Hugh Jackman: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Don't remember him being in a Woody Allen film? There's a reason for that...

Hugh Jackman didn't so much fall backwards into being a huge Hollywood star as pirouetted. Before he became the embodiment of certain measures of manly manliness €“ having a lot of visible body hair, being comfortable enough to wear vests out of the house, smoking cigars on the reg €“ the Australian-born actor was known for his musical work. As any child born in the country with any designs on being a performer, Jackman was offered a spot on Neighbours early on in his career, turning it down to continue his work on the stage. It was there that he broke through into the mainstream, thanks to an award-winning turn as the lead in the musical Oklaholma!, reprising the role in the 1999 film adaptation. Since then, however, he's diversified his acting portfolio somewhat. He's still known to the majority of households as Wolverine (even going so far as to say recent Oscar success Birdman inspired him to stay in the role until he dies, suggesting he saw a different film to literally everyone else), but he's used that fame to do some genuinely interesting work (and some awful ones too!) He was one of the few natural singers cast in Les Mis €“ thank the maker €“ but, then, he also voiced the Easter Bunny in €œAvengers for children's fantasy characters€ Rise Of The Guardians. With his new movie Eddie The Eagle out this weekend in UK cinemas, it's the perfect time to look back at five of Hugh Jackman's awesome performances...and five that sucked.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Roddy - Flushed Away (2006)

Whilst Rise Of The Guardians was something of a misfire, Jackman's previously had good form for his voice-over work. One of his earlier ventures into the field was Aardman's first big film that retained the style of their stop-motion productions (Wallace And Gromit, Chicken Run and the like), except animated in CGI (so it doesn't take the better part of everyone involved's lives). Flushed Away told a typically Aardman story, with Jackman providing the voice of Roddy, a pet rat who gets flushed down the toilet by a vermin interloper (played by Shane Richie, no less) who snuck up through the sewer system. Roddy €“ who has grown accustomed to the finer things in life €“ is aghast at the society that lives in London's sewers. It's a pretty typical fish out of water (or, rat in toilet water) story, but with Aardman's signature charm and Jackman stealing the show with his plummy turn as the upper crust Roddy. And opposite Academy Award Winner Kate Winslet as his rat love interest!

4. Tomas/Tommy/Tom Creo €“ The Fountain (2006)

Darren Aaronofsky spent an ungodly amount of time getting this borderline unfilmable script onto the big screen, even going so far as to turn it into a graphic novel when it looked like his dream project was destined to remain in his desk drawer. And yet Noah has no problem getting made. What kind of a sick world allows that to happen. Regardless of what you think of the finished product €“ a big, sprawling, ambitious sci-fi drama that spans several decades before Cloud Atlas ever thought of doing such a thing €“ it would have totally fallen apart before it even got started were it not for a powerful couple of leads performances by Hugh Jackman and Rachel Weisz. At times the structure and themes border on the bad side of pretension, but Weisz and Jackman admirably keep it together as a pair of (at times) literal star-crossed lovers: first a modern-day couple, a scientist and his cancer-stricken wife; then a conquistador and his queen; and finally, an astronaut hallucinating his lost love...or is he? Brilliant, affecting acting in extraordinary circumstances.

3. Keller Dover €“ Prisoners (2013)

Which at this point is kind of Jackman's stock in trade. Makes it all the more interesting, then, when he takes a break from the genre where he's so effectively shown his skills and tries something a little different. Prisoners is one of two highly engaging, inventive little thrillers put out by French-Canadian director Denis Villeneuve in 2013, along with Jake Gyllenhaal psychological drama Enemy. Where the latter threw in with some loosely sci-fi concepts €“ which is probably what sinched Villeneuve the director's job for the somewhat dubious upcoming Blade Runner sequel €“ Prisoners is a straight crime drama. In that it's set squarely in reality, anyway, since the plot is home to some of the more shocking twists of recent years. And again, most of that hinges on Jackman as Keller Dover, the struggling suburban dad whose young daughter goes missing on Thanksgiving; when Gyllenhaal's detective lets loose the main suspect, Jackman's character takes matters into his own hands, with morally iffy and disturbing results...

2. Robert Angier €“ The Prestige (2006)

Back to his usual wheelhouse, though, and Jackman can rarely be topped. Even when you set him in direct opposition to method actor of the decade Christian Bale, who still lives at the top of many people's best performer list despite making Terminator: Salvation and attacking his family that one time. Ah, fame, you not-so-fickle mistress. Christopher Nolan's adaptation of Christopher Priest's novel works so well because it plays to each actor's strengths: Bale plays the lesser-known, but perhaps smarter and closer to true €œgenius€ illusionist Alfred Boden €“ he's intense, unpredictable, and cagey; Jackman, meanwhile, is consummate performer Robert Angier. It's Angier who really leads the film, rather than it being an even two-hander, as his pursuit to best Boden tips him over into the unnatural (with the help of David Bowie as an historically inaccurate Nikola Tesla), the fraying edges beginning to show in both his personal life and on stage, where he's otherwise at his most confident.

