Harry Potter: 10 Worst Characters Introduced After The Philosopher's Stone

These characters deserved so much better!

Rufus Scrimgeour 01
Warner Bros.

The Harry Potter series introduced us to a lot of characters and all of them had rich, complex stories. While the first book got us started off with some wonderful characters, the weird and wonderful inhabitants of the Wizarding World only got better as the series went on.

While the books gave us rich histories and a lot of time to develop these people and make them feel almost real, the films didn't have the luxury of time or budget to do everything that the books did and some characters were unfortunately left behind.

From recasts and rewrites to characters who didn't appear in the books at all, the films definitely took liberties with storytelling and the following are some of the greatest casualties of the translation from page to screen.

10. Frank And Alice Longbottom

Neville Longbottom Parents
Warner Bros.

Frank and Alice Longbottom were Neville's parents who were tortured by the Lestrange's and Barty Crouch Jr. This brutal use of the Cruciatus Curse drove them over the edge and they lose their minds. It was a crime that saw the Death Eaters responsible locked up in Azkaban for life.

Frank and Alice never recovered and spent the rest of their days in St Mungos Hospital for Magical Maladies and Injuries. Neville often visited them with his grandmother and while they don't recognise him, Alice always gives him a bubblegum wrapper, which Neville always keeps.

It's such a tragic story and a beautiful emotional scene. It's devastating that it was cut and their appearance in the films was reduced to appearing in an old photo and being spoken about by other characters.


9. Rufus Scrimgeour

Rufus Scrimgeour 01
Warner Bros.

Rufus Scrimgeour replaces Cornelius Fudge as Minister for Magic after the former is forced to resign after denying Voldemort's return. Scrimgeour only appeared in the films from the beginning of Deathly Hallows Part One, despite his character being a major part of the Half-Blood Prince book.

Bill Nighy is a great actor, but his take on the character hardly made an impact due to this much reduced role which left him very little to play with. The Scrimgeour of the book is a fearsome, ruthless man who is likened to an old lion and walks with a limp. His past as an Auror has clearly had an effect on him, but the man we see in the films is quite ordinary. He comes across as a strong leader but not as much so as in the novel.

It was devastating to learn that Scrimgeour had been banned for the Half-Blood Prince film but was later cut. Perhaps giving him more time would have allowed audiences to warm to him, rather than cutting his screen-time to practically nothing and giving his character no time to develop.


8. Grawp

Grawp Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

Hagrid's half-brother, Grawp, was a character who got much more development in the books. Hagrid, having formed a relationship with Olympe Maxime, the giantess Head of Beauxbatons Academy, visited the giants to try and win their favour, ahead of the upcoming war.

While at the giant's camp, he met Grawp who turned out to be his half-brother. The poor giant was bullied due to his short size and Hagrid decided to bring him back to England with him. Grawp wasn't happy and proved to be difficult but when he settled into the forbidden Forest, Hagrid taught him manners and basic language skills.

The giant became much more friendly and began to express emotion and even showed sympathy for Hagrid at Dumbledore's funeral. He went on to lead a fight against the giants in the Battle of Hogwarts and ultimately survived.

In the films though, we only see Grawp in Order of the Phoenix, and quite briefly at that. He's simply reduced to a small plot point and a reason to terrorise Umbridge, rather than being a character with some growth and depth like he deserved.


7. Rita Skeeter

Rita Skeeter
Warner Bros.

Rita Skeeter is a character that everyone loves to hate and hates to love. How can we not? She's here to stir the pot and cause drama. Her gaudy fashion, her toxic Quick-Quotes Quill and her brutal spins on stories made her a perfect addition to the Goblet of Fire.

In the fourth film, Harry's life is stressful enough after he's mysteriously called as a champion for the Tri-Wizard Tournament, but that's nothing compared to his interviews with Skeeter. This sly journalist plays on Harry's tragic past and spins a narrative that isn't particularly true or flattering.

It was brilliant to see her brought to life in all her twisted glory but what really annoyed fans was that the films omitted a lot of her story. In the books, Rita becomes a recurring character and a reluctant ally after Hermione discovers a secret that allows her to blackmail Rita.

In the films, however, Skeeter causes trouble in Goblet of Fire but then vanishes until Deathly Hallows where she's only mentioned by name after causing a stir with her book about Dumbledore's life.

As awful as she is, we deserved so much more!


6. Nigel

Harry Potter Nigel
Warner Bros.

Nigel was one of the weirdest characters in the series, having never appeared in the books and being solely created just for the films. Fans quickly worked out that Nigel, who began Hogwarts during Harry's fourth year, was created to fill the role of Dennis Creevey, Colin Creevey's younger brother, who started Hogwarts that same year in the book.

After Chamber of Secrets, Colin Creevey seemed to vanish from the story, and so Nigel kind of represented him as well as his brother. He was only a small character who mostly appeared in the background, with very few lines. It just seemed odd to have a brand new character come out of nowhere with no real point to their existence.

There were a handful of continuity errors surrounding Nigel too. He attended the Dumbledore's Army meeting in Hogsmeade, despite only being a second year at the time, and therefore unable to visit the village - a privilege reserved for third year and above. He was also due to die in Colin Creevey's place in Deathly Hallows Part Two but that was later scrapped.


5. Colin Creevey

Harry Potter Colin Creevey
Warner Bros.

Colin Creevey was a notable ally of Harry's and a well-known student at Hogwarts. His love of photography saved his life in his first year, when he saw the Basilisk through his camera instead of eye-to-eye.

