Halloween Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs
The best Halloween sequel, for what it's worth.
Almost a decade after the last Halloween movie hit cinemas - Rob Zombie's wretched Halloween II - David Gordon Green attempts to retool the series once again with this direct sequel to John Carpenter's iconic 1978 original.
Critics have so far been consistently praising the new movie as a solid attempt to resurrect the flagging franchise.
Even if it doesn't get anywhere close to the searing heights of the one that started it all, it smartly ditches the inane continuity of the silly sequels and returns to a far simpler and more accessible point of entry.
With its tripwire tension, killer lead performance and rejuvenation of Michael Myers as a flagship horror icon, Halloween 2018 is certainly the calibre sequel fans have long been deserving of.
It'll be interesting to see whether or not the series just falls into its old, formulaic patterns from this point on, and while this new film doesn't knock everything out of the park, it at least sets a rock solid foundation moving forward. Because of course, there's gonna be sequels...
Downs...
4. Most Of The New Characters Are Totally Dull
The new Halloween follows a new cast of characters for the most part and sadly, the majority of them are incredibly stock and uninteresting.
From Laurie Strode's (Jamie Lee Curtis) personality-devoid granddaughter Allyson (Andi Matichak) to her gang of equally forgettable friends - who are lent a bizarre amount of screen time - two throwaway reporter characters solely intended to set the plot in motion and a fleet of no-name cops, they all feel so basic, lazily conceived and unimaginative.
The only especially interesting new characters are Officer Hawkins (Will Patton) who has a 40-year link to Michael Myers, and the "new Loomis", Dr. Ranbir Sartain (Haluk Bilginer), and even they're pushing it.
Most disappointing of all is that the brilliant Judy Greer's talents are mostly squandered in yet another thankless movie franchise role - after forgettable maternal roles in Jurassic World and Ant-Man - with her part as Laurie's daughter Karen proving intermittently intriguing at best.
3. Some Of The Dialogue Is Genuinely Awful
In fairness, dialogue has never been the series' strong suit, even in the original movie, but one definitely gets the impression that Danny McBride's contributions to the script probably resulted in some of the more groan-worthy dialogue.
From a character joking about smothering peanut butter on their penis to mind-numbingly stupid banter between the teen characters - which while embarrassingly authentic, is also utterly charmless - and a bizarre discussion two cops have about sandwiches, none of it really feels like it belongs in a Halloween movie (a good one, anyway).
Though there are certainly some great one-liners and even a few comic relief gags that actually hit the mark - a young boy being babysat by one of Michael's targets is especially hilarious - overall the script feels like a first draft in desperate need of tightening up.
2. There's A Totally Unnecessary Plot Twist
No spoilers here of course, but there's a plot twist in this movie that comes wildly out of left-field before quickly being discarded.
The moment involves a sharp motivation shift for a certain character that doesn't feel remotely earned or sufficiently telegraphed. Ultimately it just feels like a lazy way to keep the plot chugging along and set the stage for the third act.
Some may defend the reveal as a subversion of one of the original movie's tropes, but it feels more tacked-on and underwritten than genuinely interesting or entertaining.
1. The Ending Is Pretty Disappointing
Though Halloween's third act is a stomach-knotting riot for the most part, the very end of the movie sadly ends up settling back into fairly cynical and unsatisfying territory as is characteristic for the franchise.
It's especially frustrating as the film clearly steers close to a conclusion which would've been enormously gratifying, especially for long-time fans of the franchise, but Hollywood being what it is, that's just not the case.
It's no spoiler to say that Halloween's projected box office success will ensure a sequel hits screens within the next few years - but please don't call it Halloween II - yet something far ballsier and much more interesting was possible with just a few tweaks.
So, the new Halloween isn't a home-run by any means, but it is an entertaining slasher sequel for the most part. Here's everything it gets right...
Ups...
6. It's The Best Halloween Since The First
This might sound like damning the movie with faint praise, but Halloween 2018 is without any doubt the best entry into the franchise in 40 years.
