Guardians Of The Galaxy: 10 Glaring Flaws Everybody Just Ignored

Great films can have big problems, too.

Despite the fact that everybody on the planet seems to have collectively agreed that Guardians of the Galaxy - the latest movie in the extensive Marvel Cinematic Universe canon - is one of the greatest comic book films ever made, it's far from perfect; though it certainly excelled in a good number of aspects (everything from the bold casting to the brilliant special effects), there were a number of issues inherent to the picture on the whole that - for one reason or another - folk seem to have plainly overlooked. There's good reason for this, of course, which harks back to the those initial - and very universal - musings that predicted Guardians of the Galaxy as a future flop and critical dud. There were feelings amongst Marvel fans that the premise of the movie didn't gel well with the established MCU, and that characters such as Rocket Racoon and Groot would jar with what had already been laid out. As we all now know, none of this stuff proved to be an issue - not only did it make nearly a billion dollars, critics loved it. Which brings us to the point: Guardians of the Galaxy defied expectations to such a degree that people have completely overlooked its flaws. After all, if the picture had turned out even half as good as it actually did, people would have still been impressed... the fact that it was so entertaining for the sum of its parts has somehow rendered the movie immune to criticism. And, for all intents and purposes, it is a great blockbuster... for the most part. Still, here are 10 nagging flaws everybody has chosen to ignore...

10. The Villain Is Super Dull

Marvel have a real problem with villains: no matter how hard they try, they can't seem to render a bad guy with any actual personality, and Ronan the Accuser - played here by Lee Pace - joins the likes of Sebastian Stan's Winter Solider and Christopher Eccleston's Malekith in a long line of dull, forgettable MCU villains. Seriously: what will it take for the studio to realise that it takes more than a deep voice to make a villain? So Ronan the Accuser is obviously "bad," and that's about it. You know he's bad because he does all the generic bad guy things that bad guys do in movies: talks down to his subordinates; monologues when he should be concentrating on other things; stomps around with the world on his shoulders for the sum of the film. Problem is, he just feels like a plot device; we don't really "know" him. He just fills up the space.

9. The Plot Is Endlessly Shambolic

There are some people who will probably defend the shambolic nature of Guardians of the Galaxy's plot on account of the fact that "the Guardians themselves are shambolic, so it makes sense." Though there's something of a valid point hidden away in the depths of that opinion, we doubt that the screenwriters behind said picture purposely set out to render a plot that was plainly confusing, convoluted and frequently dumb. Forgive these words, but there isn't a whole lot separating the plot inherent to this movie and the plots you've glimpsed in any given Michael Bay Transformers yarn. Seriously. What all these flicks have in common is that they get too invested in trying to render a plot that feels complicated and epic, but this almost always results in a story that's impossible to recall; you can't remember "what" actually happened.

8. The MacGuffin Is Seriously Boring

Why aren't MCU fans more peeved at the fact that every second movie in the canon opts for a really, really boring MacGuffin to drive the story? And we're talking boring MacGuffins of the highest order here: artefacts that are "endlessly powerful," and thus "endlessly vague" as a result. Seriously: Guardians, like Thor: The Dark World before it, is content with offering up a MacGuffin that is of no real interest or curiosity. Fans only seem to let the studio get away with it because they're working towards a huge "Infinity Stones" plotline. The big issue, however, is that these stones have been rendered as completely interchangeable on the big screen - we can't really differentiate between any of them; they all do the same, uncertain thing, in granting already powerful bad guys with even more power. This movie deserved a lot better than that.

7. A Lot Of The Jokes Fall Completely Flat

This is sure to be a controversial point, but it's plainly true. Though there are lots of good jokes scattered throughout this flick (essentially a "sci-fi comedy"), there are heaps of gags that don't quite work; either the timing is off - due to editing - or something else is going on that distracts from the moment, like an action scene or a musical cue. That's not to say Guardians is "unfunny" - just that the humour doesn't feel honed. In a way, Guardians recalls another good movie that was only half successful in its comic intentions: Edgar Wright's Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World. In a similar way, jokes fumbled due to the editing, or because the actors unleashing said jokes seemed unsure of how to deliver them. It's not a monumental issue, but there are a healthy number of noticeably awkward moments in Guardians where the funnies don't hit their marks.

