How A Nightmare On Elm Street Remake Should Be Made
Wes Craven's estate are in the market for a new Freddy...
The news is out: there's a new nightmare coming home to one very familiar street, resurrecting an old evil from his resting place for another round of death by dream demon. Yes, Freddy Krueger is coming back in A Nightmare On Elm Street once again: but what exact form his rebirth will take is yet to be decided upon.
With a whopping 35 years of fan love for the franchise coming from nine movies under the banner, Freddy has been from the boiler room to hell itself and all the way back again, but that's not to say his adventures are over. The dream dimension has whole world full of opportunities where imagination can become reality, if only the right mind is tapped for the weirdest and most wonderful horror stories to tell inside of it.
Whether you love or hate it, Christmas really has come early for the blade-fingered baddie. But how did this whole deal come about? And what nightmare comes next?
8. The Craven Estate's New Nightmare
Just two months ago, the Nightmare property reverted back to Wes Craven's estate after being in the hands of Warner Bros. and New Line Cinema for over three decades. Due to a law that allows writers to reclaim their work after 35 years, the Cravens have waited patiently to get both the rights to the Nightmare film series and its star Freddy Krueger back in hand, and aren't wasting any time getting to creating a fresh new take on their family legacy.
As Bloody Disgusting originally reported on, the Craven estate have announced they're actively taking pitches for a new entry into the saga right now. There's been no report how they're going to go about this - so whether they'll be looking at a reboot, a sequel, or even a TV series to expand on the Krueger legend is unclear - nor have there been any revelations on if they have a distributor, or even any financial deals in place to secure whatever pitches they might decide to go with.
In short, it's at an incredibly early stage in the process. But there's still reams of excitement at the prospect of the Springwood Slasher coming back under the power of people who care about the franchise more than its profitability, and can channel Wes Craven's passion for sublime, innovative horror in a way that pays respect to his creation in a fitting way.
7. New Line Cinema & Shared Universe Potential
Essentially, the rights deal that has been reached is one that allows the Craven estate to do what they like with the property in the U.S., but Warner Bros. and New Line Cinema still retain the international rights should anything else come of creating and selling a new movie. What this means is that the studio will still have to be involved in some capacity, whether that's in a partnership with a new studio if the Cravens sell their deal elsewhere, or as the sole distributor should they decide to keep everything peachy by sticking with the company that's worked with them from the beginning. At least if they want their movie anywhere other than the states of course, which they will.
Keeping New Line Cinema sweet is always a good idea at its heart, since they've had their fingers in plenty of horror icon pies over the years and were the reason cult hit Freddy vs. Jason got off the ground when it did. With the Friday the 13th series having roots with New Line Cinema, as well as The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, something of a shared universe lies at the edges of possibility if they play their cards right. And if we all cross our fingers and pray to all that is unholy that they gift us with that level of nonsense once more just to sweeten the deal.
6. Fixing The Sins Of The Past
Whilst a shared universe would be a special kind of joy to witness come around again, we've got to think logically here. There's plenty of missteps that the Nightmare franchise has taken over the years, resulting in some less that stellar sequels in place of the quality first entry that got us all enamoured with the murderer with a mouth in the first place. Of course, the first thing that comes up when we're talking 'A Nightmare on Elm Street Remake' HAS to be the whole 2010 mess - as much as we'd all prefer to avoid it - and that's rife with mistakes that turned audiences sour on a franchise return already.
What made the 2010 effort so repellent to Nightmare fans, and what makes remakes so hard to hit with audiences when it comes to classic, beloved titles, is that it dared to imply it could do the original better. Instead of approaching with new material, it took what was already established and laid it all out again with a CGI veneer - killing the charm of the original with one look at Freddy's zombified, fleshy face.
The 2010 movie is exactly what one would expect from something with Michael Bay's grubby fingerprints all over it. It's a straight rehash of what we've already seen with the ONE difference it tested out being the idea of Freddy as an actual child molester rather than a murderer, which is not something a fandom who have long supported the killer want to be faced with. Taking a sassy slasher and turning him into an actual wrong'un was the worst choice they could have made.
5. Avoiding the Sins of the Future
So what do we want from the franchise in place of 2010's messy attempt? We know that we want something suitably different to make the whole thing worthwhile, but not changing aspects of the story that will alter the key points of the franchise we know and love. We want something that will play into the inventive deaths, dark humour, and whacky dream-manipulation that keeps the whole series fresh, but not done in a way that relies on CGI and makes the whole thing feel cheap and dated. We want something that has the heart of Wes Craven, but has its own standing with filmmakers that won't tread too closely on his toes. Basically, it's an almost impossible task to please everyone in the right ways for the right reasons. But still, that doesn't mean a new movie has to be a bad thing.
Of course, the project will be without Wes Craven - the founding father of all things terrifying and reason A Nightmare on Elm Street is what it is today. Without him, the series is already starting on the back foot, but there's at least a wealth of talented filmmakers out there more than ready to follow in his footsteps. Impassioned by growing up with the man's legend influencing everything we know about horror, there's surely some hands that would to justice to Krueger and his story, and plenty have already thrown their hats into the ring...