Of all the sequels and reboots, the only especially worthwhile Halloween movies were the original Halloween II and Halloween H20 - and maybe Season of the Witch for the sheer bizarro factor - until now.
Though it's certainly rough around the edges, the new Halloween is easily the most confident, technically impressive and straight-up scary franchise effort since John Carpenter's original.
It's easy to see why Carpenter himself was convinced to get involved as both composer and executive producer this time, because despite its glaring issues, this movie retains the eerie soul of the 1978 classic.
5. Jamie Lee Curtis' Excellent Performance
As expected, Jamie Lee Curtis steals the show as Laurie Strode, and though it's a shame the movie as a whole isn't more focused on her character, she's by far the most captivating part of the film.
Considering that H20 is the only sequel to really do the character or Curtis much justice - the original Halloween II mostly confined Laurie to a hospital bed, Halloween 4 promptly killed her off and Resurrection killed her for real - it's a relief that the new movie is her most effective franchise appearance in four decades.
Curtis is incredibly convincing as a woman effectively frazzled by 40 years of PTSD, while at the same time re-imagined as a Sarah Connor-esque action hero determined to take Michael down.
After the previous sequels largely undermined the Laurie character, it's wonderful to see this movie scrap everything but the original film and give us a far more enthralling reinvention of its protagonist.
4. Michael Myers Is Brutal & Terrifying Once Again
If the Halloween sequels quickly became increasingly silly, Michael Myers consequently became less convincing as a relentless, murderous phantom, and by the time the series revealed he was a pawn in a cult's ritual, it was all beyond saving.
Thankfully David Gordon Green takes a respectable back-to-basics approach to Myers here, absolutely nailing his unstoppable nature without having him excessively teleport around or do anything too ridiculous.
Nick Castle, James Jude Courtney and Tony Moran do fantastic work portraying Myers in various stages of the movie, making him a physical force to be reckoned with as he dismantles his victims.
Somewhat surprisingly, this is easily one of the goriest of all the Halloween films, with Myers administering some of the most brutally wince-inducing kills of his "career." Again, though, it avoids ever feeling too cartoonish or over-the-top, landing on the right side of ferociously intense.
3. John Carpenter's AWESOME New Musical Score
To the surprise of just about nobody, John Carpenter's score for this movie is a thing of sublime beauty.
Teaming up with his son Cody and Daniel Davies, Carpenter has created a new score obviously indebted to his iconic original, but also punchy and distinctive in its own right.
Many of the leitmotifs are of course near-identical, though some jazzy flourishes make them feel fresh all the same, alongside a number of new synthy compositions created from scratch for this movie.
In case you weren't sure, Carpenter's definitely still got it, and his wonderful music lends the film so much of its ominous atmosphere.
2. David Gordon Green's Rock Solid Direction
Though director David Gordon Green definitely makes some strange choices here and there, for the most part he turns out to be a totally solid choice to reignite the franchise.
Despite the Pineapple Express filmmaker's lack of experience in the genre, his distinctly art-house sensibilities actually hew pretty close to Carpenter's restrained approach in the original movie.
It's not especially flashy or exuberant filmmaking, as it absolutely shouldn't be, though there's a splendid long-take of Michael going on a rampage half-way through the movie that's probably one of the most visually remarkable sequences in the entire franchise.
There are a few moments that feel like they could be slow-bled for even greater tension and thrills, but Green acquits himself admirably for the majority.
1. The Third Act Is Insanely Suspenseful
The final reel of this movie has some of the most fine-tuned suspense you'll find in any horror movie this year.
It's no spoiler to say that the finale sees Laurie facing off against Michael, and by mostly shedding the irritating peripheral characters and subplots of the previous hour-plus, this final 20-or-so minutes feels decidedly more efficient and effective.
With the possibility that the showdown could go in one of several directions, there's a legitimate sense of unease and anxiety, and Green smartly drags it out to almost unbearable levels.
He doesn't quite stick the landing with that aforementioned eye-roller of an ending, but for the most part the climactic battle is as epically terrifying as you'd hope for.
What did you think of the new Halloween? Shout it out in the comments!