1. Wolverine €“ Every X-Men Film (2000-2014)

In many ways, Hugh Jackman isn't particularly good casting as Wolverine. Once upon a time, during a ill-fated attempt at bringing the X-Men to the silver screen back in the eighties, Bob Hoskins was floated as the main contender to play Logan. And, based on the comic book version, Hoskins is actually better suited: he was short, hairy, and adept at playing angry, socially maladroit types. Jackman, meanwhile, is a stout six foot, tends to be fairly well groomed, and comes off as one of the most charismatic and genuinely warm people working in the entertainment industry. In fact, even when Bryan Singer's first X-Men movie began shooting, Jackman wasn't the first choice: it was supposed to Scottish actor Dougray Scott. If you're saying €œwho?€, well, that's testament to what a bad choice Scott made in leaving the role. Wolverine made Jackman the star he is today, and vice versa; the X-films became all about Logan, by sheer force of how good the actor's performance was, his bringing a flat funnybook archetype to vivid life with increasing complexity belying what are cheesy superhero films. It's no coincidence that he's been in every single X-Men film since, if only for a cameo in First Class. Wolverine is how he'll be remembered, and that's not bad thing. It could certainly be worse...

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Peter Lyman €“ Scoop (2006)

2006 was a weird year. It was the year when not one, not two, but three separate films about stage magicians were released in the space of twelve months: the underrated Edward Norton and Paul Giamatti drama The Illusionist, the aforementioned Prestige, and then also Scoop €“ one of those ill-advised dramas Woody Allen keeps making, despite nobody but him enjoying them. To pile one coincidence on top of another, Scoop was the second time that year Hugh Jackman found himself starring in a film about stage magicians. In this case it was Allen himself who took that part, as €œThe Great Splendini€, with Jackman an aristocratic eccentric who might just be a serial killer. And it's up to Scarlett Johansson's plucky journalism student to get to the bottom of it for some reason! Allen's dialogue, only ever written in his voice, is clunky enough put into other's mouths for his comedies; in his dramas it's even worse, with neither Jackman nor Johansson doing much with the script. It was never released in the UK.

4. Leopold €“ Kate & Leopold (2001)

Thank god X-Men came along because, honestly, without it Hugh Jackman's career would've been over before it began. Instead of making the leap from the stage to the screen in quite such a spectacular fashion as he did, he might very well have gone the way of the Dougray Scotts of the world if he'd been remembered for...whatever this was. This is what Kate & Leopold was: a romantic comedy where Jackman starred as Prince Leopold George Duncan Albert Mountbatten, Third Duke of Albany, who finds himself bored of life in the 17th century and somehow arranges it so he gets sent through time and finds himself in present-day New York. Where he promptly falls in love with Meg Ryan's cynical and ambitious market researcher, because of course he does. Even for the often credibility-straining genre of romantic comedies, this is stretching it a bit. Jackman tries his best, bless him, but there was absolutely no charm or personality to be found in this absolute nadir of modern studio filmmaking.

3. The Drover €“ Australia (2008)

How Baz Luhrmann keeps getting work is a mystery to all. Perhaps it's some sort of conspiracy perpetuated by the costume and production designers unions, all of whom find ample work when another of his florid but otherwise completely shallow and empty projects roll into town, and they threaten to go on strike whenever a studio demurs from instantly greenlighting one of his films. Despite making some of the most awful, tasteless films that totally white wash actual history since, well, the perceived €œGolden Age€ of Hollywood he so clearly yearns to return to, Luhrmann truly reached his nadir when he decided to make a film about his native Australia. Called Australia. Starring: Australians. Here Jackman stars as the nameless cattle drover who sweeps the married Lady Sarah Ashley (played by Nicole Kidman) off of her feet when she takes a visit to that barbaric Australian outback. The stunning lack of chemistry is superseded only by the tone-deaf script which deploys the Magical Negro trope without a hint of irony.

2. Davis €“ Movie 43 (2013)

In that case, it's hard not to blame Jackman. He didn't write the script, cast the characters, or make Baz Luhrmann the way he is, but he did know what he was getting himself into. It's much the same with Movie 43, a film which didn't so much have hype surrounding it as a line of journalists scratching their heads as to how so many big-name actors had been suckered into starring in it. A sketch comedy anthology film that's technically the work of a half-dozen different directors and writers, but most of the blame can be left at the door of the Farrelly Brothers (directors of Dumb And Dumber, There's Something About Mary and so on). And blame they should take, for trying to tank the careers of fine actors from Kate Winslet to Julianne Moore. And Hugh Jackman, who stars as €œDavis€ in €œThe Catch€, opposite Winslet as a single businesswoman who goes on a blind date with his seemingly dashing single man who is concealing a pair of testicles on his neck underneath a scarf. That's it. That's the joke. This is a film that got made and released.

1. Gabriel Van Helsing €“ Van Helsing (2004)

At times it almost seems like Hugh Jackman is playing chicken with total career ruin. Despite having a sweet gig going with Wolverine, which puts him amongst some of the highest-grossing and most loved actors currently working, he keeps pulling crap like Movie 43, Kate & Leopold and €“ when he got a little greedy on the franchises €“ Van Helsing. Sometimes you forget Van Helsing ever existed. Like it was some sort of shared hallucination, like the summer Sam Worthington appeared in everything: did it actually really happen? Can anyone provide any real, tangible evidence that it occurred? Because from a purely logical standpoint, it doesn't many anything beginning to resemble sense. Apparently sick of their stable of classic monsters just lying around and not contributing anything, Universal decided it was about time they got a fresh new reboot. Except instead of bringing them all back in new takes on their old horror films, they decided to jam them all together in a stupid CGI mess of an action film where Jackman seems unwilling or unable to inject any sort of personality or pathos into his part. A waste of everyone's time, honestly. Still, at least they learnt their lesson. It'll be a long time before they do another big budget reboot of their monsters with a big name actor reduced to a grunting action hero... oh wait.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/