Harry Potter: Ranking Every Death Eater From Worst To Best

Draco turned out to be pretty useless, really.

Death Eaters Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

Harry Potter is one of the most beloved stories in recent memories. Both the books and movies immerse the audience into a world of witchcraft and wizardry, making us fall in love with the magic, the characters, and just about every aspect there is.

As much as the boy who lived is adored, a story is often only as good as its villain. There had to be someone evil and maniacal enough to put Harry in danger. A big enough obstacle in his way that when he ultimately prevailed it would feel earned and satisfying.

In Lord Voldemort, J.K. Rowling hit a home run, creating a legendary antagonist forever to be remembered as one of the best of the bad guys. However, on his own, Tom Marvolo Riddle couldn't have become the same caliber of big bad he ultimately did. Like Harry needed Dumbledore's army, Voldemort needed his death eaters - unquestioning disciples to do the dark lord's bidding.

There are some that You-Know-Who was right to put his faith in, and others he would come to regret. Those that helped his cause and moved him closer toward his goal of dominion over the wizarding world, and those that were all but passengers on his rise to, and fall from glory.

11. Igor Karkaroff

Igor Karkaroff Goblet Of Fire
Warner Bros.

It wasn't until the Goblet of Fire that the Harry Potter audience was introduced to Igor Karkaroff. The wizard was seemingly nothing more than the Durmstrang Headmaster, until his dark past was uncovered bit by bit, and he was revealed to have been a Death Eater during the first Wizarding War.

After being sent to Azkaban for his crimes, Karkaroff voluntarily confessed the names of Evan Rosier, Augustus Rockwood, Severus Snape, and Barty Crouch Jr. as working for Voldemort in exchange for immediate release. Naturally, this put him on Lord Voldemort's naughty list with a target on his back.

This is why Igor was so concerned in the Goblet of Fire that his dark mark was acting up. Though if he was expecting any help or sympathy from Snape, the man he tried to turn into the authorities, he was looking in completely the wrong place.

One characteristic that any Death Eater needs to become one of the best is loyalty. When Karkaroff betrayed Voldemort to save his own skin, he confirmed his spot at the bottom of this list.


10. Draco Malfoy

Draco Malfoy Dark Mark
Warner Bros.

Like Harry had his name down for Hogwarts since the day he was born, Malfoy was always going to be a Death Eater. Coming from the family he did, and with such an obnoxious father, Draco was never going to grow up to be a good wizard.

Going through school, he certainly lived up to this expectation, demonstrating his superiority complex to everyone at the school, picking on anyone who wasn’t a pure blood, and simply acting like the little sh*t that he was. When the time finally came for Voldemort to call on young Malfoy to step up however, he failed the Dark Lord miserably.

Of course, it was no small task he was given, killing Albus Dumbledore, but it didn’t take much to see his heart wasn’t in it. Even previously, Draco had the opportunity to turn Harry in to Voldemort’s forces, but chose not to. He was never going to be able to kill his headmaster, even his own mother knew this, seeking help from Snape.

This was just another example of how Malfoy was all talk, and when it came time for him to genuinely help in the Wizarding War, he choked.


9. Pius Thicknesse

Pius Thicknesse
Warner Bros.

There were many that backed, supported, and fought for Lord Voldemort during the two Wizarding Wars. One of the most popular excuses after the first was that these people were placed under the Imperius Curse, and thus had no control over their own actions.

In the case of Pius Thicknesse however, this was actually true. The wizard was used as a puppet for Lord Voldemort while under the control of the curse, and rose to the post of Minister for Magic, allowing the other Death Eaters to essentially corrupt the entire organisation.

Though he was not a Death Eater by choice, Pius' character and influence were invaluable to the Dark Lord as he built his army up again. However, since he was merely acting as a puppet essentially under mind control, his tasks could have been performed by anybody high up in the Ministry, making Pius somewhat expendable.

The Death Eater was killed by Voldemort himself during the battle of Hogwarts, almost just out of frustration. A testament to just how low his opinion was of his follower.