4. Finding A Filmmaker In... Frodo?
One of the most exciting people to raise their hand with a pitch is Mike Flanagan, director of The Shining sequel Doctor Sleep and mind behind cult gems like Absentia, Gerald's Game, and Hush, as well as acclaimed horror TV series The Haunting of Hill House. He poked fun on Twitter at having his own pitch to send forward.
Put me in, coach... I’ve got a pitch! https://t.co/LPUq8hDd88
— Mike Flanagan (@flanaganfilm) November 22, 2019
Put me in, coach... I’ve got a pitch! https://t.co/LPUq8hDd88
— Mike Flanagan (@flanaganfilm) November 22, 2019As one of the recent horror greats and proven skilled touch with sequels, Flanagan getting involved would be a dream come true. But he's not the only one with ideas, as none other than Elijah Wood has repeatedly expressed he wants to get his hands on the property with his production company SpectreVision. He stated in an interview with ComingSoon.net that A Nightmare On Elm Street is up there with his top five horror franchises he dreams of working on, with co-founder Daniel Noah stating:
"We have a very specific take on it. I think it would be very surprising and exciting to remake the franchise."
The company is a horror specialist production house, with A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night and Mandy just two of the HUGE names SpectreVision has pumped out in recent years. If the world has any spice in it at all, we'll see Flanagan take on directing duties under the production house for New Line Cinema to then distribute - keeping plenty happy in the wake of Nightmare's new stirrings.
3. Pitch: A Fresh Start, At The Beginning
But enough of those mystery pitches keeping their secrets. Whilst there's plenty of avenues a new Nightmare movie COULD take, there's arguably one that it really should - and that's a narrative that folds in Robert Englund as neatly as possible. There's a few options this could manifest in, with the first being the familiar territory of a sequel that ignores half the franchise and starts again at the beginning.
Just like the success of Halloween (2018), A Nightmare on Elm Street could very easily take the first film that worked its burned magic into the franchise and start from there - dropping everything else that came after it and resigning it to the canon of Wes Craven's New Nightmare as a fictional world of movies. Almost 40 years on, we'd then be able to have Robert Englund back as an aged Freddy whilst the dream-world demon himself is taken on by a new face, allowing for the cameo and the new introduction to be a passing of the torch rather than an unwanted takeover.
Setting it in future - or the present, really - would also allow for a whole new world of technology to be introduced as seen fit, allowing for more 'Prime Time' moments, as well as giving opportunity for Heather Langenkamp's Nancy to take on another maternal role and fulfil the cyclical nature of Freddy's hauntings. It's the perfect way to pay homage to the past that built the franchise whilst bringing in present-day replacements tastefully, and exampled supremely well in Halloween as a template to go by.
2. Pitch: Reincarnation
Another option that allows Robert Englund to come back - which is an integral part of making this whole thing work, and should be taken seriously - is by having a narrative that ends with his reincarnation in another body. He's a dream demon, so there's no real necessity to come up with some long winded back story as to why he can change shape since he lives in a hellscape of his own volition, but the easiest way to do this is to repeat the sins of the past by burning him alive once more.
Ideally, this wouldn't be by remaking the first movie since literally nobody wants that, not even Englund:
“We need a Freddy that can do the next eight movies – or seven, I don’t want them to remake Part 1 again. [...] I could do one more…probably."
Getting him in for his 'one more' would be as simple as beginning the movie Endgame style and having a bunch of teenagers wipe out the rampaging curse of Freddy before he's reincarnated by another evil school janitor possessed by his spirit. It'd be easy enough to have a story that serves as an origin tale for a new Freddy Krueger that plays with the sympathetic card the 2010 remake tried to use by having an almost-innocent man turn bad and become a honing beacon for his spirit to come back into, resulting in a whole new series of chaos as teens try and stop the takeover before its too late.
This one probably lends itself to the possible HBO Max series that's been whispered about, too.
1. Pitch: An Origin Story
Lastly, and most pertinently, the origin story of Fred Krueger himself would avoid any timeline nasties whilst serving up a piece of A Nightmare On Elm Street lore that fans have been gagging for since the beginning. We know all the details of his troubled upbringing and disturbing conception, but they've never been justly put to screen - watching Fred Krueger in his life as a human before succumbing to the dream world offers a chance for Robert Englund to flashback the hell out of his role whilst simultaneously setting up a new actor to take him over. How easy would it be for him, in film, to step back into his younger form when he inevitably comes back from the dead?
An origin story would allow Englund to show Freddy's past coincide with his present, perhaps ageing from kids not fearing him any more and coming back into a younger form when they remember that - "oh sh*t" - Freddy really is a threat again. Perhaps his legend goes forgotten and one finds an old journal that details his past and invokes the fear of Krueger once more.
It's the most likely option and one that would please the most fans, but all we can do is speculate for now.
What do you think of a new A Nightmare On Elm Street remake? What do you want to see done with the property? Share your thoughts in the comment section below.