Sirius Black €“ The Harry Potter Films (2004-2011)

In some ways, Oldman is woefully miscast as the godfather Harry Potter never knew when he shows up in third film The Prisoner of Azkaban (y'know, the best one, that Alfonso Cuaron directed for some reason). The clue's in his name: based on the timeline of the books, Sirius Black should be in his thirties, and a good deal more mad. Instead, Oldman was in his forties, and relatively sane €“ but, going by the book's timeline, everybody's miscast. Still, if you're not a stickler for the source material, there's a lot to love in Gary Oldman's performance as Sirius Black, the man framed for being a part of Voldemort's plot to overthrow the established wizarding order and possibly involved with the killing of Harry Potter's parents. In fact the opposite turns out to be the case, and Oldman's early scenes with the young Daniel Radcliffe elevate the actor's early, slightly less impressive performance skills. Whilst he's never quite as unhinged as Sirius appears in the books (and it's not like Oldman can't do properly bonkers), there's a value to Oldman's version of Black as an older, more wizened but no less self-important and a bit off-kliter prison escapee. As is basically law for major Potter heroes, he gets an emotional death scene, but in the hands of an actor like Gary Oldman? It's anything but rote.

2. Norman Stansfield €“ Léon: The Professional (1994)

Now this is unhinged Gary Oldman at his best. In later years his performance as Norman Stansfield, corrupt DEA agent and psychopath extraordinaire, would become a meme thanks to that one bit where he politely requests that one of his cronies perhaps call in some reinforcements. When the hapless SWAT team member asks for confirmation? He gets a spittle-flecked €œEEEEEVVERRYYYYYOOOONEEEEE€ in the face. Luc Besson's 1994 thriller is mainly remembered for its starring double act of Jean Reno, in a career-making role (which lead him to such greatness as that nineties Godzilla flick) as the eponymous hitman, and an early appearance by a then 12-year-old Natalie Portman as the Mathilda, the young girl orphaned by Oldman's character. It's Oldman as Stansfield that's the real draw, however, from his introduction where the drug-addled agent murders Mathilda's entire family one by one. It's a truly disturbing episode of violence in an film full of action, and Oldman never really lets up after. He might chew the scenery a little, but it's a character that requires it, and he does it with some insane aplomb.

1. George Smiley €“ Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (2011)

The polar opposite of that role, and many of the roles that Oldman is best known for €“ he essentially reprised the Stansfield role for Luc Besson's next film, the surreal sci-fi thriller The Fifth Element, as insane interplanetary industrialist Jean-Baptiste Emanuel Zorg €“ was his lead performance in the 2011 version of Tinker Tailor Solider Spy. John Le Carre's iconic Cold War spy drama had previously been adapted for television by the BBC. In that form the character of George Smiley, a seemingly ordinary pencil pusher within British Intelligence who's tasked with tracking down a Soviet double agent in their midst, was essayed by Alec Guinness €“ and for those less enamoured with his spell as a dressing gown-clad Jedi, it was considered his best work. Oldman doesn't even try to imitate Guinness's take on Smiley, instead inhabiting the character with a quiet dignity and almost resigned sense of responsibility for his country. Let The Right One In director Tomas Alfredson presides over not a speedy action film but a slow paced, but no less high-stakes, drama of international politics and its effects on human beings. Smiley has a lot in common with James Gordon, but perhaps with better tailoring. And less questionable facial hair. The true zenith of Gary Goldman's career so far.

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Count Dracula €“ Bram Stoker's Dracula (1992)

It's a career that's had its fair share of lows as well as highs, mind you. There was that guest appearance on an episode of Friends where he was employed mainly to spit on Matt LeBlanc's face, his genuinely (and awful) scenery chewing turn as the villain in Air Force One, and an uncommonly hollow performance in that RoboCop remake that nobody in their right mind would ask for. All of those pale in comparison, however, to the likes of Bram Stoker's Dracula. Effectively the final nail in Francis Ford Coppola's directorial career after jumping the shark with The Godfather: Part III, his ill-advised €“ and crazy expensive €“ retelling of the first vampire story for some reason cast the wooden, impossibly Californian Keanu Reeves as doomed Brit Jonathan Harker. Winona Ryder and Anthony Hopkins were surprisingly naff as Mina Harker and Van Helsing, respectively, but the real disappointment comes in Oldman as the Count himself. His Dracula is centuries old, with a motivation (seeking his long lost love) one that's admittedly difficult to essay when you've also got that ridiculous costume on and goofy fake spiky teeth in. More style than substance.