8. The Carrows

The Carrows Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

Though they do technically appear in the the Deathly Hallows, Amycus and Alecto Carrow's roles in the movies are greatly decreased from the books. Relegated to non speaking roles on screen, the siblings were appointed the new Defence Against the Dark Arts teachers when Hogwarts went into lock down.

As Neville explained, it wasn't so much 'Defence Against' as it was practice, as the Carrows forced the students to use the Cruciatus Curse on first years. If they refused, they were hurt. Their journey seemingly came to end as Severus Snape deflected one of Professor McGonagall's attacks in their direction after Harry and co. returned to the Hogwarts great hall.

Though they were loyal enough to the Dark Lord, they were never really tasked with much more than punishing those in Hogwarts and teaching them that muggles, and anyone other than pure bloods, were the enemy.


7. Antonin Dolohov

Antonin Dolohov Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

Another character that had a larger role in the books than in the movies, this Death Eater amassed an impressive list of 'accomplishments' over the course of his time with the Dark Lord. He killed both of Molly Weasley's brothers in the first Wizarding War, before escaping Azkaban and ultimately killing Remus Lupin.

As one of Voldemort's disciples fighting in the battle of the department of mysteries, Dolohov dueled side by side with Lucius Malfoy against Harry and Sirius, though they were defeated without too much trouble for Potter and his godfather.

He was also unable to subdue Harry, Ron, and Hermione in their fight at a London cafe after Bill and Fleur's wedding was attacked. Though the Death Eater was overpowered by the trio, blame surely has to fall to Voldemort for this one, for sending just two wizards to deal with three.

It certainly seems that Dolohov had much more impact on the first Wizarding War than he did on the second.


6. Peter Pettigrew

Wormtail Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

There is no denying Peter Pettigrew is a despicable character, and possibly one of the most hated in all of the Harry Potter franchise. After growing up with James, Remus, and Sirius as one of the Marauders, Wormtail went rogue and defected to Lord Voldemort and the dark side of magic.

Though he is something of a pathetic creature, and suits the rat that he hid as for so many years, Peter Pettigrew proved himself to be incredibly useful to the Dark Lord.

He revealed to He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named the secret of where the Potters were hiding, allowing Voldemort to kill Lily and James, and in theory at least, Harry. Though he went into hiding after the first Wizarding War, he sought Lord Voldemort in the Albanian forest, and was instrumental in the revival of the Dark Lord's physical form.

In the books Voldemort punishes Pettigrew for hesitating to kill Harry by taking his life, however in the movies, the man known as Wormtail does not actively let the Dark Lord down. Though he is tricked into the release of Harry and co. from their captivity in Malfoy Manor, he stayed loyal to Voldemort to the very end.


5. Lucius Malfoy

Lucius Malfoy Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

As horrible, and as warped as Draco Malfoy's views were on the Wizarding World, and the perceived difference between the pure bloods of his family and the rest who were 'beneath' him, it all stemmed from his upbringing. It all came from his vile father, Lucius.

No one believed in the values put forward by the Dark Lord more so than Mr. Malfoy. He was constantly looking down his nose at those not born pure blood, and even some that were like the Weasleys. He was even just seconds away from killing Harry after he set Dobbie free.

Held in high regard by Lord Voldemort, his skill and resources were utilised well. Lucius slipped Ginny Weasley Tom Riddle's diary in the Chamber of Secrets, and was chosen by his master to lead the attack on the Order of the Phoenix in the battle of the Department of Mysteries. This, however, proved to be an unwise choice. Draco's father was defeated relatively easily by Harry and Sirius and destroyed the Prophecy he was sent to retrieve.

After a stint in Azkaban, Lucius returned a shell of himself, and followed Voldemort simply through fear, before fleeing with his family during the Battle of Hogwarts after Harry's return from the dead.


4. Corban Yaxley

Harry Potter Yaxley Death Eater
Warner Bros. Pictures

One of Lord Voldemort's most loyal and fiercest followers through the two Wizarding Wars, Corban Yaxley was held in high regard by the Dark Lord. Appointed as the Head of the Department of Magical Law Enforcement, Yaxley was the one to place Pius Thicknesse under the Imperius Curse, essentially running the Ministry of Magic for Lord Voldemort.