6. Benicio Del Toro Was Entirely Wasted

At the end of Thor: The Dark World, Marvel fans were treated to a scene in which a couple of Thor's friends visit a mysterious character named "The Collector" (played by Benicio Del Toro), who agrees to house one of the Infinity Stones within the confines of his extensive collection. It was later revealed that this character would feature in Guardians of the Galaxy, where it was assumed we would learn a lot more about him. Benicio Del Toro's role in Guardians, however, fills less than 10 minutes; not only do we discover barely anything new about The Collector, he disappears from the movie entirely as soon as his one scene is over. Were the majority of his scenes cut or something? Worst of all, The Collector - with his dandy mannerisms - was way more interesting to watch when compared to the likes of Ronan the Accuser; what gives, Marvel?

5. The Changes In Tone Are Frequently Jarring

Okay, so it was always going to be difficult to make a movie like Guardians of the Galaxy - a sci-fi comedy set both in space and within a shared universe - whilst keeping a consistent tone running throughout. For the most part, Guardians manages to juggle its shifts in tone fairly well, but there are points at which the changes of tone actually unhinge the picture, sucking out the tension and drama inherent to certain scenes. One of the best examples of this occurs after the Guardians have faced-off against Ronan. It's the climax of the movie, there's a lot at stake, and then... well, Peter Quill does a dance to distract Ronan from brutally murdering him. Contrary to his established persona, Ronan actually stops and addressed Quill's actions, essentially making himself look really stupid. As a result, he no longer feels like anything close to a threat.

4. The Movie Is So Winking That It Gets Annoying

You know the kind: the movie that winks at you constantly throughout, breaking down the fourth wall, letting you know that it knows that you know that the people who made the film were totally in on the joke, okay? Meta to the max, guys! This approach to the blockbuster works in moderation, of course, but when you end up with a movie entirely built around total self-awareness, it can get rather annoying really, really quickly. Guardians of the Galaxy manages to avoid being "totally annoying" in this regard, and comes out - due to the insanely likeable characters - somewhere between "a bit annoying" and "annoying at times." We get it, guys - you want us to know that sentences like "Ronan is destroying Xanderian outposts throughout the galaxy!" are innately stupid. But, really, we don't need to know it every single time a dumb line is uttered.

3. The CGI Characters Upstage The Human Ones

Some people might not consider this to be an entirely negative trait, but it's hard to justify any good reason why a character made completely out of computer-generated imagery should upstage the other, actually human characters for the sum of an entire movie. Even when Lord of the Rings had Gollum, he didn't steal the movie out fully from the likes of Gandalf, Aragorn and Sam; we still felt connected to those characters. Unfortunately for Guardians of the Galaxy - and against all odds and expectations - it's Rocket Racoon and - to a lesser extent - his buddy Groot who steal the show. When the movie's over, the other characters mostly vanish from your memory banks, whilst Rocket and Groot both linger on. Again, it's impressive that these characters feel so real to us, but they do so at the extent of their less interesting human companions.

2. The Connection Between The Guardians Feels "Forced"

You can understand how a problem like this might arise, but the filmmakers could have found a way to remedy it had they not been so keen to bring the Guardians together so quickly. Which is to say that, ultimately, at the point when our heroes decide to come together - and "die together" - it just doesn't feel appropriate. They haven't known one another long enough to actually convince us that it makes sense. So at the climatic point in the movie at which Peter Quill suggests everyone teams-up, the responses feel oddly out of place: we don't buy the connection between the characters at this time, so when they each - one by one - agree to change their entire personalities to forge a friendship after a few days, it doesn't feel earned; we simply can't buy into the idea of their sudden eternal bond because the groundwork is missing.

1. That Orb Was Ridiculously Easy To Attain

The film's opening scene sees Chris Pratt's Peter Quill on a mission to locate a mystical artefact, which turns out to be a sort of orb-thing that everybody spends the sum of the movie trying to locate. What should have been super difficult to recover, however, given its ability to - you know - destroy entire planets, proves to be no big deal to attain: Quill kicks a few little lizards, opens a door, and the orb is his. That was it? You'd think that something of such great, unspeakable power would at least have trigged a few booby traps, giving Chris Pratt the chance to play Indiana Jones as he dodged poisonous arrows or rolled out of the way as a huge boulder tried to crush him. It doesn't make a lot of sense that the orb was basically just sitting there, waiting to be taken; nor does it make sense that it took so long for people to come and get it. Like this article? Agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.