Halloween: Ranking The Movies From Worst To Best

Rob Zombie Halloween Michael Myers - the terrifying masked Illinois-born psychopath - has haunted our dreams since first appearing back in 1978 and with Halloween right around the corner it seemed fitting to dust off the old Halloween movie franchise collection and take a look back at them all, one by one. Created over 35 years ago by legendary filmmaker John Carpenter, the original Halloween remains one of the most iconic pieces of cinema - not just horror - ever made and should be the blue print for all horror movies made since that day. However, it's no secret that the franchise has had mixed fortunes over the years, leaving Michael Myers' reputation mostly in tatters, like the torn flesh of one of his many victims. With no less than 10 entries in the series, there are lots to chose from when it comes to picking our personal favourites. Which is your favourite Halloween movie? Are you a purist who feels there hasn't been a good Halloween entry since the original, or are you more of a die hard fan who fell in love with the twisted mythology that developed over the many sequels? No matter how you feel about Halloween or Michael Myers, you have to have your favourite - but where does your favourite entry in the series fall in a list of best to worst? We've taken the liberty of preparing such a list so that you don't have to. So why not throw on your finest overalls and painted William Shatner mask, grab your bag of sweets, and click "Next" to begin our run down of the Halloween movies from worst to best...

10. Halloween: Resurrection (2002, Rick Rosenthal)

Halloween Resurrection Rick Rosenthal's return to the Halloween franchise seemed ill-advised after this horrendous effort made its way limply into cinemas back in 2002. After the success of the previous sequel in 1998, it seemed some life had been breathed back into old Michael Myers lungs, especially with the return of original scream queen Jamie Lee Curtis. However, even her presence wasn't enough to prevent this 8th Halloween movie from stinking. The film opens in a mental hospital where Jamie Lee Curtis' Laurie Strode character has been spending her time since the events of H20, 4 years previously. But Halloween is rolling around again and there's no way Laurie is going to sleep easy knowing her crazy older brother is still at large. Her concerns prove to be warranted when he does indeed return to kill her, but this time she has a trap ready to end him once and for all. Sadly for Laurie, though, this is still the opening sequence of the movie and there's no way the main attraction is going to be killed off in the first 5 minutes. What did she think this was, Jason goes to Hell? After finally offing his sister - which according to Myers lore should send the mask wearing psycho back to sleep - Michael returns to his old home, presumably to chill and live out his remaining days in suburbia. But some dumb bunch of reality TV wannabes have decided to turn the place into the setting for a live haunted house online attraction, and as such it's down to Michael to teach them all a lesson about trespassing. Halloween Resurrection is a fun installment, but it's also the worst. It's another case of a filmmaker ignoring the events of previous movies (except H20, which is deemed the official sequel to Halloween 1 and 2) and misguidedly tries to inject the franchise with the comedic teen slasher groove made popular by Kevin Williamson. This just doesn't work here and no amount of Busta Rhymes doing kung-fu dressed as Michael is going to change that.

9. Halloween 2 (2009, Rob Zombie)

Rob Zombie Halloween 2 I may be alone when I say I really enjoyed the Rob Zombie spin on Halloween and if I'm completely honest I had no problem with the way his sequel turned out either. However, in the grand scheme of things it is too much of a departure from everything that made the original movies so cool (even the bad ones), and therefore sits very low in the list. The film starts out very similar to the 1981 version of Halloween 2, with Michael stalking his sister in a hospital. Sadly, Zombie chose to make this an extended dream sequence, which is always a poor misdirection technique that served only to piss off the audience. The main film instead picks up where the first Zombie installment left off, with a bloodied Laurie wandering the streets of Haddonfield covered in blood and her brother's apparently dead body being loaded into the back of an ambulance. In typical Michael Myers fashion, the psychopath does not wish to stay dead and after the ambulance crashes he manages to escape again. It isn't long before the bodies start piling up once more. Throughout the film, Michael's mother appears in the form of a spooky vision suggesting that it is she who has guided him throughout his mission of murder. After surviving the first attack by her brother Laurie - who we find out is actually Angel Myers - begins experiencing the same visions leading us to believe that she has some kind of psychic link to her brother that makes them far more similar than she'd like to think. Eventually Myers finds himself surrounded by police while hiding out in a shed. After following instruction from his mother's ghost, Myers kills Dr. Loomis - a massive douchebag in this version of the story - and is then gunned down for the last time by the local police. With Michael incapacitated, Laurie takes the opportunity to put him out his misery for good by sinking a knife into his face. But this does not free her from her nightmare as the film closes with her in a psychiatric hospital smiling to herself as the ghost of her birth mother stands beside her, suggesting a whole new killing spree may begin very soon...