In the books, Colin remained friends with Harry, even though Harry was reluctant to hang out with him. Colin went on to join Dumbledore's Army, where he learned to fight and impressed Harry with his rapid progress. Despite not turning up to the battle of the Astronomy Tower in Half-Blood Prince, Colin returned to school and fought in the Battle of Hogwarts, where he tragically met his demise.

Colin was someone we'd expect to see a lot more in the films, but after being a main character in Chamber of Secrets he disappears from the films, only to be replaced by Nigel who steps in to represent both Colin, and Colin's younger brother, Dennis.


4. Cho Chang

Cho Chang Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

Cho Chang is the grieving ex-girlfriend of Cedric Diggory who begins to fall for Harry Potter. Harry had a crush on Cho for a long time, and even asked her to go to the Yule Ball with him, but she was already going with Cedric.

In the books, their relationship is given some time to develop and feels quite natural whereas in the film it feels quite sudden and is over as quick as it begins. Harry actually meets Cho in his third year, during a Quidditch match. As far back as that, it's hinted that he has a crush on her.

Throughout the Tri-Wizard Tournament Cho remains a close ally, despite dating Cedric Diggory and she refuses to take part in the bullying of Harry that a lot of others participate in. Later Cho goes against her parents wishes and joins Dumbledore's Army with her friend, Marietta, who later betrays the group to Umbridge.

Cho's relationship with Harry is a lot more awkward in the books as she tries to figure out where she stands with him, while dealing with her own guilt and conflict over liking Harry even though Cedric died. In the film all of this great drama is lost and it's Cho who betrays the DA.

It's sad that a story arc that lasted three books was completely changed and not for the better.


3. Fleur Delacour

Fleur Delacour
Warner Bros.

Fleur Delacour is the French champion in the Tri-Wizard Tournament. She attended Beauxbatons Academy of Magic in France. She came to Hogwarts and participated in the Tournament alongside Harry Potter, Cedric Diggory and Viktor Krum.

During the tasks, Fleur became fond of Harry after he rescued her sister in the Second Task she she had been forced to quit the challenge early. After the Tournament, Fleur managed to get a job at Gringott's where she met and began dating Bill Weasley. In the books, she lived at The Burrow for a time, much to the initial annoyance of Ginny, Molly and Hermione. Fleur's attitude was mistaken as rude and critical, which earned her the nickname Phlegm.

This clash of characters led to some lovely development as the women, who were probably secretly jealous of Fleur, eventually warmed to her when she proved her love for Bill. During the attack on the astronomy tower, Bill is badly injured and disfigured after being attacked by Fenrir Greyback. Fleur insists that she still loves him, and the two go on to get married and become firm allies through the rest of the Second Wizarding War.

It was sad to see Fleur's part in The Half-Blood Prince film cut, and her return reduced to mostly floating around in the background.


2. Lavender Brown

Harry Potter Lavender Brown
Warner Bros.

Lavender Brown is a popular Gryffindor and was present at all the major incidents at Hogwarts during the Second Wizarding War and the build up to it. Not that you'd know that from the films.

Lavender loved Divination and she was close with Professor Trelawney. She was initially skeptical of Harry's claims that Voldemort had returned, but quickly changed her tune and joined Dumbledore's Army.

During her sixth year, she dated Ron Weasley. Their relationship was very full-on and the two of them were consistently all over each other all the time. It didn't take long for Ron to begin feeling uncomfortable about it though. When Ron was poisoned, he began to pretend to sleep in the hospital wing to avoid having to spend time with Lavender. Lavender does all she can to try to save her relationship with "Won-Won" but eventually dumps him after seeing him leave the Common Room with Hermione. Lavender dies in The Deathly Hallows after being attacked by Fenrir Greyback - a scene which was translated to film.

It seems very strange that Lavender is such a major side character in the books, and appears at so many important moments, though she didn't appear as a proper named character in the films until Half-Blood Prince. The character had unofficially appeared in Chamber of Secrets and Prisoner of Azkaban played by Kathleen Cauley and Jennifer Smith, respectively. Until Jessie Cave took on the role, the character had been portrayed by people of colour, which led to a whitewashing controversy.


1. Nymphadora Tonks

Nymphadora Tonks
Warner Bros.

Tonks is the perfect example of what happens when a character from the books is thrown into the film but is given hardly any context or screen time to develop their character, but the filmmakers assume the audience have read the books to have a rough idea of what's going on.

Tonks is a metamorphmagus which means she can change her appearance at will. This is shown during a comedic scene in the films, but later on during the Half-Blood Prince, when Tonks' role was significant in the books, the films cut her right down.

Throughout the sixth novel, Tonks is severely depressed and spends a lot of time struggling with her mental health. While there are clues strewn throughout, it becomes clear at the end, that Tonks is in love with Remus Lupin, who rejects her. Even when the two admit their love for each other, their relationship is rocky over the remainder of the story. Remus even comes close to abandoning her and their unborn child, and then both are killed in the Battle of Hogwarts. The film doesn't explain that Tonks is related to Bellatrix Lestrange who is her aunt... and the very person who murders her!

Instead we just see Tonks appear in a scene that wasn't in the books (the Death Eater attack on The Burrow) and she announces that she and Lupin are married. It was very jarring and wrecked the story of one of the most popular couples in the franchise.


In this post: 
Harry Potter
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Simon is a writer, cat dad and presenter of a geeky radio show with his husband. He loves Doctor Who (except 10 who can get in the bin…only joking.) He idolises Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Lara Croft and would 100% be a Sith Lord in a galaxy far, far away. He wishes life was like a musical so he’d actually be a good singer.