4. Dr Zachary Smith €“ Lost In Space (1998)

Speaking of which, Lost In Space is a particularly odd episode in Hollywood's history of big budget remakes, which appears to have missed the point of the original TV series in favour of then-cutting-edge special effects. Lost In Space, the sixties television show, doesn't quite have the appeal internationally as it does in the US, but there are certain aspects that have become part of the cultural lexicon. Specifically, a robot bleating €œDANGER, WILL ROBINSON, DANGER!€ and the presence of a mostly villainous Dr Smith, whom the intergalactically marooned Robinson family keep around regardless. Both are present in the 1998 movie reboot of the franchise, with the robot rendered in Playstation 2-level CGI and Smith played by Gary Oldman. On paper, it's a character you could do something genuinely interesting with. A spy employed to sabotage the Robinson's ship, he winds up stowed away after they've taken off and helps to put a stop to his own plans to ensure his own survival. A selfish sort-of-villain who only helps others when it benefits him is exactly the sort of morally grey character Oldman excels at. Here he's basically a pantomime vollain.

3. Mason Verger €“ Hannibal (2001)

Jonathan Demme's The Silence Of The Lambs is one of the best psychological thrillers in living memory, with Robert Harris's iconic characters Dr Hannibal Lecter and FBI Agent Clarice Starling brought to vivid life by Anthony Hopkins and Jodie Foster. The thrills of the page are ably translated to the screen by Demme, and that climactic chase scene is still waiting to be bettered. It deserved those Oscars. Less impressive was Hannibal, the direct follow up directed by Ridley Scott (who, really, has done nothing worthwhile since Gladiator), with the usually dependable Julianne Moore barely making her presence felt as Jodie Foster's replacement. Hopkins returns, too, but the subtle menace of his genius cannibal is undermined by over-the-top gore and ludicrous showboating that is a complete 180 from all previous versions of the character. Perhaps most disappointing in 2001's Hannibal, though, is when Gary Oldman shows up in an uncredited role. Originally offered to Christopher Reeve, who turned down the chance of playing a a quadriplegic, facially-disfigured child rapist, Mason Verger was one of Hannibal's first victims who survived and is out for revenge. He's unrecognisable beneath the layers of make-up which also totally mask his underwhelming performance.

2. Carnegie €“ The Book Of Eli (2012)

Stupid though Hannibal is, it's by no means the most idiotic blockbuster Hollywood has put out in the past decade. A serious contender for that honour, meanwhile, is The Book Of Eli, a seriously misguided post-apocalyptic thriller from The Hughes Brothers, previously known for superior comic book adaptation From Hell and searing gangland drama Menace II Society. It all went a bit !*$% up with this story of Denzel Washington traipsing across the desert. His Eli is a nomad who is told by a voice to deliver his copy of a mysterious book to a safe location on the West Coast of the United States, navigating a dangerous post-war world along the way. It's a film predicated on a bleak, kinda dull landscape and a serious of increasingly ridiculous twists, from the reveal that Eli is blind (despite kicking ass in a number of fight scenes), and that the book is The Bible. Were it not for the all-star cast, The Book Of Eli would be easy to write off as another High Concept action film with nothing new to offer. And yet opposite Washington in the title role is Gary Oldman, as the leader of a new settlement who wishes to possess the book, and is one of many generic bad guy roles way below his station the actor has sadly fallen into as of late.

1. Rolfe €“ Tiptoes (2003)

Then again, maybe Oldman's just trying to get over some of his more high-risk experiments in acting. Whilst the likes of Carnegie in The Book Of Eli, Dreyfus in Dawn Of The Planet Of The Apes and Lord Shen in Kung Fu Panda 2 might be one-note bad guys that aren't really befitting an actor of Oldman's skill, those sort of safe roles are definitely preferable to Tiptoes. Which is a romantic comedy where the almost six foot Oldman plays a dwarf. And that isn't even the most ridiculous part of this film's set up or cast. Tiptoes stars Matthew McConaughey, pre-True Detective career renaissance, as Steven, the husband of Kate Beckinsale's Carol. They seem happy, but Steven have a dark secret €“ which he's finally forced to spill when Carol gets pregnant. Turns out Steven's family are all dwarves. Which he's worried about. It's from there that Steven introduces his wife to Rolfe, his brother. A dwarf. Played by Gary Oldman. Mind you, this is a film that also involves a lot of actors who are actual dwarves, including Peter Dinklage from Game Of Thrones. But from some reason Oldman takes the lead role, presumably acting on his knees with shoes under his legs. Regardless of the film's intentions, it's a bit of a freak show. And it's terrible, with Oldman spending more time trying to look like a convincing dwarf, and very little on bringing breadth and depth to his character. Not only one his worst performances, but one of the worst films ever.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/