Harry Potter: 10 Worst Things Dolores Umbridge Has Ever Done
Every Harry Potter fan hates Dolores Umbridge, and it's easy so see why...
Lord Voldemort is the main antagonist of the Harry Potter series. As well as murdering Harry’s parents, this psychotic wizard is obsessed with the idea of magical purity and would love to remove all Muggle-born witches and wizards from society.
But despite how evil Voldemort undoubtedly is, there’s one Harry Potter character who is hated above all others: Dolores Umbridge. This vile woman first makes an appearance in The Order of the Phoenix. With her pink dress sense and her high-pitched voice, she’s immediately irritating, and as the story goes on, she becomes more and more hateworthy.
Beneath the girlish mannerisms lies the personality of a sadistic psychopath. As well as torturing the students of Hogwarts, Umbridge neglects her teaching duties, attacks other staff members, abuses her political power, and enjoys herself immensely whilst she’s doing it.
Though we witness a lot of Umbridge’s villainy in the movies, there are even more reasons to hate her in the original novels. Every time she appears, it’s impossible not to loath her, and her extensive acts of evil will always be a notorious part of the series.
10. Refused To Teach Defensive Magic
Every year, Harry and his fellow classmates have a new Defence Against the Dark Arts teacher. Usually, Professor Dumbledore handpicks the teacher himself, but in The Order of the Phoenix, Cornelius Fudge (the Minister for Magic) selects Umbridge for this prestigious role.
Rather than teaching defensive magic, Umbridge forces her students to sit and read the textbook throughout the lesson, and this dull method of teaching never changes. The students have to sift through the same old rubbish again and again for an entire year. Given Harry and his classmates are OWL students, Umbridge’s arrival couldn’t have come at a worse time.
The motivation behind Umbridge’s lacklustre style of teaching is even more infuriating. Fudge, Umbridge and the rest of the Ministry are convinced Dumbledore is trying to raise his own army and seize power for himself, so the last thing they want is for the students of Hogwarts to be combat-ready.
In other words, Umbridge’s terrible teaching style is motivated by unfounded paranoia. Dumbledore has no desire to take over the Ministry, yet Umbridge is still determined to stamp out all forms of defensive magic.
9. Created The Inquisitorial Squad
After replacing Dumbledore as the Head of Hogwarts, Umbridge tries to bring every aspect of the castle under her control. So, as well as befriending Argus Filch, the mad caretaker, she also creates the Inquisitorial Squad.
The Inquisitorial Squad is a select group of students handpicked by Umbridge. Their job is to monitor behaviour and punish wrongdoers by deducting house points. However, due to the fact that every member of the Inquisitorial Squad is a Slytherin, the whole system is corrupt.
Before long, the other three houses – but especially Gryffindor – are trailing behind Slytherin as more and more points are taken away from them. Worse still, the reasons they use to justify the point deductions are pathetic. Malfoy even docks ten points from Hermione because she’s a Muggle-born.
Far from monitoring behaviour, the Inquisitorial Squad are hellbent on abusing their power as much as possible, and Umbridge does nothing to stop them.
8. Sacked Sybill Trelawney
Professor Trelawney is one of the worst staff members at Hogwarts. Despite being the Divination teacher, her powers of foresight are almost non-existent, and she spends too much time freaking out her students by predicting their premature deaths.
In The Order of the Phoenix, Umbridge inspects Trelawney’s classes, and – as the High Inquisitor of Hogwarts – she decides to sack her. Whilst you can understand Umbridge’s decision, trying to remove her from the castle is a step too far. Hogwarts has been Trelawney’s home for over a decade, yet Umbridge has no pity whatsoever:
“…Harry was revolted to see the enjoyment stretching across her toadlike face as she watched Professor Trelawney sink, sobbing uncontrollably, on to one of her trunks…”
Much to Umbridge’s frustration, Dumbledore steps in. Though he can’t stop Umbridge from sacking teachers, he makes sure Trelawney doesn’t have to leave Hogwarts altogether. But despite Dumbledore’s intervention, Trelawney is still shaken by the whole affair.
7. Banned Harry And The Weasley Twins From Playing Quidditch
Harry goes through a rough time in his fifth year. Thanks to the nonsense in the Daily Prophet, he has to deal with an onslaught of sly remarks from the rest of the school, as almost everyone thinks he’s an attention-seeking liar.
Quidditch gives Harry some relief from all the negativity, but unfortunately for him, it all goes wrong during the first match of the season. At the end of the game, Malfoy (who’s just been beaten to the Snitch) starts insulting the Weasleys’ parents and Harry’s mother. Overwhelmed with rage, Harry and George sprint towards Malfoy and start beating him up.
When the whole affair has settled down, Harry and George are taken to McGonagall’s office. Initially, they’re just given detentions, but then Umbridge steps in and decides to ban them from playing Quidditch ever again. And, despite the fact that he didn’t even do anything, Fred gets banned, too. The Slytherins, meanwhile, aren’t punished at all. Malfoy’s insults and Crabbe’s foul play at the end of the match are completely ignored.
Luckily for Harry, Umbridge’s ban is removed when she leaves Hogwarts at the end of the year.
6. Attacked Hedwig In Order To Read Harry’s Mail
Annoyed by Harry and Dumbledore’s claims about Voldemort’s return, Umbridge and her Ministry cronies have a vendetta against the pair of them throughout The Order of the Phoenix.