8. Halloween: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989, Dominique Othenin-Girard)

Halloween 51 As a kid, I remember really enjoying Halloween 4, 5, and 6 as they really explore the ideas behind what motivates Michael to do the things he does, but looking back objectively as an adult it's clear to see that Dominique Othenin-Girard's 5th installment is far too messy to be taken seriously. Picking up where part 4 ended, Michael's body is discovered by some random hermit who takes pity on the killer (we assume he has no idea who he is) and takes the comatose Myers back to his shack where he cares for him until Michael awakens and decides to repay the hermit's kindness by killing him. With his energy restored - presumably by the fact it's Halloween again - Myers returns to Haddonfield to continue his pursuit of his (apparently) only living relative, Jamie Lloyd, who is the daughter of Laurie Strode. Following the traumatic events of Halloween 4 Jamie has been sent to live in a children's psychiatric home, but her famous uncle has plans to lure her out into the open culminating in a showdown in the old (and ever changing) Myers family home. Halloween 5 is probably best remembered for the return of the infamous 'Shape' than it is the forgettable plot and the closing sequence in which Michael is arrested (what's that all about?) and thrown in a prison cell. With his rampage seemingly over, the mysterious 'Shape' shows up and frees Michael from his cage. But who is behind the jail break and why? Well, none of that would be revealed until 6 years later in Halloween 6, which did little to help this mess of a movie.

7. Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers (1995, Joe Chappelle)

Halloween The Curse Of Michael Myers I consider myself to be a bit of a Halloween nerd. And as such, Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers is the ultimate nerdgasm for a guy like me. It is deep in the Michael Myers mythology, explains at great length the reasons he has for doing the things he does, and opens the door for a whole manner of new directions for the character to take in future movies. Sadly, the rest of the world did not agree and as such The Curse of Michael Myers was completely dismissed with the cinematic release of Halloween H20 3 years later. If you're anything like myself and haven't seen Curse yet, then I urge you to find a copy now. If you're really lucky you may even find a copy of the never-released 'Producer's Cut,' which is an even cooler version of the movie that explains even more about Michael and the spell he is under. Chances are though that you're nothing like me and would rather spend eternity arguing my decision to place Halloween 6 at number 7 in this list than contemplate sitting through the movie again. Each to their own, I guess. The film explains that Michael was somehow marked at birth with the curse of Samhain and as such was destined to become the monster he became. No amount of nurture at home would ever prevent Michael from seeking out his family and murdering them brutally - until his bloodline is totally wiped out he will be the pawn of a notorious murder cult forever. A young, pre-fame Paul Rudd stars as the kid Michael terrorised in the original Halloween, whose obsession with all things Myers lands him on the masked psycho's radar. The fact that Rudd helps to hide away Jamie Lloyd's daughter after her death does little to help him either, but will he be able to keep her safe from her great uncles murderous clutches or will Michael finally be able to kill off his last surviving family member once and for all?

6. Halloween: The Return of Michael Myers (1988, Dwight H. Little)

Halloween Return Of Michael Myers Laurie Strode, the long suffering baby sister of masked psychopath Michael Myers, is dead. Sadly for Michael, though, she died not by his hands but instead in a horrific car accident - or so we're told. What the filmmakers should have said was Jamie Lee Curtis wanted to distance herself from her scream queen past and so refused to return to the franchise for a third time. It seems she was only really willing to return when her career was on a downturn, hence her appearances in parts 7 and 8. With Laurie dead, Michael turns his attention to her orphaned daughter who has been living in foster care ever since her parents passed away. Despite the name change, Michael is able to locate his niece and slowly begins to murder those around her. Despite his attempts to kill young Jamie, the finale of the movie suggests that Myers is perhaps trying to set his niece up as his successor- even going as far as to have the girl dressed in the same clown outfit Michael wears in the 1978 original when she murders her foster mother with a pair of scissors for no apparent reason. Halloween 4 saw the return of Michael Myers to the franchise after the failure of part 3 at the box office. The original Halloween 4 had been slated to be a ghost story, but the outcry from fans at changing the format with each passing movie was enough to convince the studio to bring the series home to Haddonfield.

5. Halloween III: Season of the Witch (1982, Tommy Lee Wallace)

Halloween 3 Despite the success of Halloween and Halloween 2, someone had the bright idea of leaving the Myers/Strode family drama behind and instead make each new sequel a stand-alone horror movie set on Halloween night. The uproar was enough to convince producer Moustapha Akkad that it was a mistake to steer the series away from the unstoppable killer storyline and quickly laid the new idea to rest. Be that as it may, Halloween 3: The Season of the Witch still exists and is - like it or not - an official part of the Halloween movie franchise experience. There isn't a great deal to say about part 3 except that as a stand-alone horror movie it isn't all that bad. It is a cautionary tale about the effects of capitalism on young children, with the idea that the very Halloween masks children buy to scare people with for fun take on a life of their own and change the kids into horrible little monsters. Nothing new there then, huh? It was the lack of Michael Myers - especially at the end of the film - that caused the most anger amongst fans and to this day the resentment towards this movie has not subsided. However, love it or hate it, you cannot deny that Halloween 3 is still one of the better sequels.