He was a key figure in the Ministry's persecution of anyone not of pure blood birth, going so far as printing 'Mudbloods and the danger they pose' propaganda. After being a key part of the interrogation of those he believed to be unworthy of the title of witch or wizard, Yaxley was forced to chase Harry, Ron, and Hermione through the Ministry.

Though he was ultimately unable to stop the three from escaping with the locket Horcrux, he did see their hiding place at Grimmauld Place, forcing them away from the safety of the Order, and into hiding in the forest. Yaxley was ruthless, cruel, and typically a strong asset to the Dark Lord.


3. Severus Snape

Harry Potter Snape Death
Warner Bros. Pictures

Snape, though originally portrayed as one of the villains of the Harry Potter saga, turned out to be one of the most complex, and misunderstood characters in the entire story.

It is incredibly difficult to assess his value to Lord Voldemort as a Death Eater, since in reality he was a spy for Dumbledore. He actively stopped Professor Quirrell from murdering Harry Potter in the Philosopher's Stone, and watched over the boy who lived in general throughout his early years at Hogwarts.

However, on the other hand, Snape did his fair share to help the Dark Lord. He gave his fellow Death Eaters the information of when the Order would be moving Harry, resulting in the following attack, and death of Alastor Moody. He also allowed Hogwarts to become what it did in the Deathly Hallows, and of course, was the one who murdered Albus Dumbledore.

Though he removed from Voldemort's path the one wizard he was scared of facing, he did so only on the express orders of the Hogwarts Headmaster himself. When all is said and done, as Snape told Bellatrix, he had deceived a great wizard for a very long time. He simply neglected to tell her that that wizard was Lord Voldemort.


2. Barty Crouch Jr.

David Tennant as Barty Crouch Jr, in 'Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire'.
Warner Bros.

Though Severus Snape may be one of the greatest double agents the Wizarding World has ever seen, Barty Crouch Jr. was better. He managed to hide his secret allegiance from everyone including his father, a high ranking wizard in the Ministry of Magic.

In fact, if it wasn't for Igor Karkaroff turning his back on the Death Eaters and giving up his fellow disciples, he could have carried on working for the Dark Lord in secret for who knows how long. Even once he had been exposed, Barty Crouch Jr. still found a way to secretly work for Lord Voldemort.

Disguised as Mad-Eye Moody, Crouch managed to orchestrate Harry entering and successfully navigating the Triwizard Tournament, ultimately leading the boy who lived to his master, allowing the Dark Lord to return in his physical form. Such was his commitment to his performance, he somehow managed to master Alastor's voice, something which no one else using polyjuice potion in the movies could manage.

As useful and reliable as he was to Voldemort however, there was just one more that the Dark Lord could count on even more so than Barty Crouch Jr.


1. Bellatrix Lestrange

Bellatrix Lestrange
Warner Bros.

Bellatrix Lestrange was one of the toughest, cruelest, and most powerful of all of Lord Voldemort's Death Eaters. After loyally following the Dark Lord during the first Wizarding War, Bellatrix survived her time in Azkaban, even managing to escape to help in the second.

She was one of the Death Eaters that used the Cruciatus Curse to drive Frank and Alice Longbottom to insanity, carved the word 'mudblood' into Hermione Granger's arm, killed Dobbie, and forced Snape to make the unbreakable vow with her sister, guaranteeing the death of Albus Dumbledore.

Possibly the witch's biggest contribution to the effort happened during the battle of the Department of Mysteries, when she killed Sirius Black. Not only was Padfoot one of the strongest members of the Order of the Phoenix, he was Harry's role model and father figure. Aside from killing the boy who lived himself, she couldn't have done anything to hurt Harry more than this.

Though she eventually fell to Molly Weasley in the Battle of Hogwarts, Bellatrix was loyal to the Dark Lord, and never once faltered. She truly is an embodiment of evil.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Harry Potter
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.