Determined to find out more about Harry and who he’s in contact with, Umbridge does her utmost to intercept his post. To begin with, she tries to get Filch to do her dirty work. But when this fails, she decides to intercept Hedwig during one of her flights.
How Umbridge managed to do this is never explained, but we do see the consequences of the attack. Hedwig turns up in the middle of a History of Magic lesson with an injured wing, and the damage is so extensive that Harry has to ask Professor Grubbly-Plank (the new Care of Magical Creatures teacher) to fix her up.
What’s particularly sinister about this attack is the fact that Umbridge was willing to maim an innocent animal in order to get the information she wanted. Even by her own standards, this was a pretty pathetic thing to do.
5. Broke Up The DA And Replaced Albus Dumbledore
Due to Umbridge’s terrible teaching methods, Harry, Ron, Hermione, and a bunch of other students form a teenage gang called Dumbledore’s Army (also known as the DA), and together, they practice defensive magic in the Room of Requirement.
But it’s a risky operation. If Umbridge catches the group, they’re in deep trouble, and towards the end of the year, the inevitable happens. In the movie, the discovery of the DA is slightly different to Rowling’s original, yet in both cases, Harry is taken up to Dumbledore’s office for questioning.
Umbridge and Fudge would like nothing more than to expel Harry. But Dumbledore has other ideas. He takes all the responsibility for the DA (even though he had nothing to do with it) and is forced to flee the school to avoid being sent to Azkaban.
So, in a single night, not only does Umbridge quash the DA, but she also forces the greatest Hogwarts headmaster of all time to flee the school. With Dumbledore gone, Umbridge becomes the new Head of Hogwarts and continues to purge the castle.
4. Sent Muggle-Born Witches And Wizards To Azkaban
Most Harry Potter fans associate Umbridge with Harry’s fifth adventure, but she also crops up in The Deathly Hallows as well.
After Voldemort and the Deaths Eaters take over the Ministry, Umbridge becomes the leader of the Muggle-Born Registration Commission. It’s her job to question and process Muggle-born witches and wizards and send them to Azkaban for the crime of stealing magic. Of course, there’s no logic to this at all. Muggle-borns don’t steal magic – their abilities are natural.
But Umbridge couldn’t care less. She relishes her new position and shows no sign of remorse. Whilst we’re never told how many people she sends to Azkaban, plenty of Muggle-borns choose to go on the run to avoid this terrible fate, including Dean Thomas and Ted Tonks.
Thankfully, this unfair practice only lasts for a year, and the whole thing is shut down in the wake of Voldemort’s downfall. As for Umbridge, she ends up being put on trial and sent to Azkaban for her crimes.
3. Tortured Students During Detention
When Umbridge arrives at Hogwarts, she’s immediately irritating thanks to her pink dress sense, her high-pitched voice, and her annoying mannerisms. But it’s not until Harry’s first detention that we realise just how evil she is.
Upon entering Umbridge’s office, Harry is given a quill without ink. But when he begins to write, a red substance oozes from the nib, and at the same time, he feels a sharp pain coursing through his hand:
“Again and again, Harry wrote the words on the parchment in what he soon came to realise was not ink, but his own blood.”
It’s a sinister, barbaric practice, and – at least in the books – Harry has to go through this ordeal for hours at a time. And he isn’t the only one, either. Umbridge uses this punishment on all those who receive detention.
The initial pain is bad enough, but the words etched upon the skin don’t always heal. Indeed, Harry reveals that he still has the scars when Rufus Scrimgeour pays a visit to the Burrow more than a year after his detentions with Umbridge.
2. Sent Dementors After Harry
The Order of the Phoenix surprises us straight away by placing Harry in a perilous position when he least expects it.
During a brief argument between Harry and Dudley, the warm summer air turns cold, and the surrounding skies begin to darken. The two cousins run for shelter, but they’re soon attacked by a pair of dementors. Though Harry manages to fend them off with the Patronus Charm, he’s forced to attend a Ministry hearing for using magic outside school in the presence of a Muggle.
Both Harry and Dumbledore assume the dementors were sent by Voldemort. But later on, Umbridge reveals it was her all along. She wanted to silence Harry due to his claims about Voldemort’s return, and even if the dementors didn’t kill him, she hoped he would be expelled and discredited in the trial that followed.
With some help from Dumbledore, Harry manages to avoid being expelled, but Umbridge’s twisted plan almost worked. If it wasn’t for the reasonable members of the Wizengamot and Mrs Figg’s testimony, he would have been expelled for sure.
1. Attacked Hagrid And McGonagall
During her brief tenure as the Headmistress of Hogwarts, Umbridge hits a new low when she strolls into the grounds with some of her Ministry cronies and tries to overpower Hagrid in the dead of night.
Harry and his classmates – who are in the middle of their Astronomy OWL exam – oversee the entire scene from above. When Hagrid refuses to go with the Ministry members, they start to attack him with jinxes and curses. But due to Hagrid’s giant blood, the spells are mostly ineffective, and the gamekeeper retaliates by walloping his opponents with his fists.
McGonagall soon intervenes and tells the attackers to stop. But before she can raise a wand to defend herself, Umbridge and her colleagues send a series of stunning spells at McGonagall, which knock her out immediately. Indeed, the damage is so extensive that she has to be moved to St Mungo's Hospital for several weeks in order to recover.
Even by her own standards, Umbridge’s willingness to assault two of her fellow teachers is beyond barbaric. This – more than anything else – demonstrates how dangerous and cowardly she really is.
Harry Potter Quiz: Did Harry Potter Say It?