4. Halloween 2 (1981, Rick Rosenthal)

Halloween 2 1981

Halloween 2 picks up exactly where the first movie ends with a highly traumatised Laurie being shipped off to the nearest hospital to recover from her wounds after wrangling with the deranged Michael Myers. After being shot by Dr. Loomis (the Donald Pleasence one - not the crappy Malcolm McDowell one) and falling from a second story window, Michael is hurt but not down. After doing his trademark disappearing act, he re-emerges in the same hospital to continue his attack on the bewildered Miss Strode. It is during this extremely well put together sequel that the filmmaker's reveal the truth about Laurie and Michael's relationship and the seeds are sown for Michael being the pawn of a religious cult which is further explored in parts 5 and 6. After somehow avoiding detection in the hospital despite amassing a considerable body count, Michael eventually catches up to his baby sister and once again attempts to introduce her to his famous knife. Before he's able to finish the job he started in Halloween, Dr. Loomis shows up, shoots him in the eyes (nice shooting Tex) and blows him up. There's no way Michael could ever come back from that attack, right? John Carpenter had no desire to direct this sequel and so the reins were passed to Rick Rosenthal, who would return 21 years later to direct the far inferior Halloween: Resurrection. Although he attempts to recreate the themes and feel of the original, Rosenthal's first attempt at the franchise falls just short of the first movie. However, as a film that was supposed to tie up a story that was never again to be visited, Halloween 2 was a complete success.

3. Halloween (2007, Rob Zombie)

Rob Zombie Halloween Rob Zombie's grimy spin on the Halloween mythology transplants the tale from middle of the road American suburbia to the much poorer end of the spectrum, with the lower class slum areas of Illinois. The depiction of Michael is also a total departure to the original source material, with Michael far more human for much of the first act - an average child growing up in a poor home with a family that loves him but also finds him incredibly inconvenient. His mum is a stripper, his step dad an abusive alcoholic. His sister is still a slut, but above all else he has a perfect little sister that he completely adores. Can you guess who that might be? After finally committing his first kill, Myers is transported to a psychiatric hospital where he eventually becomes an introverted mute who spends his days making masks and growing his hair. After years of counselling sessions with the smug Dr. Sam Loomis, Myers eventually escapes (probably to avoid spending any more time with McDowell) and begins a violent rampage as he makes his way home to Haddonfield to find his only surviving family member. This is a perfect re-imagining of the classic story and set Rob Zombie up as the rightful heir to the franchise. Sadly, his follow up just didn't make enough sense and killed any hopes of further exploring this particular version of the Halloween saga.

2. Halloween H20: 20 Years Later (1998, Steve Miner)

Halloween H201 Halloween H20 ignores everything that has come before it with the exception of parts 1 and 2, and sets the action 20 years after that infamous night where Michael Myers came home for the very first time. Despite her traumatic teenage years, Laurie has become a successful career woman and the Dean of a prestigious Californian private school. To celebrate the twentieth anniversary of becoming the world's coolest mass murderer, Michael treats himself to a trip to California to visit his sister and top up his tan (I'm joking of course) and thus a whole new killing spree begins with everyone Laurie holds dear finding themselves on the business end of Michael's famous butcher knife. H20 was a hip, modern spin on the classic Halloween story and was a huge success. It is usually a mistake to ignore previous entries, but with John Carpenter and Debra Hill back on board officially for the first time in almost two decades, Halloween H20 was the perfect reboot and finale to the incredibly popular series. Sadly, after this film Michael went straight back to his usual crap with the official follow up Resurrection, and we all know how that one turned out (badly).

1. Halloween (1978, John Carpenter)

Halloween Michael is a seemingly normal child living in the well to do suburbs who - for reasons unknown - picks up a huge knife, climbs the stairs in his house and murders his older sister. Years later, after spending his formative years in a psychiatric hospital, Michael returns to his home town to hunt down his baby sister who has been living with foster parents since that fateful night. With no obvious motive other than his desire to wipe out his bloodline, Michael begins to pick off the local teenagers until only he and his sister (Jamie Lee Curtis) are left. Will she survive or will Michael's reign of terror claim yet another member of his dysfunctional family? The original Halloween is without a doubt the absolute best. So much has been written about this genre defining horror over the years that it seems pointless saying much more. Directed by John Carpenter back in 1978, the first Halloween provided a perfect blueprint for all psycho-killer movies that followed. Sadly, many of its own sequels failed to follow the aforementioned print to any noticeable success, but in spite of all that nothing can ever be taken away from this fantastic classic - one of the greatest horror movies ever, no doubt about it. Which is your favourite Halloween movie? Tweet us @WhatCulture using the hash tag #Halloween or let us known in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Master of Quack-Fu. Fishfinger Sandwich aficionado. Troll Hunter.